Publicly accessible
Prepared for the University of Virginia Library Electronic Text Center.
On Thursday being the first of March The Confederation of the United States was finally established in Congress To be perpetual, being first Considered and acceeded to by the Ligislatures of all the States. By a Signal given at the State House The Completion of this grand Union & Confederation was anounced by Fireing thirteen Cannon on the Hill And the same number on board Captn. Paul Jones Frigate in the Harbour. At Two OClock the members of Congress, The members of the General Assembly of Pensylvania, the President and Council of that State, the officers of the Army in Town, the officers of State and a great number of Gentlemen waited on the President of Congress To Congratulate him on this occasion; And partook of a Collation prepaired at his House for that purpose. In the evening there was a grand exhibition of fireworks at the State House, & also on board Paul Jones Frigate in the Harbour-And all the Vessels in the Harbour were Decorated and illuminated on this Occasion and great joy appeared in every Countenance but those of the Disaffected.
I wrote a few Lines this morning.(2) Only just sett down Now to Tell you that the Grand Confederation of the States was this day Completed. At Ten oClock we had a Colation at the President of Congress's and at five I Dined at Mr. McKeans with the President & Vice President of this State and a number of Members of Congress & other Gentlemen And this evening we had a grand exhibition of fire works at the State House, and another on board of Paul Jones Ship-And indeed all the Day has been Spent in rejoicing.(3)
Expect to go out to board Tomorrow and in a few days after according to his Custom-Shall probably be waited on by the Minister of France-so that you See a Member of Congress is now no Small Man & yet I feel no Change in My Self, and all these flattering enjoyments would be Too weak to keep me here if the Love of My Country did not Coincide with them.
Thomas Rodney
Image missing
(1) Although Rodney wrote "Sir," the letter is addressed to his wife, Elizabeth Fisher Rodney, to whom he also had written the "few Lines this morning" printed below.
(2) The following "few Lines" to Elizabeth are in the Rodney Papers, DeHi.
"I have but a minute to write, have not had time to do Your business yet, Mrs. Vining says good black Satin is 40/ hard and unless I can buy lower Shall think it best for you to get it in Wilmington & send it up to be Made. Our Confederation will be completed to day after which Shall have more time to git private business done. My love to the Children &c."
(3) Accounts of the celebration similar to the description recorded in Rodney's diary this day appeared in the Pennsylvania Packet, March 3, and the Pennsylvania Gazette, March 7, 1781.
I have the Pleasure to inform you that Congress have been pleased to elect you to the important Office of Secretary of Marine for the United States.(1)
A Copy of your Appointment is herewith enclosed.
I have the Honor to be, with very great respect, Sir, your most obedient Servant,
S.H.
(1) JCC, 19:203. For McDougall's reluctance to accept this appointment unless permitted to retain his rank and pay as a Continental major general, a condition Congress ultimately refused to accede to, see McDougall to Huntington, March 9, 1781, note 2.
By the Act of Congress herewith enclosed your Excellency will be informed that the Articles of Confederation & perpetual Union between the thirteen United States are formally & finally ratified by all the States.(1)
We are happy to congratulate our Constituents on this important Event, desired by our Friends but dreaded by our Enemies.
I have the Honor to be &c, &c,
S.H.
(1) For the completion of ratification, which was finally accomplished when Daniel Carroll and John Hanson signed the Articles of Confederation on behalf of Maryland on March 1, See JCC, 19:213-14; and Thomas Rodney's Diary, March 1, 1781. See also Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, February 20 and February 24, 1781.
Your Excellency's Letter of the 26th Instant came to hand last Evening. (1)
Baron Steuben's Letter, which you mention as referred to in Governor Jefferson's Letter, by some Mistake of the Governors Secretary, was not enclosed in his Despatches to me and has never come to Hand. This I ought to have noted on the Copy of the Governor's Letter transmitted to your Excellency.(2)
The Detachment under the Marquis passed down the river by this City yesterday.(3)
By a Letter from Baron Steuben to the Board of War we are told, that Arnold has sent to New York for a reinforcement.(4) No farther Intelligence from the Southward.
I have the Honor to be, with very great respect, Sir, your most obedient & most humble servant,
Sam. Huntington
(1) The letter is in PCC, item 152, 10:1-4; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21 :300-302.
(2) The subject of this paragraph is actually a letter to Steuben from Gen. Nathanael Greene which the baron had originally sent to Thomas Jefferson. Because Jefferson had sent a copy of it directly to Washington, this puzzling issue was now moot, as Washington had already pointed out in the postscript of his February 26 letter to Huntington. See Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 4:590; Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:302; and Huntington's second letter to Washington of February 20, 1781, note.
(3) For the marquis de Lafayette's progress enroute to Virginia with Continental reinforcements, see his letter to Washington of this date in Lafayette, Papers (Idzerda), 3:359-62.
(4) Not found; although a February 23 letter from Steuben to the board of different import, which was read in Congress on March 7, is in PCC, item 164, fols. 218-25.
The States of Newhamshire and Rhode Island having each but one Member in Congress, they became unrepresented by the Confirmation of the Confederation-By which not more than Seven nor less than two Members is allowed to represent any State (1)-Whereupon General Sulivan, Deligate from Newhamshire moved (2)-That Congress would appoint a Committee of the States, and Adjourn till those States Could Send forward a Sufficient number of Deligates to represent them-Or that they would allow their Deligates now in Congress To give the Vote of the States 'Tiil one More from each of those States was Sent to Congress to Make
But all their Arguments were ablely confuted by Mr. Burke of N.C. and others, and the absurdidty of the motion fully pointed out, So that the question passed off without a Division-But it was the general Opinion of Congress that those members might Continue to Sit in Congress, and Debate & Serve on Committees tho they Could not give the Vote of their States.
(1) New Hampshire and Rhode Island had fallen afoul of Article 5 of the Articles of Confederation. Anticipating this problem, John Sullivan and James Varnum had written to Congress on February 28 proposing a remedy. Congress debated the question at length on March 2, 5, and 6, but the only long-term solution was the attendance of at least two delegates from both New Hampshire and Rhode Island in compliance with Article 5. See JCC, 19:208; Sullivan and Varnum to Congress, February 28; and Thomas Rodney's Diary, March 5 and 6, 1781.
(2) This motion, in the hand of Charles Thomson and dated by him March 2, 1781, is in PCC, item 36, 4:417. It was not entered by Thomson on the journals, but is printed in JCC, 19: 229.
Mr. Pryor intending to set of in the Morning have set down to Mention some News that Came to hand to day. The Minister of France informed Congress this afternoon That the America a 64 Gun Brittish Ship which having been blown of in the late Storm being returned To her Station in Guardners bay, & by that Means the Brittish having a Superiority to the French Fleet at Rhode Island it had been thought necessary to Order the Squadron back from Virginia-which he informed had Taken Six prizes one the Romulus of 44 Guns & 500 Men and Two Strong Privateers from New York.(1) By Advices also recd. today it appears that Cornwallace had passed the Roanoke River-That Col. Lee Had Made an attack on a party of his Cavalry and killed 13, & Taken 30 prisoners and Totaly defeated the Party-That Genl. Greene was Joined by 1300 Malitia
Yesterday the Confederation was finally rattified and Confirmed. At Two OClock we had a Colation at the President of Congress's. At five I dined at Mr. McKeans with the President & Vice President and Sundry members of assembly of this State and Sundry Members of Congress & others. Thus you hear this Situation is not without the flattering inducements of Good Company & Good Living. But as have not yet had it in my power to git lodgings to My Mind, have not yet been waited on by the Minister of France Whose Custom it is to wait on every member of Congress as soon as he Takes lodgings.
As I may often Communicate to you many things which ought not to be publick I shall only request that you will always attend to such things as your own Judgment points out to be of that nature which may save me the Trouble of particularising them. I am Vizt.
Thomas Rodney
N.B. I am much pleased to find that all your old acquaintances in Congress still profess the warmest Esteem for you. My love to Sally and all friends below.
(1) Congress received this information in the chevalier de La Luzerne's March 2 letter to Congress, in which he also requested the appointment of a committee to communicate additional information "relative to these operations." See JCC, 19:22425; PCC, item 95, 1:184-85; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:271.
This intelligence was also communicated this day in an intercepted letter from an unidentified delegate to William Carmichael, a fragment of which survives in the form of a poorly rendered French translation sent to Paris from the French ambassador in Spain. Archives du Ministere des affaires etrangeres: Correspondance politique, Espagne, 602:267.
(2) See the preceding entry.
Did I, my Dr. general, consult forms in those attachments which my Judgment is proud in having adopted; this letter would contain little but appology in not having earlier acknowledged the oblidging favours with wich you have honoured me-My constitution is of a different mould. I could only therefore look forward to a character with veneration, which I could not pleasantly address: and amidst those publick and domestick troubles, which united to assail the virtuous mind; a hearty Sympathy was not the Smallest, among poor ornaments of my mind.
It is with uncommon satisfaction I See you rise Superior to the Throws of hazard, not overclouded by Strokes, which must have strong affected the parent & heretofore successful general. It gives a pre-eminence to that Station in which you was placed, When Congress bestowed with So much Justice, its highest honours and marks of Esteem on the victorious General at Saratoga.
Were we, in this contest for a republican Interest to preserve our apathy for the monarch under which we formerly lived; merely for the purpose of grasping honor of a similar and baser nature, how vain and mean would be the pursuit-but when Sentiments are founded on a conviction, that Despotism ought not to enter into Human Society or constitute any part of the government of civil rights-the Same generous ardor, which is engaged to extirpate it; will ever preserve a Jealousy to prevent it. This Jealousy must be considered, to Speak en militaire, the vide of Republican Safety.
Rumours from various parts are arrived-Count d'Estaing having captured Six british men of War, part of Commodore Hoods Squadron, and a very considerable number of transports off the western Islands, This may be true-Several other accounts from the Southwd. These you know, being not of a latter date, than when I heard from you.
The Marquis delaFayette, and a detachment of light infantry, from the whole of the N____ Army, passed by here two days Since; the object, Arnolds post; but the departure of the French Ship of War and frigates from Chesapeak for Rhode Island, will possibly convert it into a reinforcement to Genl Greene. The French Ships carried into Rhode Island ten prizes: of which two or three were Stout privateers, also the Romulus of 44 Guns & 500 British-this is certain.
The Confederation was finally ratified on Thursday last. Major Deveaux who intends shortly for Berkely county, will furnish me an opportunity of Writing more at large and commencing that regular correspondence from which I will draw much Satisfaction and use.
I am pleased with the Expectation of Seeing you in Philadelphia the beginning of April, by that time important Events will await our Southern operation.
Please to introduce my Respectful Complemts. to Mrs. Gates, and Believe me Dr. General, with much respect & attachment, yr. faithful & Obed. Serv, Richd Howly
In the begining of January last, before I left head Quarters, I advised the Commander in chief, to Send Brigadier General Knox of the Artillery to the four New-England States to allarm them on the defection of the Pennsylvania line, as well as to draw their attention by that event to the important military Concerns of the United States. The Brigadier is a man of Sense and observation, so that his Judgment may be relied on; and as he is a native of N.E. and well acquainted with the people of that Country and with the means of geting information, no question remains in my mind of the truth of the Communication he has made to me, of the result of His mission. To his report I can with great truth add that I am persuaded on the best evidence, that every man in the State of New York who were in earnest & risqued every thing in opposing the British Tyranny in the first Stage of the Contest, are now Zealously attached to the independency of America, and the Alliance. For your Excellency Satisfaction I have taken the Liberty to [su]bjoin to this an Extract of His Letter to me on the Subject.(1) I have the Honor to be with great respect, Your Excellency's most obt and most Humble Servant
(1) Not found, but Gen. Henry Knox's February 7 report to Washington on the mission is in the Washington Papers, DLC. Knox undertook this mission to the four New England states upon receiving Washington's January 7 instructions on the subject, for which see Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:66-68.
Saturday. Not being in Congress I did not hear the debates of this day but the only question of importance was "that those Members who had served three years were now by the Confederation inellegeable(1) but the question was lost by passing off without a
(1) The question involved an interpretation of Article 5 of the Articles of Confederation which specified that "no person shall be capable of being a delegate for more than three years in any term of six years."JCC, 19:215.
Your Excellency will be informed by the enclosed Act of the third Instant of the Measures Congress have adopted for the Removal of the Convention Troops into the State of Pennsylvania.(1) The like Information is transmitted to Governor Lee, & the President of Pennsylvania.
I have also informed Governor Lee, that should your Excellency find it necessary to order the Prisoners taken at the Cowpens to move Northward through Virginia, as intimated in your late Advice to me, He (Governor Lee) must consider them as included with the other Prisoners and give Orders accordingly.
It is necessary that the Executive of Maryland, or the Commanding Officer have seasonable Notice that they may be prepared to receive the Prisoners when they arrive on the Borders of Maryland.
I have the Honor to be, with very great Respect, your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam Huntington President
(1) This resolve was adopted in response to a Board of War complaint of its inability to implement Congress' February 24 order for removing the Convention Army prisoners from Virginia, which had been referred to committee on February 26. The resolve herewith transmitted to Governor Jefferson contained details of how responsibility for the removal should be shared by Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania officials, which had been worked out by the committee and drafted by chairman Joseph Jones. See JCC, 19:195-96, 229-30; Huntington to Jefferson, February 25; and the following entry.
For the unsuccessful effort of the Pennsylvania Council to prevent the removal of these prisoners into the state, in part from concern that the "very great Proportion of disaffected People already among us...will...greatly increase by an Intercourse with the Prisoners," see Pa. Archives, 1st ser. 8:745, 757-58.
By the enclosed Act of Congress of the 3d Instant (1) your Excellency will be informed that all the Convention Troops both in Virginia & Maryland are to be removed to Yorktown & Lancaster, or such other Places in the State of Pennsylvania as the Executive of that State shall assign for their reception: and the State of Maryland is requested to superintend the removal, Safe keeping & Supply of the German Corps, from Nolands Ferry on Potowmack, and the British now at Frederick town, through Maryland to the Borders of Pennsylvania, and to continue the Guards until the British Prisoners arrive at Yorktown & the Germans at Lancaster, or such other Places as the Executive of Pennsylvania shall appoint for their reception. The Supplies both for the Prisoners & Escort are to be furnished by Pennsylvania after they arrive within the Borders of that State.
If the Prisoners taken by Genl Morgan in the Action at the Cowpens should be removed to the Northward through Virginia, it is necessary to include them also.
I need not point out to your Excellency the Necessity & Importance of supplying a sufficient Guard, & especially a Commanding Officer equal to the Task, to prevent Desertion or any other Impediment to the Execution of these Orders.
I suppose the Prisoners in Virginia are now on their Way to Nolands Ferry, as Governor Jefferson hath already advised me that the Situation of Affairs in that State compelled him to put them in Motion; and I have desired him to give your Excellency the earliest Notice of their Movement, that a Guard might be ready prepared to receive them at the Borders of Maryland.
It will also be necessary that President Reed have previous seasonable Notice of the Time when the Prisoners will enter the State of Pennsylvania.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with very great respect, your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
(1) See the preceding entry.
(2) For some of the efforts of the Maryland Council to comply with this congressional request, see Md. Archives, 45:353-55, 357-58.
I have herewith enclosed the Copies of two Acts of Congress of the
I have the Pleasure to inform you that Captain Tilly after he left the Bay on his return to Newport captured the Romulus, mounting 44 Guns & pierced for 50 and carried her into Newport.
I have the Honor to be, with very great respect, Sir, your most obedient Servant,
Sam Huntington President(2)
(1) See JCC, 18:854-61, 1118. Steuben had written to Secretary Charles Thomson on February 2 explaining that he had belatedly learned from General Washington that Congress had finally adopted a new "Plan for the Department of the Inspection," and requested a copy of Congress' resolutions on the subject. PCC, item 164, fol. 214.
(2) This day Huntington also wrote the following brief letter to the marquis de Lafayette, who had just passed through Philadelphia enroute to Virginia on March 2.
"While your Station shall continue between this & General Greene's Head Quarters, you will take the Liberty to open any public Despatches from him addressed to the President of Congress, in Order that you may obtain the earliest Intelligence from him, which may be of Importance." PCC, item 15, fol. 247.
We have been for some days past in the most impatient expectation of hearing that the Virtue and ardor of our Countrymen had put a stop to the Progress of Cornwallis, and a period to his handfull of men with which that adventurous Knight Errand had dared to traverse the Southern States, and (as if bidding defiance to our Patriotism and Courage) has with three thousand troops thrown down the Gauntlet to forty thousand at least, who are nearer to him than he is to any support. Good God! Shall it be said that this man has dared to Venture near three Hundred miles from the Sea Coast and above two Hundred from any of his Posts and shall be permitted again to return! I cannot believe it. It is said we want Arms-Has not every Peasant in Virginia & North Carolina a Gun? with what weapons were the Battles of Bunkers Hill, Bennington and Kings mountain fought. But I will not dwell on a Subject which affords so much Chagrin. I will suppose that the Spirit of America has again roused and that Saratoga is revived at the Saura Town.(1) I have been unwearied in my applications for a Maritime force from Rhode Island and should in my last have informed you that I had at last obtained it through the French Ministery-but was afraid to trust it to paper as it was so profound a secret that no one in Philadelphia except him & myself knew it was saild untill we had reason to expect it had arrived. Altho it had not all the desired effect
The Confederation was Signed and completely ratified on Thursday last, and was accompanied with every demonstration of Joy by all ranks of People in this Place. I thought I had acknowledged the Rect. of yrs. enclosing Col. Masons Sentiments.(3) I have little doubt of the Grants being accepted by Congress on the terms mentiond in the act of Cession which I see nearly corresponds with those in that Paper. I believe the Covert manoeuvres of the land Jobbing Companies are so well known, and so fully discoverd, that few of their abettors will be hardy enough to oppose it in its fullest latitude. Congress seems at this time more Unanimous, and less torn by factions than (from the best Information I can obtain from the oldest Members) it has ever been since its first meeting. I am clearly of opinion if the Intelligence you give of the hostility of the British against the Danish Ships be true; that the next Spring must unfold the designs of the Armd neutrality [to] their fullest extent and that Britain's Sun of Glory will set in the ocean never to rise again. We have a report-which comes from the Havannah-Martinique, & Hispaniola to Boston in short Passages that D'Estaing has taken six of Admiral Hoods Squadron of the line & three frigates & forty five of his Convoy for the West Indies. This is all the news at pr[esent] Current. You will be pleased to offer my respects to your Brother Arthur, from whom I have in vain expected a letter for some time past. I am happy to hear he is well. We are informd that the assembly has voted three Pounds Virginia Currency per day for the delegates. If so, I can assure you it will bring such as have families, and live in any manner suitable to their station, with the Utmost oeconomy, above one Hundred Pounds per Annum in debt, exclusive of traveling home once a year which is a recess from business. I think not unreasonable. I hope by the next Post to have my acct. of expenditures made out, ready to be laid before the assembly. Adieu & believe me to be Dr. Sr., Yr. most obet. Set.
Theok Bland
(1) Sauratown, Upper Sauratown, and Lower Sauratown were Indian trading posts on the Dan River in North Carolina north of Guilford Courthouse.
(2) See Virginia Delegates to Samuel Nightingale, Jr., December 30, 1780.
(3) "Col. Masons Sentiments" have not been identified.
I do myself the Honor herewith to enclose for your Excellency's Amusement, a Plan proposed by an ingenious Gentleman to be adopted for sinking the Continental Bills of the old Emissions.(1) If the Inhabitants of any State are disposed to bring in & exchange their Quota of those Emissions at the rate of seventy five for one, the Plan appears plausible & ingenious at least in Theory.
I have also enclosed the Copy of a Letter just come to hand from the Governor of Virginia,(2) which contains Intelligence more favorable from the Southward than we had of late received. Indeed the Situation of Affairs in that Quarter have been for some Time & yet are critical. Very important Events must soon take Place.
I have the Honor to be, with the highest respect, Sir, your most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
(1) Not identified.
(2) Undoubtedly Thomas Jefferson's February 26 letter to Huntington, for which see the following entry, note 1.
I do myself the Honor to forward the enclosed Despatches from General Greene, also the enclosed Copy of a Letter from Governor Jefferson which contains the latest Intelligence received from the Southward.(1)
Perhaps the enclosed Letter addressed to your Excellency, (supposed to be) from Governor Jefferson, may contain similar Intelligence.(2)
By the enclosed Copy of an Act of Congress of the first Instant your Excellency will be informed that the Confederation is finally ratified by all the States.
I have the Honor to be, with the highest respect, your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
P.S. Your Excellency's Favour of the 27th Ulto was this Day received.(3)
(1) The enclosed letters from Nathanael Greene consisted of two of the same date (February 15) to Huntington and to Washington. See PCC, item 155, 1:577, item 172, 1:55-58. For the enclosed February 26 letter from Thomas Jefferson, see Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:12.
(2) This February 26 letter from Jefferson to Washington is identical to. the letter of the same date from Jefferson to Huntington identified in note 1.
(3) This letter, which was referred to the Board of War this day, is in PCC, item 147, 6:255-58. See JCC, 19:230.
Doctor Winship went for Boston this morning in a Carriage and was so kind as to take two small Packages which I made up of Articles for Mrs. Adams, Mr. Wibert, Col. Peabody, Yourself and my Daughter.(1) In a Letter-Form he has yr. Loan Office Certificate with the Interest in Bills of Exchange, yr. Rufffles and the Edging, which he is to deliver into yr. Hands or to Mrs. S A Otis. Mrs. Lovell, in opening a small Bag will find a Bundle in brick colored Paper for you. I put up yr. damaged Cambrick and your undamaged silk Handkerchief with yr. injured muslin dos. I could not impose anything more on the Doctors Goodness than what I have done or I would have added something belonging to you with a few Articles for Mr. Cranch. I will omit no good Opportunity of sending the whole.
We have nothing of Decision from the southward that can be depended on; for, tho' Govr. Jefferson writes on the 26th that Cornwallis was retreating as rapidly as he had advanced, yet he mixes some Circumstances that we know are not true. Genl. Green wrote on the 15 that he himself had crossed the Dan without any Loss of Men or Baggage, but that he was not in condition to oppose the Enemy at all the Fords which would that Evening be passable and therefore he should not attempt to do it at any-that the militia were not coming to reinforce him and some were even leaving him-that his own Troops were in fine Spirits though they might be tracked by their bloody Feet. Govr. Jefferson says Cornwallis was retreating towards Hilsborough, and that Genl. Caswell was in his Rear with 4000. I think this probable from knowing Caswell's Influence; but it is a vi[le] toryish Country from Hilsborough to Cape Fear so that the 4000 will not grow. The Enemy are 3,250, but, if actually on the Retreat, the Hessian Brigade will as usual lose mach of its Strength by Desertions.
Mulenberg was within 4 miles of Newport with 4,000 and his advance within 1/4 mile he had two mortars and had picked off several Centinels and taken some Waggons. He thinks he shall be able to give a good account of Arnold. Baron Steuben had left that Quarter, and gone with 500 Continentals and some Rifle Men to strengthen Genl. Green.
Perhaps a more regular acct. will be in the Print Tomorrow.
I am not very well, and have other Letters to scratch.
Doctr. Jones is just in from a Kick up (2) and tells me Col. Bird's Wife of Virginia (Mr. T Willen's Sister) is goaled as a Traiteress in League & Correspondence with Arnold.
Yr. affectly, J L
(1) Concerning Dr. Amos Windship's custody of these packages, Lovell wrote the following letter to Abigail Adams this day.
"Doctr. Winship left this City Today and has been so kind as to take into his Care two small Packages. I could not impose more on his Goodness. I hope they will escape Thieves and all Injury from Wet or Rubbing. I have cautioned and he has promised. You will find at Mrs. Lovell's or Mr. Smith's after the Doctr. reaches Boston, a Package in a very coarse Wrapper. It contains yr. Band Box, your Gauzes, yr. striped Persian and your Gloves, yr. Threads and yr. Tambours Cotton. Mrs. L. will find in a small Bag a few Articles for Mr. Wibert with some for Mr. Gerry. My Daughter's straw Trunks have also a little parcel for Mr. Wibert with something for Col. Peabody. It would have afforded me much Pleasure to have been able to send all the small Articles for my Friend Cranch, Mr. P. B. Adams, Mr. Tuffts & Mr. Wibert. If I do not soon find a Chest Conveyance I shall as the Weather mends the Roads find frequent private Opportunities for small Parcells.
"I am not very well; and it is too late to detail News, and the opportunity of Carriage is not that by which I chuse to say the great Deal I have to say about our Friend in Holland. He is doing well I am persuaded." Adams, Family Correspondence (Butterfield), 4:88.
(2) That is, a noisy get-together or disturbance.
When we came to do business this Morning it was proposed by the President that Congress Should determine What number of States in Congress assemblad are Competent to do business. This brought on a long and Learned debate. It was Argued by Mr. Duane of N.Y., Mr. of Connecticut,(1) Mr. Madison of Virginia, Mr. Lovel, of Masachusets, Mr. Root (2) & Mr. Witherspoon of Jersey and Mr. McKean of Delaware-That, as the Confederation had enumerated Sundry things Which Should Not be done but by the Assent of nine States-And that no other question (except for Adjourning from day to day) Should be determined unless by the Votes of a Majority of the United States in Congress Assembled.(3) It was evident that the
(1) Rodney was probably referring to Oliver Wolcott, who represented Connecticut with Samuel Huntington and Jesse Root. Root is mentioned elsewhere in the same sentence, and Rodney is unlikely to have confused Huntington's identity because of his position as president.
(2) Rodney repeatedly misidentified Jesse Root as a delegate from New Jersey in his diary. Although Root was a 1756 graduate of the College of New Jersey and married Mary Baker of Newark, N.J., he was a citizen of Connecticut his entire life. DAB.
(3) Rodney was referring to that section of Article 9 of the Articles of Confederation that enumerated the actions of Congress requiring the assent of nine states and covered all other actions with the statement: "nor shall a question on any other point, except for adjourning from day to day be determined, unless by the votes of a majority of the united states in congress assembled."JCC, 19:220.
For the continuation of the debate on this question, see Rodney's Diary, March 6, 1781.
(4) That is, Wolcott.
I had Yesterday the Pleasure of receiving your Letter of 21 Feby by the Post. The Attention you have given to my recommendation of Major Clarkson (1) is very obliging. Besides his Merit as an officer, I confess, a Desire that all Strangers of Reputation should meet with Hospitality in Boston, has moved me to make that gentleman as well as others known to my Friends there. Some Persons who have not been acquainted with that City have imbibd an Opinion of the Inhabitants as being illiberal, severe & inhospitable. I cannot imagine what could give Rise to this opinion, for I have always thought they deservd a different Character, and it has gratified me much to hear it said by Gentlemen who have made a Tour that Way that the People are remarkeably civil & polite. It may be a Peice of good Breeding in my Friends to speak as handsomely as they can, to me of my native Town. They indeed often tell me that I discover a Partiality in nothing so much as in regard to the Citizens of that Place. I own there may be some Grounds for their thinking so, for I am sensible of the strongest Attachment & the warmest Affection, & those Feelings a Man cannot easily hide. I hope there will always be found in Boston, at least as much Urbanity as in any other City, in the Judgment of Men of true Taste, but I wish the Time may never come when his Manners shall be such as to recommend them to the unprincipled & profligate.
I thank you for your kind Intention of sending me a Quintal of fish. It would have been Luxury to our Southern Friends, but as I design very soon to return to Boston, I shall not have the pleasure of partaking of it with them.
I really think you have been hardly dealt with, in the Instance you mention in your Letter. It is difficult always to account for the opinions of Men even in Matters which nearly affect the Interest of Individuals. I am affraid mistaken Principles have been adopted to your Prejudice which may hereafter appear when it may be impracticable to do you Justice.
Inclosd is the Newspaper of the Day. The Letter from Richmond of the 26 Feb. is from Govr Jefferson of Virginia. We have just recd one from Genl Green dated the 15th mentioning his crossing the Roanoak which divides Virga & N Carolina, & that Ld. Cornwallis was on the other Side waiting for an opportunity to ford.(2) The Distance from Richmond is about 120 Miles & a good Road. The Govrs Letter is dated 11 days later than the Generals, in which Space, Circumstances m[igh]t have taken place as is therein alledgd. The Govr is a Gentn of great Prudence & not apt to be deceivd. A Detchmt [ofl 1500 Troops commanded by the Marquiss de la
Be so kind as to acquaint Mrs A that I have recd her Letter of 21st Ulto & that I am in good Health.
(1) For Adams' "recommendation of Major [Matthew] Clarkson" to this unknown correspondent, see Adams to Elizabeth Adams, February 1, 1781, note 1.
(2) See Samuel Huntington to Washington, March 5, 1781, note 1.
We have nothing further of D'Estaigns success. It is probable the sudden departure of the French Ships from our Bay will disconcert the operations agt Arnold-abt 1500 Men, (21 Compys. from so many Regts of the main army) pass'd by this place last Thursday in their way to Virginia. The Marquis de la Fayette who has the Command of them is I hope by this time with you.
The French ships which were in our Bay arivd at New Port the 24th Ulo-they took ten prizes, two of them of considerable force, on their return the Romulus of 44 Guns peirc'd for 50 fell into their hands-they took in all 500 prisoners. The America a British 64 Gunship, which was Oblig'd by the Storm to put to Sea, from Gardiners bay is returnd to that port.
As I know how uncertain Your intelligence from Virga is, I send you the enclosd (1)
I am with great esteem Yr. Excellencys Mo Obt Ser,
Danl. Carroll
(1) Not found, but probably a copy of Thomas Jefferson's February 26 letter to Congress, for which see Samuel Huntington to Washington, March 5, 1781, note 1.
I recevd my dearest polly, your affectionate Letter by this days post. The Circumstances of our publick Affairs have demanded the Attention of every man in publick Trust, in an eminent degree, especially of those whose long experience in business has acquired them Confidence and the Means of being useful. It must be obvious to you that we must be ruined unless a Successful period is put to the
You know the Integrity of my Heart and the Candor of my Mind; and you may rest assured that it is impossible you can wish more ardently for my return than I do to embrace my dearest polly and our beloved Children. I am pleased with our Son's proficiency. I have in a late Letter told you how much I lament the Loss of his preceptor. What you mention of our little darling pleases me. Why did you not say something of our Sally? But I am happy to know she is well. I much approve of your retaining the Nurse. And I entreat you not, by any means, to dismiss her. We shall find means to make it her Interest to continue her Charge when I return home. You are Anxious to know when that will be and I will satisfy you as well as I can. Brother Robert and his Lady will set out in the Course of five or six weeks and I mean to accompany them-and shall by degrees withdraw myself from Business to be prepared for that Event. Harry
Our Southern affairs wear a promising Aspect. Lord Cornwallis is retreating after a rapid march in pursuit of the Prisoners taken from his Army by General Morgan to no purpose. There is the greatest probability that he will share the Fate of Burgoine. Arnold who is Entrenched at Portsmouth in Virginia appears to be in greater danger: but we must wait the Events of War in anxious Sollitude.
Cornwallis followed General Green's small Army which has been assembling since Gates's defeat upwards of 330 or 340 miles, from Cambden in South Carolina to the Borders of Virginia. The Retreat of Greene gave the Militia an Opportunity of Collecting, And they were becoming formidable. Cornwallis now saw his danger and retreated back as fast as possible and General Greene with his Army and the militia are in pursuite of him, and he has besides a large body of militia in his front who will interrupt his progress. So soon has the Scene changed and such is the Fortune of War!
Our daughter is in good health. She Joins me in wishing sincerely to be with you and in affectionate Respects to all our Friends. Kiss and bless for us our dear Children; And believe that no Absence or distance will abate the unalterable Affection and Fidelity of my dearest Polly, your Affect. Husband,
Jas. Duane (1)
(1) Duane wrote another letter to Mary on March 11, primarily discussing domestic affairs but also reporting that "we are in daily expectation of agreeable news from the Southward which will have a decisive Influence on our Affairs. Great Exertions have been made and are making to reduce both Cornwallis & his Army in North Carolina & Arnold & his detachment in Virginia to the Condition of Burgoine and the prospect in both Cases is the most flattering....it is reported here that Mr Peter du Bois & Mr Helmes a Lawyer are come out of the City of New York & surrendered themselves. It is certain that once more the Inhabitants of that City are filled with Terror on the prospect of our Successes & some disagreable news from England." Duane Papers, NHi.
I have received your Letters of the 10th & 1 5th Ulto and forwarded your Despatches to Genl Washington.(1) I am happy to receive the earliest Intelligence from the Southward, but, in your present Situation, ever readily excuse your not multiplying Duplicates of the Intelligence.
You will receive enclosed a Copy of an Act of Congress of the 1st Instant, by which you will be informed the Articles of Confederation are finally ratified by all the States.
It will be proper to announce this important & happy Event to the Army when Circumstances will admit.
I have also the Pleasure to inform you that Moylands Corps & the Pennsylvania Line, except such as are on the western Frontiers, are ordered to join the Army under your Command;(2) and heartily wish this Measure had been sooner adopted.
I have the Honor to be, with very high respect, sir, your most obedient servant,
Sam. Huntington President
(1) These February 10 and 15 letters to Huntington are in PCC, item 155, 1:561-64 577-79. Only a copy of the latter is presently located in the Washington Papers, DLC.
(2) The February 20 congressional resolve ordering the troops of the Pennsylvania line to Virginia had actually exempted Col. Stephen Moylan's dragoons from the order, but in a February 27 letter to Huntington that was read in Congress this day, Washington recommended that Moylan's corps be recruited and remounted and included in the order. The suggestion was apparently endorsed by Congress when Washington's letter was read and referred to the Board of War this day, although Secretary Thomson failed to record the decision in the journals. See JCC, 19:177, 230; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:306, 314, 415, 431.
I have been honored with your several Favors of the 8th, 17th, & 26th Ulto,(1) And have it now in my Power to inform you, that Monsr. Tilly with the small Squadron under his Command has left the Bay & arrived at New-Port the 24. Ulto, on his passage having captured the Romulus, a 44 Gun Ship but pierced for 50 & carried her into Newport.
And you may daily expect a Reinforcement in the Bay both of Troops & Ships, Wind and Weather permitting; but this Should remain a Secret until they arrive.
The Delegates from Virginia it is presumed, will give your Excellency more particular Intelligence of this Reinforcement.
I have the Honor to be with great respect, Sir, your Excellency's most obedient Servant, S. Huntington
(1) These letters are in Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 4:559, 638-40, 5:12.
Miss Livingston (1) informed me a few days ago, that in a letter she received from you, you mention you had received no answer from
Our preperations for a final ratification of the Confederation, have suspended for a time our plan of finance. Our constitution being so materially changed, that we have felt a little awkward in our new gears; however we have got pretty well used to them now, & have again entered on business.
I hope our new constitution will prove the means of introducing a more clear & perfect understanding between Congress & the States. And whilst the first continue to confine themselves within the strict limits of their authority, the latter will conceive themselves bound by the most sacred ties implicitly to support them. The want, hitherto, of a proper line to be drawn between Congress, & the states, has been the cause of numberless embarrassments: for whilst the States were left ad libitum, some would do a great deal, some a little, & others scarcely anything. The evil consequences resulting from this conduct are apparent. My expectations are highly flattered by this important event, & anticipate in my own mind the most happy consequences resulting from it.
The return of the French fleet to Rhode Island I suppose you are acquainted with. This must of course frustrate the Marquis's expedition.
We have not heard from the southward since the 10th ulto. but we are in hourly expectation of an express from thence. We have just received dispatches from the So. ward which inform us, that Cornwallis is retreating, that Genl. Caswell had collected 4000 North Carolina Militia in his front, & 6000 Virginians were in his rear. This looks well, & probably some important stroke may be made at him before he gets back. Genls. Mughlenburgh & Nelson was laying close siege to Arnold at Portsmouth with 4500 men. They had advanced to within a mile of his works with two mortars.
Their advanced posts were within a qr. of a mile of each other-but the dog can get away by means of his shipping, unless the French fleet can prevent him. I am Dr. sir, with the most perfect Esteem Regard, yr. most Obedt. Servt. Jno. Mathews
(1) Probably Livingston's daughter Catharine, for whom see Mathews to Catharine Livingston, September 12, 1780.
(2) For his reply to Livingston's letter of February 6 enclosing a letter for Charles W.F. Dumas, see Mathews to Livingston, February 12, 1781.
I received your favor of the 26th Ulto. the 1st inst.(1) In answer thereto, I beg leave to observe, That all the gentlemen now prisoners at St. Augustine, were either acting as officers in the militia; or as private soldiers, at the time they were made prisoners. And I cannot conceive they can be looked upon, in any other light, than that in which they acted at the time of their captivity. Indeed by the capitulation of Charles Town, this is a point clearly decided. I conceive when the people of a country, lay aside the characters of citizens, and assume that of soldiers, through the whole course of the accidents of war, they are to be considered according to their military rank only, that of the citizen being absorbed in that of the soldier.
For instance, all the British officers taken in America, who have been members of their parliament, or House of Lords, have not been considered as such, at the time of exchange, but simply in the ranks they have held in their army. Genl. Burgoyne was a Governor, he was never considered in all the Cartels that have been propos'd in any other light than as a Genl. officer. Several other officers, I believe, have held civil commissions, independent of their seats in parliament.
From these considerations, I cannot think Sr. Henry Clinton, can have an Idea of holding those gentlemen at St. Augustine, by any other characters than those they respectively held in the military line at the time of their capture. Should your Excellency find this objection started by Sr. H. Clinton, in the course of your negotiations, I think Congress should be immediately acquainted with it, that they might be enabled to take their measures accordingly.
If they can bring any criminal charge against those gentlemen, let them exhibit them. And if the charge is proved, they must suffer, if not, it is high time, that justice should be done them. Congress cannot with honor, longer delay it. A speedy exchange, has hitherto been the only cause of it's being suspended.
I am, Dear sir, with the highest respect & every sentiment of the most sincere Esteem & regard, yr. Excys. most Obedt. servt.
Jno. Mathews
(1) Washington's February 26 letter concerning the difficulty inherent in negotiating the exchange of prisoners at St. Augustine because of their "eminence in the Civil line" is in Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:303. For Congress' recent instructions to the commander-in-chief on the exchange of prisoners, see Samuel Huntington to Washington, January 2, 1781, note 1.
This Morning the Subject So Much debated Yesterday Came on the Carpet again (1)-but all the Members being Tired out With the debate and Concluding it Would be unsafe To Make any final determination on a Matter which So Materially affects the freedom and Sovereignty of the respective States Generally Agreed that the Rule of their Conduct Should be Not to go upon any business but When Nine States at least are represented in Congress-And Not to pass any Vote but with the assent of Seven States at least Untill otherwise Determined, When all the States are represented-and upon this Rule we proceeded to business.
The Deligates of N.Y. Moved that the memorial from there State Should be Taken up Which requested that Congress Would recommend it to the respective States To repeal all Laws Making paper Money Legal Tender, or that they Would permit that State to pay of the Certificates Which had been given for Supplies With the New Money-or that they Would furnish Money to pay of those Certificates &c. or that they Might be ordered to Exchange the New Money for the Old &c.(2) Doctr. Weatherspoon opposed this Motion and Said that it Tended to increas the paper Money in Circulation if they were permitted to pay of the Certificates in that way-And a member from Connecticut (3) Observed that they had Called in all the Old Money in that State by Tax-and it Would be hard Now that it Was in great part Collected that they Should be Obliged on Account of New Yorks Application To give the New Money out for the Old, which would be Taking to Much from the Treasury-And oblige them to be at the Expence and delay of Collecting another Tax as the old Money Must be distroyed and wou'd Serve to pay the army or purchase Supplies-postponed Till Tomorrow.
General Vernon of Rhode Island, Then Moved that Congress Should appoint a Committee to Draw up a Code of Laws giving Congress full power to punnish All their Own officers And that it Should be recommended to The United States to Confirm the same. This Motion was at first opposed but the Committee was afterwards agreed to & the Debate reserved Till they Report (4)-another Grasp.
1 The "Subject" was the question of whether Congress could take action through a majority of states present and voting or whether the vote of nine states or seven states would be required. See Rodney's Diary, March 5, 1781, note 1.
2 New York's January 17 "Memorial" for financial relief had been presented to Congress on January 29, when it was referred to a committee which had reported to Congress on March 2. The committee's report on New York's proposal to repeal legal
3 That is, Oliver Wolcott.
4 Rodney apparently confused a motion made this day by "General Vernon of Rhode Island" [i.e. James M. Varnum] with one made by Theodorick Bland, for which See JCC, 19:235-36. It is clear that Bland's motion was an attempt both to revive and revise a portion of the February 16 report of the committee chaired by John Mathews that had been appointed the preceding December to consider the proceedings of the Hartford Convention. That committee had recommended that civil officers "amenable" to Congress be held responsible for "offences and delinquencies committed by them whilst in office" and proposed that a three judge court be established "for the tryal and determination of all causes relative to offences committed...in the civil departments." The committee's report was debated and recommitted on February 24. See JCC 18:1141, 19:155-56, 190; and PCC, item 33, fols. 419-21. Bland proposed this day "that a Committe be appointed to prepare a Code of Laws and devise a Jurisdiction to take Cognizance of all the Civil officers acting under the orders of Congress, and to render such officers amenable thereto for Malpractices in office or neglect of Duty." See PCC, item 33, fols. 422-23. This motion was referred to Mathews' committee on the Hartford Convention proceedings, but there is no evidence that it ever submitted a revised report to Congress. Its deliberations were probably superseded by the work of the committee appointed this day at the recommendation of James M. Varnum, for which see Varnum to William Greene, March 16, 1781, note 3.
Mr. Barney Father to Nathan Barney of your regiment has been with me for a Certificate respecting his Son who he Says is Detained after his Time of Enlistment is Expired on Account of his having Deserted. I am not able to remember the Tenor of the Pardons published by me while in Command at Rhode Island. If it was General & without any Conditions or Exceptions Expressed, he ought not in my opinion to be held, as it would be a breach of Faith. But if he returned & agreed to Comply with any Conditions rather than risque the punishment Due to the Offence he ought to be held to the agreement. But if he was Suffered to return & Enter on Duty without being brought to Comply with the Conditions or at Least brought to Tryal he ought not in my opinion To be held.
This I Say upon a General view of the matter; not being able to recollect particulars & I doubt not your wish will be to Comply with the Intentions which we then had in view. I will Take the Liberty to add that if he returned before the Pardon & was permitted to go on Duty that no punishment can regularly be Inflicted or advantage taken of his Desertion.
I am most respectfully, Dear Sir your most obedt. Servt,
Jno Sullivan (1)
1 Below Sullivan's signature, the following endorsement by Gen. Benjamin Lincoln, dated April 16, 1781, appears: "In my opinion as the lad mentioned above did not sign an inlisting paper he cannot be held."
I am honored with your favor of the 19th Ultimo. As you and I seem to be agreed respecting a medium & as I have no reason to Dispute your opinion respecting my abilities as a Financier unless I should Depart from my usual method & Strive to obtain a Judgment against myself I shall not Trouble you with any Comments on that part of your letter.
The War Department you Seem to avoid giving an opinion upon. I can Guess your Sentiments only from your placing the refusal in the Last Stage of your Letter. I have generally observed that Luzernne will State a matter in Every point of view always reserving for the Last that point in which they wish the Question to be taken. If I am right in this Your Sentiments & mine Coincide & I Shall not be Liable to abuse for Serving my Country, or part with the Sweets of Domestic Life for an office which Depends on the will, the Caprice or the Fancy of Individuals. The Choice of this officer is however postponed.(2) The news of the City is that Lord Cornwallis pursued General Green to Dan River which Green Crossed, that the militia Gathered round on all Sides which oblidged his Lordship to retreat & Green is in pursuit of him. This Comes by a Letter from the Governor of Virginia & is Confirmed by a number of others all Dated the 26th of Feby.(3) They all agree that his retreat began the Twenty first of Feby and I have no reason to Doubt but I have Some Apprehensions that this is a Maneuvre to bring General Green to an Action. Your Assembly has been pretty well worked up by Mr Olcutt to Act Just as New York would wish them & have given me Instructions Accordingly (4) but I must obey & they must Look to the Event. I beg you will make my Compliments agreable to Mrs Langdon & believe me to be with great Truth & Sincerity, Dear Sir Your most obedt. Servt. Jno. Sullivan
1 The dateline is badly faded, but Sullivan probably wrote this letter on March 6, when he wrote letters of similar content to Meshech Weare and George Washington, and after the March 5th reading in Congress of Thomas Jefferson's February 26 letter, herein discussed by Sullivan.
2 For the postponement of "the election of a Secretary at War...to the first day of October next," See JCC, 19:205; and the following entry, note 4.
3 See Samuel Huntington to Washington, March 6, 1781, note 1(not in printed text).
4 See Sullivan's letters to Meshech Weare of February 5, notes 3-5, and of this date.
I was Duly honored with your Excellencys favor of the 4th of Feby (1) & omitted writing since upon a Supposition that you had gone to Rhode Island. I am happy to find your Excellency Entertains the Same Sentiments of the virtues and abilities of Colo Hamilton, as I have Ever Done myself.(2) After I wrote your Excellency I found The Eyes of Congress Turned on Robert Morris of this City as Financier. I did not therefore nominate Colo Hamilton as I foresaw that it would be but a vain attempt. I Shall this Day nominate him as Secretary of Foreign Affairs on which I Think I Shall meet the Approbation of most of the States.(3) The Choice of a Minister of war is postponed to the first of October. This was a Maneuvre of Saml Adams & others from the North, fearing that as I was in nomination, the Choice would fall on me who having apostatized from the True New England Faith by Sometimes voting with the Southern States am not Eligible. They were not however acquainted with all the Circumstances. I was nominated against my will & if Chosen Should not have Accepted.(4)
General Mc Dougle is appointed minister of marine.(5) The plan of Finance & all other matters go on So Slowly that I Tremble at the Consequence. I am mortified at the useless harangues which Consume our Time to no purpose. I am now Endeavoring to obtain an Adjournment of Congress & for Leaving a Committee to Transact the Business as the only way of having the Publick Business Done with propriety and Dispatch.(6) I fully agree with your Excellency That Congress ought to have more power but I also think that the old members Should be in Heaven or at Home before this Takes place.
The Traffic carried on with the Enemy is alarming as it not only Serves to furnish them with necessaries but Tends to reconcile our Citizens to the Idea of renewing their Connection with Great Britain and of Course Disaffects them to our Government.
Since General Greens Letter of the 15th February we have received advices from Governor Jefferson & Divers others that Cornwallis is retreating that General Green Crossed the River in pursuit of him the 21st & that the Militia had Collected all round him: I hope it is not a Maneuvre to bring General Green to an Action.
I have been Settleing my Accounts with the Treasury Board & find I Stand Charged with Money received at Cambridge to pay the Bounty to the New Hampshire recruits in 1776. All my papers were Lost at New York & I can remember Little of the matter. This I am Sure of That I never received any publick money but what I immediately applied to the use Intended.
Perhaps Colo Harrison has Some papers which will Settle the matter. I also am Charged with the money paid for the Troops Engaged at Trenton in December 1776. I remember the whole of this was Settled at Morristown about two months after & I received a receipt in full which is in New Hampshire. Perhaps your papers may Save me the Trouble of Sending for it.
I have the Honor to be with the High[est] Esteem Dear General yr most obedt Ser[vt], Jno. Sullivan
1 Washington's February 4 letter to Sullivan is in Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:181-83.
2 Washington had described his aide Alexander Hamilton in glowing terms: "there are few men to be found, of his age, who has a more general knowledge than he possesses, and none whose Soul is more firmly engaged in the cause, or who exceeds him in probity and Sterling virtue." Ibid., p. 181.
3 No nomination for "Secretary of Foreign Affairs" was entered in the journals on March 6; nor had Hamilton been nominated on January 17 when the names of Robert R. Livingston and Arthur Lee were placed before Congress for that post. JCC, 19:65.
4 The reasons given for this postponement varied widely. Sullivan's view that his candidacy was the principal cause was shared by James Mitchell Varnum. Although Ezekiel Cornell, a member of the Board of War and former congressional delegate, wrote on February 19 that he expected "that General Sullivan will be Elected to the head of the War Office in a few days," Varnum later explained to Washington that the election has been postponed "to get rid of the Embarrassment" of Sullivan's nomination. See Staples, Rhode Island, pp. 329-30; and Varnum to Washington, August 20, 1781.
In contrast to Sullivan's assessment of Samuel Adams' motive in opposing his election, the French minister La Luzerne believed that Adams' opposition was based on principle rather than personal animosity, explaining to the comte de Vergennes on March 25 that Adams feared that transferring such power from congressional committees to executive departments headed by independent officials would undermine the authority of Congress. Correspondance politique, Etats-Unis, 16:6, Archives du Ministere des affaires etrangeres. And Philip Schuyler explained the postponement to Washington on April 3 in the following, very different terms: "The motives which led Congress to postpone filling the War department have leaked out, and been communicated to me. General Gates was in nomination; but his friends reflecting that the impropriety of appointing him before he had exculpated himself from the imputation of misconduct in his command, would be too glaring an abuse of power, deferred it, in hopes that, by an acquittal, the public confidence will be restored to him." Washington Papers, DLC.
For Washington's consternation over Congress' refusal to fill the post, which for a time he believed would go to Schuyler, see Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:261-62, 360, 374.
5 See Samuel Huntington to Alexander McDougall, March 2, 1781.
6 For this effort, see John Sullivan's and James M. Varnum's Memorial, February 28; and Thomas Rodney's Diary, March 2, 1781.
As I mentioned to you in Former Letters my Suspicions respecting Colo Olcutts (1) being Either a Friend to New York or at best a mistaken one on the part of New Hampshire I now take the Liberty of inclosing you Copy of his Petition to Congress Delivered in Feby. 1780 Signed by him and Bezal. Woodward; by which it will appear that he was one of the first if not the very first mover for Taking away a great part of New Hampshire and annexing it to New York.(2) This together with his Joining with New York in having their favorite Question determined would alone have been Sufficient to place him in a Suspicious point of Light: but I had other Reasons. This will Easily Account for his not being able to Collect any real Sentiment respecting Vermont & for my Conversing with him in a manner which appeared most Likely to Draw forth his real Sentiments. I am no Less mortified Than Surprised that this Should be Looked upon by the assembly as a breach of Trust or a Deviation from my Instrictions (which I have Learned by Private Letters from New Hampshire). The Events which have already taken place by pursuing his Plan & the Reasoning in my Late Letters will Either Serve to Justify or Condemn the measures which I have Adopted. The Least attention to the Resolves of Congress will prove at Least how much it would be against the Interest of New Hampshire to have the Question respecting the Independency of Vermont first Determined, for Congress Long Since Resolved That The Inhabitants of that Territory Should Submit to the Jurisdiction they were under before the Commencement of the War. Now the Decree of the King and Council having given New York the Jurisdiction in 1764 & New Hampshire not assuming a Jurisdiction over them afterward it is inevitable that that resolution if Complied with would have placed those people under the Jurisdiction of New York. And if this Question So warmly argued by New York is first Determined a Decision making it Independent will Destroy the Claims both of New York & New Hampshire. But if the Determination Should be That it is not & Shall not be an Independent State will not the Decree of the King and Council & the former Resolution of Congress operate to fix them to New York untill New Hampshire by wading through a Tedious Dispute can Convince Congress or at Least a Committee of it That the Decree of 1764 was Erroneous. This will Throw the Onus upon New Hampshire and perhaps a Final Decision will be Delayed untill the Art of New York in the Exercise of their power reconciles the minds of the People to their Government-& renders an Acquisition of this Territory to New Hampshire more Difficult.
These are my Sentiments respecting the views of New York (3) & the
I do not mention These things to [hold] up the Idea of Deviating in the Least [degree] from my Late Instructions but as a Justification of my Conduct prior to the receipt of my Late Instructions.(4)
I have the honor to be, with respect your most obedient Servant,
Jno. Sullivan
1 See Sullivan to Weare, February 5, 1781.
2 For further information on the February 7, 1780, "petition" of Peter Olcott and Bezaleel Woodward and the status of the Vermont controversy in Congress at that time, see James Lovell to Samuel Adams, February 1, 1780, note 1.
3 The "views of New York" on the Vermont question were stated in the letters of the New York Delegates to George Clinton, March 11, and Alexander McDougall to Clinton, March 12, 1781.
4 The New Hampshire delegates had been instructed on January 13 to seek a "speedy decision respecting the claim of this State to the New Hampshire Grants." N.H. Slate Papers, 8:884-85. Although the journals are silent on the point, Sullivan did move at this time to seek a determination on Vermont's claim to independence, according to the testimony of the New York delegates, for which see New York Delegates to George Clinton, March 11; and Alexander McDougall to Clinton, March 12, 1781.
The Minister of France having imparted to Mr. Jones as Chairman of a Committee appointed to confer with him (1) on Some Secret matters the intentions of Ct. Rochambeau and Mr. Destouches explained in the inclosed note,(2) we thought it of such consequence that your Excellency should be certainly apprized of them, that notwithstanding the probability of the communication being made through some other channel we determined to guard against all risk of failure by despatching one of the established Expresses. As the success of the Enterprize may depend much on secrecy of preparation, and celerity of execution, We beg leave to intimate to your Excellency, that it is the wish of the Minister that no persons should be admitted to a knowledge of it, from whom it can be justifiably concealed, and that such military Stores, particularly heavy cannon & mortars, as are in the hands of the state and will be wanted for a siege may be in readiness to go forward at a moment's call. The Minister also wishes that some supplies of provision, of beef especially, for the French troops may be included in your general preparations. We are with great respect, Yr. Excelys. obed. hum Servts. Jos. Jones
Jas. Madison Junr.
1 At La Luzerne's request Jones and four others had been appointed on March 2 to confer with the minister on the progress of French naval operations. See JCC, 19:224-25; PCC, item 95, 1:184 85; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:271.
2 The "inclosed note" has not been found, but it was undoubtedly a report that Admiral Destouches intended to sail from Newport with his entire squadron and 1,100 French troops to operate against Benedict Arnold's forces in the Chesapeake. See Lafayette, Papers (Idzerda), 3:357, 363, 388. See also Samuel Huntington to Jefferson, this date.
By the Act of Congress herewith enclosed your Excellency will be informed that Samuel Patterson & John Thompson Esquires are appointed Commissioners on the Part of the United States, to endorse the Bills that shall be emitted by the State of Delaware pursuant to the Act of Congress of the 1 8th of March last.(1) I have the Honor to be, with very great Respect, Sir, your most obedient Servant, Sam. Huntington. Presidt.
1 For this March 6 appointment, See JCC, 19:235. For a similar appointment (on May 28) for which no presidential letter of transmission survives (authorizing Tench Francis to sign such bills issued by Pennsylvania), See JCC, 10:571; Pa. Archives, 1st ser. 9:185; and Pa. Council Minutes, 12:740.
The motion Made Yesterday by the Delegates of N.Y.(1) Came on the Carpet again to day. Upon enquiry into the Journals of Congress it appear'd that the States Were at Liberty to exchange the new Money for the Old at any exchange not less than 40 Old Dollars for One new one So that the Motion Was reduced to this-"Will Congress give the State of N. York permission to pay of[f] the Certificates in that State with the new Money?" (2) Mr. Burk & Mr. McKean Urged that to permit this Would be Subverting the Intention of the Resolution of the 18th of March Unless the Old Money Was first drawn in. Mr. Weatherspoon & Mr. Bland Spoke to the Same purpose. Mr. Duane Said that it was out of the Power of N. York to call in the Old Money by exchange or Taxes because it Was Not in the State-That the inhabitants had let the Army have all their produce, for Which they only recd. Certificates-So that now they had neither Money nor produce to git it with, That these
He was Seconded by Genl Sullivan & Mr. Root of Jersey (3) Who insisted on permission for useing the new Money to pay of those Certificates &c.
But Mr. Burk replied and urged the keeping of the publick faith as held forth in the Resolution of the 18th of March-So that When the question Was put it passed in the negative.
A long debate also arose to day on a report of the Treasury board-Whether Congress Should pay Sundry Iron Masters for Shot and Shells on Bills on France at 4/6 Specie for 4/6 Sterling. Genl. Sullivan and several others Urged this to be done upon the Principle of establishing the Credit of the States. Mr. Burk & Mr. McKean represented this as ruinous to the Publick to give Sterling for Currency. The debate was long & Tedious but afforded Nothing very instructing-it passed in the negative.(4)
1 See Rodney's Diary, March 6, 1781, note 2.
2 "The Motion" was not reported in the journals.
3 That is, Connecticut.
4 This "long debate" was not reported in the journals, but the treasury report on payment for shot and shells had been read in Congress on March 6 and referred to the Committee of the Whole. After debating the question on several occasions, Congress voted on March 19 to pay the ironmasters for shot and shells in bills drawn on the American minister at Versailles. See JCC, 19:204-5, 234-35, 254, 263, 278-79.
According to the Order of the day Congress Resolved itself into a Committee of the Whole upon the Subject of finance-Attending first to generl. Pickerings Letter informing Congress that the Tender Laws put it out of his power To pay his Specie Contracts according to their real value in Current Money.(1)
The Whole Congress at once agreed that We ought to pay all our debts Honestly and that the Tender laws obliging people To Take paper Money at a rate above its Current Value was pernishous. Yet
"Whereas the United States in Congress Assembled, being Convinced that Honesty is the best police in publick, as well as private, affairs are determined to conform faithfully To the Golden rule of Equity & Justice-Therefore
Resolved that all the debts and Contracts now due, or which May hereafter become due from the United States, to any person or persons whatsoever (being first liquidated according to the real value of the Money Lent or Contracted for, at the Time of Lending or Contracting) Shall be paid in Specie or an equivalent in paper Money, Computed at its current not legal Value When paid: Any thing heretofore done to the Contrary notwithstanding.
All persons Acting under the Authority of the United States are required To Take notice of this resolution & Govern themselves accordingly. And that the officers of the United States, may not be prevented from discharging their Several duties under the above resolution, or Offend against Any Law or Laws of the respective States Making paper Money legal Tender-Resolved that it be recommended To the respective States to revise and repeal all those Laws-As in the opinion of Congress they are greatly prejudicial to the Interest of the United States and Tend rather to depreciate than Support the Credits of their Money-which Cannot be done effectually but by providing Sufficient funds of Specie by Taxs or Otherwise, for the purpose of redeeming & Sinking it".
1 See JCC, 19:245. Rodney was referring to Timothy Pickering's March 3 letter to President Huntington, which is in PCC, item 192, fols. 49-56.
2 These resolutions are not recorded in the journals, but they may have formed the basis for similar resolutions molded in the committee of the whole and adopted by Congress on March 16.JCC, 19:266-67.
Caractors of Some of the Members of Congress.
His Excellency Samuel Huntington President is a Man of a Mild, Steady & firm Conduct and of Sound & Methodical Judgment tho
General Sulivan, of Newhamshire has been in the Army from the beginning of the War, has a good Idea of Publick affairs-is of Honest Political Sentiments, desirous of Supporting the credit of the States, and doing Justice to their Servants-he is generally cool & firm with an appearance of diffidence in debate, generally keeps to the point in question, but does not possess any great poli[ti]cally abilities; Such as are necessary To Take into view Such an Extensive Systematical arrangement of things as is Necessary in So extensive a government.
Samuel Adams of Massachusetts has been in Congress from their first Meeting has a pretty general knowledge of their affairs and is particularly attentive to every thing that affects his own State or friends; he is neither elloquent nor Talkative; but having the full command of his passions, and possessing a great deal of caution and Court cunning he is fitted for a politician in every Case Where great and good abilities are not requisite.
General Varnum of Rhode Island is a Man about Thirty, of florid habits-he has read Some little in books, is fond of Speaking & Spouting out every thing that his reading has furnished him With Whether apt or not to the purpose-his Temper & Councils are very precipate and but little calculated to be useful in Such an Assembly, he is very desirous of inlarging its powers.
Mr. (2) Of Connecticut appears To be a man of Integrity, is very candid in debate & open to Conviction and does not want abilities; but does not appear to be possessed of Much political knowledge.
Mr. Duane of New York has been in Congress from the first-Is of good & even Temper, Attentive To business, of a low soft Voice, not Elloquent, nor designing, but upon the Whole a good republican, desirous of promoting the general Weal and particularly attached to the Interests of his Own State.
Doctr. Weather Spoon of New Jersy is A man in years perhaps 70 of the New light Presbeterian Order-Is possessed of a good Share of knowledge in books and the Languages; Speaks With a low and broken Voice in the Scotch Accent; And has all the design and arch Cuning that is necessary or practiced in an assembly of the kirk of Scotland-But does not seem To possess Much of that Candid integrity, Honesty & Wisdom Which is necessary in the Governing an Honest Confederacy.
Mr. Root-of Jersy (3) is a Man that Seems to be Without passions and therefore has a Capacity to Conceal the Most artful designs under the Most Specious Shew of Candor, and plausible Arguments yet his language is So Weak & innervate that he Seldom Succeeds in
Doctr. Montgomery of Pensylvania is a Man possessed of a good Share of reading and knowledge & is an Agreeable companion in private-has an apt Memory and a fertile imagination-Yet is Vain, fond of power & governed in publick Council by capricious Whims.
Mr. McKean of Dalaware, now Chief Justice of Pensylvania-has been in Congress from the first-is a Man of Talants-of great Vanity, extremely fond of power & entirely governed by passions, ever pursuing the Object present With Warm enthusiastic Zeal Without Much reflection or forecast.
There is none from Maryland that may be particularly distinguished at present.(4) Therefore I Take notice of a Mr. Madison of Virginia, Who with some little reading in the Law is Just from the College, and possesses all the Self conceit that is Common To youth and inexperience in like cases-but it is unattended with that gracefulness & ease which Sometimes Makes even the impertinence of youth and inexperience agreeable or at least not offensive.
Col. Blann (5) of Virginia is a Man of Moderate Talents, of firmness & Candor and Much Attached To the Constitution of the States-Tho not very Systematical nor always of the best Judgment and is rather rustic in debate.
Doctr. Burk, of N. Carolina, tho not equal To Many Who have been in Congress, May Justly be Stiled the ablest And Most useful Member there at present. He has been in Congress five Years, is very Attentive and well Acquainted with business-is Nervous tho Not Eloquent in his language, he is Correct and pointed in his debates, possesses the Honest integrity of a republican and is for preserving inviolable the rights of the people Without being lured away by power-Yet he is Some times not fully guarded from Dictatorial language and does not Attend Sufficiently To System, order and Arrangement, in a general view but Confines himself Too Much To particular Objects.
Governor Bee of South Carolina, is a Man of Some Talents, of a cruid restive Temper, not Eloquent but of a harsh & disagreeable dilivery; consiquensial in his deportment and Conceited in his notions-very desirous of Order in the House, but Most abt to transgress it himself.
Mr. Mathews Chief Justice of S. Carolina, is a Man of Tallants and More Agreable in his Address as well as language-but has an interuptive Maner of Speaking not Well adapted to Command attention-is undesigning and possesses a goodeal of Candor, Which leaves him open To Conviction-and upon the Whole is a good republican.
Governor Howley of Georgia is a Man of great reading and knowledge Which he generally displays without System or design Staying far from the object in question, so that he often leaves it in doubt What side of the question he is on. He is loud but not very eloquent, therefore rather excels in Declamation than Argument-and of course is not Closely attended to-but when he entertains the House With Strokes of Wit or Spouts of knowledge. He would Shine more in a Democratic assembly.
The rest of the House May be Thrown into one Group of inferior Talants, Mostly young, inexperienced, & unconnected in any regular political Views.
The Judicious Will See by this exhibition of Caractors-That the affairs of the United States in Congress are not Conducted by the ablest Talants and Men of the first Abilities, therefore Will Not be found agreable to the rules of unexceptionable Wisdom. Neither are they Conducted by the Most True, disinterested & amiable Spirit of Patriotism. Yet Congress Considered Collectively possesses a firm & Independant Spirit-With a determined & Unalterable resolution To Support the liberties of America. And the selfish Conceit and Opinions Which Most of the Members possess has in Some Measure the effect of the Most disinterested Patriotism, because it occasions them To disagree in every thing but those measures Which is notoriously for the good of all. Yet this disjointed manner of proceeding throws government into that disorder'd Tract of adopting one expedient after another perpetually by Which Means the States have lost their Credit, and Congress that Confidence which the People ought to have in their Wisdom.
Therefore it is To be wished That Congress Would ad System, order and arrangement Well Organized, To the Honesty and integrity of their Measures-And I trust now that the respective powers of Congress and the States are prescribed & Marked out, these improvements will soon begin to Take place.
Indeed it is not much to be Wondered at that this has not Taken place before. Such a Variety of interests as their Must be among a people forming thirteen Independant States extended over a vast Tract of Country, and only connected by political Ties, requires Much Time & experience To reduce them To Systematical order, and so To Organize and arrange them as to be Sutable and agreable To a people So jealous of their Liberties as the Americans are-And So as to give no reason of complaint to one part of the Community against another.
But I am pursuaded a Noble, Honest And generous love for Mankind, United With a firm and unalterable attachment for our Country, Together With a Virtuous Mind, relying in the favour and blessings of Providence Will lead us To this at last-And by its
1 Although it is unclear exactly when Rodney wrote these "Caractors" of members of Congress, they appear in his diary immediately after his March 8 entry and just before his summary statement of activities between his March 10 departure from Congress and April 10 return.
2 Oliver Wolcott. The other Connecticut delegates were Samuel Huntington, whom Rodney described as president, and Jesse Root, whom Rodney repeatedly misidentified as from New Jersey.
3 That is, Connecticut. See Rodney's Diary, March 5, 1781, note 2.
4 Daniel Carroll and John Hanson were representing Maryland at this time.
5 That is, Theodorick Bland.
At a Time when Congress have affairs of great Public importance before them, some apology is necessary for taking up a moment of their Time with the concerns of an individual, and I hope my particular situation will plead my excuse especially as I shall put this application on such a footing as to preclude all debate.
Near three years ago I was, without my knowledge appointed an assistant Deputy Quarter Master General on the Communication to Fort Pitt, & the appointment was made in such a manner that I thought myself obliged to accept of it altho' it interferred with my private business, & would not have been my choice if it had not. Last spring a Company of Artillery were added to Fort Pitt, with a Quantity of Military and other Stores under their Care. There was an urgent request from the Board of War to the Quarter Masters on the Line to forward them to the utmost of their Power, tho there was great difficulty in complying with this request, as we not only had no Money; but were greatly in Debt, and not having paid according to our Contract no Person would give us credit on the Public acount-the consequence of which was that not only that Company & those Stores; but also the Stores that were sent up the Pennsylvania Road & were detained all winter by the deep Snow; would have remained where they were, altho the army under Col. Broadhead were in the utmost distress for the want of them, had I not borrowed Money & given my personal security, to forward them, as well as to defray the expences of the Detachment that was sent down to guard the Stores detained on the Pennsylvania Road all winter-as the forwarding these Stores had been so warmly urged by the Board of War & as I knew the absolute necessity there was that this Should be done without delay, I hesitated not a moment. But I will candidly confess that had I believed I should have been put to such difficulty in being
"That on the application of Charles Pettit A.Q.M.G. on Account of Major Genl Greene late Q.M.G. a Warrant issue in his favour for thirty thousand Dollars to repay a like sum borrowed by Col. Thos. Smith ADQMG to enable him to forward the Stores & Artillery under the direction of Capt. Craig to Fort Pitt & for which the said Major Genl. Greene late QMG is to be accountable." The Warrant issued but I have not yet obtained the Money nor do I know when I shall-the consequence was that being determined to comply faithfully with my Contracts I sold a Tract of Land & paid the whole I had borrowed: of other Debts due to me, I should blush even to give a hint that I wished any preference, while I have the honour of a seat in Congress; and as for Wages as it was not for the sake of any that I undertook the business, my demand on that account shall be one of the last made for similar services. I think it an honour that I have impaired my private Estate while in public service even tho' I had a very beneficial Practice, at a Time when others who had no Estates have created large ones-under these circumstances, I submit to the consideration of Congress the propriety of ordering a Warrant to Issue in my favour on Thomas Smith Commissioner &c for 750 Dollars of the new Emissions as an Equivalent for the said Warrant being 1 for 40, which will be far from being of equal value to me as the service mentioned in the first warrant would have been had I obtained it when I ought; nor will it be of one third part of the value of the Land I parted with by reason of my not obtaining it. The justice of this request will be acknowledged by all-but if it should be thought not consistent with Policy as well as founded in justice & equity, I wish not to have it complyed with. My feelings would be more hurt by having any preference, than by having my request rejected-for this reason I have not spoke to any of the honourable Members to say a word on the subject-and I now request your Excellency, that if it causes a minutes Debate you will on my behalf withdraw this application.(1)
I have the honour to be, your Excellency's most obedient and very humble servant,
Thomas Smith
1 Smith's application was referred to the Board of Treasury on March 16. Upon
Your Excellencys Letter of the 20th of December, was refered to a Committee of which I have the Honor to be one.(1) We yesterday gave in a Report which being read appeared Satisfactory to Congress as no objection was made to it. I moved That previous to its being Considered it might be refered to your Excellency for your opinion upon which it was recommitted; and The Committee Instructed to Consult your Excellency upon it. I Therefore take the Liberty of Inclosing your Excellency a Copy of the Report and of requesting (in behalf of the Committee) your opinion upon it.
The first Paragraph is agreeable to the Line of promotion which your Excellency was pleased to point out: But as it could not be Extended to Hazens Regiment & others in Similar Circumstances the 2d Resolution became Necessary.
The Third & fourth respecting the Artillery and Cavalry are Liable to Some objections but much Less so than any other which Suggested themselves to the Committee.
The Promotion of Brigadiers & Major Generals comes nearer to that of rising in the Line of the Army than any which has yet been Adopted or Suggested, and any other would be attended with Insuperable Difficulties-That of Suffering the States to have officers according to the number of Troops furnished would prove injurious to officers of the Smaller States & Even if they were to Stand Intituled to promotions when they became the Senior officers In the Line of the Army. Their promotion would be uncertain as they would Constantly have to Combat with the Interest of States & the Caprice of Individuals to obtain it.
The Committee will Thank your Excellency for your Sentiments upon Every Paragraph of the Report (2) and beg you to give the Date of Colo Tilghman & Doctor McHenrys Entering the Service.(3)
In behalf of the Committee, I have the honor to be with the Most Lively Sentiments of affection and Esteem Dr Genl. your Excellencys most obedt Servant. Jno Sullivan, Chairman
P.S. The Clause respecting volunteers will prevent the Army from being Commanded by illiterate Serjeants which must inevitably be the Case in a few years if Some Such mode is not adopted. J.S.
1 For the committee appointed on January 1 to consider Washington's December 20 letter, respecting the promotion of Continental officers, see Sullivan to Washington,
2 Washington's lengthy remarks "upon Every Paragraph of the Report," which he enclosed in an April 4 letter to Sullivan, are in PCC, item 152, 10:43-52; and Washington, Wntings (Fitzpatrick), 21:403-10. These became the basis for the revised report submitted by the committee to Congress on May 9 and adopted on May 25, for which see PCC, item 152, 10:57-62; JCC, 20:491, 539-42; Sullivan to Washington, May 17 and 28; and Samuel Huntington's second letter to Washington of May 28, 1781.
In his letter to Sullivan explaining his "remarks" on the report, Washington tactfully observed that "where I have been unfortunate enough to differ in sentiment from the Committee I have, in as concise a manner as I was able, assigned my reasons for it." Washington, Wntings (Fitzpatrick), 21:410.
3 For his response to the query concerning the date of commissions for Lt. Col. Tench Tilghman and Maj. James McHenry, the 9th and 10th items submitted for Washington's consideration, see ibid., p. 406; and JCC, 20:541.
I forward Gazettes, Journals & some particular Resolves, by Way of Amsterdam. (1)
The Arrival of the Ariel has given us Dispatches from you, long expected-of June 1st, Aug 9, Decr. 2d & 3d.(2)
Congress had, before the Receipt of your Letters Feb. 19th, written to Mr. Adams Jany. 10,(3) and signified their Concurrence in Opinion with Ct. de Vergennes as to the Time & Circumstances of announceing his (Mr. A's) Powers to Gr. Britain. They had also on Decr. 12th (4) expressed their Sentiments upon his Letter of June 26th inclosing to them his Correspondence relative to the Act of the 18 of March for calling in the old Paper Money. I send you Extracts from the Journals for your fuller Information on those Points. And I shall forward, yet for a Time, all Acts of Congress intended for your Guidance whenever they are finished. But I most earnestly look for the Appointment of a Secretary for foreign Affairs, agreably to their Determinations of Janry. 10. Such an Officer may authoritatively communicate his Opinions, and in many Ways make your Station more easy & reputable to you than it can have been under great Want of Information of our Circumstances.
Your most humb Servant, James Lovell
1 Lovell undoubtedly enclosed copies of the resolves of March 9 concerning the American victory at Cowpens, S.C., and a resolve of that date directing a committee to consult with the French minister about the destination of the frigate, Ariel. JCC, 19:246-48.
2 These letters to President Huntington (along with duplicates of March 4 and May 31, 1780, letters which had been received previously) were read in Congress on February 19, 1781. See JCC, 19:174; and PCC, item 82, 1:259-78, 287-96.
3 See Samuel Huntington to John Adams, January 10, 1781 (not in printed text).
4 See Committee for Foreign Affairs to John Adams, December 12, 1780.
You will herewith receive Gazettes and Journals; also a Resolve respecting the compleat Ratification of the Articles binding these 13 States as a confederated Body.(1) The Delay of that Business appears now like all the other Circumstances of our Rise & Growth: For, the present is really the best of all Times for that particular Event. Our Enemies have been ripening themselves for this capital Mentitis.
We have no Letters from you or Mr. Carmichael later than those mentioned in my last a Copy of which attends this.(2)
I am, Sir, Your Friend and humble Servant,
James Lovell
1 See JCC, 19:213-14.
2 See Lovell to Jay, February 20, 1781.
I was honored with your Excellencys favor of the 2d Instant, covering an act of Congress of the 27th Ultimo, by which I am elected Secretary of the Marine.(1) Permit me, Sir, through you, to express my Gratitude to Congress, for this additional honor and mark of their Confidence. If any new incentive was necessary to bind me to America, or to increase my Zeal, for her Safety and Glory, this would be a powerful one. It is however a great Satisfaction to a Freeman; especially a Servant of a Republic; to have the approbation of its Representatives.
I am fully impressed with a due Sense of the importance of the Office. My Silence therefore till now, is owing to a mature Consideration of the duties of it, and my relation to the army, in the present State of our public Affairs, which I hope will plead my apology.
Upon full Reflection on the duties of the Secretary of the Marine, and the probable extent of them, during the War; I am persuaded, I can discharge them without interfering with my Command, in the field, in the active part of a Campaign. I cannot therefore in the
I wish to explain to Congress, the Subject of this Address more fully, than can be done in the Compass of a Letter.
I have the honor to be with great Respect, Your Excellencys most obedient & most humble Servant. Alex M Dougall
1 See Huntington to McDougall, March 2, 1781.
2 Congress referred this letter on March 12 to a committee consisting of John Mathews, Meriwether Smith, and James M. Varnum who submitted a report on the 29th substantially endorsing McDougall's appeal to be permitted to retain his rank as a Continental major general while exercising the duties of the newly created office of Secretary of Marine. Congress rejected the committee's recommendation the following day, however, resolving finally that since McDougall was unwilling to relinquish his command in the army to undertake the new appointment they "do not therefore expect his acceptance of that office." He accordingly returned to his military command in May after receiving a request from General Washington to do so. He had stopped attending Congress with the ratification of the Articles of Confederation on March I and did not resume his seat as a delegate after declining the proffered marine office. See JCC, 19:253, 326-27, 332-34, Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:80n.10; and McDougall to George Clinton, March 12, 1781, note 1.
Having Experienced so much Ingratitude myself I cannot help feeling for those in Similar Circumstances. I Therefore take the Liberty of mentioning to your Excellency Colo Derrick who I think has Sacrificed much in our Cause and has Experienced only Ingratitude in return.(1) He first Entered in the Pensylvania Line as Captain, was afterward Transfered to the Artillery & perswaded by General Mifflin to Enter the Quarter Masters Department as a place which would be most Serviceable to the Interest of these States. He afterward received a Lieut Colonels Brevett & was then Sent to Holland to promote our Interest in that Quarter & after having used Every Effort in his power & Spent Large Sums of money to answer the End in view he now Experiences the Loss of Rank, the
As your Excellency has the appointment of Officers in Hazens & Some other Corps, and as by the Report herewith Transmitted your Excellency has the power of Calling reduced officers to Act in the Inspectors Department perhaps you may find it in your power to do him that Justice which Congress have neglected to do. His zealous Endeavors to serve the Common Cause in the Expedition against Rhode Island in 1778 when he Acted as a volunteer & Served on his own Expence induces me to wish that Something might be Done for him.
I have the Honor to be, with much respect yr Excellencys most obedt Servt, Jno Sullivan
1 For Jacob Gerhard Diriks' inability to secure a vacancy in the Continental Army, although he had been granted a brevet commission of lieutenant colonel as compensation for his efforts to promote a Dutch loan, see William Churchill Houston to William Livingston, May 20, 1780; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:26768. For his return to Holland after learning of the final rejection of his appeals, see Samuel Huntington to John Adams, May 21, 1781.
By the enclosed Copy of an Act of Congress of the 5th Instant you will be informed that your resignation is accepted, and you will be entitled to a similar Allowance for past Services with other Officers in the like Station & Department.(1)
And that at present it is recommended to the State of Massachusetts, to advance you two hundred & two Dollars in Bills of the new Emission, of which I have informed his Excellency Governor Hancock.(2)
I am Sir &c &c &c, S.H.
1 Congress adopted this resolve pursuant to a February 28 recommendation of the Board of War, to whom Barber, "commissary of military stores at Boston," had directed a request to resign on February 11, 1781. See JCC, 19-232; and PCC, item 147, 6:221-26. For Barber's subsequent complaints that the enclosed resolve contained a slight error in the pay due him, an explanation Congress apparently ignored, see PCC, item 78, 4:171-74, 24144; and JCC, 20:504-5, 21:911.
2 Huntington enclosed this same congressional resolve in a brief cover letter to John Hancock of this date, which is in PCC, item 15, fol. 249.
By the enclosed Copies of the 3d & 5th Instant you will be informed that Doctor J. Craick is appointed Chief Physician & Surgeon to the Army & Doctor W. Burnet Chief Physician & Surgeon of the Hospital. (1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c. S.H.
1 JCC, 19:230, 233. Huntington's letter of this date to James Craik notifying him of his appointment is in PCC, item 15, fol. 250. For the appointment of William Burnet, a New Jersey delegate to Congress, see Burnet to Huntington, February 28, 1781, note.
You are directed to publish in general Orders the enclosed Act of Congress of the 9th Instant, in Testimony of their Approbation & Esteem, merited by the Fortitude & good Conduct of Brigadier General Morgan and the brave Officers & Men under his Command displayed in the Action at the Cowpens in North Carolina the 17th of January last. (1)
I have the Honor to be, with very great respect, Sir, your most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 For the adoption of "the enclosed Act," which was the work of a committee to which Greene's initial report on the Battle of Cowpens had been referred on February 8, See JCC, 19:129, 24547. In addition to Gen. Daniel Morgan, who was to receive a gold medal for his conduct at the Cowpens, other officers singled out for special recognition were Col. William Washington, Col. Andrew Pickens, Lt. Col. John Eager Howard, Maj. Edward Giles, and baron Glasbeck.
I was honord with Yr. Excellency's favor last night (1) and have as far as my time wd. admit complied with your desire-But not being personally acquainted with Majr. McPherson,(2) and not knowing where he was to be found-I have enclosed the letters(3) to Yr. Excellency, and must request the favor of you to forward them to him. I have no doubt but that the Gentn. to whom I have
Theok. Bland
1 Not identified.
2 Maj. William McPherson of the Pennsylvania Line, who had recently been assigned to the southern army, had applied to Congress on February 28 for three months pay to "enable him to repair to General Greens Head Quarters." He had requested an immediate reply "as tomorrow is fix'd for his departure." Congress read McPherson's memorial that day and referred it "to the Board of War to take order the resolution of the 4th January notwithstanding."JCC, 19:207; and PCC, item 41, 6:229-30. McPherson became aide-de-camp to Benjamin Lincoln in June 1781.
3 Not identified.
The representation which your Excellency transmitted to Congress on behalf of our State after a deliberate commitment and report has for several days engaged the attention of Congress;(1) the second proposition which you state for our relief (to wit) to issue the new bills in satisfaction of Commissary and Quarter Master's certificates was recommended by the Committee as the most eligible; but they did not propose it as a partial but a general indulgence extending to all the States.
On making an estimate of the probable amount of those certificates in the different States it was supposed that if they should be discharged on that principle, the Act of the 18th of March would be effectually frustrated. The Report was therefore almost unanimously rejected,(2) as a very capital dependance for carrying on the approaching campain is placed on the four tenths to arise to the public from the new emission.
The first proposition to advance money to our State in discharge of the Commissary and Quarter Master's certificates-however just and reasonable is put out of question, the exhausted State of our Finances rendering it totally impracticable.
The last expedient is attended with all the difficulties and inconveniences suggested by your Excellency, and cannot be embraced without operating greatly to the detriment of public credit and deeply injuring the new money. Other States, as North Carolina, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut were not restrained by the prohibition of Congress from adopting this project. It has given them temporary relief, and this seems to be all they consulted. For nothing is more certain than that if they issue only as much State
Congress however are fully convinced of the distresses and sufferings of the State of New York, as well as of their Spirited and expensive exertions in the common cause. And since they cannot afford us relief, they will not be displeased at any measures which the Legislature may think fit to adopt to extricate themselves from their present deplorable circumstances.
And if the emission of paper State money appears to the Legislature to be the only or best remedy for those pressing evils, it ought not to be rejected.
There can be no doubt but the requisitions made on our State must undergo a revision; Congress see the necessity of it. Indeed when the quotas were fixed, we apprized the Committee (of Estimates and Ways and Means) of our inability to contribute so largely under our present misfortunes. But finding it would lay a foundation for much altercation, as other States might claim a reduction of their quotas, it was thought most advisable to wait for the representation of the Legislature, as a ground for reasonable abatements. Nothing can now be exported from our State but what the Legislature shall judge compatible with their distresses: but care ought to be taken to point out what you cannot supply, that it may be required from the other States.
We ought not to omit mentioning that your Excellency's representation was communicated to the Assembly of Pennsylvania by the Committee to whom it was referred, with the approbation of Congress.(3) It was expected that this Assembly from motives of justice might have been prevailed on to advance money out of their Treasury to pay for flour which they and not we ought to have supplied. But it is reported to be out of their power, and a great waste of time is the only effect which has been produced.
A repeal of all Tender Laws is under consideration.4 The Quarter Master complains that they have effectually closed all the avenues to credit and confidence. The citizens will not part with their property while they are compellable to take paper in payment, which is not worth its nominal value.
It is probable that another measure will soon be adopted. A late law of Pennsylvania will not permit the old Continental money to be taken in, under Seventy five dollars of the old, for one of the new emission. The Act of New Jersey directs that the old money shall be paid in at its current value compared with specie.
An Act of Maryland in effect nullifies the bills of the old emission, after the period by which they ought to have been called in by taxes. These measures introduce such inequality and confusion, and open
If our State should think proper to pass a law similar to that of Pennsylvania or New Jersey, and Congress should take decisive order to bring in the old emission, it may be taken for granted, that when Pennsylvania shall have issued their proportion of the new money, the people of that State will be glad to exchange at your Treasury, on the same terms as others had in their own, rather than suffer the old emission to sink in their hands. This event would furnish our State with the means of issuing the new bills under vast advantages, as 75 dollars of the old would enable us to put in circulation near four of the new, and the debt of 200,000,000 dollars would be cancelled almost insensibly.
We have executed the trust reposed in us by the Legislature respecting the Western Territory within our State.(5) From the manner in which this business was conducted it was left to us make the cession without a formal treaty with Congress. We therefore availed ourselves of the discretionary clause of our instructions, and have limited the State by a western boundary which, if there is any correctness in the maps must include the whole of Lake Ontario, and more considerably than twenty miles west of Niagara, and our Northern boundary we have limited by the forty fifth degree of N. Latitude. But lest it might possibly happen that this Western Boundary should fall short of the ultimatum assigned by the Legislature, we have made their ultimatum itself an alternative in that case in the words in which it is expressed in the instruction.
Virginia demanded in consideration of the cession she made, which consists of her claim to the Northwest of the Ohio, an explicit guarantee by the United States of her remaining jurisdiction. If we had in express terms made the same condition, it might have been liable to a construction that we were seeking a benefit, instead of conferring a favor; and yet it would have been imprudent to bind our State in a special guarantee of the jurisdiction of Virginia, when our own was not secured in the same manner. We therefore thought it necessary to connect our cession with an Act which subjects it to the ratification or disallowance of the Legislature, unless our State received the same guarantee from the confederated States as any other of its members which have or shall make cessions of territory for the common benefit.
We flatter ourselves that this precaution, though not directed by the Legislature, will meet with your Excellency's and their approbation. The authentic copies of the declaration and instrument of cession are herewith transmitted.
The government of New Hampshire has lately pressed Congress
Our Southern operations wear the most promising aspect. General Cornwallis is retreating, the country armed on all sides of him, and General Greene in pursuit; in several Skirmishes we have had the advantage. Arnold is not in a better Situation, as the Virginians, supported by Some Continental Troops will speedily be reinforced by the Marquis de la Fayette at the head of 1200 light infantry.
We hope soon to send you agreeable intelligence from those armies, which will have a decisive influence on our affairs. The collection of papers which are enclosed will communicate the particulars of our Southern operations and all the news.
We have omitted two important objects of your Excellency's representation, the defence of our frontiers, and a provision for the Oneidas. Your Excellency knows that the Commander in Chief has unlimited authority to direct the operations of the war, and to dispose of the troops at his pleasure.(8) And we are confident his sensibility and his particular regard for our State will induce him to take every measure for our protection which your Excellency may recommend as necessary. The Oneidas, we hope, are by this time in Some measure relieved, as the Commander in Chief acquaints the Board of War, that the clothing he had to spare would, he hoped, be sufficient for the present to make them comfortable.(9)
We are most unfortunate in the importation of our clothing: Colo. Lawrence and Colo. Palfry who are lately gone to France (10) on publick business have this necessary Article in Charge And we hope they will be able to send it forward. There is nothing gives Congress so much pain as the delays & too probably the sinister designs & frauds which have exposed our Army to nakedness & distress: At a time when a considerable Quantity of Clothing was actually purchased We can't entertain a doubt but if these Supplies arrive our Oneida freinds will have a Share. At present while it is impossible to Cover our own Army they cannot expect to be provided for as their sufferings & their merit require.
We have the Honour to be, with the utmost Regard & Respect, Sir, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servants,
Jas. Duane
Will. Floyd
Alexander McDougall
1 Governor Clinton's February 5, 1781, letter had been read in Congress on February 14 and referred to the committee that had been previously appointed to consider a similar January 17 letter of New York legislative leaders Pierre Van Cortlandt and Evert Bancker. The committee's report was subsequently discussed in Congress on March 2-3, o-7, and 9; the decisions of Congress are explained in this letter to Clinton. JCC, 19:145, 206, 225, 230, 236, 241, 249.
2 See Thomas Rodney's Diary, March 7, 1781.
3 See JCC, 19:206.
4 See Rodney's Diary, March 8, 1781.
5 The New York law of February 19, 1781, ceding a portion of its western lands and the formal papers of cession signed by the New York delegates had been presented to Congress on March 1, 1781.JCC, 19:208-13.
6 See John Sullivan to Meshech Weare, March 6, 1781.
7 See Alexander McDougall to Clinton, March 12, 1781.
8 At this point in the FC Duane wrote and then crossed out the following sentence: "Congress will not interfere in the Campaign nor do I think you woud wish them to interpose, nor can it be Necessary."
9 For General Washington's February 23 letter to the Board of War concerning clothing and provisions for the Oneida Indians, see Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21 :284-85.
10 Remainder of text taken from the FC in Duane's hand.
[I have] receiv'd by Post both your favors of the 9th. One inclosed a sum of money as underneath, which falls short 200 Dollars of what is mentiond-Pray be so Kind as to particularize the denominations of the several Bills you may herafter send.
I shall forward the articles I have, or shall procure for you by Col Forrests man, who will return with Capt Stoddard as soon as he can finish his business at this place. The Large Bearskin Portmantau which I have to send down will carry them safe from bad weather.
Forrest left me in Lodge Alley where I still remain. I am determind to leave it as soon as I can & to make a tryal of House keeping for some time. I have been told it wou'd be cheaper. I am sure it will be more agreable & what is of no small consequence, my time will be more at my command. The Sale of the wine began this day, the first quality is reserv'd until Thursday. Before I receivd
Present me to yr Lady. My sincere wishes for the happiness of you & yrs [...] you. I am Dear Sir with great esteem, Yr. Mo affectionate hble Ser. Daniel Carroll
P.S. The man comes in [...] two pr of Silk Stockings.
12-60-720
7-80-560
3-70-210
1-65-65
1-60-60
1-50-50
1-40-40
9-20-180
1885 Dollars rcd
1 See Maryland Delegates to Lee, March 13, 1781.
I am yet without the satisfaction of knowing that any Copy of the Letter of July 11, 1780 from the Committee of Foreign affairs has reached you,(1) I therefore now send a fifth by the good opportunity of Mr Harrison to whom also I have delivered Some Volumes of the journals of Congress for your acceptance, I shall take care to Send those parts which will compleat the Sett.
Mr Harrison will be able to give you the general State of our affairs; as he ha's lately been to New England and is now on his return to the Southern Theatre of the War. I will therefore not enlarge at this time, but close with assurances of very respectful prejudice towards you, founded on the testimony of all those, who
For the Committee
1 See Committee for Foreign Affairs to Dohrman, July 11, 1780.
I Intended to have written to you very fully by this Conveyance, but being indisposed for some days, I must defer it till another opportunity offers. I have not attended Congress since the first instant, when the Confederation was compleated.(1)
Colonel Floyd from his Circumstances, will be obliged to leave this when the Roads are settled; and as the Confederation requires two Delegates at least to represent a State, ours will be unrepresented, unless some of the Delegates come on about that time.
The Question of the New Hampshire Grants will now soon be settled, as the State of that Name, urge its Delegate to press for a Decision, and there is great reason to expect it will be a just & Honorable one for our State.(2)
The Session made by Virginia to the United States, has removed the Cause of opposition, which Maryland gave, to have our dispute setled; and the other small States not near us, will cease their opposition, as the Cause of it is removed. Pensylvania will urge a determination of their dispute with Connecticut, as soon as the business of their legislature is over. This I had from their President in a confidential conversation with him, on the Subject of the New England encroachments. The influence of the Officers of the New England Lines is considerable in their States, and the habits of thinking which they have acquired in the army are more conformable to the Genius of our Constitution than the Yeomanry of those States, who will unavoidably come into ours; and it is necessary the levelling principles of the Latter, should be tempered by those of the former.
It will be a good Stroke of Policy to grant those Gentlemen Land in our State, and it might be expedient to extend it to those of New Jersey; Vacant Lands in the grants might make a part of it. If this should be judged prudent, the Grant should extend to the Officers of those Lines who have resigned with good Reputations and to all the Soldiers who have served three years, and to all who shall serve during the war. Certain I am we shall derive great utility from such a measure, if it is soon done, and in my opinion no time is to be lost in doing it. I understand a Bill of this Nature was prepared in the
The present State of it and their probable Funds will not take up the time of a qualified person in that Office, more than Six or eight Months of the Year, when the proper arrangements are made for its Government & future increase.
I am Dear Sir with great Respect, your humble Servant,
Alexr. McDougall
1 Although McDougall subsequently claimed compensation for "62 days expences as Delegate for the state from the 5th Jany 1781, to 7th March," he carefully explained in a note to the draft of his account that "I did not attend in Congress after the first of March,... the expence after that arose on my returning." Emmet Collections, NN; and McDougall Papers, NHi.
2 For New Hampshire's recent efforts to force Congress to confront the question of Vermont independence, see John Sullivan to Meshech Weare, March 6, 1781, note 4. In a March 14 letter to Robert R. Livingston, former New York delegate Gouverneur Morris described the status of the Vermont issue at this time in the following terms: "Our Delegates are very urgent with Congress to do what Congress cannot do, and what they have not the Inclination to do, if they could. Opposition has made Vermont just as opposition made Wilkes and yet we are not content. McDougall pressed me to state the claims of New York in a Pamphlet and I agreed because I saw there was a design to attempt it elsewhere and I thought I could write on that subject more in a style of Conciliation than Mr. Duane whose Mildness on other occasions I shall not question. Mr. Duane has done a great deal towards writing everything about it that is writable and has indeed said so much and so well that I can say nothing. I think silence will be best and therefore I shall say nothing." Bancroft Collection, NN.
3 See McDougall to Samuel Huntington, March 9, 1781, note 2.
"As we have a Constitution which is admired for its genuine Principles, I have been sollicitous to know whether our Countrymen at large partook of the Spirit of those who formd it. I have conceivd strong hopes, that in organizing the Government and electing Persons to fill the important Places of Trust, no Consideration would have been sufficient to govern their Suffrages in favor of any Candidate unless he was possessd of those Qualities which are
"I was sorry to hear that the Number of Votes returnd the last time, did not amount to more than a Quarter of the Number of qualified Electors. The Choice of Legislators, Magistrates & Governors is surely a Business of the greatest Moment, & claims the Attention of every virtuous Citizen. The Framers of our happy Constitution while they gave due Attention to political, were not forgetful of Civil Liberty-that personal Freedom & those Rights of Property, which the meanest Citizen is intitled to, & the Security of which is the great End of political Society. It was not indeed their Province to make particular Laws for these Purposes. To do this, & to provide for the equal & impartial Execution of such Laws, agreable to the Constitution, is the Duty of the Legislature. Hence every Citizen will see, and I hope will be deeply impressd with a Sense of it, how exceedingly important it is to himself, & how intimately the Welfare of his Children is connected with it, that those who have a Share in making, as well as in judging & executing the Laws should be Men of singular Wisdom & Integrity. Such as are conscious that they are deficient in either of these Qualities, shoud even tremble at being named as Candidates! I hope the great Business of Elections will never be left by the Many to be done by the Few; for that few, before we are aware of it, may be the Engine of Corruption, the Tool of a Junto. Heaven forbid! that our Country
1 This essay appeared in Benjamin Edes' Boston Gazette, April 2, 1781, under the heading: "Extract of a Letter from the Southward." Adams wrote it in hopes of inspiring the Massachusetts voters at the annual state election to select the "fittest persons" for higher office, i.e. the opponents of John Hancock, the incumbent governor and a political rival. In the April election, Adams was chosen for the Massachusetts Senate for Suffolk County and when the new members convened he was elected president of the senate. William V. Wells, The Life and Public Services of Samuel Adams, 3 vols. (Boston: Little, Brown & Co., 1865), 3:138.
(2) The following disparaging comments about Hancock were also written by Artemas Ward to Samuel Osgood, newly elected Massachusetts delegate to Congress, in a March 13 letter extracted in Charles Martyn, The Life of Artemas Ward, the First Commander-in-Chief of the American Army (New York: Artemas Ward, 1921), p. 258. "Measures ought to be taken by the States to inform Congress of everything they have done in consequence of their requisitions for men & money. Since Novr last the Governor gives no more information than if he was at the East Indies, notwithstanding it is his duty. If he don't know his duty I wish his Council would advise him; if they don't know it to be his duty, do let some body be appointed to teach them."
I beg the favor of you to communicate to the General Assembly my wish to return home as early as may be; and to request that I may be relieved by one of my colleagues, or in such manner as shall be thought most proper.(2)
I flatter myself I shall be excused in making this request, from a consideration of the length of time since I last left Massachusetts,
I am, with every sentiment of duty and respect to the Assembly, sir, your most obedient and very humble servant,
Samuel Adams.
1 Jeremiah Powell, formerly president of the Massachusetts Council.
2 Adams apparently left Congress to return home at the end of April or beginning of May, although his new "colleagues" Samuel Osgood and George Partridge did not arrive to relieve him until June 12, 1781. See JCC, 20:450, 628; and James Lovell to Elbridge Gerry, May 8, 1781.
We are under the necessity of requesting the favour of Your Excellency and Honors, to transmit us, each, three months allowance as Delegates in Congress, as soon as the state of the Treasury, will enable you to do it.(1) We beg leave to premise, that the Maryland state money does not pass here.
We have the honor to be with the highest esteem and regard, Your Excellency (2) and honors most hble Servants,
John Hanson
Daniel Carroll
1 Although Governor Lee explained to the delegates on March 23 and April 6 that an "exhausted" treasury prevented the state from sending them money immediately, the council was able to remit $ 1,500 each to Hanson and Carroll by the end of April. See Md. Archives, 45:361, 371, 417, 421.
2 This day Georgia delegate Richard Howly also wrote a brief letter to Governor Lee, enclosing "a Majors brevet for Mr. E. Giles, a Gentleman of your State which has been voted him by Congress for his Merit & Services." Edward Giles, who had recently delivered to Congress news of Gen. Daniel Morgan's victory at the battle of Cowpens, S.C., was aide-de-camp to Morgan. See JCC, 19:129, 158, 246 47; and Red Books, 5:68, MdAA.
Rodney reports that on his way to Wilmington from Philadelphia the 11th he met "a gentleman from Richmond (Virginia) who informed me that an express had arrived there just before he set off informing that Cornwallace, had made a Shew of prepairing Timber and boats as if he intended to pass the
Mr. Bagnal, the Bearer of this Letter, this Moment informs me, that he sets off in half an hour for Boston. I am sorry he did not give me more timely Notice, because I chuse to write to my Confidential Friends by private Hands rather than the Post. I have in a Letter forwarded yesterday, given Notice to the General Assembly, of my Wish to return home as early as may be and requested to be releivd by one of my Colleagues or otherwise as may be thought proper. I expect to have General Wards Servant to attend me on my Journey. He is afterwards to return here.
I am much concerned at the Dissention in the New South Society,(1) who have generally been remarkeable for Peace & Harmony. They should strive for a conciliatory Spirit as far as is consistent with good Conscience, condescend to each other in smaller Matters, and bear with each others Tempers.
I have not been unmindful of my Sons Situation, (2) as mentiond in his Letter to me some time ago. He will see by the Journals of Congress (Sept 30 1780) (3) that the officers in the Medical Department, are intitled annually to draw Cloathing from the Stores of the Cloathier General in the same Manner & under the same Regulations as are established for officers of the Line by a Resolution Novr 25. 1779-such Cloathing to be delivered by the Cloathier General
Pray let Mrs Fogs know that Mr. Lovel & I have done all we could for the Relase of her Son who was made a Sea Prisoner & carried to New York. Our officers have some of them been sent to England, but not any of the Seamen, so that it is hoped he is still there. Many of them have died. They have lately been better treated than they were some time ago. The british Sea officers are retaind in close Confinement here till we hear what is to become of ours. We are in hopes there will soon be an Exchange of the whole.
Remember me to Friends. Adieu SA
1 That is, in the congregation of the New South Church attended by the Adams family.
2 Dr. Samuel Adams, Jr., was a Continental Hospital Physician and Surgeon, stationed in Rhode Island.
3 JCC, 18:887.
I inclose you an account (1) delivered me by Mr. Dunlap for the hire of three waggons to transport the Printing Materials to Virginia and the amount of 7 dozen Parchment for the use of the Legislature. Mr. Dunlap assures me he engaged the waggons upon the best terms he could. They are to deliver their loads at Richmond and return to Fredericksburg with any loads the State may furnish. From thence they are to come to my House to transport some necessaries for my Family to this place but if the State can furnish them a back load to Philadelphia this part of the engagement may be void. If they are to return by my House the Country should be credited for such proportion of the waggonage as may be reasonable from Fredericksburg to Philadelphia and charged to me. I have desired Mr. Hays to receive the money for the waggon hire and parchment and after
Joseph Jones
1 For John Dunlap's enclosed "account," see ibid., p. 158. For the Virginia government's venture in establishing a press in Richmond, see ibid., 3:579-80, 4:396, 431-32; Jones to Thomas Jefferson, February 6; and Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, February 20, 1781.
I am endeavoring to save myself from Ruin and to serve another as effectually as if I went on in the old Course of neglecting my Family. I mean to pay into your Hand for M-D's (1) use 140 Spanish milled Dollrs. or the equivalent and not merely 700 Livres Tournois. Take therefore from me whatever is the Exchange. My Friends pd. from 75 to 78, but perhaps it may have been raised a little by a Run of Paper from this Quarter or it may have fallen by "The Arrival of a french Frigate at Boston with four Million Dollars." (2) I would have you do full Justice to M-D and I know you will also act the friendly part to me. If Bills are there, as I hear they are, you make an advantageous Purchase of them to the amount of what you shall think proper to demand of me in Exch. of the 140 Ds. which I mean to pay. But, if you think it more essential to M.D.'s. Interests you may purchase the Coin, and remit it to buy a Bill here; where 4/6 Pensylvania will purchase 4/4 1/2 sterling. That is, provided the minister shd. continue drawing. M-D preferred having it done there, that the Proceeds might also remain under your Discretion. It was a Loss to me of 1300 Dollrs. that the 49 State were sent instead of 25 hard which they would have purchased. I am told also that I lose the Interest on every Sum recd. from the State. However, as I mentioned to you confidentially before, I am determined not to be the martyr of that and other such like Circumstances to which I have long been exposed.(3)
I send you now only 6360 Dollars, not knowing M D's Wishes till this Evening, and the Bearer being to set off in the Morning; and he being also in doubt whether he shall be able to take the Size of a Letter from me. But you must not omit to do the needful on that Score because I know of a good Opportunity to transmit you more in a few days that you can have occasion for; and the Surplus of
I wish I could give you better accounts from the southard than are circulating now. I must own I do not think Cornwallis is in any Danger of being ruined. He may be harrassed Somewhat. But he will reach a Port of Embarkation. I think this is much more than probable.
An Express came with two Duplicate Letters of Doctr. Franklin,(4) and many old Newspapers. It is the second Exertion of Zeal in that Way. The french Minister indeed had many Letters as well as Papers but the fr. Consul should have seen to the Portrage of them. The Expence, is great. The other Time alluded to, a Horse was lost in Hudson's River, whereby the Public were brought to extra Cost for their old News Papers sent from Boston to York Town.
The Marqs. de la Fayette got safely with his Troops to Maryland But the Enemy were after him at the Dawn of next morning with 18 & 28 Guns.
Your Silk Stockgs. & Gloves are recovered so as scarcely to discover what they have been exposed to. The ribbed Hose are much spotted; perhaps are not rotted and may take Dye well.
We have decided today recommend all Tender Laws so far as they respect Ratio of Exchange. A large Tax is also recommended and the new Bills to be taken as Silver tho we promise to pay all Debts in Silver or real current Exchange so that if the People still chuse to do it they may go on biting their own Noses loading themselves with new Taxes to make good the Deficiencies which are caused by their specuting Principles & Practice.(5)
I must quit I have hurt myself of late by Watchings.
Yr. Friend, JL
[P.S.] Nancy Shippen is married to H. B. Livingston Brother of the Chancelor.
1 Undoubtedly the Miss Dalley referred to in Lovell's February 20, 1781, letter to Gerry.
2 Lovell wrote in the margin beside this quotation: "News of the day!"
3 For a discussion of Gerry's and Lovell's currency speculations, see George A. Billias, Elbridge Gerry. Founding Father and Republican Statesman (New York: McGraw Hill Book Co., 1976), pp. 133-35.
4 See Lovell to Franklin, March 9, 1781, note 2.
5 For the final measure passed by Congress, see Samuel Huntington to the States, March 23, 1781.
Mr Brown arrived here day before yesterday (1) & we were honoured with your Two letters with their enclosures, the act of assembly vesting Congress with the power of laying duties on Imports for so limited a period as three years after the end of the war, I fear will in a great measure defeat the Important end proposed.(2)
Our debt is very Considerable now and will be annually increased while the war lasts-can it be Supposed that those duties with the other aid the States will be able to give will be Sufficient to discharge the national debt within that period.
Besides Congress have no resources for Supplies or funds on which to obtain a Credit, but from the States-and Can the States furnish us with either in So easy & equitable a way as by duties & Imposts-it would be easy to borrow money at home or abroad were we possessed of funds Commensurate to the loans or even to the Interest of the Sums we need-at present we are obliged to draw bills of Exchange on our Minister at the Court of France at a great risque & Sell them at a great loss.
Congress in a Committe of the whole have agreed to report that an Estimate of the Sums wanted for the Current year, beyond those all ready Called for, be transmitted to the States, & that they be Called upon for 6,000,000 of dollars to be paid in Specie or the new Continental bills in quarterly payments. I think that the old Continental bills Should be Called in or exchanged at their Current value & that the new bills Should Issue equal to Specie, in this Case neither the public or Individuals Can Suffer & there is nothing in the resolves of Congress that Contradict this, the Committee of the whole have likewise agreed to report to recommend to the States to Amend their laws making paper bills or tender other ways than ad valorem.(3)
I inclose Some extracts from Govr Jeffersons letter (4) which Contains the Substance of the intelligence from the Southward.
I must leave Congress by the Middle of April. Genl Woolcot designs to leave it Sooner & Mr Huntington is determined to go home about the last of April. Some Gentlemen must Come on or the State will be without a representation in Congress.
March 17th. The Resolutions mentioned to have been agreed in Committee are now passed in Congress & will be forwarded by Brown.
Mr Robt Morriss is elected Superintendant of Finance, Genl McDougal Secretary of marine-both have given their answer but
With Sentiments of the highest respect, your most obedt humble Servt, Jesse Root
1 Upon messenger Jesse Brown's arrival, Connecticut delegate Samuel Huntington executed the following receipt, dated "Philadelphia March 14th, 1781," for money from the state treasurer. "Receivd of John Lawrence Esqr Treasurer of Connecticutt by the hand of Jesse Brown Two thousand Seven hundred & four dollars in Continental bills of old Emissions prior to the 18th of March 1780, it being the Same Sum for which I have drawn an order on the Said Treasurer in favour of Said Brown." Seaport Autographs Catalogue, no. 35 (July 1987), item 44 (photofacsimile), p. 12
2 See Samuel Huntington's first letter to Trumbull of March 24, 1781.
3 Samuel Huntington to the States, March 23, 1781.
4 That is, Gov. Thomas Jefferson's March 8, 1781, letter which was read in Congress on March 15. See PCC, item 71, 2:53-55; and JCC, 19:262.
After considering the Subject you were pleased to mention To me this morning; with all the Coolness which a matter of such Importance requires; I am of opinion That Either Mr. Burk or myself must Stand in the Light of an aggressor by the Correspondence between us; without any relation to the Confidential State of Facts which I took the Liberty of Laying before you; and that this cannot alter the nature of the Dispute.(1) I am Therefore inclined to think, that there would be a manifest Impropriety in making it the Basis of a Decision; for though I am convinced of the Justice of the Relation; yet as it mentions two other Persons, either of whom I had much greater Reason to Suspect than Mr Burk, it will have an appearance of shifting a Supposed Charge from one to another to avoid Consequences; And as Mr Burk took up the Matter and applied it to himself without proper Evidence and made that the Foundation for a Letter so full of Asperity: I cannot Suppose that My Explanatory Letter (intended only to Satisfy you that I was not the aggressor) Should be Considered as having any weight in the Determination: for when Considered as Intended for your Information, it is proper and necessary. But if Considered as a Communication from me to Mr Burk through you; it will amount to an Explanation of my Letter to Congress which Mr Burk has already Demanded and I have refused; & which I think from the Correspondence Mr Burk is by no means Intitled to. I am far from wishing to Sport with my own Life,
I have the Honor to be very respectfully Dear Sir your most obedt Servt, Jno Sullivan
P.S. If Mr Burk had in his first Letter requested an Explanation of That part of mine to Congress which he Erroneously Supposed was intended for him (personally) & had Informed me of the part he had taken in Congress & had Even in Decent Terms hinted his opinion respecting my Conduct & Capacity as an officer I Should have given him the Explanation Contained in my Confidential Letter to you & Endeavored to remove his ill grounded prejudice against me. But when he undertook by Letter to Inform against himself & in Justification to accuse me of the want of Every Talent requisite for an officer & this without the proper Evidence, & I am Sure I need not tell You That the whole Army from the Commander in Chief to the Lowest Soldier (with only one or two Exceptions) would Join in refuting the assertions: I say to a Letter of this Complextion for me to have given him the Explanation he Demanded would have Argued a want of Spirit and Even a meaness which in any Event Mr. Burk shall find me Incapable of, & I must Submit to Your Judgment whether Admitting my Confidential Letter to Serve as a Basis for reconciliation will not be Tantamount to what he has heretofore very improperly Demanded & I have peremptorily refused.
Yrs, &ca. JS
1 For this "Dispute," see Sullivan to McDougall, January 27, 1781, note 1.
2 Sullivan was ultimately spared having to resolve his dispute with Thomas Burke by resort to arms, for McDougall and Burke's second (Hugh Shiell) were preparing the ground for a resolution that rested upon mutual declarations of the two seconds, rather than of the two principals. That is, McDougall later disingenuously avowed that it was not Burke who was the actual object of Sullivan's protest to Congress of September 27, 1777, and in turn Shiell declared that Burke's response had not been intended as a "personal insult." See McDougall to Sullivan, May 22, 1781.
Our latest Accounts from General Greene are in his Dispatches of the 28th Ultimo.(1) He was then at Guilford Court House, North Carolina; Lord Cornwallis had crossed a little River called the Haw; The two Armies were with in Ten Miles of each other. Greene expected a Body of six or Eight hundred mounted Riflemen under Colo. Wm. Campbell soon to join him from over the Mountains, when he hoped to harrass the Enemies Rear. He was but illy assisted by the Militia and remained the Inferior Army. The People were much disaffected, having many of them joined Cornwallis. Our Genl. had been successful at all Times in the Pettit Guerre. In one Instance the Enemy having killed & hung in Quarters a Trumpeter of Lt. Col. Lee's Corps, our Cavalry made an immediate Charge, and sacrificed sixteen of the Enemy's Troopers. In a late Attempt to surprize Tarlton, Genl. Marian of the Militia, and Lt. Colo. Lee, came across upwards of Hamilton's Corp's and N. Carolina Tories, most of whom were cut up, on the Spot; This occasioned Tarlton's Escape, who was alarmed by some of the Militia's firing. The Enemy have ordered two Regiments of Negroes to be embodied in So. Carolina and are drafting many of the effective Whites to serve during the "Rebellion." Indeed Sir, we must reduce New York, or put on foot a very expensive Campaign, against the Enemy in the Southern States; Otherwise their Numbers there will encrease in a Geometrical Proportion. I send your Excellency all the Journals of Congress that have come officially; I wish, for the Honor of my Country, they contained some of those Master Strokes Of Policy that would adorn the History of Mankind But great Bodies move slow, and the Tediousness of their Deliberations forms a Sacrifice to be offered up at the Shrine of Freedom.
Congress have nearly finished their Estimates for the present Year, & the Demand to be made upon the States, in Addition to those already required. I hope they will soon be transmitted.(2) A Plan is also maturing for the States to enable Congress to oblige the Delinquent States to do their Duty; This, as it will be additional to the Articles, must be first proposed to the States for their Ratification. It is finished in a Committee; and I hope will be approved by Congress. Should it, and the States acquisce, the willing States will be greatly relieved.(3)
I have the Honor of being Sir, with perfect Esteem, your Excellency's most obedient, & very humble Servt.
J.M. Varnum
1 Gen. Nathanael Greene's February 28 letter to Samuel Huntington was read in Congress on March 15. JCC, 19:262; and PCC, item 155, 1:580-81. Greene also
2 See Samuel Huntington to the States, March 23, 1781.
3 Acting on Varnum's motion on March 6, Congress had appointed Varnum, James Duane and James Madison as a committee "to prepare a plan to invest the United States in Congress assembled with full and explicit powers for effectually carrying into execution in the several states all acts or resolutions passed agreeably to the Articles of Confederation." The committee's report, chiefly in the hand of Madison, was dated March 12 and brought in to Congress on March 16, but was not taken into consideration until May 2, when it was referred to a "grand committee, consisting of a member from each State." The committee's report was subsequently revised by the "grand committee" and yet another regular committee before it was allowed to die after a final committee report on August 22, 1781. See JCC, 19:236, 272-73, 20:469-71, 773, 21:893-96; Thomas Rodney's Diary, March 6; James Madison to Thomas Jefferson, April 16, 1781; and Edmund C. Burnett, The Continental Congress (New York: Macmillan Co., 1941), pp. 504-9.
I write this from the Presidents, who is this moment Sending of an express, with intelligence from Genl. Washington of the sailing of the French fleet from Newport on the Evening of the 8th Instant, & of the sailing of the British from Gardiners Bay on the morning of the 10th. Underneath is a list of the two fleets as I have been informd. We are anxiously expecting intelligence from the Southward. I am, Dear Sir, with great respect, Yr. Excellencys Yr. Most Obt. Ser. Daniel Carroll
| State of the French Fleet | Guns | British | Guns |
| Le Duc de Buorgoyne | 80 | London | 90 |
| Le Neptune | 74 | Royal Oak | 74 |
| Le Conquerant | 74 | Bedford | 74 Note A |
| Le Eveille | 64 | America | 64 ____ B |
| Le Jason | 64 | Europa | 64 |
| Le Ardent | 64 | Prudent | 64 |
| Le Province | 64 | Adamant | 50 |
| Le Fantasque | 64 C | 480 | |
| 548 | difference | 68 Guns | |
| 548 | |||
| Frigates | Guns | Frigates | |
| Romulus | 44 | Guadalupe | 28 |
| La Survellante | 32 | diffrence | 112 & 14 |
| La Gentille | 32 | 140 -- 14 | |
| L' Hermione | 32 | ||
| 140 | |||
| La Guisse Cutter | 14 |
Note A. The Bedford supposd to be refitted.
B. The America had returnd to Gardiners Bay before the British Saild.
C. Did not sail, being an old Hospital Ship.(2)
1 Carroll undoubtedly misdated this letter which was written at the same time as Samuel Huntington's March 18 letter to Lee, for which see the following entry. See also Carroll to Lee, March 20, 1781, note 1.
2 This note "C" is in the hand of Lee, who received this information in Carroll's letter of March 20, ibid.
I do myself the Honour to Transmit you the enclosed intelligence from his Excellency Genl Washington, as it may be of Importance if you Should not have obtaind the Information from the fleet before this comes to hand.(1)
I have the Honour to be with the highest Respect your Humble Servt, Sam. Huntington
P.S. I have been Honourd with your favour of the 14th instant.(2)
1 Huntington's enclosure consisted of a March 11 letter from Washington, who reported that the French squadron at Newport had just embarked, and that "By advices from New London the British, which were in Gardiner's Bay, did the same yesterday morning with their whole force." With Washington's letter was also one of the same date to the marquis de Lafayette, which Lee, in his March 23 reply to Huntington, explained that he had forwarded upon receipt. See MdAA, Brown Books, 1:64; PCC, item 70, fols. 461 64; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21 :333-34.
2 Lee's March 14 letter to Huntington is in PCC, item 70, fols. 457-60.
I did myself the honor of writing to your Excellency a few lines by express, the 18th Instant,(1) & enclosd a List of the force of the two fleets which lately Saild from New Port & Gardiners Bay-One of the French Ships mentiond calld the Fantasque did not Sail, being an old Vessel made a hospital Ship of-please therefore to correct the list.
The Board of war referd to Congress two Letters from your
I am Dear Sir, with great esteem, your Excellencys Mo Obt Servt. Daniel Carroll
1 For this letter, which Carroll had misdated March 20, see Carroll to Lee, March 18, 1781, note 1.
2 For Lee's "two letters" of February 1 and 12 requesting the rank of lieutenant colonel for Alexander Lawson Smith and commissions for the officers of the state's four artillery companies, see PCC, item 147, 6:267-70; and Md. Archives, 45:297-98, 308, where Lee's first letter is dated February 2. The Board of War's March 6 report was read in Congress the following day and referred to a committee of three chaired by Carroll. The journals contain no further mention of the committee. See JCC, 19:240-41; and PCC, item 147, 6:259-63.
I have written by this Conveyance to our Governour (1) giving him Notice of my Intention to return home as soon as the Roads permit, and requesting that some of the other Gentlemen may be sent to keep up our Representation in Congress. Whether the Legislature complies with my request or not I shall, I flatter myself, be with you before the first of May as I most impatiently long to be with you. I am considering a mode of Conveyance as my daughter tho' pressed to pass the Summer with Mrs. Peters will accompany me.
A few days will decide the fate of Arnold, as it is more than probable that by this time the French and British fleets have had an Engagement. Their force is equal and the French went to the Southward with an Intention to fight and an opinion that they woud be victorious.
We are greatly superior to Arnold's detachment by Land and he can only hope to escape; not to retain possession of Portsmouth, and much less to make any progress in Virginia. We hear nothing by the last post from General Greene who is in pursuite of the British, under Lord Cornwallis. Our Expectations are high and our Anxiety
[P.S.] I omitted to mention that the British have declared War against the Dutch and taken St. Eustatia, Curocoa & 160 Vessels in the Texel.(2) This Event will give us another Ally. Kiss and bless for me our dear Children. Adieu! God bless you.
1 Not found.
2 This news appeared in the Pennsylvania Gazette this date, coming to Philadelphia by way of a ship arriving from Antigua. For the events leading to the Anglo-Dutch war, see Jan Willem Schulte Nordholt, The Dutch Republic and American Independence, trans. H.H. Rowen (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1982), chap. 10; and Daniel A. Miller, Sir Joseph Yorke and Anglo-Dutch Relations, 1774-1780 (The Hague: Mouton & Co., 1970), chap. 5.
On Account of Some disagreeable Information which I have rec'd from my family; as well as on some other Accounts, I am under a Necessity of Returning home, and Shall Sett off in a few days;(1) I considered it my duty to Inform your Excellency of this, that Some person may Come on, to Represent the State.
By the Inclosed paper of this days Date, (2) you will See the Manifesto of the King of Britain; which amounts to a Declaration of War against the Dutch. This appears to be a Rash measure, and looks like the Effect of Desparation-what will be the Consequences among the Neutral powers of Europe is not Certain, But we have Reason to Expect that the Armed Neutrality will in General Disapprove of the Conduct of Britain.
Arnold's Situation is very Critical and Dangerous, and We have the Greatest Reason to Expect that he will be Secured in a very few Days if it is not already done.
By our last accounts from Cornwallace, he has Retreated near fifty miles, General Green was Reinforced so as to pursue him, and had got within ten miles of his Rear, and was growing stronger Every hour-under those Circumstances we have Reason to hope for a Successful Battle against him which will Restore the two Southern States again to the Union.
From Sir Your Most Obedt. and humble Servt.
Wm. Floyd
1 Floyd's last recorded action in Congress at this time was his vote on March 22; he returned to Congress on November 23, 1781. JCC, 19:293, 21:1132.
2 That is, the Pennsylvania Gazette. See the preceding entry, note 2.
Having received no letters by the two last posts, I suspect the course of it beyond James River must by some means be interrupted; this will therefore go under cover to Mr. Neilson at Petersburgh. Before this reaches you, great events must have taken place in our country. God grant they may be favorable to our wishes. The paper which I have desired Mr. Neilson to forward to you with this letter contains all the news: whether good or bad for America, can only be known by the event. The immediate loss of property to the merchants of America in 'Statia and other Dutch ports, will for some time have a very sensible effect on our commerce. Pray make all the interest in your power with your friends in the Assembly to have me relieved as speedily as possible-both my health and finances require it. Present my love to my sisters, Nelly and the children: I long much to see them. Remember me to all our friends, particularly Mr. Barker. And believe me ever, Your affectionate and obedient servant, Sam Johnston.
Yours of the 1st reached me yesterday by Post and I have also to express my Obligation for one of the same date written to us jointly about a Regulation wch. is not now essential so far as one Voice was intended to serve in the Delegation, But I wish not to be going on without having our Suppression of the Norr. Order Sanctified. We have written for the Purpose.(1)
You will, eer this reaches you, have learnt the Fate of your little Property which arrived in the Ariel. Your Chance must have been very singular, as I am told by some Merchants that they never in the whole Course of their Business saw such an Effect as the Sea has had on yr. blue Cloth. The Roads are so extremely bad that I shall have no opportunity of sending any Thing of the Box kind till I have your clear Opinion and Directions.
I see by the Boston News papers that Interest is not to be demanded on the New Bills. It has twice been taken of me on my Draughts.
Those Friends you mention think much of you, one of them perhaps ever instead of "never."
I have written to you by a Gentleman of the Name of Randall who left this City 3 days ago.(2) As he went in a Sualky he will not perhaps reach you so soon as this Sheat. I wish you to accomplish the Business for your Friend D____ (3) which I have mentioned to you. I only wait for another private Hand by which to put you fully in the Way of executing the Business to the Extent I named. And if you chuse to go something beyond, it will be more agreable to the Wish of D who is now fully capable of enabling you to do it, was it decided that you would pursue the first of my measures and not the second. But I have heard since I wrote, that you will find more Difficulty in the first than the 2d. I wish I had been 3 weeks sooner. Upon the whole I confide altogether in yr. Judgement to do the best for D & me. I inclose you some Proceedings of a few Days old which will be forwarded to the Government together with a Proclamation for a Fast the 1st Thursday in May. I hope we shall have great occasion to rejoice also. Much may be done by the Allied Force in Cheseapeak and I hope the Dutch will instantly combine with France & Spain. George 3d is downright Bobadil (4) at this Period. If you do not get the News before this reaches your Hand you will have it by the Gazette inclosed to all the Extent we have.
Give my affectionate Comp[liments] to Doctr. Holten. I intended [to] write to him in answer to his fa[vor] by Browne, but I am forced to scratch this at a Window and am too tired to scratch more than that. I am, sincerely, Yours, J.L.
1 See Massachusetts Delegates to the Massachusetts General Court, February 27, 1781.
2 See Lovell to Gerry, March 16, 1781.
3 That is, Miss Dalley, for whom see ibid.
4 That is, a cowardly braggart, named for Captain Bobadil, a character in Ben. Jonson's Every Man in His Humor. OED.
Since our last nothing new has happend except the Sailing of the French fleet Consisting of (as near as we can obtain intelligence) the Ships and Guns as per list inclosed (1) together with about twelve Hundred of their Chosen troops which we f[l]atter our selves are by this time actively and Successfully employd in our Bay; And the
James Madison Junr.
Theok Bland
PS. Mr. Hays Set off a few days ago with his printing implements.(2) We sent by him 50 Copies of the last French memorial (3) to be distributed as your Excellency thinks best. He has also a number of Skins, of parchment for the Assembly.
1 The "list inclosed" has not been found, but for a similar list of the "Ships and Guns" of the French fleet, see Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, March 18, 1781.
2 See Joseph Jones to the Virginia Auditors, March 16, 1781.
3 Not identified. The "last French memorial" entered in the journals was La Luzerne's brief February 26 letter to Congress announcing the February 11 arrival of Captain Tilly's small squadron in the Chesapeake-a fact the Virginians would have known for some time and for news of which "50 Copies" would hardly have been necessary. See JCC, 19:199; PCC, item 95, 1:180-81.
I have Wrote you one or two Letters since I recd. any from you,(1) but however I will not insist upon a critical Ballance of Accounts at present. I have recd. a Letter from Oliver of the 10t instant of which you will please to inform him, and thot I shall Acknowlege it in a particular Manner. No News from the Southward. We hear nothing particular of the French and English Fleets since they sailed from the Eastward. Events interesting both in Virginia and N Carolina may be soon expected. The inclosed Papers will inform you of an Event of an important Nature(2) if you shall not have recd. an earlier Acco. of it. I shall make no Observations upon this Affair. Accept this hasty Line from Sir, your Most Obedt. servt.
Oliver Wolcott
1 Wolcott's latest extant letters to Lyman were dated December 28, 1780, and February 26, 1781. In the latter, Wolcott acknowledged receipt of a letter from Lyman of February 16.
2 That is, the recent British attacks on the Dutch-at St. Eustatius, Curasao, and the Texel.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed a Resolve of Congress of the 19th Instant, recommending to the Supreme Executive Council of this State, to forward the March of their Line in Detachments with all possible Expedition to join the Southern Army.(1)
I have the Honor to be with very great respect, Sir, your most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington Presidt.(2)
1 JCC, 19:275.
2 This day Huntington also sent a brief letter to Commissary General Ephraim Blaine, enclosing a memorial from former assistant commissary James Smith seeking compensation for purchases made by him on Continental account during 1780. PCC, item 15, fol. 252; and JCC, 19:264. Smith's memorial is not in PCC, but for an April 24 follow-up letter from him to Congress and two Blaine accounts concerning the claim, see PCC, item 78, 21:61, item 165, fols. 409-14; and JCC, 20:458n.
Your Excellency will receive herewith enclosed, a Proclamation of the 20th Instant, earnestly recommending that Thursday the third Day of May next may be observed as a Day of Humiliation, Fasting & Prayer by all the United States.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c, &c. S.H.
1 See JCC, 19:284-86.
I little expect this will reach you in any short time as your last informed me you were about moving to Bizarre (1)-unless having deposited Fanny and the Children in a Place of safety-you have
I must request that you will contrive to remit me if Possible the Amount of that Small Ballance in Tobo.-in a Bill on this City for hard Money it being a Commodity I stand much in need of for some Certain Purposes-shd. you not be able to get a Bill for Hard money-I must intreat you to send it in Specie by some safe hand. Can I request another favor viz that you will apply to the Proper office for my depreciation of Pay due to me which I am told the state has Issued to its officers-mine is to be reckond to the 10th day of Jany.1780 at which time my resignation was accepted-shd. you be so fortunate as to obtain it-please to remit it in the most convenient manner you can. I am much distressed for Cash-insomuch that I am unable to pay even for Fanny's Picture or your locks. I am Dr. Tucker Yr. Friend & Bro. Theok Bland
[P.S.] Inclosed I have sent you an oratorio which was performed by Some Gentn. & Ladies the other night at the Minister of France's Hotel before a numerous Audience at which Mrs. Bland and myself were present.(4)
1 A Tucker plantation in Cumberland Co., Va., west of Richmond.
2 That is, an infant or young child.
3 That is, David, Richard Kidder, and Everard Meade.
4 Bland undoubtedly attended what may have been the first performance of Francis Hopkinson's "America Independent," an opera celebrating the Franco-American
Captn. Stoddart carrys with him several matters for you as underneath. He will deliver them to some trusty person in Baltimore to be forwarded to you. It has not been in my power to get the Brown thread Stockings suitable or a hat; I have been with the hatter frequently, & have received repeated promises, but have been disapointed. I shall continue to press him. I do not expect to get one of the best much under two thousand dollars. The green waistcoat I mentiond was taken by the Spanish Agent (1) before I receivd yours & I thought it best Notwithstanding what you said to take the white one with flours-which was cheaper, & I think hansommer.
The wine sold from 34/ to 38/ State money per Gallon. I believe it is not more than four years old-& I have managed it with Mr. Biddle so that you may have a quarter Cask, hogshead or pipe as you shall direct-but this must be done by the first opportunity.
In paying a way some of yr. money I found several Convention Bills which I return as mentiond underneath-likewise an 80 Dollar Bill which woud not pass. Present my Comps. to Mrs. Lee & be assur'd, I am Dr. sr. with great regard, Yr. Most Obt Serv.
Danl. Carroll
| Dollars | ||
| Amt of Coll[ungers?] Bill. | 3940 | |
| Do. of L Blank 4 p Stockgs | 2600 | |
| Paid for a Silk waistcoat | 1500 | |
| Do. for Buttons | 750 | |
| Do for 10 yds of fine Jean or dimoty | 2250 1st Parcel recd | Dolls 16109 |
| 11,040 2 Do | 1885 | |
| 19-8 Ds Convention Bills | 152 | 17994 |
| 18-6 Ds | 108 | |
| 1. 80 Dollar Bill will not pass | 80 | |
| 11,380 |
1 That is, Francisco Rendon.
Your favour to me which was accompanied by a Memorial to Congress I had the pleasure to receive. The Memorial was immediately referred to the board of War and I have informed them that it's your wish that no Report shoud be made till you have had an opportunity of stating your Claims in person.(1) I have no doubt but so reasonable a Request will be complied with. To this day we have no news from the Southward but what you may find in the prints: our Expectations are high, and our Anxiety great in proportion. Much depends on the Maneuvres of the French fleet & probably on the issue of a naval Engagement. Arnold unless reliev'd by Sea must in all human probability fall with all his detachment into our Hands. Our prospects with respect to General Green's Success continue favorable. I need not tell you the great Effects which are to be expected from a Successful Issue. The Dutch with all their deliberation are hurried into a War, and considerably injured in the unlookd for Seizure of St. Eustatia, Curacoa and 160 of their Ships in the Texel. If they have any national Honor or Pride left they will rouse to Vigorous Exertions. They are poor in Revenue: but as a People the richest perhaps in Europe; and they want nothing but Virtue-and that may be supplied by Resentment-to throw a decisive Weight into the scale of the Allies.
I am with great Esteem, Sir, Your most obedt Servant,
Jas Duane
1 William Malcom's February 18, 1781, letter to Samuel Huntington, asking for a new review of his claims to back pay as a regimental commander from February 1779, was referred to the Board of War on March 21. See JCC, 19:289; and PCC, item 78, 16:135-38. See also Huntington to George Clinton, January 13, 1781.
The Subject of the Dutch War engrosses the Conversation here. The Capture of St. Eustatius has interfered very deeply with the Property of several Merchants in the City, and some of the best Ships belonging to the Port have been lost in the Fracas. I cannot think, either from the whole Circumstances of the Case, or from the Tenour of the Manifesto, that Great-Britain is persuaded The United Provinces will engage in a War, but rather that it is expected they will descend, as, I am sorry to say, they have sometimes
At writing we have no authentick Intelligence from the Cheeseapeak, but expect it hourly. I think it unnecessary to trouble your Excellency with vague Reports, as you have enough of them at Trenton, and as I am to do myself the Honour of transmitting whatever may come certain or official by the first Hand after it arrives.
23 March-in the Morning. It should seem, by the last New-York Paper brought to Town, and by some Reports from below, that either the French or British Fleet have got into the Cheeseapeak, but it is doubtful which it may be. I am, with much regard, your Excy's obedt Servant. WC Houston
You will please to communicate to the Honorable Legislature of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania the enclosed report of Committee & Act of Congress relative to the Law passed in Connecticut to vest in Congress a Power to levy certain Duties.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S. H.
1 In response to Congress' February 3 resolve requesting explicit authority from the states to levy a 5 percent impost, Connecticut had immediately assented, but had
Huntington made haste to report this resolve to Speaker Muhlenberg because the Pennsylvania Assembly was already in session and was about to take the subject under consideration.
The Committee to whom the letter from the Minister Plenipotentiary from these United States at the Court of Versailles, relative to a proposition for furnishing Provisions to the amount of four hundred thousand dollars specie to the forces of our Ally, was committed, have received your letter of the 9th instant,(1) in which you inform them that you "are not acquainted with the present wants of his Majesty's fleet and Army in America, and have reason to believe they are amply supplied." The object of the Committee's enquiry was, not their present wants, but, a specification of such provisions as future or contingent wants may require, together with the places of delivery. Precise information on these particulars is necessary to be had before Congress can determine whether the resources of these States will enable them to furnish the supplies.
The Committee, therefore, request you to furnish them with a particular estimate of such provisions as his Most Christian Majesty's forces, or the Officers appointed to supply them, shall require from the United States, on a Supposition that the aforesaid proposition shall be ratified by Congress. And to Specify the kinds, qualities and quantities and the places of delivery. Should it not be in your line to give them this information the Committee will be obliged by your pointing out to them the proper Officer to whom application ought to be made.
I am Sir with repsect, your very Obedt Servt. (on behalf of the Committee) Thos Burke
1 This committee, consisting of Samuel Adams, Thomas Burke, and Joseph Jones, was appointed on February 19 in response to a December 2 letter from Benjamin Franklin recommending the establishment of a fund in France that would enable him to pay drafts drawn on him by Congress. Because the great obstacle to establishing Continental credit in Europe was the British blockade of the American coast, Franklin suggested that he be authorized to draw on the French minister of finance in Paris to the value of $400,000 in return for the delivery of provisions of equal value directly to
It is obvious from the present letter that the committee had previously written to Holker, the French agent of marine in America, about the needs of the French forces, and that he had either misunderstood or evaded the committee's query in his reply of March 9. Hence the necessity for this follow-up letter, the only one from the committee to Holker that has been found, to which he replied on March 25 with a "memorandum of the articles that may be wanted By his Majesty's naval force & army in America, & which may be procured in the United States." See PCC, item 96, fols. 217-18, 255 62.
Almost simultaneously the scheme proposed by Franklin was also brought before Congress in the form of a memorial from the French minister La Luzerne requesting a conference to discuss the plan, to which Congress responded by appointing a committee of six. For La Luzerne's memorial and the work of this second committee, See JCC, 19:308-11; PCC, item 95, 1:196-203; and Committee of Congress to La Luzerne, March 29, 1781.
By the New-York Paper of 17 March inst. printed by Rivington(1) we are informed that the following officers were advanced to the Rank of Rear-Admirals by the late Promotions in the Navy of Great Britain
Those marked with + are now in Admiral Arbuthnot's Fleet.
By the above you will perceive that Capt. Archibald Kennedy is promoted to a Rear-Admiral; your Excellency will determine from Circumstances whether it is the same Capt Kennedy who is under Parole to the State of New Jersey.(2) It is probable you have seen the Paper, but not being certain of that, I have extracted the above.
I am your Excellency's obedt Servant. WC Houston
1 That is, James Rivington's New York Royal Gazette.
2 Capt. Archibald Kennedy (d.1794), a British navy captain of 28 years service who settled in New Jersey in 1765, had been arrested as a loyalist in 1776 and paroled by the New Jersey government. He settled in England after the war, and eventually succeeded to an earldom in 1792 as the 11th earl of Cassillis. Livingston, Papers (Prince), 1:394; and Peter W. Coldham, American Loyalist Claims (Washington, D.C.: National Genealogical Society, 1980), 1:271.
Your Excellency will receive herewith enclosed, two Acts of Congress of the 16th & 23rd Instant, directing that all Debts liquidated in or contracted for Specie Value shall be paid in Specie or other Money equivalent, according to the current Exchange compared with Specie.(1)
Also recommending to the several States to amend their Laws making the Bills of Credit emitted under the Authority of Congress a legal Tender, so that such Bills shall not be a legal Tender in any other Manner than at their current Value compared with Gold & Silver.
But, what will more particularly claim the Attention of your Legislature as of great Importance, is, the requisition for six Millions of Dollars, that is one Million & an half of Dollars to be paid quarterly; the first quarterly Payment to be made on the first Day of June next, the Quota of each State being apportioned in the enclosed Act; and Payment to be made on this requisition as also the several others therein referred to, in Gold or Silver, or Bills emitted by any of the States whatever in Pursuance of the resolutions of the 18th of March 1780.
This Assessment is not to be considered as the Proportion of any State, but, being paid, is to be adjusted & settled with Interest in Future upon equitable Principles in the Manner expressed in the Act.
It is with reluctance that Congress are compelled to make this requisition, but the absolute Necessity of the Case will appear so obvious that we presume the respective States will yield a ready & cheerful Compliance therewith to the utmost of their Power.
I have the Honor to be, &c &c, S.H.
1 The resolves were adopted in the hope that the states could be induced to contribute their 1781 quotas in specie or the equivalent in new emission bills at the current exchange. To this end, Congress declared on March 16 that Continental debts would be revalued in such terms and recommended that the states adopt legal tender laws that would require acceptance of new bills (emitted pursuant to its resolves of March 18, 1780) "at their current value compared with gold or silver." Simultaneously a committee of 13 was appointed to apportion the states' quotas for a quarterly requisition of $1.5 million due on June 1. The committee's report was submitted and adopted on March 23. JCC, 19:266-68, 298-99.
These resolves were also an effort to turn a new leaf in congressional fiscal policy, stimulated by both the recent adoption of the Articles of Confederation and the continued deterioration of Continental finances. Thus Congress had declared on March 6 "That Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday in every week be assigned for the subject of finance," and accordingly resolved itself into a committee of the whole on March 8, 9, 10, 13, 14, and 16 to consider several new fiscal proposals, including those adopted on the 16th. See JCC, 19:245, 250, 252-55, 258-59.
I send you an Extract from the Journals of Congress which may tend to convey Information to the Genl. Assembly of Massachusetts by being lodged with you Officially.(1)
Your Friend & humble Servant, James Lovell
1 Lovell's enclosure, described in an endorsement as the "proceeding of Congress respecting Impost Duties & Prizes," undoubtedly consisted of Congress' March 22 appeal to Connecticut to remove the three-year limitation from its act of February 3 "vesting in Congress, for a limited time, a power to levy and collect duties," for which see JCC, 19:295-96; and Samuel Huntington's first letter to Jonathan Trumbull of March 24, 1781.
I am to acknowledge your kind attentions of Feb. 10 and March 1st. I hoped to be able to give you a better account of Cornwallis than you have of Arnold: But we must wait some Days longer before we can judge whether he will fail in his Retreat. As to Arnold He is yet too safe. I shall have opportunity of writing again next Thursday and will forward any Intelligence that may happen to arrive before that Time. I wish you had been a little more diffuse as to the Calculation of Interest at yr. Treasury Office. I do not well comprehend your Hint in your Postscript. I will give you on the next page the Result of that Appointment of a Comtee of which you was one April 10.(1) It is only giving Good Words to some of the Staff.
You will find that we got very happily through a Resolve respecting Allen's Department at the Eastward. The Resolve has been transmitted.(2)
Yr. Friend and affectionate humb. Servt.
James Lovell
The Resolve was reconsidered and recommitted. I therefore tear it off.
1 Lovell is referring to the committee appointed on April 10, 1780, "to report a proper compensation to the staff of the army in consequence of the depreciation of the currency." Holten had been an original member, but James Duane and Jesse Root had been named to the committee in the place of Holten and Nathaniel Peabody after their departure from Congress; and at the same time, January 5, 1781, instructions from Massachusetts to her congressional delegates on this subject were also referred to it.
The committee's report, recommending limited compensation for depreciation, was adopted on March 7, but two days later Congress abruptly resolved that the resolution "be reconsidered and recommitted." A revised report was eventually taken
It was Lovell's belated discovery that the resolve of the 7th had been recommitted on March 9 that inspired the postscript to this letter.
2 For the transmittal of a resolve authorizing Col. John Allan to raise a company of Continental Artillery at Machias, see Samuel Huntington to John Hancock, February 17, 1781.
We have just received an Account from the Captain of a Vessel who belongs to Newport & is arrivd in this river. That the French & Brittish fleets which lately left Newport & Gardners Bay fell in with each other a little to the Southward of Cape Henry on the 16th instant when an action commenced between the van of the two fleets & lasted forty five minits.(1)
The Captain says He saw one of the Brittish drove out of the line after which the firing ceased, & both fleets were maneuvring, the French being to windward when the Informant left them, & Sailed for this place, this report leaves us Still in anxious Suspence.
During the action he lay at about three miles distant from the fleets, having Sailed from Newport under convoy of the French.
We have no Intelligence from the Southern Army later than you will find in the public papers.
The Brittish Manifesto against the Dutch with the Sudden & violent proceedings against their Shipping & property must have reached you before this comes to hand.
This Event must produce Some Important Change in the affairs of Europe, time will discover its Effect.
I am Sir with Esteem & Respect your Humble Servt,
Saml Huntington
1 The French fleet from Rhode Island, commanded by the chevalier Destouches, and the British fleet, commanded by Adm. Marriot Arbuthnot, clashed indecisively off Cape Henry, Va., on March 16. The fleets broke off action after the French gained a clear advantage, damaging several British ships in the battle. William M. James, The British Navy in Adversity (London: Longmans, Green 8: Co. Ltd., 1926), pp. 270-75.
I have been honored with your Excellency's two Letters of the 8th Instant with the several Papers to which they refer.(1) The Limitation of the Act impowering Congress to levy a Duty &c to three Years
The Proceedings of Congress relative to this Subject, as also the several other Despatches contained in your Excellency's Letters will be forwarded immediately after they are completed.(2)
We have just received an Account by the Captain of a Merchant Vessel arrived in this river, that the French & Brittish Fleets that lately left Newport & Gardners Bay fell in with each other a little to the Southward of Cape Henry on the 16th Instant, when an Action commenced between the Van of the two Fleets which lasted forty five Minutes. The Captain reports that he saw one of the Brittish drove out of the Line, after which the Firing, ceased and both Fleets were maneuvering, the French being to windward when he left them, so that we are left in anxious Doubt as to the final Event of their Meeting.
We have no Intelligence from General Greene or the southern Army later than the 2d Instant. The Delay of Intelligence from him is construed rather favorable, though it must be supposed Affairs in that Quarter are in a critical Situation, Arnold & his Party lie still at Portsmouth, should the french Fleet so far succeed as to be able to enter the Chesapeake & maintain their intended Station at that Place, it must give a very favorable Turn to the ensuing Campaign.
Before this comes to Hand your Excellency will probably have heard of the British Manifesto & their violent Attack upon the Dutch, their Shipping & Property; which must produce some important Change of Affairs in Europe. I am once more earnestly to request that a Delegate may be sent to relieve me as soon as possible. Genl Woolcot & Col. Root both expect to leave Congress in the Course of a few Weeks, when the State will be unrepresented & I cannot think of enduring the Burden & Confinement of my present Situation another Summer.
I have the Honor to be, with every Sentiment of Esteem & respect, your Excellency's most obedient Servant, Sam. Huntington
1 Only one March 8 letter from Governor Trumbull, enclosing Connecticut's new act "vesting in Congress a Power to levy & Collect Duties & Imports within this State," is in PCC (item 66, 2:186-87). The enclosure was read and referred to committee on March 15 and became the subject of Congress' resolves of March 22 which are the subject of the following note.
2 Actually "The Proceedings of Congress relative to this Subject" had already been completed on March 22, the day Huntington transmitted them to the speaker of the Pennsylvania Assembly, for which see JCC, 19:262, 295-97; and Huntington to Frederick A. Muhlenberg, March 22, 1781. In misrepresenting this fact to Trumbull, Huntington was apparently playing for time, perhaps apprehensive over Connecticut's reaction to Congress' request to drop the three-year limitation attached to the state's grant of authority to Congress to levy a 5 percent impost. In contrast to the Connecticut grant "for a limited time," New York had just adopted a measure meeting congressional expectations, and the Pennsylvania Assembly had just introduced
I have been honored with your Excellency's Letter of the 26th of February through Genl Washington. The Letter, by an accidental Mistake of your Secretary, being in the Superscription addressed to the General & by him on discovering the Mistake forwarded to me.(1)
By the enclosed Act of Congress of the 16th Instant your Excellency will be informed that Congress are of Opinion that the Invalids belonging to the Line of Connecticut cannot be stationed in that State agreeable to the request contained in your Letter, consistent with the general Benefit of the United States.(2)
The whole of the Invalid Corps amount to but a Small Number, how many are of the Connecticut Line I am unable to say; they are, at present, to the Eastward, I believe in Massachusetts.
I have the Honor to be, with great respect & Esteem, your Excellency's most obedient Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 Governor Trumbull's February 26 letter to Huntington, addressed "His Excellency General Washington, Head Quarters, N. Winsor," is in PCC, item 66, fols. 182-85.
2 Trumbull's February 26 letter requesting assignment of Connecticut troops belonging to the Continental Corps of Invalids to duty within the state had been referred to the Board of War on March 6. The board had recommended against the request simply because of the impracticability of attempting to determine invalid assignments on the basis of residence, and Congress endorsed the recommendation on March 16. See JCC, 19:233, 265-66.
Congress have Called for 6,000,000 of Dollars to be paid quarterly to defray the Charges of the Current year. They have recommended to the States to amend their laws which make paper bills a legal tender other ways than at their Current value-have appointed the annual Fast to be on the 1st Thursday of May. We have no news,
P. S. A vessel arrived here today the Capt. Says he Sailed with the French fleet from Newport-that on the 12 they were parted in a fog. The adml. Came too off Cape Charles on the 1 6th the rest of the fleet joined him in about 2 hours after the british hove in Sight, the french to windward. An action insued for 45 minutes. One of the british was drove out of the line & both fleets Stood to Sea the French having the wind.(1)
1 See Samuel Huntington to Benjamin Huntington, this date, note.
I have taken the liberty to Trouble you with the Charge of Some packages by Brown to be forwarded. The large one Contains Some garden peas & Seeds-you may if you please open it and take Some of the low bush pea which is the largest parcel as I fancy they are not to be got in our Country & are more than I shall want & be kind enough to Seal them up again.
England has made war with the Dutch. Adl. Rodney has Captured St. Eustatia & all the Dutch & American vessels in the harbour, a heavy blow upon Some of the merchants here. The unfortunat Capture of Mr Laurences papers I hope will in the End be productive of beneficial Consequences to America.
We have had no late news from the Southward or the French Fleet; are in hourly expectation of Some interesting intelligence from that quarter.
Congress have Called for 6,000,000 of dollars to be paid quarterly as necessary to defray the Charges of the Current year. They have recommended to the States to amend their laws which make paper bill[s] a tender otherways than according to their Current value, & have appointed a fast on the 1st Thursday in May.
I enclose a newspaper. With Sentiments of esteem & respect I am your most obedt humble Sert.
P.S. A vessel Just arrived. The Capt. Says he sailed from N Port with the Fleet, that on the 12th they were parted in a fog. The admiral
England has declared war with the States of Holland have Seised upon St Eustatia and all the Dutch & American vessels in the harbour, Said to be upwards of forty of the latter-a heavy blow upon the merchants in this city. The Dutch admiral it is Said was killed; Curasoa, report Say, is likewise taken-the English it Seems like men of desperate fortune are endeavoring to retreive their Circumstances by robery & plunder-which Must draw on them the Enmity of the whole world.
Thus the unfortunate Capture of Mr. Laurences papers will probably be productive of the most fortunate event to America-this is Marvelous to Consider.
We have had no account lately from the Southward or from the French Fleet and are in hourly Expectation of Some very interesting intelligence from that quarter. The resolution of Congress Calling for Six million of dollars to be paid quarterly-and recommending to the States to amend their laws which make paper money a tender otherways than ad valorum-and appointing the 1st Thursday in May for a fast-will be transmitted to your Excellency by the President. The old Continental bills Continue to depreciate nor do I think it at all probable that any of the States will get their quota out of Circulation by the time prescribed. I need not repeat to your Excellency the necessity I am under to return home by the Middle of next month & that the State will be without a representative unless I am releived. I have enclosed the December Journals & Some news papers and am with the highest esteem & respect your Excellencys most obedt, humble, Servt.
Jesse Root
P.S. The Minister of France as Informed that the 2nd division will arrive early this Spring & wishes us to be ready to Cooperate with them. This day a Vessel arrived in the river, the Captn. Says that he Sailed with the French fleet from N port, that on the 12th the fleet was parted in a fog, that the Admiral with 4 Ships Came too off Cape Charles, on the 16th the rest of the fleet Joined him, that in about 2 hours after the british fleet hove in Sight, the wind at NE, the
1 On March 23 Congress had approved the relocation of the British officers of the Convention Army to Simsbury, Conn., as part of a larger plan to remove the Convention Army prisoners from the path of the British army in Virginia. See JCC, 19:301-2. See also Samuel Huntington's first letter to Washington of May 28, 1781, note 1.
I have been honoured with your Excellencys Letter of the 7th instant, with the Constitution or Articles of Government of Connecticut in 1636. The renewed Charter of Charles the 2d has also been recd. Before these came to Hand it became Necessary to print the Constitution of our State according to the Act of Congress. As I had a general Knowledge that the Charter of Charles the 2d was no more than a Confirmation of the Government established by our Ancestors with Some Additions and Improvments-And that the original Form of Government would not exhibit a full Idea of our present Constitution-And the Charter of Charles the 2d would be improper to be published-And that the Principles of our Government were in a great Measure founded upon certain fundamental Laws. I had no apprehension that the real Constitution of the State could be otherwise given to the Publick, than by an Account of the leading and main Princeples upon which the Goverment Operated, And having found an Account of the Constitution of our State printed in 1779 with tolerable Judgment and Accuracy, I have upon the Advice of the President of Congress, agreed to publish this Account with some Alterations (1)-which I think will give a good general Veiw of the Princeples of our Goverment as now existing, without entering into a Detail of it's Origin or Derivation which would be rather perhaps a Matter of Amusement than useful Information or productive of real Benefit. I shall be happy if what I have done Shall Meet with the Approbation of your Excellency and the State.
Your Excellency will recive from the President a Recommendation of Congress to the State to revise and amend their late Law
Your Excellency will likewise receive a Recommendation, that the States collect in Quaterly Payments Six Millions of Dollars in Specie or the New Emission beginning the first of June. I shall make no other observation upon this Measure than that it will be obvious that the Portion Assigned to Connecticut is too high compared with Massachusetts and some other States. In this Congress have governed themselves by former Precedents, except by lessening the Quotas of N York and N Carolina and placing the Deficiency proportionably on the other States. In this Place I will Observe to your Excellency that We have but the least Reason to expect Money from Abroad. This has been So clearly communicated that We must depend upon it.
The Commissary Genl. of Purchases Complains that by Reason of the Scanty Supplys of fresh Provisions the Army are fed with that which is Salted, in great Measure. This Circumstance will be severely felt the next Summer unless rectified as We are officially Acquainted that a Cooperation against The Enemy is designed. The Commissary also says that there is a most unreasonable Deficiency between the
The Rate of Exchange here is 130 Dollars old Money for one in specie. This Occasions Vast Quantitys to be sent on to the Eastward. And indeed the People from thence are here buying the old Money, as the Exchange is So much lower there than here. I mention this Circumstance as I suppose that a Depretiation at the Eastward may be expected soon to take Place. This old Money is continually undulating from one Part of the Continent to the Other, And productive of all the Mischief which can Attend a fluctuating Medium, But I will make no Observations but State Facts, upon which your Excellency is the best Able to judge with Regard to what Measures May be the most proper to be adopted.
We have no News from N Carolina but what your Excellency will See in the Papers. There is an Acco. which is probably true that the Two Fleets from the Eastward had an Ingagment On the 16t off the Capes of Virginia. The Capt of the Brig who brings this Intelligence left the Fleets in the Action-he says that the French were at the Windward, that but one of the English Ships supposed to be the Admirals had engaged, that as he was Attacked by three or four French Ships She was drove out of the Line. We must Wait to hear the Result of this affair.
I Wrote to Mr Ellsworth some time ago that it was Necessary for me to Return home early in April.(3) He has given me no Reason to believe that either he or Mr Law would be here by that Time. I hope that the Assembly have Appointed New Members in the Room of the late Mr. Hosmore and Col Adams resigned. Mr Huntington and Mr Root I suppose will tarry here till the latter End of next month Altho Mr Root talks as if he Should Return a little earlier yet I think he will tarry till that Time.
I am with the highest Esteem and Regard, your Excellency's Most Obedient Servant, Oliver Wolcott
1 Wolcott's "Account" of the Connecticut constitution was included in the compilation printed by direction of Congress' resolution of December 29, 1780-The Constitutions of the Several Independent States of America..., for which see James Madison to Thomas Jefferson, May 5, 1781, note 1 . See also Wolcott to Trumbull, January 9,
2 See Samuel Huntington's first letter to Trumbull, this date, note 2.
3 This was undoubtedly the following undated and damaged letter to Oliver Ellsworth that Edmund C. Burnett printed under the date March 24? 1781 (Burnett, Letters, 6:35-36), from the original manuscript in the Sprague Collection at the Congregational Library (London) now on deposit at Dr. Williams's Library (London).
"I wrote to [you sometime ago] informing you that I [planned to return] Home early in the Spring, [and I believe] that I mentioned to you the first of April. But wheither my Letters have been recd. by you I am not able to Say. Mr. Huntington and Mr. Root will probably continue here till the latter end of April, at which Time they will Return. Whiether the State has supplied the Vacancies made in the
"I have No News but what you will find in the publick Papers. Congress are upon the Subject of Finance. But nothing has been lately effected upon this Head."
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, an Act of Congress of the 24th Instant, requesting the Supreme Executive of Virginia to appoint suitable Persons to settle the Accounts of Colonel Wood respecting his Command in superintending the Convention Prisoners. (1)
Your several Letters of the 8th, 19th & 21st with the Papers to which they refer have been received & laid before Congress.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with very high regard, your Excellency's most obedt humble Servant, Sam. Huntington President
1 See JCC, 19:258, 289, 306. In addition to this directive for settling the accounts and defraying the travel expenses of Col. James Wood as commandant of Convention Army prisoners, Congress this day also requested Maryland to furnish Wood "fifteen thousand dollars of the old emissions" for the expenses of an officer to be sent to Connecticut in connection with the planned move of the Convention Army prisoners, a request Huntington enclosed with a brief letter of this date to Gov. Thomas Sim Lee. JCC, 19:307-8; and MdAA, Red Books, 8:44.
2 For these Jefferson letters, see JCC, 19:262, 313; PCC, item 71, 2:53-70; and Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:91-92, 179, 198-99.
Congress have been pleased to refer to your Excellency the enclosed Letter of the 21st Instant from Colonel Wood, soliciting in Behalf of Lt Colonel Hill the Liberty of being indulged his Parole to go to England, as also the Letter of the 20th Instant from Lt Col. Dubuyson, desiring that a similar Favor for himself may be made the Condition on which Lt. Col. Hill's Request should be granted; if obtained. (1)
The Circumstances of Lt Colonel Dubuyson, from the Wounds he received at the Battle of Camden, seem to entitle him to an equal Indulgence with the other Officer.
I have been honored with two of your Letters of the first Instant & one of the 21st, with the several Papers to which they refer;(2) am
It is probable the Letters which accompany this will give your Excellency the latest Intelligence I have received from the southern Army, & the British Fleet now in the Chesapeake, yet as the Intelligence is important, have thought proper to transmit the enclosed Extracts of Letters from Governor Jefferson & Mr Barron.(3)
The Minister of France will give you the Particulars of the Action between the two Fleets on the 16th Instant with more Exactness than I have been able to collect. No Vessel captured on either Side-the french Fleet I suppose are gone to Newport.
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Regard, your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington Presidt.
1 See JCC, 19:289-90. The enclosed letters from Col. James Wood (on behalf of Lt. Col. John Hill of the 9th Regiment of Foot of the Convention Army) and the chevalier Dubuysson des Hayes are in the Washington Papers, DLC. For the previous efforts of Dubuysson to obtain his exchange, see Huntington to Washington, October 23, 1780; and Theodorick Bland to Thomas Jefferson, January 29, 1781. Although Washington continued to oppose such special exchanges, there is indirect evidence that an arrangement of some sort was worked out, for in June Hill was granted permission to go to New York, and in September Dubuysson obtained leave to return to France. See Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:242, 248; PCC, item 78, 7:4034; and JCC, 21:931.
2 Washington's letters are in PCC, item 152, 10:5-10, 21-22; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:326-27, 349-50.
3 These "enclosed Extracts," consisting of Thomas Jefferson's March 21 letter to Huntington and a March 20 letter to Jefferson from James Barron reporting the appearance "within the Capes" of 12 ships "under English Colours" preparing to join Benedict Arnold's ships in Hampton Road, are in the Washington Papers, DLC. See also Jefferson Papers (Boyd), 5:187, 198-99.
Before this can reach you, our Countrymen will have finishd the important Business of electing their Legislators, Magistrates and Governor. I hope they have made a wise Choice.(2) At least, from the Opinion I entertain of their Virtue; I am purswaded they have acted with all that Deliberation & Caution which the Solemnity of the Transaction required. They may then reflect, each one on his own Conduct, and appeal to the Monitor in his Breast, that he has not trifled with the sacred Trust reposed in him by GOD & his Country-that he has not prostituted his Honor and Conscience to
But our Countrymen will not imagine, that having filled the several Departments of Government, they have no further Concern about it. Their Duty and Interest, I humbly conceive, should lead them to attend to the Manner in which it is administerd, by those whom they have entrusted. How often has the finishing Stroke been given to publick Liberty, by those who have possessd or seemd to possess many amiable Virtues! Gustavus Vasa was viewed by the Swedes as the Deliverer of their Country from the Danish yoke.(3) The most implicit Obedience, says the Historian, was considered by them as a Debt of Gratitude and a Virtue. He had many excellent Qualities. His Manners were conciliating-his Courage & Abilities, great. The People by an entire Confidence in him, sufferd him to lay a Foundation for an absolute Monarchy. They were charmd with his Moderation and Wisdom, Qualities which he really possessd; but they did not consider his Ambition nor had they a Thought of his Views. They found Peace restord, Order establishd, Justice administerd, Commerce protected & the Arts and Sciences encouragd, & they looked no further. They did not imagine that he who had been instrumental in recovering the Independence of their Country, was the very Man who was to effect the Ruin of their Liberties. By the Constitution of Sweden their Kings were elective, & the Powers of their Sovereign were exceedingly limitted. The unsuspecting People even voluntarily gave up their Right of Election, & sufferd Gustavus to increase the Powers of the Crown & entail it in his own Family! This is the Account which the History of Sweden gives us; and it affords an Instance among a thousand others, of the Folly & Danger of trusting even good Men with Power, without regarding the Use they make of it. Power is in its Nature incroaching; and such is the human Make, that Men who are vested with a Share of it, are generally inclind to take more than it was intended they shoud have. The Love of Power, like the Love of Money, increases with the Possession of it; and we know, in what Ruin these Baneful Passions have involvd human Societies, in all Ages, when they have been let loose, & sufferd to rage uncontrould. There is no Restraint like the pervading Eye of the virtuous Citizens. I hope therefore, our Country
1 The following essay appeared in Benjamin Edes' Boston Gazette on April 16, 1781.
2 Adams was himself elected a senator for Suffolk County. See Adams to the Public, March 13, 1781, note 1.
3 Gustavus Vasa (1496-1560) was elected king of Sweden in 1523.
It is a long time since I have been favourd with a Line from you. It is more than probable that our Communications on both sides miscarry, Indeed I have had so little, which coud afford pleasure, to transmit, and I think it the worst of All Employments to vex my Friends who are happy enough to retire from this anxious Theatre with Incidents which may depress their Spirits without being of publick Advantage. All our Evills may be resolved into the Want of money which seems to pervade every State, at least none of them have made Exertions to remove the Complaint. To keep the general Treasury exhausted while the Country abounds with plenty and there is a high market for every sort of produce, and many of the States enjoy uninterrupted Tranquillity: cannot be accounted for on any principle which does Honour to our Patriotism or publick Spirit. Where this backwardness is avoidable it ought to be reprobated; for there seems no doubt but with a very moderate Share of Vigour the Enemies of this Country will be expelled in a single Campaign.
Every thing practicable here has been done for maintaining the Southern States in a spirited opposition against Cornwallis & Arnold. I am convinced that if the Pensylvania Line instead of revolting for want a little money had marched to Join Greene the British Powers in the Carolinas & Georgia must have been totally
Arnold has a Reprieve. The French and british fleets have met near the Capes of Virginia and a Hardy Engagement ensued. Night separated them. De Estouches expected and prepared to renew the Combat next morning; Arburthnot was contented with his Share of the battle, and in the night time steered his Course for Portsmouth leaving his Antagonist master of the Sea. Can a british Admiral Justify thus retiring from an inferior Squadron of the French who they pretend[....]He will plume himself on relieving Arnold; But it coud not have hurt his Reputation to beat the French in the bargain. To hide from them seems inglorious.
I have now passed nearly another year in Congress, and am sufficiently tired & homesick. You will I presume be requested to take my place. Your Services will be exceedingly necessary. I set out as soon as the Roads admit. Col. Floyd has heard disagreeable Accounts of his Ladys health which hurries him away this day.(1)
You will have the pleasure of seeing your new Sister soon, as the Col. thinks of setting out to morrow.
I am with great Respect & affectionate Complements to your Lady, mamma & every branch of the family.
Dear Sir, your most Obedt & very hume Servt.
Jas. Duane
1 With William Floyd's departure, New York remained unrepresented in Congress until July 31 when Ezra L'Hommedieu returned to Philadelphia. Alexander McDougall had not been attending since March 1, and Duane himself returned home at the beginning of May although he resumed his seat with L'Hommedieu on July 31. Actually, as neither Duane nor Floyd attended on March 24, New York did not cast a vote in Congress from March 22 until August 1, 1781. See JCC 19:293, 305, 21 :816, 822.
The difficulty of maintaining New York's representation at this time was also the substance of the following extract from a March 28 letter of Robert R. Livingston to Philip Schuyler.
"Have you provided for the delegation? McDougall will quit, Duane will either be elected president or return home soon. The chair will be vacant soon by Mr. Huntington's retiring, Duane, Jones, Mathews are talked of. Would it not be prudent to meet in some measure, the complaints of the people & have one or two delegates who are not refugees especially as what I have mentioned will weaken the delegation greatly. I could heartily wish that Morris supplied McDougall's place & that you wd.
In my last I acquainted your Excellency there had been an Engagement between the french & British Fleets a little to the Southward of Cape Henry on the 16th Instant, since which the British have got into the Chesapeake, no Vessels were captured on either Side, you will likely hear the french Fleet are returned to Newport before this is received.
Genl Greene has had an Action with Lord Cornwallis, the enclosed Extracts will give the most authentic Intelligence respecting it which hath yet been received.(1)
I have the Honor to be with the highest respect, Your Excellency's most obedt & humble Servant, Sam. Huntington
1 This preliminary report on the battle at Guilford Court House in North Carolina between Cornwallis and Gen. Nathanael Greene on March 15 was contained in a March 21 letter from Gov. Thomas Jefferson that was read in Congress this day. See JCC, 19:313; Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:198-99; and James Varnum to Catharine Greene, this date.
I yesterday received your Favors of the 5th & 12th.
I have already written to you fully in regard to what was brought for you by Capt. Jones.(1) I will pursue all modes of forwarding the Articles which I may think convenient. Brown had left Philada. before I recd. your hint about his purchasing a Carriage. I believe the Badness of the Roads prevented him.
I thank you for your Direction about the Chintz. I must omit to follow it till some time when you shall have been more in Luck than now.
Baron Arandt would be very glad to be a Pensioner upon us in the military Line or to be sent as our Agent to Prussia.(2) He had been home on furlough for his Health, being burstan,(3) he outstaid his Time, is not established, but having determined to come over again, The Chamber of Commerce in Prussia or Somebody of that Kind instructed him to inform them of the nature of American Commerce, which is no more than what our commercial Comtee. ought
I have acknowledged your Letter by Genl. Knox and have sent you the Bill of Exchange by Doctr. Winship who I suspect will stick deep in the mud a long time with his Waggon. I will send you the Comments by the first private Hand.
I dare not show your Vermont Anecdote to Jemmy D. -- -a pious McDougal almost swore.
For Conscience Sake weigh well our Request of the 5 pr Cent Impost. I have sent to Mr. Avery a Resolve upon the Connecticutt Act: (4) see it for your Information. He will make one of his Clerk's copy it upon yr. Request, if you are not at Boston.
We shall this afternoon put an End to all favorable Exemptions which the Bermudians have had in the Admiralty Courts, and also to the Priviledges heretofore granted to persons coming to settle.(5)
We have been very unlucky in a Naval Engagement of the Fleets. Privateers have had success. Our Allies behaved, all for the best, under the Government of Necessity. They have been very gallant; But a Fog at first, and the Bad sailing of 5 Ships afterwards, made it impossible for them to gain Cheseapeak before the British.
Arnold is safe at present; and the Neighbourhood of the Waters of Cheseapeak must suffer for a Time. I think the british Fleet will not long remain at such a Distance from the french.
One of my Sons writes that some southern Speculators upon hard Money have been driven from Boston.
I wrote to you by Mr. Randall & again by Mr. Brown upon Business for your Friend D_ (6) act immediately or wait awhile as you shall judge best for D & me.
I am, affly yrs. JL
[P.S.] Doctr. Shield wonders much that he does not get a Line of answer to several Letters.
Genl. Roberdeau is here and often asks me if I have no Letters from you for him.
Mrs. Clymar still breathes but is limited by her Doctors to 3 daies. Compliments from the Heads of this Family.
1 See Lovell to Gerry, March 5, 1781.
2 For a discussion of baron d'Arendt's latest claims for benefits from Congress, see Virginia Delegates to Thomas Jefferson, January 1, 1781, note 3.
3 That is, a "broken" man.
4 See Lovell to John Avery, March 23, 1781.
5 An ordinance restricting trade and travel between Britain's dependencies and the United States, introduced by James Madison on March 16, was adopted this day. See JCC, 19:270-72, 314-16; and Samuel Adams to Caleb Davis, April 3, 1781.
6 That is, Miss Dalley. See Lovell to Gerry, March 6 (not in printed text) and 20, 1781.
I yesterday received your Favor of the 15th, as I did also some Letters from Mr. Carmichael through Mr. Gerry's Care;(1) But still I have none from Mr. Jay, which is very mysterious.
I am rejoiced to find the Spirit of our State so high in the common Cause notwithstandg. all its particular Burthens.
You will know the Conduct of the french Fleet off the Capes of Virginia before this reaches you; but you are now also to hear that Green has lost a Battle. The french were under an absolute necessity of fighting, they would otherwise have sacrificed a little Glory to the main purpose of their sailing from Newport. They behaved most gallantly. We have only to lament their and our Disappointment by a Fog first and afterwards by a Want of Swiftness in 5 of their Ships which obliged the 3 fast Sailers to tarry for them and risque the Battle. You will have your wish as to Bermuda. All saving Clauses of former Resolves respecting that Island, and respecting Settlers and the Importers of Arms &c. will be repealed unless so far as that the Repeal shd. not condemn Vessels now in port or Bermudians with Salt only arriving before the 1st of May.(2) You will not publish my Communications unless I send the Acts of Congress. I hope you will see that the unparallelled Distress of Congress in Money Matters leaves no Remedy but calling upon such States as are able to furnish enough for our Necessities without affecting the true Quota which individual States ought to pay upon the confederal Principles.
I wish you Happiness being sincerely and with Esteem, Your friend and humb. Servt. J.L.
1 Lovell had received William Carmichael's letters to the Committee for Foreign Affairs of September 25 and October 15, 1780, for which see Lovell to John Jay, March 31, 1781, note 2. The letter of September 25 was a duplicate; that of October 15 was read in Congress on March 26. See JCC, 19:311; PCC, item 88, fols. 99-102; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:99-100.
2 See the preceding entry, note 5.
As we have Allready requested of your Excellency and the Honble Council, A Supply of Cash,(1) we have only to add, that the new Bills Issued under the Act of Congress of the 18th March, will Answer our purposes, And that we hope shall be Supplied Soon with a thousand dollars each of that Emission for Which We Will Account at the Current Exchange.
We are honored With your Excellencys favour of the 23d.(2) We have the honor to be With the highest esteem, Gentlemen, your most hble servts, John Hanson
Daniel Carroll
1 See Maryland Delegates to Lee, March 13, 1781.
2 See ibid., note.
I have been honored with your very agreable Letter of ; but have it not about me. Should you pursue your Intention of going to the Southward, I shall be peculiarly happy in seeing you on the Way. We have not Accounts of late from General Greene, but a Letter received Yesterday from Governor Jefferson of Virginia, gives us the following Intelligence.(1) "That on the fifteenth of this Month a General Action was fought between the two Armies, wch. continued incessant for an hour and a Quarter; That General Greene then retired in good Order, unpursued, one Mile and an half, with the Loss of four Pieces of Canon and between two & three hundred killed and wounded. The Enemies Loss between five and six hundred: That General Greene intended a second Attack the day following, but was prevented by Rain; That every Circumstance indicated a new Engagement." This Acct. the Governor received from a Capt. of Artillery who was in Action. I now know what the Sensations of your Breast will be upon reading so far; But lest your Cheeks should become too crimson, I shall not mention them; For you are sensible I can never command my own Countenance When that of a Lady is agitated. However, This, to me, & most People who think cooly, is very good Intelligence. For Considering the small Number of our Continental Troops, and the irregular Nature of the Southern Militia, we might have expected a total Defeat, instead of a Conflict so equally maintained. To convince the Militia that they can fight is half making them Veterans; And We may safely pronounce General Greene's Strength after the Battle, a Quarter greater than before. So true it is that all the Benefits of a long Experience may be gained in an Hour. I have not felt so firm a Persuasion of Success from the Beginning as at present. Perhaps you may think me too anxious on the Side of Friendship, and too much interested in your Felicity to indulge different Reflections; But I give you the Account exactly as we have received it; & shall repeat my Information as soon as more authentic Intelligence shall be obtained. I love Sincerity for its own sake as well as for the Relation it bears to social Connection, And I declare upon my Honor, America ought, and doubtless will
1 See Samuel Huntington to Jonathan Trumbull, this date, note.
On the receipt of your favor of the 22d of February inclosing the Memorial of Mr. Stodder and Kerr with the protests and affidavits annexed, we communicated the matter to Congress, and have obtained an instruction to the Hon'ble Mr. Adams to represent the same to the States General of the United Provinces, and to claim such redress for the Memorialists as justice and the law of Nations require.(1) We have also received your Excellency's favor of the 15th instant relating to Mr. Nathan with the several papers under the same cover and shall carry your Excellency's wishes into execution in the best manner we can.(2)
Capt. de la touche is arrived here from the French fleet,(3) with the stores belonging to Virginia,(4) which were delivered to him at Providence...Capt de La Touche confirms the intelligence of an action between the two fleets on the 16th It does not appear to have been by any means a decisive, though a pretty severe one. The French claim the advantage, and say that the English appeared very willing to decline a renewal of the combat.
We have the honor to be with the most perfect respect and esteem y'r Excellency's Obt. and humble Servants
James Madison Junr.
Theo'k Bland
1 Jefferson's letter of February 22 and an undated memorial from David Stodder, George Kerr, and William North, complaining that their ship Renown has been illegally seized by the British the preceding August in the neutral Dutch harbor of St. Martin, were read in Congress on March 26. See JCC, 19:312; PCC, item 71, 2:45, item 41, 9: 133-34; and Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 4:689-90. Upon a motion by James Madison and Meriwether Smith, Congress ordered that the documents be forwarded to commissioner John Adams to seek redress from the States General in the Netherlands "as justice and the law of nations require."
2 For Jefferson's letter of March 15 and a reconstruction of the complicated and drawn out claims of Philadelphia merchant and speculator, Simon Nathan, against the Virginia government, see ibid., 5:152-53, 6:321-24; and Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:20-21.
3 Capt. Louis-Rene-Madeleine, comte de La Touche had arrived aboard the frigate L'Hermione in Chester, Pa., on March 26 with the Virginia goods originally consigned to the French schooner Le Comite, for which see ibid., 3:40n.3; and Virginia Delegates to Samuel Nightingale, Jr., December 30, 1780, and January 2, 1781.
4 Remainder of text from Henkels Catalog.
I have wrote you two Letters by way of Boston since you left us,(1) but not hearing of the Sailing of this Vessel untill this Moment, I have scarcely time more than to inclose you the late papers which will give you all the material Intelligence since my last, The failure of the French Fleet in not getting into Chesapeak, is very unlucky as Arnold must certainly have fallen had they arrived, however we are in daily expectation of the 2d Division appearing who I hope will enable us to retrive our Southern Affairs-you will see by the Papers a short Account of an Action between Genl. Green & Lord Cornwallis on the 15th Instant, but as yet we have no particulars except that it was expected the Attack would be renewed in a day or two, we are anxious to hear the Event. Sumpter, Marian, & Pickens had a considerable Body of Militia in Motion between Camden & the Enemy, & about 1000 North Carolina Militia were in the neighbourhood of Wilmington, where the British had not more than 300 Men intrenching themselves by Accounts from So. Carolina dated last Month, we find our Friends at St. Augustine were in good Spirits & determined to hold out to the last, but many of those left behind had been reduced to the necessity of making a temporary submission rather than see their families starve, which they must otherwise have done. Capt. Vanderhorst who had been in a Flagg to fetch away his Family was arrived at Newburn, & writes me, that he could give me interesting Accounts of our Friends in that quarter, but he did not venture to commit it to paper, if we can give them any Effectual Aid, many of them will be ready to cooperate with us, but others have lost themselves for ever-for instance, Old Colo. Pinckney has accepted the office of Superindant of the Police in the room of Jas. Simpson who has gone to New York, but our Ladies to their eternal Honour have uniformly supported their Characters of staunch Whiggs-they steadily refuse any Association with the British Officers, will go to none of their Public Amusements, & it may be depended on as a Fact, that many who were reduced to the necessity of selling their Buckles now wear Black & White Roses in their Shoes in Honour of the alliance, which is now a distinguishing
Tho Bee
P.S. Please present my Complmts [to] Major Jackson, & inform him I sent a draft for the amount of his whole debt to Boston, which money Mr McCall will receive for him.(3)
1 Probably his letters of January 16 and February 9, 1781.
2 In this protracted invective, which appeared in the March 14, 21, 28, April 4 and 11 issues of The Pennsylvania Gazette and Weekly Advertiser under the pseudonym "An
3 On April 3 Bee also sent partial payment from a debt owed to Messrs. North, Triscot & Blake, merchants in Charleston, S.C., for which see the Cornwallis Papers (P.R.O. 30/11), 105:12, PRO.
This Morning I had the Honour of your Excellency's Letter dated the 24 inst. I should have written you by Post Yesterday, but knowing of a Conveyance today or tomorrow Morning, I postpond it hoping to possess myself more fully of the News from the French Fleet as well as from General Greene.
The Substance of both you have probably heard; I will set down as shortly and correctly as I can the Details I have collected.
On the 15 inst the Engagement between General Greene and Lord Cornwallis was fought. The Intelligence of it comes verbally to Richmond in Virginia by a Captain Singleton of the Artillery who left General Greene's Head-quarters next Day. Governour Jefferson writes it from thence to Congress. It is said both Armies were prepared and desirous of Action; that the Contest was pretty general and severe, and lasted near two Hours; that it happened about a mile and a Half from Guilford Court-house in North Carolina; that Lord Cornwallis was about 2500 strong and General Greene near 4000, mostly Militia, but this according to General Greene's Letter to Congress dated a few Days before the Action, must be a Mistake, as he could not from Probabilities have more in the whole than about 26 or 2700; that the Militia and Regulars of our Army suffered nearly equal Numbers; that General Greene retreated about a Mile and a Half from the Ground leaving it to the Enemy, who did not think fit to pursue; that our Loss was about 300 killed, wounded and Prisoners and 4 Pieces of Artillery; among the killed Major Anderson of the Maryland Regulars and Capt Barret of Washington's Cavalry; among the wounded General Stevens of the Virginia Militia and Capt Fontleroy of the above mentioned Cavalry, the latter left on the Field; the Informant says that from what he saw he was of Opinion General Greene meant to renew the Action next Morning but was prevented by a heavy Rain; that there appeared no Want of Spirits in his Army, but being mostly Militia or raw Recruits they fought at great Disadvantage against Cornwallis' Veterans; that when he left General Greene it seemed to be his Intention to fight the Enemy again as soon as the Weather permitted. I cannot
The Action between the Fleets is important only in its Consequences, our Disappointment and the British Fleet getting into Hampton-road. Both Fleets arrived off the Capes of Virginia nearly at the same Time, the French rather before, but not long enough to get fairly into the Bay and prepare for debarking the Men. They were under the Necessity of fighting, though neither Side appears to have been very desirous of beginning or earnest in continuing the Action. Nothing decisive has taken Place on either Side; both had some Ships a little disabled. In the French Fleet the Conquerant was shot in the Rudder and the Ardent in her Masts and Yards so far to be in an unfavourable Situation for fighting. Some other Ships suffered a little in their Rigging. The French have returned to Rhode-Island to refit. One of their Frigates is unfortunately left in Cheeseapeak; the Hermion, Capt de la Touche, is arrived at Chester with Dispatches for the Minister. This sadly deranges our Plans, but however we will hope for our Day.
No late News from Europe. As I expect to be at Trenton in a Day or two, shall beg your further attention to what I mentioned respecting the Dutch. Your Ideas are certainly right.
I have the Honour to be, Your Excellency's obedt Servant. W C Houston
The Committee recollect your Excellency's Communication that his most Christian Majesty's Minister of Finance had obtained or Acquired from the Minister Plenipotentiary of these States a letter of Credit on Congress for Provisions to the amount of four hundred thousand Dollars.(1) They request your Excellency to inform them whether his Majesty's Ministers rely on the letter of Credit alluded to, as a Contract absolutely concluded and which Congress are in all Events bound to ratify and perform? (It they Consider it in this light The Committee have no doubt that Congress will employ every means in their
1 For this reference to a letter of credit obtained by Jacques Necker, French director general of finances, from Benjamin Franklin for the delivery of $400,000 worth of Provisions to the French forces in America, see JCC, 19:308-11; and Committee of Congress to Jean Holker, March 23, 1781, note.
This committee, consisting of Samuel Adams, Thomas Burke, John Hanson, Joseph Jones, Thomas McKean, and James Madison, had been appointed on March 24 to respond to a memorial from La Luzerne requesting a conference to discuss Franklin's proposal for establishing a line of credit in France in return for the delivery of provisions to French agents in America. In addition to this draft letter to La Luzerne, a translation of his response to the committee and three pages of "Notes from the Minister of France on a Conference" on the "Subsistance de l'Armee," are also located in PCC, item 96, fols. 265-72.
2 The surviving documents on this subject suggest that congressional support for this proposal was never in doubt, and that once Franklin offered the delivery of provisions to French forces in America in return for a line of credit of $400,000 he could draw upon in Paris, only the means for implementing the plan remained for serious discussion. The committee's report on La Luzerne's March 24 memorial r ecommended that the United States "take every measure in their power" to implement the scheme and Congress adopted the committee's recommendation on April 11, for which see JCC, 19:370-73; and Samuel Huntington to La Luzerne, April 15, 1781.
I presume in this you have received the Paper Intelligence; but as that is not authentic nor so particular as the Account from the Southard by Governor Jefferson's Letter to Congress Received on Wednesday last, I do my self the Honor to favor you therewith.(1)
The Governor Writes that on the 15th Inst. about a Mile and a Half from Guilford Court House Green & Cornwallis had a Battle, which lasted one Hour & a Quarter, that Green retreated a Mile & a Half in good Order, having lost two Peices of Cannon and about 300 killed and wounded, Cornwallis lost between 500 & 700 killed and wounded, that General Green determined to renew the Attaque the Next Morning, but the Weather prevented. The Enemy were 2500, & our Troops including Militia or Mostly so 4000, our Men &c behaved well, were in high Spirits & anxious for another Engagement, this Account the Governor had from an Officer who was in the Action.
This I call a very good Account, for if Green is so strong as to Attac the Enemy, he only has to keep up the Ball awhile and he must
All the Accounts we have of an Action between the Fleets have been published which I dare say you have seen, and I think it may be said, (all things Considered) that the French Arms have gained Reputation.
I would just Mention to you that Monday come a Week Mr. McKean has to attend a Court in this City and Tuesday Week our Supreme Court begins, so that Delaware will be unrepresented in Congress. Newhampshire, Newyork & Rhode Island are now in the same situation. I shall be detained about 10 Days and I wish you if possible to order Matters so as to be here on Sunday come a Week, for you know that your Attendance (although you alone cannot give the Vote of the State) is Necessary & may be very useful. Mr. McKean [h]as attended every Day since I came up & seems in good Health.
Please present my Complimts. to Mrs. Rodney, and believe me to be, yr. Most obdt. Nichs. Van Dyke
1 See Samuel Huntington to Jonathan Trumbull, March 27, 1781, note.
This will be handed to my dearest Polly by Col. H.B. Livingston. How they will get on I know not as the roads even here are unfit for a Carriage.
I have orderd a Phaeton to be made for Brother Walter which is to be finished in a fortnight. In this our Daughter will have a Seat and probably Sister Robert C. as we all propose coming together. I include Brother Harry. I hope by the latter End of April or the beginning of May your Roads will be tolerable. I wish to hear when you favour me with a Line. For my own part as I prefer a Horse it is of no Consequence; but the Carriage must be attended to.
We have nothing from the Southward since I wrote to you last; except that Cornwallis lost 800 killed besides the wounded in his late battle with our Army under General Greene & that the next morning he proceded to Court house leaving all his dead unburied altho' General Ohara was among the number. We have yet no further particulars except that our Regulars as well as militia behaved with uncommon Spirit and that Cols. Washington & Lee of the Cavalry have acquired great Glory. The opinion is as strong as ever that Lord Cornwallis and his Army must fall into our hands.
I enclose you the late news papers. Present my dutiful & affectionate Regards to our honord Father & Mamma & my respectful Compliments to every branch of the family. Kiss and bless for me our dear Children and believe me to be with unalterable Affection, my dearest Polly, Your ever faithful Husband,
Jas. Duane (1)
1 Duane also wrote a brief letter the following day to Col. John Davis of Carlisle, Pa., asking for the payment of "47.10 specie due for my mare." John Davis Papers, DLC.
Your Excellency will receive herewith enclosed, an Ordinance relative to the Capture & Condemnation of Prizes, and repealing all former Acts & Resolutions of Congress contrary to the true Intent & Meaning of this Ordinance.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c S.H.(2)
1 For this March 27 ordinance, which was also aimed at "putting a stop to all commercial intercourse" between British subjects and the United States, see JCC, 19:270-72, 312, 314-16; and Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:25n.27.
2 Huntington also wrote on March 29 to Dr. Nathan Brownson, Director General of Hospitals John Cochran, and Gen. Nathanael Greene, enclosing notices of Brownson's appointment as deputy purveyor of hospitals in the southern department, for which See JCC, 19:292-94, 316; and PCC, item 15, fol. 257.
I left a Line for you at my Lodgings before I came out of Town,(1) to which I make no Doubt you will give Attention, as the Subject of it is so nearly connected with the Justice and Honour of Congress.
I will frankly confess to you that my Mind labours under a Load of Anxiety respecting the Settlement of the Powers of the Superintendent of Finance,(2) and indeed the whole Business of that Department. It appears to me that there is no Alternative. Those Powers, or similar ones, must be vested in some one Person, in Order to extricate our Affairs from the Confusion in which they are at present involved. The Board of Treasury only make bad, worse. To go on in the present Train is absolutely impossible. A total Stagnation must soon take Place, and Ruin cannot be far off. Were our Affairs in a State of Beginning, Powers so extensive would not be necessary; but perplexed,
I was in Congress but a very few Days, but during those few Days near 100,000 Dollars were voted to a Member or two of Congress, the Deputy Secretary and a Clerk in the Treasury.(3) Would not this have relieved many poor People who are almost starving for their Interest of Money in the Funds, or almost ruined through the Failure, on our Part, of fulfilling Contracts? Who can justify these Things? and can Congress suppose they will be borne with? And yet this will ever be the Case while the Expenditure of the publick Money is managed as at present.
As to the Gentleman who is elected Superintendent of Finance, I have no great Acquaintance with him, nor more Predilection for him than any other capable and upright Man. He is acknowledged a Man of Abilities and Character, and I believe if he has Time given him will yet retrieve our Affairs, Almost hopeless as they are in that Line. But it is the Trust I speak of and not Men. What he has to do cannot be done without efficient Powers, and Congress may at length see the Necessity of giving those Powers, when a less capable Man must have them.
I foresee Clamours, Memorials and Resignations, but if Congress refuse a Measure on that Account, no Reformation will ever take Place. However Diana of the Ephesians (4) is not so great as she was in the Year 1778 and 9 when Men were paid a large percentage for contriving the Means of Squandering the publick Money. See what a Man says of Congress in the Papers because he was disappointed of an Office.
If however cannot think of conferring the Powers without Limitation, restrict them to the Duration of the present War, or to a Year, or so many Years for Experiment. Desperate Diseases require peculiar remedies. The Power of Suspension you are convinced will not do. Trusting much to your Friendship and great good Sense I have written freely, but I hope not impertinently. I am sincerely yours, W C. Houston
1 Not found.
2 Houston had been appointed on March 21 chairman of a committee to consider the conditions submitted by Robert Morris for accepting the post of superintendent of finance. For the committee's negotiations with Morris over these conditions and Morris' March 26 response to the objections raised by the committee to his demands see Morris, Papers (Ferguson), 1:16 25. The committee submitted its report to Congress on March 29, but Houston had already left Philadelphia before debate on it began. See JCC, 19:326 27, 337-38; and PCC, item 19, 4:309-11.
3 During Houston's brief attendance in Congress March 21-30, Congress made the following grants referred to here by Houston, which were made in old emission money: to North Carolina delegates Thomas Burke and Samuel Johnston, $20,000 each; to George Bond, deputy secretary of Congress, $20,000; and to John L. Clarkson, clerk of the Board of Treasury, $10,000. See JCC, 19:302, 314, 325.
4 That is, the goddess of fertility in the Temple of Ephesus, to whom gifts of silver and gold were routinely rendered.
I send you a few Prints and the last monthly Journals yet from the Press. The Enemy will give you one of the most candid accounts of the naval Engagement on the 16th (1) that I have at any time seen in Rivington's royal Gazette. Our Allies have conducted most gallantly: a Fog which seperated their Ships a few days before the Engagement deprived them of the Opportunity of giving an immense Turn to our southern affairs. However, their proved Zeal & Activity have so impressed the Enemy that the british Fleet has not ventured to remain in Chesapeak to push the Advantages which had fallen to them by the Chance of War. We have some pretty possitive Information of a severe Cannonade of three hours at Sea on the morning of the 24th after the british had gone down the Bay of Cheseapeak at present I suspect that both the Severity & Continuance are heightned by Imagination from some single Engagement between two Frigates. It cannot be the Rhode Island Squadron.
I have not heard from your Lady of late. I shall have Opportunity in a few days, I think, to send what Jones brought for her.
We impatiently wait for your Comments upon the british Conduct at St. Eustatia and the manner in which Their H Ms. of the U Provinces (2) receive it.
I am affectionately yours, James Lovell.
1 That is, off Cape Henry, Va.
2 That is, Their High Mightinesses of the United Provinces.
I send you a few News papers and the last monthly Journals which have come from the Press. The Enemy will tell their own Story of the naval Engagement on the 16th. They have ventured nearer to Truth in Rivingtons royal Gazette than almost at any one time before, since the very Commencement of Hostilities. Our Allies conducted most gallantly: And the Enemy are so convinced of the Activity of the french Commander that they have not ventured to remain in Cheseapeak Bay to do all the Damage which the Event of the Battle had put into their Power. I send you Genl. Greene's Acct. Of an affair between him & Cornwallis.(1) I will endeavor to have it struck at the Press. You shall have it at least with our Secretary's Attestation which is in the best Credit even with the Enemy. The Opportunity of sending is too precarious to allow of my enlarging. Your most humble Servt, James Lovell
1 That is, Gen. Nathanael Greene's March 16, 1781, letter giving an account of the March 15 Battle of Guilford Courthouse, which was read in Congress on this day. See /CC, 19:335; and PCC, item 155, 2:1-5.
Mr Govr Morris now covering some Papers which I furnished, and which I send to France & Holland, I only add that we had another Letter from Mr. Carmichael (of Oct 15) without any from you. We received it on the 26th.(1)
Your most humble Servant, James Lovell (2)
ENCLOSURE
Memdum. inclosed Feb. 20th.
| Dated 1780 | Mr.Jay Recd. |
| Feb. 20, 29 Mar 3, 3 | May 18 |
| May 26, 27, 28 | Aug. 14 |
| July 10 | Oct. 16 |
| Sepr. 16 | Decr. 4 |
| Dated 1780 | Mr. Carmichael Recd. |
| Feb. 19 | May 11 |
| May 28 | |
| July 17 | Oct 16 |
| 2 plic Aug 22 P.S. Sepr. 6 2 plic Sep 9 | Decr 4 |
| 3 plic Aug 22 Sept 6,25 | Decr 9 |
| 3 plic Sep 9 Orig Sep 25 | Decr 11 |
| 2 plic Sep 25 | Feb. 12 |
| Novr. 28 Dec 19* | Feb. 12 |
| Sepr. 25 Oct 15 | March 26 |
*omitted in my former List
1 See Lovell to Samuel Holten, March 27, 1781, note 1.
2 With this letter, Lovell also sent the copies of his letters to Jay of February 20 and March 9 printed above. His enclosure consists of a list of letters received from Jay and Carmichael that he had originally enclosed in the February 20 letter, to which he added two Carmichael letters received on March 26 and two "omitted in my former List."
I yesterday was favoured with your Letter but know not when or from whence wrote as it was without date.
The Night before last we recd an Official Acct. of Genl Greens engagement with Cornwallis on the 15th March; it differs but little from the Accts before recd. The Victory was on the Side of Cornwallis as Genl. Green retired from the field with near 300 killed & wounded, & 4 field pieces lost, and near 900 Militia & some Continentals mising who mostly run away in the beginning of the Action-his order of battle was three lines-the North Carolina Militia composed the first in front with the field pieces, most of those run away without firing a gun throwing away their Arms, some few of them fired once some twice but none more; of those about 550 are missing. The Virginia Militia principally composed the Second line, they made some short stand, of these about 260 are missing but not Supposed to be taken. The third line was Continentals, the engagement was very severe and Obstinate and the Victory dearly purchased owing wholly to Superiour Dicipline. One or two more such Victories would ruin his Lordship as he must be greatly encumbered with his wounded, ours were brought of. Cornwallis was 160 Miles from Cambden & near that distance from Wilmington the nearer Seaport-my greatest fears are that the detachments from New York are gone to his relief, and may join him before Genl. Green may be in Condition to renew the fight, tho' in Case Cornwallis attempts to move he will meet probably with a constant Anoyance from our Troops, who, it is said are in high Spirits and wish for another engagemt.
You must have heard before this a full Acct. of the Naval engagemt. on the 16th between the French & British fleets, of the formers bending their Course for Rhode Island, and the latters going into the Chesapeeke and which by a Letter from the Marquis had put to sea again on the 24th.(1) One part of the Marquis's Letter Occasions various Conjectures he informs that soon after the British fleet had got out of the bay he heard a very severe Canonade for three hours without interruption as he had not heard of the french fleets returning for Rhode Island he makes no doubt that the engagemt. was between them & the British and appear extreemly Anxious to hear how it issued. It is Certain the french fleet was on their way to Rhode Island on the l9th when the Hermoine left them & came into this river, with whom then this engagemt. could be is only Conjecture; if any such really happened it must be, either the fleet bound to Rhode Island meeting with one or more french ships had returned; or the second division bound to Rhode Island from France, which is the most general opinion but how that fleet should happen to be [at] the mouth of the Chesapeeke is a question not easily answered, & besides it seems rather too early in the year for their Arrival. I think it might be our frigates the Confederacy & Saratoga bound here from the Cape at whom they might fire three hours on a Chase at long shot, this however is my fear but I am alone m it.
As to Politicks, I never mention any in a Letter unless I am Certain of a safe Conveyance. The Letter you mention to have sent me some time since I recd. and to the best of my Recollection Answered.(2)
I am, Dr Sir, Your Humble Servt. Abra. Clark.
1 The marquis de Lafayette's March 25 letter to President Huntington, which was read in Congress on March 31, is in PCC, item 156, fols. 109-10.
2 Not found.
In this letter to his sister,(1) Bland discusses family business and the education of his children. "All the news we have here at present comes from yr. Quarter-who wd. have thought it-except that on the 16th of March last-the whole French fleet which was steering for our Bay but prevented from entering by Contrary winds was met at sea by the whole British fleet, which last was rather Superior in number of line of Battleships and frigates, an Engagement ensued-the conclusion was a drawn Battle-the British rather worsted but the latter takeing the advantage of the night and being better acquainted with the coast besides having better Pilots (the Goodriches &c.(2)) got into
1 Bland's sister Frances Bland Randolph Tucker (d. 1788) was the widow of John Randolph of "Matoax," and since 1778 the wife of St. George Tucker. "St. George Tucker," DAB.
2 For the loyalist Goodrich family of Portsmouth, Va., see these Letters, 6:189.
Mr Carroll and I wrote to your Excellency and the Honorable Council by last post,(1) requesting a Supply of one thousand Dollars each of the new Emission, but at the present Exchange, I find that Sum Will be insufficient to answer my Immediate purposes. The Exchange between gold and silver, and the Emissions of the 18th March, Issued by the State of Maryland, is as 40 to 140, so that one silver Dollar is equal to three and a half. I must therefore request that my Sum may be increased to fifteen hundred Dollars for Which I Will be Accountable at the Exchange that may be Settled by the state.(2)
The Marquis Delafyette Writes from Williamsburgh of the 26th Ult.(3) That the Whole British fleet put out to Sea on the Morning of the 24th and return'd again With a number of Transports (Supposed to be from New York) on the 25th-it is said these Transports had 2000 Troops on Board. These Joined with the Army under Arnold it is feared Will do great Mischief. I have inclosed you a hand Bill Containing an Account of the Action of the 15th and of the Killed, Wounded And Missing of the Continentals-by the return from the DA General We also lost of the Militia 97 Killed and Wounded officers included and missing 846 privates Supposed to be gone home. The Riffle regiments Commanded by Campbell and Lynch had 224 Killed and Wounded, officers included.
I have the honor to be with great Esteem & Regard, Your Excellencys & Honors most humble Sert, John Hanson
1 See Maryland Delegates to Lee, March 27, 1781.
2 For the approval of this request, see Maryland Delegates to Lee, March 13, 1781, note .
3 For Lafayette's letter of March 25, not 26, see Abraham Clark to Elias Dayton, April 1, 1781, note
I have just had the pleasure of receiving your letters of the 11th and 17th, and one from Mr. Smith, and another from my brother. I wrote to them both last week.(1) You will, before this reaches you, have received an account of the action between the two fleets off the Capes of Virginia. I have seen the New York account, which is rather more in favor of the French than their own. Upon the whole the French gained more honor than profit in that conflict, as they miscarried in their principal object, that of destroying the party at Portsmouth, who have since been reinforced, and I fear will be very troublesome. We have reason to expect essential reinforcement from our ally; I am not at liberty to be more particular.(2) There are many things I would wish to say as well regarding the public as my private affairs, but the fear of my letters miscarrying withholds me. I therefore submit every thing to your discretion. We have very speedy intelligence here of every interesting motion of the armies to the westward. I. Buchanan sent me the New York papers as late as the 29th ult.; they contain nothing interesting, nor have we any late advices from Europe. My brother writes me of his indisposition, which gives me very great concern. I hope to be in as good health as ever in a few weeks of warm weather. Remember me affectionately to my sister, and the children, and in general to all our friends; and believe me ever, with the most sincere friendship and esteem, Dear sir, Your affectionate brother, Sam. Johnston.
1 Not found.
2 Johnston is undoubtedly referring to information contained in the French minister's March 24 memorial to Congress, for which See JCC, 19:308-10.
Reports that he will prod the Board of War into acting on Laurance's request for additional "provission for the Deputies in your line.''(1) Explains that Congress has rejected his conditions for acceptance of the post of Secretary of Marine: "Major McDougall inclosed to you a Copy of my Letter to Congress on the new appointment. The Committee appointed to confer with me made a full and ample report to my Satisfaction. But Congress instead of taking up the report, have passed an independant act of which I send you a Copy.(2) It is flattering, but the motives of it I shall inform you of, when I have the pleasure of Seeing you, which I hope will be three weeks hence."
1 See JCC, 19 194.
2 See JCC, 19 332-34; and McDougall to Samuel Huntington, March 9, 1781, note 2.
It is a long Time since I have been honored with any Commands from your Excellency, which makes me impatient to know the Result of my last Application. Inclosed is an official Account of a late Action between General Greene and Lord Cornwallis. Had the North Carolina Militia behaved well, General Greene's Success must have been brilliant. We lost four Pieces of Artillery, the whole that were in the Field.
The British Fleet, on the Twenty sixth of March past, were in the Chesepeak, having been joined with a Number of Transports, supposed from New York, as General Phillip's Command, consisting of about two Thousand, had, some Time since, em[b]arked. Every Circumstance indicates a vigorous Campaign in the Southern States. We are not in the best Situation to oppose the British Efforts. The great Departments are very deficient in Supplies of every kind, & public Credit will not answer as a Substitute for Money. There are two Obsticles to that Energy and Vigor wch. are absolutely necessary in the United States. In the first Place, the United States have not vested Congress, or any other Body, with the Power of calling out effectually the Resources of each State. The Articles of Confediration give only the Power of apportioning. Compliance in the respective States is generally slow, and in many Instances does not take Place. The Consequence is Disappointment, & may be fatal. In the second Place, an extreme, tho' perhaps well meant Jealousey, in many Members of Congress, especially those of a long standing, seems to frustrate every Attempt to introduce a more efficacious System. Prudent Caution against the Abuse of Power, is very requisite for supporting the Principles of republican Governments; but when that Caution is carried too far, the Event may, and probably will prove alarming. We have Experienced a recent Instance of political Diffidance. Mr. Robert Morris of this City has been chosen Financeer. Previous to his final Acceptance, he insisted upon the Power of removing from Office, all Persons entrusted with the expenditure of public Money, for Abuse, Fraud &c. without being answerable, except to the Party injured in the Courts of Law. Without this Authority, he despaired of introducing ceconomy, so esentially important at this critical Situation. A Majority decided against the Proposition.(1) The Consequence is, we are replunged into our old Situation, so agreable to some Gentlemen, and I fear, shall
By all Accounts, the French Squadron had greatly the Advantage in the late Action off Chesepeak, altho' the British were one hundred & thirty eight Guns superior in Number.
I have the Honor of being, with great Respect, your Excellency's most obedt. humble Servt. J M Varnum
1 See JCC, 19:290-91, 337-38; and William C. Houston to Thomas McKean, March 31, 1781, note 2.
2 For Varnum's role in the movement to strengthen the power of Congress, see Varnum to Greene, March 16, 1781, note 3.
3 Varnum's call for a "convention" to revise the Articles of Confederation was among the earliest known proposals for this avenue of constitutional reform. For a similar, previous proposal by Alexander Hamilton, see Hamilton, Papers (Syrett), 2:407.
The Underwritten Delegates from the State of Virginia (1) have been informed that there are among the refugees taken by Capt. Tilly commanding his M. C. Majesty's Ship IEveille on his return to New Port from Chesapeak Bay, a considerable number who were formerly inhabitants of Virginia.(2) As some of these persons according to the laws of that State fall under the description of Traiterous Citizens and consequently are not proper subjects of exchange, and others, although they do not fall under that description may if exchanged or released be very prejudicial to the State during the operations against it by giving information & counsel to the Enemy and by their seductions among the people, the Delegates abovementioned wish that no steps may be taken for exchanging or releasing them untill the fact shall have been communicated to his Excellency the Governor of Virginia. With this view they ask the favor of you, Sir, to intimate this circumstance to the Commander of his M. C. Majesty's Squadron at New Port, and to obtain from him a list of the names of such of his Captives as were formerly inhabitants of Virginia.(3)
The paper inclosed (4) herewith will inform you of the pretensions of three persons, Citizens of the State of Virginia, founded on their having been on board the Eveille in the character of Pilots during her expedition into Chesapeak bay, in which a number of prizes were taken. We leave it with you Sir to determine on the justice of them, and to direct the mode in which they ought to be pursued. We wish to be enabled to give the claimants a proper & satisfactory answer, as future operations may render their services again necessary to us, and the facility of commanding them may depend on the temper in which they are now dismissed.
1 Theodorick Bland and Meriwether Smith were the Virginia delegates attending Congress with Madison at this time.
2 The small squadron under Capt. Arnaud Le Gardeur de Tilly that had raided Benedict Arnold's shipping in Chesapeake Bay in mid-February captured several British prizes, one of which carried Loyalist refugees en route to Virginia. See Thomas Rodney to Caesar Rodney, March 2, 1781, note; Madison Papers (Hutchinson),
3 La Luzerne was reluctant at first to provide a list of prisoners captured by French naval forces which were not, unlike French land forces, under Washington's nominal command, but he eventually complied. See Madison to Jefferson, April 3, and Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, May 5, 1781.
4 Not found.
I have just receivd your favor of the 17th Ulto by Mr. Dugan. The Request he proposes to make to Congress cannot be complied with, consistently with the inclosd Ordinance, which strictly forbids all Intercourse between the Citizens of the United States and the Subjects of Great Britain. There have been so many undue Advantages taken from Indulgences of this kind, as to render the Continuance of them unsafe to us, and disgusting to our Ally.(2) I shall always pay a due Regard to your Recommendations, and should have been particularly desirous of rendering Service to your Friend Mr Dugan whom I personally know and of whose Integrity I have no Reason to doubt.
Your Letter of the 23d Feby never came to hand, and I the more regret it because you tell me, you then wrote fully of the State of Affairs in Boston, which I should have been glad to have receivd. Let me observe to you as a private Friend, the Delegates from Massachusetts are by no means duly informd of what is done in their own State; and when they receive any kind of Information it is not in a Manner adapted to give them Weight. I do not mention this on my own Account; for I intend very soon to take Leave of Congress & get my self excusd from any future Attendance. You mention a certain Juncture when you wish me to return. I think I can discover your Motive and your old Partiality for me. I do assure you, I am not at all sollicitous about any thing of the kind which your Letter seems to intimate. I have always endeavord to confine my Desires in this Life within moderate Bounds, and it is Time for me to reduce them to a narrower Compass. You speak of "Neglect," "Ingratitude" &c. But let us entertain just Sentiments. A Citizen owes every thing to the Commonwealth, and after he has made his utmost Exertions, has he done more than his Duty? When Time enfeebles his Powers & renders him unfit for futher Service, his Country, to preserve its own Vigour, will wisely call upon others; and if he decently retreats to make Room for them he will show that he has not yet totally lost his Understanding. Besides, there is a Period in Life when a Man should covet the exalted Pleasure of Reflection in Retirement.
I thank you, my dear Sir, for the Information you gave Mrs A of
Your affectionate, S a
1 Caleb Davis, who has been identified in these Letters, 11 :288n. 1, was speaker of the Massachusetts House of Representatives.
2 Adams undoubtedly enclosed a copy of Congress' March 27, 1781, "ordinance" adopted in response to conflicts brought about by people such as Dugan and George Howell, who sought to bring "property" into the states from areas controlled by the British. See JCC, 19:314-16; Adams to James Warren, October 3, 1780, note 1; and James Lovell to Elbridge Gerry, March 27, 1781, note 5. See also Samuel Huntington to Thomas Mumford, August 26, and to Jonathan Trumbull, September 1, 1780.
Congress see in the Treatment of the honourable Mr Laurens formerly their President, and now one of their publick Ministers, a fresh proof of the sanguinary disposition of the Court of Great Brittain, and of how little Avail in their Estimation are the Laws of Nations, sacred throughout all the rest of the civilized world, when opposed to the Intemperance which marks their publick Councils. It is now well known that Mr Laurens in his passage to Europe was intercepted and conducted to England by a british Frigate: that on a warrant signed by three british Secretaries of State he was committed to the Tower of London; and that a Suspicion of Treason is assigned as the only Cause for his Imprisonment:(2) In short that the whole of this extraordinary procedure is calculated to fix upon this respectable Patriot the Odium and the Consequences of high Criminality.
The Causes of our happy Revolution have so often been illustrated in the publick Appeals of Congress that it is unnecessary to discuss them minutely. It is our greatest Glory that they have produced general Conviction of our Grievances, our Rights & our moderation! A Conviction founded on the Basis of artless Truth, & not to be shaken by the Suggestions of Malice. Is it not from these Sentiments that the profuse offers of our Enemies for Succours, to every power of Europe, upon whom they hoped to make an Empression, have, with very few Exceptions, been disdainfully rejected? Is it not from these Sentiments that we have been supported by the Arms of France and Spain and honourd by the Approbation and good wishes of every Friend to mankind! Indeed the Policy of the british Councils immediately after the Close of the last War-a War rendered succesful by our vigorous Cooperation-
Let us consider the Nature, and the Rights, of a Civil War, according to the Law of Nations; and apply its Maxims to the Condition of the united States: Hence we shall more clearly perceive how destitute of foundation is the Attempt of the british Court to impute to Mr Laurens the Crime of suspicion of Treason, against that Government.
"If there be War between part of the Citizens on one side with the Sovereign and those who continue in obedience to him on the other it is sufficient that the malcontents have some Reason for taking Arms to give this disturbance the name of civil War and not that of Rebellion. This last Term is only applied to such Insurrection as is void of all Appearance of Justice. The Sovereign never fails to term Rebells All subjects openly resisting him: but where these become of Strength to oppose him so that he finds himself Compelled to make war regularly on them he must be contented with the Term of Civil War." "Things being thus situated it is very evident that the common Laws of War founded on maxims of Humanity, moderation & probity are in civil Wars to be observed on both sides. The same Reasons on which the Obligation between State and State is founded render them even more necessary when two incensed parties are destroying their common Country. Shoud the Sovereign conceive he has a Right to hang up his Prisoners or to burn and destroy, the opposite party will follow the Example and the War become cruel and horrid." Thus we are taught by the Law of Nations, and how applicable are these maxims to the Events of the present war! Have not the Efforts of the Enemy been serious, powerful and persevering? Have they not wasted the Lives of mighty Armies and expended countless millions to reduce us to Slavery? Have we not in the face of their fleets and Armies and in the high Tide of (3)
1 Henry Laurens' treatment by the British had been a subject of congressional concern since mid-December 1780 when news reached Philadelphia of his imprisonment
In the meantime, Congress instructed Benjamin Franklin and John Jay to seek Laurens' release and exchange, possibly in return for Gen. John Burgoyne, and on April 3 South Carolina delegate Thomas Bee moved that Burgoyne and all other enemy officers absent on parole from America be recalled immediately unless Laurens "be also enlarged on his parole." Congress thereupon adopted Bee's motion in an amended form, and the same day ordered Duane's committee to "prepare and bring in a draught of a manifesto" on Laurens' case. It seems clear that the present document was drafted in response to that directive, but before Duane returned to New York on May 9. It was apparently never formally submitted to Congress. Little is known about the document beyond the fact that it is located in a collection of James Madison Papers, and was probably handed on to Madison after he was appointed on September 28 to a similar committee charged with recommending a course of action to be taken in retaliation for a number of other enemy abuses such as the execution of Col. Isaac Hayne in South Carolina, and for depredations committed by British troops under Lord Cornwallis in Virginia and under Benedict Arnold raiding Connecticut. The document is incomplete and seems to have had little direct impact on the "Manifesto" Madison drafted and submitted to Congress on December 3, which was referred the same day to the committee appointed to confer with General Washington in Philadelphia. See JCC, 19:345-46, 21:1023, 1029-30, 1150-51. See also Samuel Huntington to Washington, April 5, 1781.
2 This information had reached Philadelphia about December 11, 1780, for which see John Hanson to Charles Carroll of Carrollton, December 11, and James Madison to Edmund Pendleton, December 12, 1780.
3 Remainder of MS missing.
I have received your favor of the 23d of March.(1) The publication of which you wish to have a copy for your private use is not yet finished;(2) as soon as it is I shall take care to provide one for you. I have repeatedly reminded Dr. Smith of his promise with respect to the map,(3) but have never obtained any thing more than a repetition of the promise. He is at present an inhabitant of Maryland. Just before he left this City he assured me that he should soon send me what you wanted. I have not since heard from him and have very little hope that I ever shall on that subject. It is not improbable that he calculates the value of the Chart on its being the single one remaining, and thinks the issuing of copies would depreciate it. The genius of the man and the manner of his behaviour in the course of my applications to him justify such a surmize.
Notwithstanding the personal advantages which you have a right to expect from an emancipation from your present labours and the
The letter from the Delegation by the last post informed you of the arrival of the Stores here which were to have been delivered in Virginia by one of the French Ships.(5) The infinite importance of them to the State, especially since the arrival of a reinforcement to Arnold of which we are just apprized by the Marquis has determined the Delegates to forward them by land without loss of time. This will be attempted in the first instance in the channel of the Q. Master's Department and if it cannot be effected in that mode without delay we propose to engage private waggons for the purpose on the credit of the State. Should the latter alternative be embraced, I find it will be necessary to stipulate instantaneous payment from the Treasury on the arrival of the waggons at Richmond in Specie or the old Continental Currency to the real amount thereof. I mention this circumstance that you may be prepared for it. The expence of the transportation will be between five & six hundred pounds Virginia Money. The exchange between specie & the old paper here at present is about 135 for 1.
The Delegates having understood that the Refugees taken by Capt: Tilly on his return to New Port from Chesapeak consisted chiefly of persons who formerly lived in Virginia, some of whom were traitors who deserved exemplary punishment, and others vindictive enemies to the State thought proper to make the inclosed application to the French Minister.(6) By conversation I have since had with him on the subject, I doubt whether it will be deemed consistent with their general rules of conduct to give up to be punished as malefactors any of the captives made by their fleet which does not serve like their land army as an auxiliary to the forces of the United [States]. If these persons had been taken by their land forces which serve as auxiliaries under the Commander in chief it seems there would have been no difficulty in the case. However the application will certainly prevent the exchange or release to which it refers, if the Executive think it expedient to do so. On the least intimation I am persuaded the Apostates would be even sent over to France and secured in the most effectual manner during the war. Perhaps this would not be amiss as being not our Prisoners no use can be made of them in redeeming our Citizens from captivity.
About one thousand of the Pennsylvania line will march in a day or two from York Town for the Southern service. When the remainder will follow them is altogether uncertain. The detachment under the Marquis is still at Annapolis. The orders of General
The Ordinance published in the Newspaper [of this] day will be an answer to your request by Col. Harr[ison of the] sense of Congress on .one of the subjects to which it rela[tes.(8) The] flagrant abuses which were covered by those indulg[ences] and the offensive light in which they were justly viewed by our Ally called loudly for their abolition.
I am Dr Sir, yr. sincere friend & servant,
James Madison Junr.(9)
1 Not found.
2 Samuel Wharton's Plain Facts: Being an Examination Into the Rights of the Indian Nations of America...(Philadelphia: R. Aitken, 1781), which "vindicated" the Indiana Company grant and "proved" that the territory west of the Alleghenies had not belonged to Virginia, was in press at this time according to the April 24 issue of the Pennsylvania Packet and was probably the publication that Jefferson sought.
3 See Madison to Edmund Pendleton, September 26, 1780, note 2.
4 For Jefferson's "final determination" not to seek reelection as governor and the subsequent election of Thomas Nelson on June 12, 1781, see Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 6:77-79n.
5 That is, the Virginia delegates' letter of March 27.
6 See Virginia Delegates to La Luzerne, April 2, 1781.
7 From this point words in brackets are taken from the extract in Stan V Henkels Catalog, no. 694 (December 6, 1892).
8 For Congress' March 27 resolve banning commercial intercourse with Great Britain and its possessions, which was published in the April 3 issue of the Pennsylvania Packet, see Samuel Huntington to the States, March 30, 1781, note 1. In a letter of January 29 Jefferson had asked special delegate Benjamin Harrison to determine whether Virginia's continued trade with Bermuda of corn for salt would give "Umbrage to Congress or the French minister." Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 4:466.
9 For Madison's expense account for the quarter December 20, 1780, to March 20, 1781, which he sent to the Virginia auditors on March 27, see Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:37-38. See also his receipt to Michael Gratz for monies received during this period, ibid., 2:273-74.
The enclosed paper Contains all the news we have here also a Resolution of Congress respecting Prises & Captures.
Virginia we are Informed have emitted ten million of dollars.
This State are about to Issue three hundred thousand pounds.
A difficulty has arisen upon the Treasurers Computing the Int. on the new bills in favour of the States, and there is a report now lying
P.S. I inclose a bill for a law in this State which the assembly are very unanimous in & is to pass today.(2)
1 The next day, April 4, Congress resolved that "no interest be computed on the money emitted pursuant to the act of the 18 March, 1780, at the time of issuing the same from the loan offices, or when any officers of the United States shall make payments therewith for supplies, or in discharge of public debts."JCC 19:352.
2 That is, a bill to impower Congress to collect an impost. See Oliver Wolcott to Samuel Lyman, this date. See also Samuel Huntington's first letter to Trumbull of March 24, 1781, note 2.
We have been favord with Your Excellencys enclosing a State of the affair between Mr. Nathan and the Commonwealth of Virginia which we are endeavoring to put in train for a decision on the Principles you have been pleased to direct, the event of which yr. Excellency shall be informd of as soon as tis decided.(1) The Unfortunate consequences which have attended the Naval engagement of Chesapeake on the 16th Ultimo, we feel with unspeakeable regret, as they have snatchd from us the pleasing prospects we had cherished for some time past, of frustrating the Sanguine project of the Enemy (of subjugating most of the Southern States this Campaign) and thrown our Country into a Situation which must require her utmost exertions, with all the aid that can be sent her to extricate her from. This we shall leave no means unessayed to effect, on our parts.
The Same unhappy event, has deprived us of the immediate Use of the Arms and Stores, which were to have gone from Rhode Island (the Cargoe of the Comite) on board a french frigate, but we have the Satisfaction to Inform yr. Excellency that they are safe arrived at
Theok. Bland.
1 The delegates had already acknowledged the receipt of Jefferson's March 15 letter "enclosing a State of the affair between Mr. Nathan and the Commonwealth of Virginia," for which see Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, March 27, note 2. In a surviving letter fragment probably written on April 10, for which see Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:65, the delegates also informed the governor of an exchange of letters that they had had with Simon Nathan and requested further instructions concerning Nathan's new demands. For the next episode in this case see Virginia Delegates to the Pennsylvania Executive Council, July 9-10, and to Joseph Reed, July 13, 1781.
2 See Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, March 27, note 3.
3 Christian Febiger had been sent to Philadelphia by Gen. Nathanael Greene to expedite the procurement and shipment of supplies to the southern department. When the goods from Le Comite' arrived in Philadelphia, the Virginia delegates reminded the Board of War of its responsibility under Congress' October 1780 directive to transport the goods. The Board quickly discovered that the wagoners to be employed refused payment in either Virginia money or tobacco, whereupon the Board recommended and Congress agreed this day that the treasurer issue a warrant for $995 in the new emissions to Col. Samuel Miles, deputy quartermaster general for Pennsylvania, "to enable him to transport to Virginia the stores now in this city belonging to that State, for which the said State is to be accountable." See JCC, 18:890, 19:344-45.
Your Favour of the Ult. inclosing some Act of our Ligeslature &c have been recd. I have Nothing in Return to inform you of but what you will find in the inclosed Papers, except that after the British Fleet had left the Cheasepeak as Mentioned in the publick Prints, they Met a Fleet with Transports from N York having or it is
The old Money here is continually sinking. Exchange is 135 for one. Vast Quantitys of this Money has been and is going on to the Eastward where the Exchange is not so great. But that will probably Not long be the Case. This Money Exerts the approbrium of America-and I always thot We ought to get rid of this Dishonour by cancelling the Bills as soon as possible. This I have long been convinced will not be effected by Taxation. Some other equitable Mode ought therefore to be adopted to put an End to that Speculation & Injustice which is not only practiced by Individuals but by one State to Another. The Act of the 18t of March in its great Principle in my Apprehension was just and Necessary to be adopted. I wish that it had been farther extended. But the Ignorance and the insidious and unworthy Veiws of too Many Individuals perhaps rendered a more extensive Plan inexpedient. But Justice and publick Necessity will before long compel the States to adopt Measures more definitive with respect to their Money.
This State has passed a Bill Vesting Congress with the Powers to Collect the Impost precisely According to their Requisition, this Day it is said that it will be passed into a Law of the State without scarcely any Opposition. I was much Surprized that Connecticut has adopted this Measure in so partial a manner not only as I am fully convinced that it is the only Mode by which a Tax of this kind can be equitably laid. But as our State consumes much more than they Import they have a particular Interest in adopting the Measure. Certainly they cannot Wish to pay large Dutys in N York and Boston for the particular emoluments of those States which will be the Case unless the Dutys are applied for National Purposes. This Plan will not collect a large Sum (it might perhaps have been farther and more beneficially extended), But as the Dutys are defenite there can be no Danger that Trade will be improperly Burthened, and as the Revenieu tho' not large would be certain and increasing, it might have done something considerable towards putting publick Credit upon a better Footing-tho farr Itself from being Adequate.
My domestick Affairs are such as that I shall judge it my Duty to leave Congress soon. I expect to be at Home about the 20th of this Month. I am Sir with respect, your Most Obedt. Servt,
Oliver Wolcott
NB. The Legislature of this State are I am informed about to Emit 300,000 pounds on their particular Credit. The Bills Will be well funded on Property. They do not collect in the old Money Very fast. I cannot Say what the precise Sum of the New Money is which has been Emitted-it passes about five for one compared with Specie.
Altho the Tender act still continues-and which this Assembly do not think proper to Repeal. My best Compliments to Mr Ellsworth. I write in hast. Excuse Errors. The eastern Mail expected in here this Week I hear is taken and Carryed in to N York.(1)
1 The capture of the "eastern mail" was gleefully reported in the April 4 issue of lames Rivington's New York Royal Gazette. A March 25 letter from Oliver Wolcott, Jr., to his father was among the letters subsequently published by Rivington, appearing in the April 6 issue.
In Consequence of your Excellency's Letter of the l9th Ulto(1) Congress have passed the Act of the 2d Instant Copy of which is enclosed, for securing the Pay & Subsistance of two Regiments of Militia & two Regiments of Infantry mentioned in the Act at the Expence of the United States while in Service.(2)
Your Excellency will readily observe the Saving that will be made by appointing half pay Officers, as far as may be, to command these Corps, beside the Advantage of their Experience if in other respects meritorious. This Preference of experienced Officers will readily coincide with your Excellency's Sentiments; yet from the Nature of the Case, your Wisdom & Discretion must be exercised in directing the Appointment in such Manner as shall appear most eligible & beneficial.
Your Favour of the 23d Instant, covering the Exemplification of an Act of the State authorizing Congress to lay a Duty on foreign Merchandize imported into the State is this Day received.(3) The Legislature of Pennsylvania have published a similar Act for Consideration which will, it is said, be enacted into a Law in a Day or two.
I have the Honor to be with very high respect & Esteem, Your Excellency's most obedient Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 This letter is not in PCC or the Clinton Papers, N [see Clinton, Papers (Hastings), 6:737n], although an extract of it, enclosed with Huntington's letter to Washington, this date, is in the Washington Papers, DLC.
2 This resolve was adopted upon the recommendation of the committee to which Clinton's letter had been referred on March 26, for which See JCC, 19:311, 329, 339; and PCC, item 19, 1:305-7.
3 See JCC, 19:353. Clinton's letter is in PCC, item 67, 2:362-65; a copy of the New York act enclosed with it is in PCC, item 75, fols. 157-59.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed an Act of Congress of the 2d Instant, wherein they have engaged for the Pay & Subsistence of two Regiments of Militia & two Regiments of Infantry proposed to be raised by the State of New York, over & above their Quota of Continental Troops, during the Time they shall be in actual Service. The two Regiments of Infantry to be raised for three Years by the Proposals contained in Govr Clintons Letter referred to, are to be placed under the Direction of the Commander in Chief, yet so as not to be removed out of the State of New York without the Governors Consent.(1)
I have the Honor to be, with the highest regard, your Excellency's most obedient humble servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 See the preceding entry. The restriction that the two New York regiments were not to be ordered from the state without the consent of the governor is not found in the enclosed congressional resolve, but had been a condition of the New York act authorizing the creation of the proposed regiments. See JCC, 19:339; and Clinton to Huntington, March 19, 1781 (extract), Washington Papers, DLC.
Je vous remercais tres humblement; pour le bonte que vous aviez eu, de corriger La Lettre, que Je en avais fait Le honneur de vous ecrire; Je suis beaucop encorage en Trouvant, qu'il n'ya pas plus de fauts comme Je l'avais ecrit par memoire seulement. Je vous en assure monsieur, que Je n'ai pas vu un Dictionaire francoise depuis que Je suis arriva a Philadelphie & Je suis persuade que J'apprendrai beaucoup Sous Les yeux d'un si habile instructeur.
C'est tres malheraux Monsieur que nous avons perdu le troisieme malle au Post celle de La derniere Semaine Etoit prit, au Clove, dans La nuit au Samedi [passe]. Ilaya Continoit plusieurs Lettres a mon addresse: les toute Sont perdues et Seront publies par Monsieur Rivington. C'est bien malheuruse d'avoir les Lettres de Confiance tomber entre les mains de L'ennimie & Je ne suis pas sans Craintes que L'or de Bretagne a ete employe a accomplir cette evenemente. Le President du Congres avait Donne L'ordre a Monsr. Hazard & Monsr. Beache dienvoyer le Post par La route en derriere des montagnes de Nouvel Jersey, a Nouvel Windsor pour y passer la riviere a Fishkill; & pour continuer sa route par Litchfield a Hartford, mais ils ont continue de l'envoyer par Le Clove a Peaks
J'ai oui dire aujourdhui que Monsieur Arnold est a present a Cette cota de La Baie de Chesseapeak volant du farine et autres Chases des habitants; on m'a dit qu'il y a avec Lui deux Mille d'Hommes; mais Je ne Le crois pas, Nous n'avons point d'autres nouvelles.
J'ai L'honneure detre avec les respects Le plus Sincere Monsieur, votre tres humble & tres obeissante Serviteur.
Jno. Sullivan
I wish to thank you very humbly for your goodness in correcting the letter which I have had the honor to write to you.(1) I am greatly encouraged in finding there are no more errors, as I have written only from memory. I assure you, Sir, that I have not seen a French dictionary since I arrived in Philadelphia, and I am persuaded that I shall learn much under the eyes of so capable an instructor.
It is very unfortunate, Sir, that we have lost the third mail-coach, that of the last week. It was taken at The Clove during the night of Saturday last. It contained many letters addressed to me: all are lost and will be published by Mr. Rivington.(2) It is very unfortunate that confidential letters should fall into the hands of the enemy, and I am afraid that British gold has been used to accomplish this result. The President of Congress has ordered Mr. Hazard and Mr. Bache to send the post by the route behind the mountains of New Jersey to New Windsor, to cross the river at Fishkill, and to continue the route by Litchfield to Hartford, but they have continued to send them by The Clove to Peekskill, to cross the river there, and from thence to follow the river to Fishkill. You may see, Sir, that on this route it is easy to capture the post. I cannot conceive the purpose of these gentlemen in sending the post by this route where it is always easy to attack in broad daylight.
I have been informed today that Mr. Arnold is at present on this side of Chesapeake Bay taking flour and other things from the inhabitants. It is said he has 2000 men with him, but I do not believe it. We have no other news.
I have the honor to be with the most sincere respect sir, your very humble and obedient servant, Jno. Sullivan
1 Only Sullivan's December 10, 1780, letter to Marbois, which was composed in English and not French, has been found.
2 Two letters to Sullivan from Meshech Weare, dated March 17 and 19, were published in James Rivington's New York Royal Gazette, April 21 and 25, 1781.
I have the Honor of transmitting your Excellency the enclosed resolve of the 3d Instant, directing the recall of Lieut. General Burgoine and all other Officers Prisoners of War now absent on their Paroles from America to return immediately.(1)
It is proper to inform your Excellency, that this resolution is adopted in Consequence of Information, that the late President Laurens is confined in the Tower of London as a State Criminal, under Pretext of his being guilty of treasonable Practices.
Should this Resolution embarrass or impede any Measures your Excellency may have adopted relative, or preparatory, to a general Exchange of Prisoners, it is taken for granted you will please to represent the same to Congress previous to any Proceedings for carrying the resolve into Execution.(2)
Before this comes to Hand your Excellency must have received Information that the Post on his Way from New Windsor to Morristown on the last Saturday was taken, and the Mail, as I am informed, is carried to New York. 'Tis also said that Letters from your Excellency were parcel of the Mail.
The enclosed Copy of a Letter from General Greene Seems to evince that the Field was dearly bought by Lord Cornwallis on the 15th Ulto, the Particulars of which Action it is presumed you have received.(3)
I have been favored with your Letters of the 24th & 31st Ulto, with the Despatches to which they refer.(4)
I have the Honor to be with the highest respect & Esteem, Sir, your most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President (5)
1 See JCC, 19:345; and James Duane's Draft Manifesto, April 3-May 9? 1781, note 1.
2 For Congress' immediate withdrawal of this instruction upon learning that Washington had already proposed Burgoyne's exchange to Sir Henry Clinton, see Huntington to Washington, April 23, 1781.
3 The enclosed March 23 letter from Nathanael Greene to Huntington contained additional details on the battle of Guilford Courthouse, which he had previously reported in a March 16 letter to the president. Washington Papers, DLC; and PCC, item 155, 2:13-15.
4 Washington's letters are in PCC, item 152, 10:23-30; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:369-71, 399-400.
5 Huntington also sent an emergency appeal this day to New Jersey and Pennsylvania for flour for the troops garrisoning West Point "and its dependencies." With his letters to Gov. William Livingston and Pres. Joseph Reed, Huntington enclosed a report from the Board of War and a letter from Charles Stewart, commissary general of issues, explaining that the provisions on hand at West Point would be exhausted in ten days and that at the moment New York was not able to furnish the flour needed. See JCC', 19:345-46; and PCC, item 15, fol. 261, item 148, 1:339 46.
I was on the Evening of the 3d honored with your Excellencys favor of the 31 Ulto.(1) and have the pleasure of Inclosing to your Excellency Copy of an Act of congress of yesterday respecting the Conduct of our allies.(2) I am Convinced that the Bravery of Monsr Des Touch & the officers and men under his Command has convinced the British that with Equal numbers the French are at Least Equal to them. I Lament our having failed in the object yet the Action will have some agreable consequences; and the manner in which it was conducted by Monsr Des Touch deserves Every Eulogium.
I am also honored with your Excellencys favor of the 24th ulto. & Shall be happy in receiving your Excellencys Sentiments upon the whole report which I had the honor to inclose you (3) & I perswade myself that Congress will agree with your wishes upon the Subject.
I have the honor to be with the Most perfect Esteem Dear General Your Excellencys most obedient Servant, Jno Sullivan
1 See Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:400n.2
2 See Samuel Huntington to the chevalier Destouches, April 6, 1781.
3 Neither Washington's March 24 letter nor one of Sullivan to him enclosing "the whole report" (for which see Committee of Congress to Washington, March 9, 1781) has been found.
Last Night late one Dr Newil who lives in Shrewsbury came here with a Letter to me from Mr John Imlay recommending him as a Person firmly attached to the American Cause and one very fit to obtain Intelligence telling me at the same Time that he then had some Intelligence from New York worthy of the Attention of Congress. The Intelligence he brought was that another Expedition was preparing at N. York not yet quite ready but that it was Supposed Genl Clinton was to go upon the Head of it himself, that
The same Person says the Mail was taken in the Clove by Moody & one other Man & carried to New York on Saturday where they received 40 Guineas each before it was opened. Nothing had transpired as to the Contents of the Mail.
By the last Accounts from the Southward the English Fleet which left Lynhaven Bay on the 24 of last Month & went out at the Capes returned again next Day with several Transports supposed to be with Troops from N. York.
I expect to be at Princeton Saturday Night or Sabbath Morning before Sermon. I am Your Excellencys most obedt, humble Servant,
Jno Witherspoon
The Delegates from Connecticut (1) beg leave to Represent to Congress That the Schooner Spy Capt Niles Master was dispatched to France by his Excellency the Governor of Connecticutt at the request of the Committee for foreign affairs pursuant to order of Congress to carry the Ratification of the Treaty between the United States & France.
That Said Schooner arrived with Said Ratification & duly deliverd the Same & on her return laden with Articles for the united States by order of the Honbl. B. Franklin Esqr. was Capturd & Carried to Great Brittain.
That the Said Delegates have long Since recvd the accounts of the said Schooner & the Expense of her voyage, with a letter from the Govr of Connecticutt Requesting the Same may be adjusted & paid; which hath not yet been done.
Whereupon they request that Said Accounts may be Settled; & if the State of the Treasury will not Admit of Immediate payment, that the accounts may be liquidated in Specie value & placed to the Credit of the State of Connecticutt to bear an Interest at the rate of Six per Cent per Annum from the time the Same became due until paid.(2)
1 Jesse Root and Oliver Wolcott were the Connecticut delegates attending Congress with Huntington at this time.
2 This "representation" from the Connecticut delegates was referred this day to the Board of Treasury, which upon investigation concluded that Capt. Robert Niles' claims were excessive and accordingly recommended that they "be referred to the commissioners of accounts at Hartford in Connecticut, for settlement," a recommendation Congress endorsed on June 21, 1781. See JCC, 19:357, 20:684-86.
For the Spy's delivery of the ratified Franco-American treaties to France, see these Letters, 9:714-15.
I have the Pleasure of transmitting you the enclosed Resolve, expressing the Sentiments of the United States in Congress assembled respecting the Zeal & Vigilance which the Commanders of the Army & Fleet sent by his most Christian Majesty for the Succour of his Allies have manifested on all Occasions to fulfil the Generous Intentions of their Soverign and the Expectations of these States.
I am particularly directed to present the Thanks of Congress to you Sir, and the Officers & Men under your Command for the Bravery, Firmness and good Conduct displayed in the late Enterprize against the Enemy at Portsmouth and the arduous Contest so gallantly & advantageously maintained in the Engagement on the 16th of March last off the Capes of Virginia against a superior British Fleet.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S.H.
1 For this April 4 congressional vote of thanks to Destouches, who had assumed command of the French fleet at Rhode Island upon the death of Admiral de Ternay in December, See JCC, 19:348-50.
Huntington also sent a copy of this resolve this day to the commander of the French army in America, the comte de Rochambeau, and to George Washington; and on April 10 to the chevalier de La Luzerne. See PCC, item 15, fols. 261-62, 265-66.
On Saturday the last of March the eastern Mail was taken in the Clove & carried into New York. We know not of what Importance the Despatches might be, but have pretty direct Information that two Men which took the Mail received eighty Guineas for their reward on delivering it in New York.
The enclosed Paper will give your Excellency the latest Intelligence we have received from General Greene.(1)
It is now reported that another Embarkation is taking Place at New York, and given out that their Destination is Delaware Bay to take post at New Castle.(2)
Genl Woolcot expects to leave Congress this Week & Colo Root the next. I hope that a representation of Delegates are on their Way from Connecticut as I expect in a few Weeks to leave Congress myself, and should be very desirous to set out with Colo Root if possible.
I have the Honor to be with very great Respect & Esteem, sir, Your most obedt & most hbble Servt, Sam. Huntington
1 Probably the April 3 issue of the Pennsylvania Packet, which contained a number of letters pertaining to Nathanael Greene's recent successes in the southern department.
2 See the following entry.
I have the Honor to enclose Copies of Letters from Governor Livingston & General Foreman received this Morning, which from their Importance it is judged necessary to communicate to you with all possible Expedition.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S.H.
1 Copies of the enclosed letters to Huntington from Gen. David Forman of April 2 and from William Livingston of April 5, reporting an imminent embarkation from New York designed "to take post at New Castle," are in the Washington Papers, DLC; and PCC, item 68, fols. 577-80, item 78, 9:447-50.
Maryland delegates Daniel Carroll and John Hanson also sent copies of these enclosures to Matthew Tilghman, "President of the Executive Council for the Eastern Shore," with a brief letter of this date. Ridgely transcripts, fols. 248-49, MdAA.
I have received your very obliging letter of the 18th ulto. and am the more thankful, as I know you can afford but little time to correspond with individuals. The sufferings, distresses and losses of your army pains me to the heart, and be assured that for some time past there is nothing in our power unattempted for your relief, altho our embarassments are infinite. And give me leave also, my dear Sir
We have just now received intelligence from New Jersey, copies of which is inclosed.(1) I can scarcely believe it is Sir Henrys object to come into the Delaware, but it is not altogether improbable, in order to divert the Pennsylvania line from going to the southward. That line is now ready to march a detachment of 1000 men if they were paid 37,000 dollars new emissions which will soon be ready for them.
Ere this reaches you, you will have heard of the operations of the French & British fleets on this coast-the former, altho disapointed, deserve great praise.
Not a word of the arrival of the second division of French nor of the cloathing & Stores for the Army. Inclosed I send you a copy of an enquiry and report of the board of Admirality on that and other subjects,(2) to show that the blame does not lie on Congress nor Docr. Franklin. Of this the Army and the Legislature ought to be acquainted.
The copy would have been certified by the secretary of Congress, but you will observe that it is not their act, only an enquiry & report for their information. It is nevertheless a true copy which I have procured for your particular information.
We have not heard the effects, in Europe, of England's declaring war against the united provinces-their Navy must be greatly weakened by the captor of so many seamen as England must take before they can look about them.
I am in great haste the express waiting.
Be so obliging as to make my best compliments to the Officers under your command.
With the highest sentiments of esteem and respect I have the honor to be, Dear Sir Your most Obt. Humble Servt.
Wm. Sharpe
1 See the preceding entry.
2 Undoubtedly the Board of Admiralty's March 28 report on responsibility for the delays encountered in preparing a shipment of clothing from France, for which see JCC, 19:316-20; and Jesse Root to Jonathan Trumbull, February 20, 1781, note 1.
I fear from our disappointment of succor from the fleet of our ally under the command of the Chevalier D'Estouches, that the enemy will be able to establish a strong post at Portsmouth, and maintain it
Never was a poor fly more completely entangled in a cobweb than Congress in their paper currency. It is the daily subject of conversation in that body; but our situation is so very intricate and delicate that I have as yet heard no proposal that is not subject to numberless objections. Dr. Burke, who is to be the bearer of this, has just called to tell me he is not to leave this for some days.(1)
1 For the continuation of this letter, see Johnston to Iredell, April 12, 1781.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed an act of Congress of the 8th Instant recommending to the Executives of the States of Delaware, Maryland & Virginia respectively to take immediate measures for the removal of all public stores, and also all provisions & forage public & private which will not be necessary for the consumption of the Inhabitants on the Peninsula between the Chesapeak and Delaware Bays, to prevent such articles falling into the enemy's hands. I should suppose it equally expedient to include valuable horses tho' they are not mentioned in the Act.(1)
This recommendation is in consequence of intelligence received
As future events must determine with certainty the designs of the enemy, so future intelligence may influence the measures now recommended, yet it is to be hoped such precautions may be taken as will prevent any valuable supplies of any kind falling into the enemy's hands should they attempt to execute their designs as reported.
I have the honor to be, with great Respect, your Excellency's most obedt. Servt. Sam. Huntington Presidt.
1 The enclosed resolution, adopted during a rare Sunday session, endorsed a recommendation of the Board of War based upon recent intelligence that an enemy expedition was about to embark from New York for New Castle, Del., for which see JCC, 19 365-67; and Huntington to Washington, April 7, 1781. For this threat to the Delmarva peninsula and the steps taken to alert Maryland through the president of the state's special eastern shore council, Matthew Tilghman, see also Huntington's letters to Washington and to Tilghman of April 26 and 27, 1781.
I am directed to request your Attendance in Congress as soon as possible. There are but eight States at this Time represented in Congress, a Circumstance by no Means proper in the present Situation of Affairs.(1)
As Chief Justice McKean sets out this Day on the Circuit to be absent some Time, it is necessary that two Delegates from the Delaware State give their Attendance immediately.
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c. S.H.
1 Huntington also wrote a similar letter this day to New Jersey delegate William Churchill Houston. PCC, item 15, fol. 265.
I receivd yours of the 6th with the money enclosd-& Shall loose no time in forwarding the wine. Col. Harrison has been in Town
I am Dear Sr. with great regard & esteem, Yr hu Obt Sert,
Danl Carroll
[P.S.] Please to let Mr. Richard Lloyd & Mr. Carroll have the perusal of the New York papers I send-they are for Parson Gates from Mr Meade.
I sent to Mr Carroll by the Express a paper contg Genl Greens last Letter & cannot [Jind] one to send you by this opportunity.
1 See Samuel Huntington to Washington, et al., April 7, and to Certain States April 9, 1781.
I received yours yesterday by the post. Am glad to be informed of your safe Arrival At Annapolis where I hope you will stay as long as Janey finds Any advantage from being there. Change of Air And Exercise Sometimes have Surprising Effects And would fain flatter my Self that it will in the present instance. Janey and Tammys State of health and the distressed and perplexed Situation Mrs. Hanson is in left alone a prey to Melancholly and despair destroys my peace of mind and renders me truly Misserable. Should have left this place last week but since the ratification of the Confederation 9 States are required to make a Congress. 4 are unrepresented And my withdrawing would leave a number insufficient to transact Business which at this Critical Conjuncture would perhaps be thought unpardonalbe however I hope to get Away by Thursday next. Some absent Members are sent for (1) And one from Jersey is expected in today or tomorrow when that State will be represented.
I hope you put yourself to no inconvenience in sending the money you inclosed. I could have done without it tho I have not received one farthing from the state since I have been here. What you have directed Shall be purchased. By the last of this month the second Division of the french may be Expd. I wish they were Arrived, it might be a means of withdrawing the British fleet And
Yrs. most affectionately, J.H.
1 See Samuel Huntington to Thomas Rodney and Nicholas Van Dyke, April 9, 1781.
2 Hanson had also expressed concern for his daughter's health in the following brief, March 13 letter to Thomas. "This only Serves to Cover the news papers, & to acquaint you that I am greatly disappointed and distressed, not hearing from you by the last post. I am in good health, but my peace of mind is much disturbed, being ever under dreadful Apprehensions that When I do hear from you, the Account will be unfavourable. I pray God that this may find your family and mine in much better health than When I left home. My love to Janey And the little ones...." Hanson Letters, MdHi. Jane's health continued to decline, however, and she apparently died a few weeks later.
Although Edmund C. Burnett records that Hanson was in continuous attendance through the spring and summer of 1781, he apparently returned to Maryland in mid-April to be near his daughter through her final illness. His name does not appear in the journals of Congress from April 12 until his return on September 24. See Burnett, Letters, 6:xlv; and JCC, 19:381, 392, 21:995.
By several untimely meetings of Congress within a few days I have been deprived of Leisure to write to you confidentially by an Express who went from hence this morning. I have much to say which cannot be trusted to Post Conveyance.
I have directed a Person to whom I wrote by that Express (1) to make application to you for assistance in a Business which I desire to have done for me either immediately or at your own Time according to Convenience and the Promotion of my Views as explained to you in a former Letter by Mr. Brown and also in one by Doctr. Winship.(2)
I do not find that Rivington has yet published any Thing from the last captured Mail but a Letter from the Genl. to Mr. Lund Washington. This does the Genl. great Credit as a private man of Justice, but there is a Design in Jemmy to make a Coolness between our Commander & the french, because Genl. W says Arnold would have been ruined if his Advice had been taken to send the whole Fleet instead of that Part which took the Romulus.(3)
Congress have determined that the superior Judges in each State with the Judge of Admirality (or such one of the Judges of Admiralty where there are several as the Executive shall chuse to commissionate) shall be Judges for trying Piracies on the high Seas; any two or more to be a Quorum. The Tryals were to be under all the Forms of prosecuting such Crimes on Land by grand & petit Juries.
You must see that we are now without our 9/10 of that money which were to have been completely put into our hands before the 1st of April. The Consequence of which Disappointment is beyond your Conception. Those States which longest neglected to take Steps upon the Plan of March 18 are now wanting the new Bills out before the old are called in. Notwithstanding the Necessities which press us (and they are great from an apprehended Expedition of the Enemy to Delaware to take Post at Newcastle) we have, as yet, refused. I have gone farther than I intended, by Post.
Yrs. affectionately, J L
[P.S.] Is Peabody alive? I have never been able to hear even of him since he left the Jersies. I will do my best with his and your Packages now under my Care.
1 Not found.
2 Lovell may be referring to his ventures in currency speculation, which he discussed in his letters to Gerry of March 16 and 20, 1781. However, neither of these letters could have been carried by Dr. Amos Windship, who left Philadelphia on March 5. See Lovell to Gerry, March 5, 1781.
3 For Washington's embarrassment over the interception of one of his letters to his brother Lund and its publication by "Jemmy" Rivington in the New York Royal Gazette on April 4, see Freeman, Washington, 5:275-76 (illustrations), 278-80; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:385-87. The offending passage from the letter Rivington attempted to use to discredit Washington in the eyes of Rochambeau and Destouches reads: "It was unfortunate; but this I mention in confidence, that the French fleet and detachment did not undertake the enterprize they are now upon, when I first propsed it to them; the destruction of Arnolds Corps would then have been inevitable before the British fleet could have been in a condition to put to Sea.
Instead of this the small squadron, which took the Romulus and other Vessels was sent, and could not, as I foretold, do any thing without a Land force at Portsmouth."
There are in this City about 4000 Rampart pieces belonging to the public-they weigh from 16 to 20 lbs each-it is thought the lightest might be useful in the hands of the Militia, and the others on board of Vessels. If you think it proper we shou'd apply for any of them, on account of the State, we think it is probable a thousand or 1500 might be obtaind, with some old cartouch boxes belonging to them. There are likewise some Brass Field pieces mounted, three or four of which might possibly be obtained on yr. request.(1)
We are, Sir, with great respect, Yr. Mo. Obt Servts.
John Hanson
Daniel Carroll
Dr. Sir, Col. Forrest left directions with Mr. Gaddiss & Mr. Wilkinson about the paper, & a memorandum about the types for the small money with me-but the directions were not particular enough as to the latter, & all the paper was not to be engagd until further orders.(2) Please to let me Know what is to be done, & no time shall be lost.
I am Yr Excellencys Mo Ob Serv, Danl Carroll
1 On April 14 the Maryland governor and council authorized the delegates to apply for 750 "of the best" rampart pieces and cartridge boxes as well as the four brass field pieces "for they are much wanted." See Md. Archives, 45:399. See also Carroll to Lee, April 24, 1781.
2 On April 6 the governor and council had informed the delegates that prices in Maryland had risen considerably "for want of small change" and asked when "the Plates for the small Denominations of our State Money, and the paper for printing them...may be expected." Md. Archives, 45:379. It is not known what "further orders" the delegates may have received in response to this letter.
I wrote you a few lines the 22nd of last month, (2) which I hope will reach you in due time.
I have been uneasy for some time past, at not receiving a line from you, the last I got was dated so far back as the 15th Decr.-and have been greatly at a loss to know where to find you, after the Retreat of Genl. Greene's Army. I have since been informed of your being indisposed and had come off with the Hospital. I sincerely hope you have long since recovered and will in future enjoy a great share of health & evry other happiness this World can afford you.
I send this Letter, as I did two others, to the care of Colo. Dart and requested of him to forward them to you with all convenient speed. I wish you may meet, as he can inform you of many circumstances & of the situation of most of our acquaintances in Carolina-he has seen several Persons from thence. I have not had a Letter from Polly since the middle of November, but have had the satisfaction to hear since, that she and the rest of our dear Relations & Friends were well, the latter end of January. I am very unhappy on their account and more so, as I see no speedy prospect of extricating them out of their difficulties-tho' I cannot help mentioning to you, in Confi-dence, that there is great reason to expect the second division of the French Fleet will be here soon, in which case, I flatter myself our Affairs to the Southward will be in a good way-the exertion of the Southern Delegates in Congress will not be wanting in effecting evrything that will contribute to the expulsion of the Enemy from our native Country. The situation of Lord
The failure of Monsr. des Touches not getting into Chesapeake Bay, has rather damped our Spirits and does, for the present, secure the Traitor Arnold in his strong hold at Portsmouth and 'tis reported, that a strong embarkation is preparing at New York to re-inforce him, others say, that [it has sail]ed for Delaware Bay & that Genl. [Sir Henry?] Clinton is to command in Person. [He will try?] to take Post at New Castle. [...] the intelligence I do not bel[ieve and I do?] not think they are strong e[nough at] York to allow of a sufficient detachment for [...]. I fear 'twill sail for Carolina.
The News Papers herewith sent, will give you all the Public News and to wsh. I beg leave to refer you, And I am, with many good wishes for your wellfare, My Dear Sir, Yours very Affectionately,
Isaac Motte.
P.S. I have been told, that Maurice & Keating Simons, have both lost their wives.
1 Militia captain Alexander Broughton (d. 1793), a minor official and landowner in St. John Berkeley Parish, S.C., was Motte's brother-in-law. Bio. Dir. of S.C. House of Rep., 3:93.
2 Not found.
I was in hopes to have had some European intelligence before I closed this letter; but Doctor Burke is to go in the morning, (1) and there is nothing authentic from that quarter. A report prevails that the Dutch have declared war with Great Britain, which is not improbable. We have assurances that the aid to be furnished by our ally this campaign, will not be less than 12,000 land forces, and the same number of seamen, including those already in America. Should they arrive seasonably, I hope, with proper exertions on our part, the enemy may be driven from every part of the United States
Your own discretion will direct you not to make my sentiments on this subject public; should you mention them to any of our particular confidential friends, I hope they will be cautious to keep it secret, as I would not wish that any thing which drops from me should occasion any degree of despondence. I am very sorry my sister finds so much difficulty in writing to me. She knows how much I love her, and how acceptable any thing that comes from her would be to me. I should have wrote to her, but consider my letters to you as if wrote to her. Present my love to her and my sister Blair and her children, &c., &c.
Your affectionate brother and obedient servant,
Sam. Johnston.
1 Thomas Burke never returned from the "leave of absence" he obtained this day because of his unexpected election to the governorship of North Carolina on June 25, 1781. See JCC, 19:376; and John S. Watterson, Thomas Burke, Restless Revolutionary (Washington, D.C.: University Press of America, 1980), pp. 169-70.
A Letter from Genl. Washington being read (2) Sitting forth that there was the greatest Necessaty for the detachment of 1200 Men Under the Marquis now at the head of Elk, and the Pensylvania line To go to the Southward, and that he was fearful they Could not go &c with pay &c.
In this Case it appeared that the detachment under the Marquis, as well as the Pensylvan'a expected pay to be advanced them beside paying up arrears-And it did not appear that there Was Money in the Treasury Sufficient for this & other purposes Without Calling for the 6/10 of the new Money Subject to the Order of Congress; And that a Sufficient quantaty of the old Money had not yet been recd. To enable them to Call for this portion of the New Money agreable to the Resolution of the 18th of March. However a Motion was Made that Congress Should Call for the Whole 6/10 of the new Money immediately-and it was argued by the Movers That it was absolutely necessary that the Troops Should March immediately to the Southward, that they Would not March Without the pay & arrears
It is to be lamented that Congress is So deficient in the abilities of Financing that No Member is capable of offering a System that is Worthy the Establishment of Congress None Whose Idea's are at the Same Time both Simple & Systimatical enough for this purpose. Both the plans now offered are deficient in this respect. They are both Too Complex and incoherent To be admited-therefore will probably Occasion Much debate and no Effect. While our affairs related to Simple Constitutional questions only the Americans appeared great indeed because every Man Was naturaly raised up a midst the Most pure & Clear principles of Liberty that ever has been practiced or enjoyed by Society, But having paid very little or no Attention to the Study of useful knowlidge farther than was Necessary To Conduct their Own Occupations, Now Their Matters has grown Complex and extensive they appear unable to Conduct
1 Rodney had just returned to Philadelphia after a month in Delaware, which he explained immediately preceding this entry in the following terms:
"The 10th of March I returned home Where I Stayed Seven or Eight days then Went down to Kent Where I Stayed Two Weeks on My own private affairs-returned home to Wilmington The last of March and Came again To Congress The Tenth of Aprill-When I found Congress in the Same imbarressed Situation With Their finances as When I left them.
"Aprill The 11th This day I took My Seat in Congress again."
2 This was Washington's April 8 letter to President Huntington which was read in Congress this day. See JCC, 19:374; PCC, item 152, 10:67-70; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:429-31.
3 This ambiguous passage undoubtedly should be punctuated to read: "Two other plans, offered by a Cent. from Virginia & one from Massichusats, was referred To a Committee of five"-as only two, not three plans, were apparently offered. Rodney further compounded the confusion by misidentifying the plan moved by Connecticut delegate Oliver Wolcott as one offered by a gentleman "from Massichusats." See JCC, 1 9:376-8 1.
J'ai lu hier au Soir, la Lettre qui a ete publiee par Mr. Rivington, Sous le nom du General Washington, je ne crois pas qutelle a ete ecrit par Son Excellence, mais Si elle L' a ete il n'y a rien qui puisse donner la moindre inquietude aux les Commandans de l'arme et d'Escadre du Roi: il y a dit qu'il etoit tres malheureux que toute l'Escadre francoise ne soit pas Sorti d'abord; avec les troupes de terre, au Lieu d'un vaissau de Ligne et deux fregattes (comme il L'Avoit propose) parceque si cela etoit fait dans ce tems la qu'il falloit que Mr Arnold avec son Arme ait ete prise mais que cette petite flotte ne pouvoit rien faire sans les troupes de terre. II arrive journellement Monsieur que les plus grands Militaire pensent bien differement Sur le Meme objet et La reussite n'est pas toujour la miellure preuve de la Sagesse de leur mesures neamenoins le
Je crois que Le General a mentionne cette affaire mais non pas avec les meme expressions que Sont publiee dans la Gazette Royal. Je Suis Surpris que Mr Rivington n'y ait pas adjoute davantage il a publiee dans une Autre Gazette une Lettre du General au Congres dans laquelle il lui demande la permission de Sa retirer du Service, des etats unis. II a publie aussi la reponse du Congres a Cette Lettre dont ni L'une ni l'autres n'ont jamais existe. Si Mr Rivington pouroit forger une Lettre et one reponse tout entier il ne devoit point trouver beaucoup des difficultes d adjouter a Cette du General Washington, tout ce quil Lui etoit agreables.
J'ai L'honneure detre avec La plus parfaite Estime votre tres humble & tres obeissante Serviteur, J S
I read yesterday evening the letter which was published by Mr. Rivington under the name of General Washington.(1) I do not think that it was written by His Excellency, but if it were there is nothing that can give the least uneasiness to the Commanders of the army and Fleet of the King. He said that it was very unfortunate that the entire French Fleet did not go out at first with the land troops instead of one ship of the line and two frigates (as he had proposed) because if that had been done at the required time Mr. Arnold with his Army would have been captured; but this little fleet could do nothing without the land troops. It happens every day, sir, that the greatest Soldiers think very differently on the same subject, and success is not always the best proof of the Wisdom of their measures, nevertheless the world in general forms its Judgment according to Results.
I think the General mentioned this affair, but not with the same expressions that are published in the Royal Gazette. I am Surprised that Mr. Rivington did not add more; he published in another Gazette a Letter from the General to Congress, in which he asked the permission to withdraw from the Service of the United States. He published also the answer of Congress to this letter; neither of which ever existed. If Mr. Rivington could completely forge a Letter and its answer, he ought not to find much difficulty in adding to General Washington's letter, anything that he liked.
I have the honor to be with the most perfect Esteem your very humble & obedient Servant, J S
1 See James Lovell to Elbridge Gerry, April 10, 1781, note 3.
Great part of the Time of Congress being Taken up by the Consideration of Various Officers & others particularly for Money it Was now, in Substance resolved that Such applications hereafter Shall be Made In the first Instance To the Auditors, Treasury &c. &c. To be Adjusted and allowed by them agreable To general principles Directed by Congress from Time to Time.
A resolution was Moved by Genl. Varnum Introduced by Words like the Man himself Arora borialis fine indeed but not well adapted To the Occasion for Confering on John Paul Jones What he Well deserved-The thanks of Congress and a Gold Meddal, for his truly brave & Splendid Action as a Naval Officer.
These favours were opposed in Some Measure as untimely by that Cautious Senator S. Adams-Who only urged that Such favours being the highest in the power of the States (and Next to those of Heaven) ought to be granted With cautious delibration. But it was Alledged that those Services for Which these favours Were urged had been known to Congress & the World that no further diliberation was necessary. However as the resolution wanted amendment it was Committed.(1)
Money in its use is only a Medium or Standard by Which the Value of all the articles of Trade & Commerce are Compaired-And assertains the price as scales & Weights does the Weight Upon this principle gold and Silver has been found the Most usefull and Convenient for that purpose, and therefore has been universally adobted by all Trading & Commercial people from the earliest knowledge of its use.
Previous To the revolution, there not being enough gold & Silver Money in America To Serve as a circulating Medium The deficiency was Made up by paper Money, Which being issued in Such quantities only as was found absolutely necessary for that purpose and redeemable by Certain funds, it always passed at the Value Stamped thereon in all the provinces Where these essentials Were adhered To. But in New England Where they Issued Too Much on Account of the last War the Money depreciated To 1/20 part of its Nominal Value.
Upon the Commencement of Hostilities between great Brittain and America, The Congress finding that the greatest part of the Specie had been Sent out of the Country, and that this Together with the Total Stoppage of Trade put it out of their power To lay Taxes, began To Issue paper Money upon No better fund than their pledging the faith of the States that it Should be redeem'd with Specie agreable to the Value Stamped on the Bills. The Virtue of
The depreciation Still proceeded rapidly So that the Taxes Collected for publick use Would not answer the demands and the Congress pressed by Necessaty adopted the System of the 18th of March 1780. This being Materially defective in Several things and particularly in having the execution of it Committed to the respective States, they proceeded upon it in different Modes So that the good effects that Might have flowed from it were in a great Measure lost by this means. And now that the States are in the utmost distress for want of Money they feel little or No releaf from that System-because they Cannot Command the use of the new Money for want of the old having Timely exchanged-and What they have being depreciated in the very issuing by Tying it to the old Money at a Certain exchange which differs in Most of the States &c. &c. &c. it does not answer the wished for purpose. When we Consider the use of Money-and what it is that Makes it useful it is no Wonder that our Revolution paper Money has all failed-There not being any essential fund To Support it.
We are therefore now greatly in debt, and have not Money To pay them; and most that has been paid Since the Money depreciated, have been Cheated by this Means out of What was their Just dues. And the rest have no Certain Security for What is due them only a late resolution of Congress that they Shall be paid the real Value of their debts.
Suppose then that all the debts now due from the United States to Individuals Should be duly liquidated at their Value in Specie and the Creditors receive Publick bills or Loan office Certificates Promissing payment in a few years With interest annually-And the united States provide a fund immediatley by an impost on Goods or
1 On the page after this entry, Rodney inserted the following brief fiscal essay, setting it off by indenting the entire opening paragraph.
Your Excellency will recieve enclosed, a resolve of Congress of the 13th Instant, relative to the Mode adopted to pay the new Levies, recommending it to the several States to make Payment.(1)
And also directing the future Application of Claimants for Settlement of Accounts, for Payment of liquidated Accounts, for Rank, Discharges, Losses &c, or for resignation.
The former Part of this resolve respecting the new Levies, I presume is intended for those only who served the last Campaign, and if any of them have received partial Payments from their regimental Paymasters, which is probable as I am informed by the Paymaster General, Care should be taken to transmit the same to the respective States.
I have the Honor to be, with the highest respect, Your Excellency's most obedient Servant, Sam. Huntington President
1 According to Secretary Thomson's endorsement, the Board of War report containing this recommendation was read in Congress on January 17, although for reasons unknown it was not adopted until April 13. See JCC, 19:384; and PCC, item 147, 6:93-96. For the transmittal of the enclosed resolve to the states, see Huntington to the States, April 15, 1781.
Your Excellency's Letters of the 24th & 31st Ulto the 3d & 4th Instant, with the Despatches to which they refer have been received. (1)
You will observe by the enclosed Resolve it is the Pleasure of Congress that you employ an additional confidential Secretary, and as many Writers as you shall judge proper to arrange & register the
Sam. Huntington President
1 Huntington had previously acknowledged the first two of these in his April 5 letter to Washington. That of "the 3d...Instant" actually consisted of Washington's "remarks" on a report concerning rank and promotions in the Continental Army submitted to him by a congressional committee. See PCC, item 152, 10:43-52, 63-66; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:403-12.
2 This resolve was adopted in response to a request contained in Washington's April 4 letter, for which see ibid., 21:411-12; and JCC, 19:368.
The Complement to Captn. J. P. Jones was reported, in More decent language and the thanks of Congress Agreed to-but the question on the Medal postponed.(1) Mr S. Adams urged on this Occasion that the American Sea men in Europe ought to receive their prize Money that Capn. Jones was Concerned in this (2)-that inquiry ought to be had &c. Mr. Sharp one of the Admiralty Members Said that the papers produced by Captn. Jones cleared him from fault in this and all the political disputes of our Agents &c. &c. in Europe-that it appeard by those papers a Man lately high in Office in Eu____ was concerned in advising Captn. Landa To run from there with the Alliance which Occasioned the delay of the Cloathing for the Army-that the Same Gentleman was concerned in the Mutiny that happen'd on board of the Allyance. Mr. Mathews delivered in a scheme for funding the Continental debts-and for Mortgaging 5,000,000 Acres of the backlands as a fund To borrow Money on the Interest of all to be paid by an impost on goods &c. Committed to the Commitee of finance.(3)
1 For the commendation of John Paul Jones, see Samuel Huntington to Jones, April 19, 1781.
2 Congress directed the Board of Admiralty to examine the "cause of the detention of the prize-money due" to United States seamen. JCC, 19:392.
3 For John Mathews "scheme" for funding the Continental debt, see JCC, 19:394-95.
There is Nothing new at this Time either from Europe or from the Southward, except what is contained in the Gazette extraordinary of the 10 inst from New York, (1) which I doubt not, you have seen. What is said respecting the Portuguese war, and the Assistance which Russia has agreed to give to Great-Britain, may be true because it is not naturally impossible, but it is not supported either by Fact or Probability which has come to my Knowledge.
I beg Leave to urge to Your Excellency the immediate and evident Necessity of altering the Exchange of the Continental Currency. I do not think we ought to wait for Pennsylvania, especially when they appear to be pursuing a line of Conduct so generally disapproved, and, as far as I can judge, I must beg Leave to add, not easily reconcileable to Fairness and Honesty, and the Intentions of those who vested the Power. The Stationary Condition of the legal Exchange, while the popular or mercantile is moving foward, must inevitably ruin the State-or lawful Money, because it will be utterly impossible to bring it back again to the value from which it depreciates. Whatever Reasons induced the fixing it at 75 in November last now certainly require it should be fixed above 100. If suffering it to stand will hurt the new Money, and altering it will probably, I think it will absolutely, help it, what Justification can be given for not altering it? That it will take Money out of the State is a Mistake. Everyone knows that though the legal Exchange here is 75 no Man deals at less than 140. I am with great Respect, your Excellency's obedt Servant. W C Houston
1 That is, James Rivington's New York Royal Gazette.
Your several Letters of the 28th February, 10th, 16th & 23d of March with the Papers to which they severally refer have been received; also your Letter of the 14th of January was received the 22d of March by Doctor Brownson.(1)
I have the Honor of transmitting you the enclosed Act of Congress of the 22d of March, containing aditional regulations for conducting the medical Department & military Hospitals.(2)
Claypoole's Paper which is enclosed, contains the most authentic
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S.H.
1 Greene's letters of February 28 and March 10, 16, and 23 are in PCC, item 155, 1:580-83, 595-98, 2:1-8, 13-16. A copy of his January 14 letter concerning the hospital supplies needed by Dr. Nathan Brownson, purveyor general in the southern department, is in PCC, item 172, 1:88-89.
2 See JCC, 19:292-94.
3 The April 14 issue of David C. Claypoole's Pennsylvania Packet contained reports from the St. Christopher Gazette concerning Adm. George Rodney's attack on St. Eustatius and capture of 138 French, Spanish, American, and Dutch vessels in the harbor, the outbreak of war between the Dutch and Portuguese, and Dutch overtures to the court at St. Petersburg.
I do myself the Honor of transmitting for your Information, the enclosed resolve of Congress, relative to furnishing Supplies to the Amount of four hundred thousand Dollars, for which our Minister at the Court of Versailles has entered into Engagements.(1)
I have the Honor to be, with the highest respect, Sir, Your most obedient & humble Servant,
Sam Huntington Presidt.
1 For the adoption of the enclosed April 11 congressional resolve, see JCC, 19:370-73; Committee of Congress to Jean Holker, March 23; and Committee to La Luzerne, March 29, 1781.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, a resolve of Congress of the 13th Instant, directing the Commander in Chief to transmit to the Executives of the several States, Lists of the Names of all the new
Levies belonging to each State respectively, authenticated in the Manner specified in the Resolve; and recommending it to the said
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c S.H.
1 See JCC, 19:384; and Huntington's first letter to Washington of April 14, 1781.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed the report of a Committee & consequent Resolve of Congress of the 22d Ulto relative to the Act of Connecticut vesting in Congress for a limited Time a Power to levy & collect Duties &c; earnestly recommending to the Legislature of the State of Connecticut to revise the above mentioned Law and to alter & amend it agreeable to the requisition in the Act of Congress of the 3d of February last.(1)
I have also herewith enclosed, Copies of the Acts passed by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and State of New York fully comformable to the Request of Congress.(2)
It must be observed that from the Tenor of the Act of Congress of the 3d of February, all the States who are in Circumstances to meet in Assembly must enact Laws conformable to the requisition, otherwise the whole will prove abortive, as none of their Acts will be obligatory until all have passed similar Acts.
The Delegates in Congress, who are frequently retiring not to return again can have no separate Interest from their Constituents to prejudice their Minds in Favour of the Act requested, they may have formed different Sentiments from the continual View of a pressing and absolute Necessity of a national Fund to suppport the national Credit and enable them to prosecute the War with any Degree of Vigour.
I do myself the Honor to enclose for your Excellency's Information an Extract of a Letter from Genl Greene which contains the latest Intelligence received from that Quarter. It is to be lamented that General Greene could not have obtained a little more Assistance from the Militia of the adjacent Country. Cornwallis in his last retreat shews such evident Marks of Distress that it seems very little Opposition from the People in Aid of General Greene must have made the Enemy all Prisoners.
I have the Honor to be, with perfect Respect, Your Excellency's Most obedient servant, Sam. Huntington President
1 For Congress' adoption of the enclosed resolve and Huntington's decision to
2 For the enclosed March 23 New York act, received by Congress on April 5, see JCC, 19:353; and PCC, item 74, fols. 157-59. For the adoption of the enclosed April 5 Pennsylvania act, see the Minutes of the Second Sitting of the Fifth General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, pp. 399, 418, 421, DLC(ESR).
The inclosed paper is a copy of a report from a Committee now Iying on the table of Congress for Consideration. The delicacy and importance of the subject makes me wish for your judgment on it before it undergoes the final decision of Congress.(1)
The necessity of arming Congress with coercive powers arises from the shameful deficiency of some of the States which are most capable of yielding their apportioned supplies, and the military exactions to which others already exhausted by the enemy and our own troops are in consequence exposed. Without such powers too in the general government, the whole confederacy may be insulted and the most salutary measures frustrated by the most inconsiderable State in the Union. At a time when all the other States were submitting to the loss and inconveniency of an embargo on their exports, Delaware absolutely declined coming into the measure, and not only defeated the general object of it, but enriched herself at the expence of those who did their duty.
The expediency however of making the proposed application to the States will depend on the probability of their complying with it. If they should refuse, Congress will be in a worse situation than at present: for as the confederation now stands, and according to the nature even of alliances much less intimate, there is an implied right of coercion against the delinquent party, and the exercise of it by Congress whenever a palpable necessity occurs will probably be acquiesced in.
It may be asked perhaps by what means Congress could exercise such a power if the States were to invest them with it? As long as there is a regular army on foot, a small detachment from it, acting under Civil authority, would at any time render a voluntary contribution of supplies due from a State, an eligible alternative. But there is a still more easy and efficacious mode. The situation of most of the States is such, that two or three vessels of force employed against their trade will make it their interest to yield prompt obidience to all just requisitions on them. With respect to those States that have little or no foreign trade of their own, it is provided that all inland trade with such states as supply them with foreign merchandize, may be interdicted and the concurrence of the latter may be enforced in
There is a collateral reason which interests the States who are feeble in maritime resources in such a plan. If a naval armament was considered as the proper instrument of general Government, it would be both preserved in a respectable State in time of peace, and it would be an object to mann it with Citizens taken in due proportion from every State. A Navy so formed and under the orders of the general Council of the States, would not only be a guard against aggressions & insults from abroad; but without it what is to protect the Southern States for many years to come against the insults & aggressions of their N. Brethren. I am Dear [Sir] Yr. Sincere friend & obt. servt.
J. Madison Junr.
1 For the enclosed report on proposals for strengthening the Articles of Confederation, see JCC, 20:469-71; Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:17-19; and James M. Varnum to William Greene, March 16, 1781, note 3.
Coincidentally, Virginia delegate Joseph Jones, who was about to set out for Philadelphia at this time, was similarly preoccupied with the inadequacy of the powers granted to Congress under the confederation, and accordingly set about consulting key Virginia leaders on a remedy for the perceived defects. The following undated draft letter, in Jones' hand and endorsed by him "Copy letter to Pendleton, Wythe, Jefferson," is in the Madison Papers, DLC, although there is nothing to indicate just when or how Madison came into possession of the document.
"Maryland having subscribed the Articles of Confederation the alliance of the States is now compleat and in future Congress are to be governed by those Rules. If the Powers granted to the Representative Body of the States by these Articles are inadequate to the purposes of carrying on a vigorous War and of this all the States from experience are able to judge-would it not be wise while common danger presses us together and the States see and feel the necessity of enlarging the powers of Congress for the purposes of War, that the defects of the Articles in this respect be timely considered and remedied. Danger may spring from delay-good will result from a timely application of remedy. The present temper of the States is friendly to the establishment of a lasting Union. The moment shod be improved-if suffered to pass away it may never return; and after gloriously and successfully contending agt. the usurpations of Britain we may fall a prey to our own follies and disputes. I am aware of the danger of granting great powers and of the reluctance of the States to yield them and attribute the present disposition to give Congress more competent powers to a conviction from experience that it is for the common good to do so. In the course of business the defects of the Confederation will no doubt appear and Congress will point them out to the States and propose the necessary alterations for their concurrence. One, and of the first importance hath already become a question, that is, the Power of compeling the States to comply with the requisitions for men and money agreeably to their respective quotas. The States appear to have yielded to Congress the right of ascertaining the Sum necessary for the public expence & oblige themselves to furnish their proportions agreeably to the mode prescribed. They also yield the right of fixing the quotas of Men for the common defence wch. shall be binding but no mode is stated how a disobedient or delinquent State is to be compelled to furnish the one or the other and for want of this controuling power in Congress over the States when refractory war cannot be prosecuted with vigor and the safety of the whole endangered besides the hardship and injustice to those that comply and the prolongation of the War by such delinquencies. If in surrendering the right of fixing the proportions the Power of compelling obedience is implied, how
For a similar expression of Jones' views, contained in a letter to Jefferson bearing this day's date, see Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:469-71.
I mentioned in my last,(1) that by the first good opportunity, I would communicate to yr. Excy. some thoughts respecting the present political state of affairs-such as they appear to me-perhaps my opinions may differ, from the generallity of your correspondents, as I know many are but too apt to keep their eyes contantly fixed on the pleasing side of the picture, & feel an aversion to take a View of the reverse, or if they do, endeavour by the most specious colourings to extenuate it's deformities, & if possible cast a veil over the whole. The lines I now address to your Excy. will convince you, I am not one of those botchers, I represent things as they really are. Your station sir, entitles you to the most unreserved communications. The friendship you have done me the honor sir, to entertain for me, demands it of me. Yet it is with reluctance I enter on the task, well knowing your Patriotic bosom is already, sufficiently torn with the embarrassments you daily encounter, and pants for some friendly hand to pour balsam into the wound, but still is incapable of shrinking from increased pain. Accept this apology most worthy sir for the unpleasant theme, which justice to your conspicuous station bids me discuss in the most p[l]ain and unequivocal (manner) language.
I have for some time past contemplated the state of our affairs with extreme anxiety, which was not a little increased by the contents of your last letter to Congress:(2) the information it contained; astonished me, as we had been repeatedly told, that the battalions eastward of Hudsons river were nearly compleated. What must the friends of America think of their cause when they see so small a body as twelve hundred men(3) collected for a particular purpose, & the United states cannot command as much money, as will enable them to march?-another body of men ordered to march (4) & such a disposition manifested by them, that there was not time to wait your orders, but the interposition of a collateral power became immediately necessary to stop them, to prevent further evils? When our creditors are daily clamouring around us, for their just dues, & those excuses so long held out to them for with-holding payment, can no longer be made use of with the least degree of propriety? Our army-God knows how long-in arrear for their pay, & I must fear will, in a very little time, be in want of bread?-as this state informed us, they could purchase no flour, unless we would lend them the money. The army not only in want of pay, but almost every necessary? the southern army, literally in want of every necessary? no manner of preperations going forward for military stores for the ensuing campaign which is coming fast upon us, nay, which may be said to be arrived-Although we daily expect the arrival of a large reinforcement from our Ally, which we solemnly engaged to be in respectable condition to Co-operate with, on their arrival? Were I to enter into minutia, I should tire your patience in pursuing the black catalogue. Enough has been said. This sir is the true picture of our affairs, and I do boldly assert that Congress have not a single means in their power, to remedy either the one or the other of these accummulated evils, and what is above all, worse, their does not appear to me a disposition to endeavour at it. Whenever the subject is brought forward, men seem to shrink from it as if the case was desperate.
It is true, Congress have called on the States for 6,000,000 of dollars-they calculate upon 4,000,000 out of the new money-as well as upon 5,000,000 from the Court of France. These sums, together with the specific supplies, are the funds on which we depend for the support of the present campaign. Now let us examine for a moment what prospect there is of their productiveness. As to the first, little or no relyance is to be placed on it, because, they are now in arrear 6,400,000 dollars specie & I know of no measures that have been taken to procure it. To the second: 1,000,000 is already spent, the three southern states can emit no part of theirs, New York can do very little, & this State has damn'd the plan, & adopted one of their own, for emitting literally state money, which will not begin to operate before the first of June. So
When will all this end? In an unsuccessful campaign, I have no manner of doubt. But will this be the least evil to be apprehended? I fear not. Indeed my Dearest sir, I begin almost to despond. Were I to consider my private interest, or that of my state only, I should altogether despair. And clear I am, in my opinion, that unless some effectual, vigorous, & decisive measures are speedily taken, to extricate us, from the labryinth of difficulty, & distress, into which we are at present plunged, all the generous blood that has been spilt in this glorious contest, will have been spilt in vain, & the spirits of those who have so nobly fallen, will stalk terrific through our land, seeking vengeance on those who have so infamously suffered their children to become slaves.
As a citizen of America, as one who has more at stake than any man in it, as one who from our mistaken policy, is debared an intimate knowledge of our affairs, but who, from his station, ought to be acquainted with every thing. By these considerations I say sir, I have been led to make you these free communications. I know they must give pain to your generous nature, yet I supposed, you would rather wish to be made acquainted with them, than not. Whatever changes take place either for the better, or worse, with yr. Excys. permission, I will inform you of.
Please to make my respectful complements to Mrs Washington, and believe me to be, My Dr. sir, with every sentiment of the sincerest friendship, & highest respect, Yr. Excys. most Obedt. servt. Jno. Mathews
1 Not found.
2 Washington's letter of April 8 revealing the states' failures to meet their troop quotas had been read on the 12th. See JCC, 19:374; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:429-31.
3 At this point Mathews inserted an asterisk, to which he keyed "Pensylvania line" at the foot of the page.
4 That is, "The Marquiss's detachment," noted in similar manner at the foot of the page.
A Letter from Captn. Clark informing that Certain Stores Ordered to be laid up at fort Pitt for an expedition against the indians was not fully furnished and a request that Congress Would make up the deficiency by Sendg. forward Certain articles Mentioned Was read.(1) Genl. Varnum opposed the Motion & inquired Whether the expedition Was at the Instance or Under the direction of the United States or Virginia &c. Genl. Sulivan Said that this was an expedition of Virginia, that they were going on Some Wild goose Chase against the Indians or Detroit as he Supposed, when they ought to have Turned all their force against the Enemy now distroying the Most Cultivated part of their Country-and wanted Congress to Support them in it when All their fource & Supplies Was necessary against the Enemy Who were invading Sundry parts of the Country; that Virginia had been upon the Same Scheme for Several years past And allured the publick With An expedition against Detroit While all their views had a different effect. That they nor no other State had a right to form any Such expeditions Without the approbation of Congress &c. &c. &c.
Governor Howly Said he was Now in favour of the Measure Since the Matter had gone So far that it wanted only a little assistance to Complete the Matter but that he lamented the Cause. That Virginia had wontonly Settled part of the back Country and now it was necessary to protect it-but that the occasion aught Not to have been Made &c. &c.
Mr. Mathews informed Congress that this expedition had been Communicated to, & approved by the board of warr & Commander in Chief but that Virginia alone was to pay the Expence &c. for it. passed.
In the report of Rules for the Conduct of Congress It was a question That no Motion Should be received unless Made or Seconded by a State. Genl. Sulivan, Governor Howley, Col. Bland & Mr. Clark Spoke against it. Mr. Mathews, Bee, Madison &c. &c. were for it-not past-rejected.
1 George Rogers Clark's April 2 letter had been forwarded to Congress by the Board of War, to whom it was returned this day with instructions to comply with the request "so far as the stores requested can be conveniently spared." See JCC, 19:396; and PCC, item 60, fols. 33-34.
General Washington had already been directing the commander at Fort Pitt to provide supplies to Clark. Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:33-35, 316, 462, 480, 500.
I return you many thanks for yr favor of the 13th Instant & feel for the distresses of those whose Situation puts them so much in the power of a savage Enemy. God grant something soon to relieve them. I expect the Enemy will make a Stroke at most of the warehouses soon; Surely every thing liable to be destroyd or taken will be removd from the Shores. A temporary inconvenience cannot be put in competition with the evills which must otherwise result. My Compts. To Col. Brice. I receivd his letter for Mr Peale last night, & my Servt shall carry it immediately to him.
Mr A Buchanan is just from N York. He says there is the appearance of a very considerable embarkation there. They give out that Genl Clinton is to sail with 4000 Men for Chesapeake. Genl Washington in a Letter to Congress of the 12th (1) says he had not receivd any information on the Subject more than what he had from Congress-& is inclind to think Clinton wod not embark a force so considerable as to induce him to take the Command without risking the loss of N York.
The president has a letter from Genl Green the 30th Ulo. from Ramsays Mill abt halfway between Guilford & Cross Creeks.(2) He had left his Baggage & made a precipitate march to strike Cornwallis, who retreated in so great a hurry that he left his dead of their wounds & fatigue unburried; he is retreating to Cross Creek & Wilmington. The war is therefore over in those parts for some little time. If the Supplies sent by the Board of war abt 20 days past reach our Men they will receive some Comfort. I will next post send a list of what were forwarded. I do not Know whether there is more danger of their falling into the Enemies hands, or of our friends who have applied Some that were sent before to the use of the Militia.
My Compts. to Mr. Harwood, I request the favor of him to send me by the next post the Amount of the Cont money receivd under our law, & the 4/10ths in treasury belonging to Congress. It is of importance I shoud be informd on this Subject.
I am much obligd to you for your attention abt a Supply of money for me. I am realy at present in a very disagreable Situation. I cannot touch a farthing from the Conl Treasury here. If I am not supplied very shortly I shall be under the disagreable necessity of returning, & even for that must try my own Credit.
I observe what you say abt the Wine. A quarter cask went of[f] a few days past in a waggon of Col Harrisons to be left at Mr Archy Buchanans-it was put in a Case.
Present my Compts to all friends, & am, Dear Sr., Yrs. Sincerely & Affectionately Danl Carroll
[P.S.] I am alone. The distresses of Mr Hansons family has obligd him to return home.
1 For Washington's letter of April 12, which was read in Congress on the 16th, see JCC, 19:396; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:448-49.
2 Nathanael Greene's March 30 letter, which was read in Congress this day (JCC, 19:398; PCC, item 155, 2:17-21), also stimulated the following brief letter of this date from William C. Houston to William Livingston.
"This Morning brought us a Letter from General Greene. It is dated 30 ult from Col. Ramsey's on Deep-River about 45 Miles N.W. of Cross-Creek. Lord Cornwallis was still retiring towards that Place in no small Distress and Genl Greene following in Distress full as great. It appears from Circumstances that his Lordship feels very deeply the Consequences of the Action of the 15 ult near Guildford Court-house. Had Genl Greene an efficient Force, Supplies and Money, he would ruin him effectually, but he cannot act with Vigour for Want of these Essentials. I do not imagine any Action will happen in that Quarter for some Time. Lord Cornwallis can establish himself at Cross-Creek, and if he should ever fail in this he can at Wilmington about 80 Miles further S.E. I am afraid the next News will be that Genl Greene is either retreating before the Enemy or retiring for Want of Supplies." William Livingston Papers, NN.
I have this day recd. your Favor of March 29th and am as barren of news as you were at that date. The Post is become useless for Politicians to a very great Degree but I cannot refrain from giving you a Return made to Genl Washington on the 1st of April and by him forwarded to Congress.
| joined | unfit | retained | |
| N. H. | none | ||
| Mass. | 59 | 5 | 54 |
| R. I. | 125 | - | 125 |
| C. | 270 | 35 | 235 |
| 454 | 40 | 414 | |
| after the Return. | |||
| N. Yk. | 67 | 67 |
Cornwallis has retreated quite out of Green's Reach. The Time of the Virga. militia being expired our army is weak. There were the greatest marks of Distress left by the British. Their Dead were buried by our People. You were in Congress at an easy happy Period of Business tho' you did not know it, nor did I then guess it.
Yours affectionately J.L.(1)
1 Lovell also wrote letters this day to Abigail Adams and to Elbridge Gerry concerning efforts he had recently made for the shipment of goods for them by wagon to Boston. The letter to Abigail is in Adams, Family Correspondence (Butterfield) 4: 102-3. The letter to Gerry reads: "Yours of the 28th of March reached me yesterday. I have delivered the small one inclosed.
"I could not send yr. Box by a Return of Mr. Dugan's Waggon, because, as the Waggoners judged, the Tobacco Hogsheads would crush it, they being very badly shipped, one in each Waggon being short & one long.
"I will write you more at my Leisure by a better Conveyance." Gerry-Townsend Papers, NN.
A Letter recd. To day from Genl. Green dated 30th March-relating in Substance that he had left his Baggage and Made a forced March To Overtake Cornwallace-but that before he arrived Cornwallace had decamped leaving his dead unburied & Taken his rout to Cross Creek And thence Toward Wilmington N.C.-That as the Virginia Malitia Would leave him in a few days, & his Army had Suffered greatly with fateague & Want of Provisions, and he left With an inferior force he Could not pursue any further-That the Whings & Tories in that Country were killing one another so fast that it Seem'd likely to Depopulate that Country-he also Sent a Copy of a Proclamation Issued by Cornwallace, Giving general Pardon and Protection To all (Murderers excepted) Who Would return to their homes & Take the Military oath before the 20th of Aprill. It was Moved by Govr. Bee that Genl. Greens Letter Should be Published, past in the negative. Govr. Bee applied and got leave to take the letter out of Congress.(1)
A Long Letter Was read from a Mr. Baily, Phisition & Surgen in the Hospital department, by Genl. Varnum and the cause of the said Mr. Baily Was espoused by all the N.E. members. It was alledged by them that this man had been very III-Treated by the Medical Commte. particularly Mr. Clark. It was opposed by all the rest of the House and Mr. Houston alledged that he had done no duty Since 1779-but had been in Philada. postponed.(2)
Mr. Bland Moved that as the Minister of France had offer'd us 400,000 Dollars in Specie and Bills if we Could Supply provisions To that amount, we ought to Accept the offer-and at the Same Time Offered a Scheme for doing this. Committed to a Special Committee. Mr. Moyland appointed Clothier Genll.(3)
1 Not in the journals.
2 "Baily" has not been identified, and no information on this incident has been found in PCC or the journals.
3 That is, John Moylan. See JCC, 19:402.
The inclosed resolution of Congress answers your Excellency's letter of the 26th ulto., relating to the appointment of Col. Davies to the War Office of Virginia.(1) You will observe that it determines his rank in the Army alone, to be the bar to his acceptance of a civil office. Should Col. Davies be willing to give up that, and his place be supplied by one of the supernumerary Colonels, So that no additional expence would accrue to the United States, Congress we beleive would not hesitate to let him retire, without forfeiting any of the emoluments to which he is at present entitled. General McDougal was lately appointed by Congress to a civil Office under the like circumstances with Col. Davies, and as he did not chuse to part with his rank in the Army, the appointment was annulled.
We have been favored with your Excellency's two letters of the 6th & 7th instant.(2) The steps already taken by us & of which you will have been informed, will, we flatter ourselves accomplish your wishes with regard to the Refugees taken on board the Romulus.(3)
Your Excellency will also have seen, by our late letters, that we have not been unmindful of the distressed state of Virga., for want of the stores lately brought hither by the French Frigate. We wish however, that our efforts to foward them had been more successful. Our first plan for the purpose, was the one suggested by your letter. The probable emptiness of your Treasury, and the impossibility of our making our requisite advance to the Waggoners here, led us to substitute the other plan of placing the Stores in the Quarter Masters Channel, and procuring from Congress a warrant for the money necessary for the purpose. He at the same time engaged the attention of Colo. Febiger to the business, who has been very alert in expediting the supplies for the Southern Service. Notwithstanding these precautions we have the mortification to find, that the stores are not yet on their way. Since the receipt of your letter, we have determined to recur to our first plan.
The Q. Master & Colo. Febiger assure us that every exertion shall be used to execute it. They say however, it will be several days, before the waggons can possibly be on the road. According to an estimate of the Q. Master, we shall be obliged to draw on your Excellency for near £500 specie or, as much paper as will be equal to it, at the current exchange, to be paid on the arrival of the waggons.(4) The only paper they will receive is the old Continental bills. The Exchange here is 150 for 1; and the depreciation progressive. Your Excellency's other requests relating to the debts left by Col. Finnie in his department, and the accommodation of Mr. Ross with funds in this place, shall have all the attention we can give them.(5)
The Extract of a letter from Genl. Washington, herewith enclosed,(6) contains all the Authentic information received since our last, on the subject of another embarkation from N. York. For some days of late the report has died away into a general disbelief. Some persons just come out of N. York have revived it, with this variation, that it has a Southern object.
We are extremely concerned to inform your Excellency, that the detachment of the Pennsylvania Line, on which our expectations have been so long fixed, are still detained by the want of money. Every expedient within our invention has been tried, without avail, to remove the obstacles to their march; and we have no encouragement that the resources of the State will put them in motion, in less than 8 or 10 days, at the nearest. The detachment under the Marquis de la Fayette, is, we understand, again moving Southward. but we have great reason to apprehend, that the general cause of our embarrassment will at least retard their progress. The Extract above referred to, will give an idea, how far the Commander in Chief is likely to be in a condition to spare other detachments from the Troops immediately under him. By a return lately transmitted to Congress, it appears that he had not rec'd five hundred effective recruits from all the States whose levies were assigned to the Northern Department.
It is pretty certain we believe that the British fleet under Arbuthnot is arrived at N. York from Chesapeak. That of our Ally has certainly returned into N. Port.
On receipt of yr: Excellency's letter of the 8th ult.(7) respecting a plan to be concerted with the States of Maryland & Delaware, for the transportation of supplies to the Southward, we communicated the matter to the Delegates from those States, but they have never been furnished with any power or instructions relative to it.
The Acts of this State, taking off the embargo, are under the same cover with this.(8)
We have the honor to be, with sentiments of the highest respect,
Yr: Excellency's obt and hble Servants
[James Madison Junr.]
[Theok: Bland]
[M. Smith]
1 Jefferson had, in fact, written two letters on March 26 to Congress and to the delegates concerning the anticipated appointment of Col. William Davies as commissioner of the Virginia State Board of War. See PCC, item 71, 2:75-76; Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:246-47, 251; and Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:31-32. The governor explained to Congress that Davies would decline the office "unless his rank in the army, half pay for life, land & allowance for depreciation of pay can be reserved to him." To the delegates he pointed out two "instances of similar Indulgence." George Clinton held a Continental commission as brigadier general while serving as
2 For Jefferson's letter of April 6, see ibid., pp. 58-59. His letter of the 7th has not been found.
3 See Madison to Jefferson, April 3, 1781.
4 For the delegates' recent attempts to forward Le Comite's cargo, see Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, March 27, note 3, and April 3, 1781, note 3.
5 For the governor's "other requests" concerning deputy quartermaster William Finnie and Virginia commercial agent David Ross, see Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:59n.6, 60n.8.
6 Not found, but "the Extract" was undoubtedly taken from Washington's April 12 letter to Congress which had been read on the 16th. See JCC, 19:396; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:448-49.
7 See Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:8-9.
8 Jefferson had requested copies of this February Pennsylvania legislation in his March 26 letter to the delegates. Ibid., pp. 32-33.
Your Excellency will be informed by the Act of Congress enclosed that it is incompatible with the Rules established by the United States in Congress assembled for Colonel Davies to exercise a civil Appointment while he retains his Rank in the Army.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with very great Respect, Your Excellency's most obedient, humble servant,
Sam. Huntington Presidt.
P.S. I have been honored with your several Despatches of the 26, 28, & 31, of March, & 7th Instant.(3)
1 This day Huntington also sent the following letter to Pres. Joseph Reed of Pennsylvania, enclosing letters from Washington to Congress of April 12 and 14 concerning the army's distress for want of provisions, for which See JCC, 19:398; Pa. Archives, 9:71-72, 75-76. "I am directed by Congress to Transmit your Excellency the enclosed Copy of a letter from the Commander in Chief." Pequot Library Deposit, CtY.
2 See the preceding entry, note 1.
3 These letters are in PCC, item 71, 2:75-90, 97-100; and Jefferson, Papers (Boyd) 5:24647, 269-70, 302-3, 370.
A report of Committee brought in Stating all our debts, and the expences or estimates of the Current year-Ordered to be Coppied & Sent to the States.(1)
Mr. Maddison Moved that Genl. Washington Send effectual force to the Southward-And that he be impowerd to draw out as Many Malitia from the ea[s]tward of the North river as May be Necessary to the Eastward &c.(2) Mr. Smith of Virginia Said that Virginia had done her part in the War that they had afforded great Succour lately to the Southern States at her own expence that She Was So Much exhosted that now She Was invaded She Wanted assistance-that there Were Many disaffected in that State & When opertunity offered Would Assist the Enemy-That for Two or three years past it had been an opinion that prevailed that if that State was invaded it was to be given up by the other States That if they Were neglected & Were forced to give up to the enemy this consideration Would Make them very inveterate against those States and Willingly help To Conquer them &c.
Mr. S. Adams Said that he Was Willing all the Army Should go to the Southward & the Malitia only be left to defend the Eastern States provided they had notice, & it was not Contrary to the plans of the Genl. &c.
Committed to three.(3)
Unfortunately my Engagement in private business; as well as in Congress prevented my Continuing this account during the year 1781. It being an Important year.
I was long on the Committee of finance and always on the Committee of the States. Prevailed on having the New business of Congress assigned to Ministers & Officers.
Was at the appointment of Commissioners for Making piece & Controled that appointmt. so far as to git five in Stead of three and so to Include Doctr. Franklin & Mr. Laurance (with A., J (4) & Jefferson).(5)
But I did not mind any Small business, only applied My attention to What was of Great Consiquence as I observed great deficiency in the knowledge of governmt among the Members-tho Many of them possessed great abilities.
1 For the transmission of this report to the states, see Samuel Huntington to the States, April 21, 1781.
2 The journals simply report that James Madison made a motion that was referred to a three-man committee. JCC, 19:420.
3 This concludes Rodney's diary for 1781. The remainder of this entry was obviously written after 1781, perhaps when he resumed his diary upon returning to Congress in May 1786. For another addendum of this sort, see Rodney to Caesar Rodney, July 10, 1781, note 3.
4 That is, John Adams and John Jay.
5 For Rodney's self-proclaimed influence on the selection of peace comrnissioners, see Rodney to Caesar Rodney, June 14, 1781.
I have the Pleasure to transmit you the enclosed Resolve(1) of Congress of the 14th Instant, whereby you will be informed, that they having taken into Consideration the Report of the Board of Admiralty respecting your Conduct as Captain in the Navy, have been pleased to direct that the Thanks of the Untied States in Congress assembled be presented to you, and to the Officers & Men who have faithfully served under you from Time to Time, for the Zeal, Prudence & Intrepidity with which you have supported the Honor of the American Flag; for your bold & successful Enterprizes, and in general for the good Conduct & eminent Services which have added Lustre to your Character and to the american Arms.
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S. H.
1 See JCC, 19:390-91. For the origins of this resolution, see also Jesse Root to Jonathan Trumbull, February 20, 1781, note 1.
Your Excellency will receive herewith enclosed, an Ordinance(1) for establishing Courts for the Trial of Piracies and Felonies committed upon the high Seas, passed in Conformity to Articles of Confederation.
I have the Honor to be &c, &c, S.H.
1 For the adoption of this April 5 ordinance, which declared Congress' "sole and exclusive right and power (inter alia) of appointing courts for the trial of piracies..." and empowering "the justices of the supreme or superior courts of judicature, and judge of the Court of Admiralty of the several and respective states, or any two or more of them" to hear and try offenders charged with such offences, See JCC, 19:234, 274, 354-56; and PCC, item 31, fols. 281-84, item 175, fols. 54.
I am directed (1) to acquaint your Excellency that the State of Maryland is unrepresented in Congress having but one Delegate present for some Time past, and it is earnestly requested that a Representation may be kept in Congress at present. Matters very important & interesting require a full Representation from all the States. It is to be hoped and expected that one or more Delegates from Maryland may immediately come forward if not already on the Way.
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c, S.H.
1 No such directive was recorded in the journals, but for the same issue see also Huntington to Thomas Rodney, April 9, 1781.
I am directed to transmit your Excellency the enclosed Report of a Committee & resolve of Congress thereon of the l9th Instant.(1) The Subject Matter to which it relates is so fully stated & discussed in the Report, it is needless for me to add any further Observations to urge a Compliance with the Sentiments of Congress therein expressed.
Enclosed you will also receive the Copies of Acts of New York & Pennsylvania authorizing Congress to levy a Duty agreeable to their requisition.(2)
I have the Honor to be with the highest, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington, President
1 In reply to Congress' request for authority to levy a 5 percent impost, the Massachusetts Senate had complained that the state was "already called upon in undue Proportion to their Abilities" and that the proposed duty would be "an unequal Burthen, operating very heavily on some States & with little Weight on others." The complaint was referred to a committee consisting of Samuel Adams, James Duane, and Oliver Wolcott on March 26, and the enclosed resolve merely adopted the committee's lengthy report, which was drafted by Duane. It was endorsed by Secretary Thomson "April 19. 1781. Read twice and agreed. Ordered that copy thereof be transmitted to the general Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts in answer to their letter of the 10th March last," but entered only on the secret domestic journal to keep the sensitive subject from public view with the annual publication of the journals. See JCC, 19:311, 421-27; PCC, item 1, vol. 31, item 20, 1:65-73, item 65, 1:521-24.
2 New York's act authorizing Congress to levy an impost was received April 5, the same day the Pennsylvania Assembly adopted a similar law. See Huntington to Jonathan Trumbull, April 16, 1781, note 2.
I am directed to transmit your Excellency the enclosed Copies of Letters, viz, one from his Excellency President Reed to me, the other from Mr Fowler to President Reed, with the consequent Resolve of Congress of the l9th Instant, directing that effectual Measures be taken to make Enquiry into & correct the Abuses therein mentioned and for bringing the Offenders to condign Punishment.(1)
This Mr Fowler is an Auditor appointed by Congress to settle public Accounts in that Quarter.
It may not be amiss to mention to your Excellency, that it hath been suggested by Gentlemen of Character, that Colonel Broadhead for some Reasons is disposed to obstruct, rather than to aid Colonel Clarke in his present Expedition to the westward, & prevent his Proceeding. How far the latter Suggestion, or those Facts mentioned in Mr Fowlers Letter are well founded I cannot pretend to say. A proper Enquiry is necessary to ascertain those Matters; and I am firmly perswaded your Excellency's Prudence will direct to such Measures as that the Public may not suffer by flagrant Abuses, and at the same Time no faithful Officers may be injured by ill founded Misrepresentations if any such there be.
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Respect, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble servant,
Sam. Huntington President
P.S. I have been Honourd with your Excellency Letters of the 12th & 14th instant.(2)
1 Washington had recently sent an appeal to Congress for provisions for the garrison at Fort Pitt, which Congress had referred to Pennsylvania president Joseph Reed on April 18. Responding the same day, Reed pointed out that "proper measures were taken last fall" to ensure that sufficient meat and flour would be available at the fort, hinting that improprieties related to Col. Daniel Brodhead's command there rather than poor planning or other deficiencies were at the root of the crisis. To substantiate the complaint, Reed cited the findings of Alexander Fowler, an auditor for the western district, who charged in a long March 29 letter to Reed that discipline had been "totally neglected" at the fort, and that under Brodhead's command "private interest shamefully predominates over public ceconomy." See JCC, 19:420-21; PCC, item 69, 2:341-44, 365-76; and Huntington to Thomas Jefferson, April 18, 1781, note 1.
For Washington's May I response to this letter and the steps taken the following month to investigate Fowler's charges which resulted in Brodhead's removal in September, see Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:20 21; and Huntington to Washington, June 2, 1781.
2 These letters are in PCC, item 152, 10:73-76, item 169, 8:94-95; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:448-49, 457-58.
The distresses of the Army for want of pay give pain to every patriot but in a more eminent degree to those who by being placed at the head of Government are considered in some measure, as responsible. If their office shielded them from common Calamities, or afforded Support to their Families. If they had of themselves the means of filling the publick Treasury or If the States had complied with their Requisitions the Charge of Severity towards the reformed officers in not paying their Arrears to the time of their reduction woud have given me less pain. As an Individual I can compare my Sufferings, the dangers of the Field excepted, with any Gentleman of the Army. As a publick man I have had my full Share of Anxiety and Care. Conscious of my own Integrity & of my respect and affection for those brave men who have fought the battles of my Country, I feel that I deserve no Reproach. Believe me,.Sir, that to oblige and serve yourself in particular woud have given me pleasure. Nor as far as my little abilities extended have you wanted a faithful Friend whenever your Interest coud be promoted. The Reduction was a general Measure in which you in common with many other worthy & gallant officers participated.(1) I never heard it objected to. The Rule of Seniority was preferred from the difficulty of Selecting as Congress first recommended. It was preferred on military Ideas & Advice. The officers reduced were not paid: the whole Army were unpaid. The Reason is that there was no money in the Common Treasury. And the States tho' earnestly called upon to advance their Quotas of the Arrears have not complied. What coud Congress have done more? What more can they now do?
With respect to the two additional Regiments to be raised in our State I sincerely believe it did not originate from any Scheme to injure you or to prefer favorites. I have understood that an offer was made the State to raise those Regiments on Land Bounties and that it was expected that the men woud be recruited in New England. To this moment I never heard but from yourself who were appointed Officers. Congress in approving this plan paid Attention to the reduced officers it being their wish that they shoud be preferred as far as this Service permitted. Your own Government I am perswaded highly esteem you, and cannot wish to do you Injustice or to
Jas. Duane
P.S. I have been here a whole year with the Intermission of a short visit to Mrs Duane in her Indisposition. I return home in a few days. I have communicated your Letter to General McDougall who promises me to write to you. Excuse haste!
1 For the "reduction" of Col. Marinus Willett's regiment, see New York Delegates to Willett, May 30, 1780. For their continued concern over the restoration of Willett's Continental rank, see New York Delegates to George Clinton, March 12 and 29, 1782.
The United States in Congress assembled, deeming it proper & necessary to communicate to their Constituents in the several States, as fully as can be done, a proper Representation of their national Affairs, the Amount of the public Debts due from the United States, together with the Estimates for the current Year; having examined & agreed to the Report of their Committee on that Subject of the 18th Instant, I do myself the Honor to transmit your Excellency a Copy thereof.(1) And am with the highest Respect, Your most obedient, humble Servant, S.H.
1 For the enclosed 24-page report on the public debt, the product of a committee appointed on February 7 consisting of James Duane, William Sharpe, and Oliver Wolcott, and submitted and adopted on April 18, See JCC, 19:125, 402-20.
I can only say thus on the Report, which is transmitted to Lovell, Sharpe & Clymar and herewith delivered to you.(1)
Mr. Parsons had a Right to think from Mr. Bingham's Powers and the Influence which the Advice of the Marqs. de Bouillee had always with Mr. Bingham, that He who succeeded Mr. Bingham in a Manner in Commission ought also to be influenced by that same
Yr. most humble Servt, James Lovell
1 The enclosed April 21 report of the Board of Admiralty (JCC, 19:429-30) concerned the claims of Samuel Parsons for services rendered to the United States after he had been designated by William Bingham in March 1780 to act in his place as Continental agent in Martinique. In a February 15, 1781, letter to Congress, Parsons explained that in the fulfillment of duties as agent he had expended his own money for the schooner, Fame, purchased to carry news of the British capture of St. Eustatius to Philadelphia, and for supplies and medical treatment for American sailors in distress, but his claim was complicated by the fact that Congress had never actually named a successor to Bingham, despite Parsons' requests dating from April 7, 1780, for such an appointment.
Responding to his February 15 letter and accompanying accounts, the Board of Admiralty submitted a report critical of Parsons, which Congress promptly referred to Lovell, George Clymer, and William Sharpe. Lovell in turn wrote this note seeking the assistance of the superintendent of finance, but no evidence has been found to indicate precisely when it was written, and Morris did not actually accept the post of superintendent until May 14.
Despite Parsons' repeated appeals, no additional action was taken in the case for more than a year, when on June 21, 1782, Morris recommended that he be authorized to settle Parsons' claims, although simultaneously advising against the formal appointment of any American agent or consuls in the West Indies. Congress thereupon endorsed Morris' recommendations on July 2, but the actual payment of Parsons' accounts remained unsettled until 1785. Parsons renewed his request for reimbursement in January 1785 after returning to the United States, but added a claim for back pay as Continental agent. Congress brusquely denied the additional claim, noting that he had not received such an appointment, while directing the Board of Treasury to settle the balance due on the original accounts submitted in 1781.
For this protracted affair, See JCC, 19:429-30, 21:968-69, 22:366-68, 28:11n, 114, 129, 221-22, 250-51; PCC, item 78, 18:407-18, 535-37, item 90, 1:232-37, 323-24, 335-44, 372-79, item 137, 1:567-635; and Morris, Papers (Ferguson), 1:353n.5, 5:457-58.
I have received your Excellency's Letter, notifying me that no Delegate will come from the State 'till after the Election.
General Cornell, who is absent by Leave of Congress, for visiting the military Magazines, Laboratories &c, and causing some necessary Reforms,(1) will be able to give every necessary Information respecting our Situation. As my Time for representing the State will soon expire, I apprehend my Return home will be consequent thereupon.(2) Previous to which, A Supply of Money will be essential. Should the Necessity of this Request be doubted, it need only be
I have the Honor of being with great Respect, your Excellency's most obdt. Servt. J M Varnum
1 Congress had this day directed Ezekiel Cornell, a member of the Board of War and former Rhode Island delegate, to "visit the military stores and elaboratory to the eastward" and to help forward military supplies to the "main army, or to the southward." See JCC, 19:434.
2 Varnum had been elected on May 1, 1780, to represent Rhode Island in Congress "for One Year," but he was re-elected on May 2 and continued to serve until November 19, 1781, when Ezekiel Cornell and William Ellery returned to Congress. See JCC, 20:768, 21:1101, 1123.
3 It is not clear precisely which letter Varnum is referring to, but see Varnum to Greene, January 8, 1781.
I did not receive your favor of the 3d Instt till yesterday; a week later than Letters of the same Date from some others of my Boston friends were brought to me by the Post. As the Subject is delicate, I do not chuse to continue it in this Letter, which is to go thro' a Channel provd from repeated Experience to be uncertain & unsafe. It was for this Reason that I committed to the Care of a private friend, my Letter to Mrs A of the 1st of Feby which she communicated to you. I am glad she did it in a Manner so acceptable-Indeed I never found Reason to doubt her Discretion. What you have written is very obliging & satisfactory to me. I hope to have the Pleasure of seeing you next Month. We will then, after our usual Manner, disclose each others Hearts.(1)
Your Letter of the 31st Decr was not long ago deliverd to me by the Count Charlus.(2) He appears to be an amiable & fine-spirited young Nobleman. After a short stay here, he proceded with the Marqs de la Fayette to the Southward.
You will recollect a Design which I mentiond to you respecting our Friend Mr L ,(3) & the Omission which, we were informd the Evening before I left Boston, had happened thro' Mistake. I early wrote to you & requested your Influence to have it rectified. I have heard Nothing of it since. In my opinion the most essential Interest of the Town of Boston will be servd by it, & therefore I cannot look
You & I, among others, have had the Honor of being abusd by Rivingtons Press; A labord Performance has lately crept out, called the Times. I have had a cursory reading of it. It appears to me so much like the Productions of certain Geniuses who figurd in Mr Popes Time, that had the Author been cotemporary with them, a Page might have been added to the Dunciad,(4) to immortalize his Works. I will endeavor to get some Parts of it transcribd & carry them to Boston. I am sure the reading it would serve to divert rather than give you the least Pain. My due Regards to Friends, your affectionate, SA
1 For a discussion of the breach in correspondence between Adams and Cooper, see Adams to Elizabeth Adams, February 1, 1781, note 3.
2 That is, Armand-Charles-Augustin de la Croix de Castries, comte de Charlus.
3 Not identified; but perhaps John Lowell, a political ally of Cooper and a member with Adams of the committee that drafted the 1780 Massachusetts state constitution. Charles W. Akers, The Divine Politician. Samuel Cooper and the American Revolution in Boston (Boston: Northeastern University Press, 1982), p. 307.
4 That is, Alexander Pope's Dunciad, a famous lampoon on sundry English writers.
I have been honored with your Excellency's Letters of the 16th & 18th Instant.(2) You will observe by the enclosed Resolve of this Day, that it is the Sense of Congress, on receiving the Information contained in your Letter of the 16th, of the Proposals you have made respecting the Exchange of General Burgoine, that you be authorized to proceed in perfecting the Exchange, if you shall think fit, the Resolution of the third Instant notwithstanding.(3)
I have the Honor to be, with very great Respect & Esteem, Sir, Your most obedient & most humble servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 This letter is properly dated in Huntington's letterbook; PCC, item 15, fol. 276.
2 These letters are in PCC, item 152, 10:77-84; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:474-77.
3 JCC, 19:436. In his April 16 letter to Huntington, Washington had explained that he had already proposed the exchange of General Burgoyne to Sir Henry Clinton before receiving Congress' April 3 resolve directing him to "recall" Burgoyne from his parole, for which see Huntington to Washington, April 5, 1781. See also Huntington to Washington, June 20, 1781.
Not receiving any Line from you by this day's post, I recur to your favor of April 3d already answered in part.(2) I wrote to Col. Hughes (3) to endeavor to forward the two Packages left by Doctr. Winship, if he could find where they were deposited. I hope he will have found them and had them cased in Boards.
Capt. J. P. Jones is without Letter or Invoice and supposes they must have been sent by the Alliance. A Vessel is in the River from France in 11 Weeks Passage, perhaps I shall get some Light by her. I assure you I have had some considerable fears of losing on the Road what I have to forward. The Tories rise in Insolence of Pillaging. But we have Today Reports of such large Embarkations from New York as will make that City very weak. It is even said that the Refugees are ordered to prepare for Halifax or Georgia.
Be persuaded, amiable Friend, that I will act for you as for myself.
Apr. 14 [i.e. 24]. Capt. All has been 9 Weeks from France. He put his Letters ashore at the Cape; perhaps they will be here before the Post goes.
P M. The Letters are come. None from Fiance, (4) but a short one of Decr. from J Williams about his hopes and Intentions of forwarding what had been granted 14 months before to cover our naked Soldiers. We have at last a very long Letter from Mr. Jay. But, your Curiosity, charming Patriot, must await the Return of Mr. (S.A.) which may procede next Post.
Very sincerely and self-pleasingly yr. Servant. J L
1 Although Lovell clearly dated this letter "Apr. 13," he later explained in his June 16 letter to Abigail that "My letter dated April 13 was written the 23."
2 See Lovell to Abigail Adams, April 17, 1781 (not in printed text).
3 Not found.
4 The "Letters" received this day included two from John Jay at Madrid dated November 6 and 30, 1780, which were read in Congress on April 24 and 25.JCC, 20:437.
This day, by Post, I recd. your Favors of the 7th & 9th. Your tender apprehensions respecting my Health, your instructive Hints as to the Removal of ill-grounded prejudices, and your generous Direction to convert a Part of your Invoice to my own use form a Chain of pleasing Stricture upon my Gratitude. The Blessing of Health will be enhanced by my having Opportunities of employing a Portion of it in rendering you any Services here. The Preservation of an honest independent Spirit will be so much more my Care as it is what tends to prolong your Friendship for me on the Principle of Simularity.
I shall forward your blue Cloth with the other Articles whenever a good Conveyance presents itself. You will find, by the Copy which I inclose of Col. P's (1) Invoice as you desired, that nearly the same Balance of both Bills of Exchange has been kept back from you. The Weather is so bad that I shall not have the Information of Mr. Ross respecting the Deficiency before this letter goes, but I will obtain and send it speedily. I have had a single Line from Col. P since Nov. 18 and you do not mention him in that Letter where you mention having been to New Hampshire.
I have had the mortification to find that Winship left his Baggage at Fish Kills. I fear ill Consequences to Mrs Adams & you. I write to Col. Hughes (2) to find where the two Bundles were which I had sent and to case them in Board, as Friction or Rain would ruin the Lady's Property. I find it very hard to forward even a small Parcell by Horse so long a Way in these Times when even Sulky Boxes are so loaded with "Limber-Chink," as the Tories call Paper Money, that I have had a letter returned for being more than could be stowed.
I send Doctr. Holten a news Paper with the Pensylvania act in it for a New Emission of money.(3) The old Continental is limited to June 1st and indeed all monies not by Law equivalent to Gold & Silver. They mean to purchase 4/10 of the 18th of March money of other States so as to avoid emitting of their own. If Congress cannot limit State Emissions it is in vain to attempt any Thing continental with a paper medium. The Congress must deal only in Gold and Silver. If the precious Metals are not our only medium or Funds are not absolutely provided for one general Paper I see ten thousand Embarrassments to every public Movement in the War. Can the People expect to be served by Officers, who engage for 50 Dollars Specie per month and are to be paid in Paper under the Idea of Equivalent, unless current Exchange is intended? But, if that Exchange rises every day during the Delay of supplying the public Treasury by Taxes long called for, how can Government furnish any Estimate? and will the People be satisfied wth. eternal Calls in Taxation
Randall had arrived in Boston 9 days before yr. last Letter, but he was to deliver what he had in Charge from me to Mr. Otis. Please to present my Regards to Mr. Otis and tell him that Col. Hay, being here, acknowledges the Receipt of his Letter, imagined to be lost, after being committed to my Care.
1 That is, Nathaniel Peabody. See Lovell to Nathaniel Peabody, July 25, 1781.
2 Not found; but for the packages Lovell was attempting to have delivered to Gerry and Abigail Adams, see Lovell to Samuel Holten, April 17, 1781, note.
3 The following brief note to Samuel Holten from Lovell dated "Apr. 24, 1781," is in the Essex Institute Historical Collections 13 (July 1876): 228 29.
"I am to thank you for your Favor of the 12th and can only make Return at this Time by inclosing Gazettes which I hope you will show to Mr. Gerry before you send them to the Navy Board as usual to be forwarded. He will in return let you know how little we know from Europe. Some very particular Engagements public & private prevent my enlarging further than to add affectionate and respectful assurances of being, Yours J.L."
The Board of War having spared to the Special Council for the Eastern Shore, & to the Virginia Delegates a number of the Rampart peices, I coud not obtain an order for more than 500-They have likewise given me an order for 2 four pound Brass Field peices complete. (1) If 41b Ball shoud be wanting, it will be proper to mention the number you woud have. It not being safe to Send the arms by water I presume you will order waggons up, or some to be procured here.
The following is an extract of a Letter from Genl. Washington-"Head quarters, New Windsor Apl. 16th. 81, I have receivd advices through different Chann[e]ls corresponding with that transmitted Congress by Mr. Foreman. They strongly assert that a further detachment is going from New York, & that it is to be commanded
The Letter from St. Piere dated the 18th of March in the enclosd paper is from Mr Parsons Agent for Congress, to the Board of Admiralty (2)-The intelligence from the Havanna is thro' Don Fran-cisco.(3)
Some exchangd officers are arrivd here in a flag from Charles Town, they left it 13 days past-& inform us that Genl Sumpter had taken the Enemies post at 96, & made about 300 prisoners.
I have the honor to be, with great esteem, Yr. Excellencys Most Ob Sert. Danl. Carroll
[P.S.] We have reason to believe the Confederacy is taken by two British frigates.(4)
1 For the Maryland Council's order for 750 rampart pieces and four brass field pieces, see Maryland Delegates to Lee, April 10, note 1.
2 Samuel Parsons' March 18 letter from Martinique concerning the impending arrival of a French fleet of 400 sail including "thirty Sail of the Line" is in Miscellaneous Papers of the Continental Congress, reel 3, fols. 509-11, DNA, where it is endorsed "recd Apr. 22d." Extracts from the letter as well as various "intelligence from the Havanna" appeared in the April 25 issues of both the Pennsylvania Gazette and the Pennsylvania Journal.
3 That is, Francisco Rendon.
4 The Confederacy, with a large cargo of military supplies, had indeed been captured on April 15 by the British frigates Roebuck and Orpheus. Gardner W. Allen, A Naval History of the American Revolution, 2 vols. (1913; reprint ed., New York: Russell & Russell, 1962), 2:556.
This day Carroll sent a nearly identical letter to Matthew Tilghman, president of the Special Council for the Eastern Shore, by the care of "Messrs. Goldsborough and Emory." Ridgely Transcripts, MdAA.
Nothing new worthy your attention has been the cause of my silence, and all that I have now to communicate are merely reports. I will however take the liberty of giving them to you, such as they are. By a letter from our Agent at Martinico (1) we are informed that a fleet of our Ally, consisting of 14 sail of the line, had fallen in with 131 sail of transports from Cork, with their convoy, & that they had captured the greatest part of them. By a vessel from the Cape, we are informed, that a lugger had arrived there, announcing the French fleet of 23 ships of the line being off that coast, & that they had under convoy 400 transports, a part of this fleet with 7000 men
I should be obliged to you Sir, to forward the inclosed for Miss Livingston.(2) I have the honor to be, with the highest respect yr. Excys most Obedt. servt. Jon Mathews
[P.S.] When you have read the inclosed paper, please to forward it to Miss Livingston.
1 For Samuel Parsons' letter of March 18 containing quite different information, see the preceding entry, note 2.
2 Undoubtedly his April 18 letter to Susan Livingston, for which see Mathews to Catharine Livingston, September 12, 1780, note.
I recd. yours of the 6th inst. yesterday, informing me of the melancholly news of the death of our Friend Major Harleston.(2) I am greatly distressed on account of his wife-her situation is truly pitiable. I feel much for her-'tis a severe stroke, to her, poor Girl! I make no doubt you'll give her all the comfort in your power & hope will remain with her as long as you can. I have advised her to return to South Carolina as soon as an opportunity offers. I think she will be best with her Mother & Relations & will be a great means of recovering & saving her Estate. I cannot but think the Enemy will give her possession of it. I am sorry her Husband did not appoint some other Person as Executor, as well as myself, 'tis impossible, situated as I am at present, that I can be of any Service to her. I shall return the will to her by the first safe opportunity and I shod. be glad you wou'd assist in having it proved-it will be best to have it done in Virginia and I have desired her to send me an authentic Copy of it. Cou'd you not contrive to get a Passage in one of the Flaggs, intended to be sent with Necessary's to the Virginia Troops in Carolina? It will be the best way & I suppose you cou'd easily dispose of her Horses and anything else she wou'd not chuse to carry with her.
The Flagg is at last arrived-she came up last Sunday afternoon-Mrs. Gillon, her son Willm., Mr. May, Capt. Gadsden, Major DeBrahm, Majr. Melvin & his Lady, the familys of Stone & Smith, our two Pilots, and some Virginia Officers come out on Parol. The enclosed Letters will give more particulars, perhaps, than I can write
We have accounts from Genl. Washington, that another Embarkation is preparing at New York & 'tis believed Sr. Henry Clinton will take the command of it & proceed to Virginia. I have no doubt, but that the War will be removed into the Southern States.
We have a report in Town, that the French Fleet is arrived in the West Indies, consisting of 28 Sail of the Line and a large number of Troops-more of this in my next.
Colo. Eveleigh (3) & his Wife, with Miss Skipwith has been here ten days-I lodge with them at Mrs. M.Kenzie's-the Apartments that Mr. Walker of Virginia had when you was here.
Adieu! my Dear Sir, and believe me to be, Yors. very affectionately, Isaac Motte.
1 John Sandford Dart (1741?-98), a Charleston merchant, was auditor of accounts for the southern army and Motte's brother-in-law. See Samuel Huntington to William V, January 1, 1781, note 2; and Bio. Dir. of S.C. House of Rep., 3:171.
2 John Harleston, Jr., for whom see ibid., p. 317.
3 That is, South Carolina delegate Nicholas Eveleigh who took his seat in Congress on April 25. JCC, 20:437.
We were yesterday Honord with your Excellency's of the 13th Inst. with its enclosures.(1) You may be assured that our utmost endeavors have been exerted in forwarding the arms and stores mentiond in our last, but insurmountable difficulties have prevented their seting off until now, but we are happy to inform you that the first of them will go on to day as the Qr. Mastr. assures us.(2) We have anticipated the circumstance mentiond in the Extract of Genl. Greenes letter to the Baron,(3) by urging the board of War with every argument for the necessity of a Speedy Supply which they are taking measures to procure but I fear with little prospect of immediate effect, neither theirs nor our exertions will be slackend on that head but we cannot advise a reliance on the Success. Your desire concerning the Prisoners, has been communicated to the Minister of France who has expressed his fears that such a step could not be Justified on the Common principles adopted by European nations at War, but at the Same time thinks there will be no difficulty of
We have the honor to be with sentiments of the highest respect & esteem, Yr. Excelly's Most Ob & hum. Servts.
J. Madison Junr
Theok. Bland
P.S. We are happy to inform Yr. Excy. [that] a large detachment of the Pennsylva line are at length in motion towards Virginia & we hope will arrive in time to Check the Progress of the Enemy in that state. we have accts that the Confederacy is taken by the Roebuck & Orpheus off this Coast.
1 See ibid., p. 68.
2 For the delegates' arrangements with Quartermaster General Timothy Pickering to haul the goods from Le Comite to Virginia, see Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, April 17, note 4.
3 For Nathanael Greene's April 2 letter to baron Steuben concerning his immediate need for lead, see Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:418n.
4 For Jefferson's "desire concerning the Prisoners," see Virginia Delegates to La Luzerne, April 2; Madison to Jefferson, April 3, note 6; and Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, May 5, 1781, note 3.
5 See Samuel Huntington to Certain States, April 9, 1781.
6 For the siege and final capitulation on May 9 of the British fort at Pensacola to overwhelming forces under Louisiana captain general Bernardo de Galvez, see James Leitch Wright, Jr., Florida in the American Revolution (Gainesville: University Presses of Florida, 1976), pp. 88-91.
The Underwritten delegates (2) from the State of Virginia Sensible of the distress of that and the Southern states for want of arms, and anxious for the relief of their own state in particular as well as its neighbouring States, were desireous of persuing every measure for that purpose; They were exceedingly happy to be informed that you Gentn. were not only possessed of the necessary means, but of the patriotic disposition, to forward so desireable a work, and therefore not only listend with pleasure to your proposals for purchasing a Number of arms, that were laying in the Public Magazines and might with some small repairs be soon made Serviceable, and of forwarding them (after having them repaird) to the State of Virginia with Expedition, but took every step in their Power to facilitate your disinterested and Patriotic intentions. We then understood that your intentions were to lay out the money arising from a Qy. of Tobo. in your hands to purchase the Said arms of the Public and fit them up with all possible Expedition, Paying for them at a reasonable and moderate Price which the board of War shd. ascertain and engage that they shd. be deliverd to the Executive of Virginia, at a moderate profit to yourselves for the Purchase and trouble-we engaging to give you draughts on the State treasury Payable at Sight-at the real Value without your Suffering by any casual intervening depreciation. We are unhappy on account of our suffering Country, on a revisal and consideration of the terms presented in writing, to concieve it impossible that we can on behalf of the State engage on terms, which would be so evidently disadvantageous to the State without promising more expedition, or a more speedy relief, than may probably be had in the common mode, while from the terms you propose the Public will reap no additional advantage but be subject to the payment of the whole expences of fiting and transporting the Arms, of furnishing the money for the payment of the first Cost, and an addition of fifty Per Cent; which being guarded against depreciation is, we consider a profit too great for us to agree to,(3)
1 This undated and unsigned FC was undoubtedly written a few days before the delegates' April 27 letter to Thomas Jefferson in which they identified the "Centn." addressed here as "Virginia Merchants" who were in Philadelphia at this time. The delegates had apparently reached a verbal agreement with the unnamed merchants to supply arms for the state "at a reasonable and moderate Price." When the merchants submitted a written proposal shortly thereafter, however, they revised the conditions of sale and delivery in "terms...so evidently disadvantageous to the State" that the delegates were compelled to reject them.
2 Theodorick Bland, James Madison, and Meriwether Smith.
3 Remainder of sentence crossed out and unreadable.
You will receive herewith enclosed, two Resolves of Congress, of the 20th of March and 21st Instant. The former, you will observe, is in Answer to a Paragraph of your Letter therein recited, the Latter ascertains certain Powers with which the Superintendant of Finance is vested.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c S.H.(2)
1 For the enclosed resolves and Congress' negotiations with Morris over the stipulations he had made as conditions to his acceptance of the office of Superintendent of Finance, See JCC, 19:287-89; 431-33; and Morris, Papers (Ferguson), 1:20-25. See also Huntington to Morris, May 1, 1781.
2 This day Huntington also wrote a brief letter to Joseph Reed enclosing an extract of an April 16 letter from Washington explaining prospects for an enemy expedition against Delaware, for which see Pa. Archives, 1st ser. 9:102. Huntington's letter to Reed is in the Americana Collection, PPRF.
As the fate of Nations has sometimes depended, so that of States may now depend upon events appearing trifling. The irregular situation in which the Citizens of Georgia have been for some time past, has been cause of some uneasiness to us: for altho we know their merit in opposing the Enemy to be equal to any, and are confident that they have given tone to some of the most brilliant actions in that department upon the small scales yet for want of order and direction among themselves, the state for which they act has lost the credit of their exertions, and may lose more.
To remedy these evils, and to render their endeavors more useful in future, we have invested Doctor Brownson with a Brigadier
With perfect confidence & much esteem, we have the honor to subscribe ourselves your most obedient and very much obliged servants,
Geo Walton.
W Few
Richd Howly (2)
1 Dr. Nathan Brownson (1742-96), a former delegate to Congress, was just leaving Philadelphia to assume his position as deputy purveyor for hospitals for the southern army when he was commissioned by the delegates to unite the various Georgia militia units under a single command. General Greene, in the meantime, was attempting to end a year-long hiatus in Georgia civil government by forming a temporary council in Augusta. Following the withdrawal of the British from Ninety Six in July an assembly was elected that met in Augusta on August 17, electing Brownson speaker, then governor. See JCC, 19:316, PCC, item 78, 4:165; and Kenneth Coleman, The American Revolution in Georgia, 1763-1789 (Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1958), p. 161.
2 The Georgia delegates had also written to Greene on April 5, asking him to ensure that the "quantity of cloathing" they had sent on Continental wagons "for the Georgia militia...be delivered for their intended uses." A.S.W. Rosenbach, The History of America in Documents, 3 vols. (Philadelphia: The Rosenbach Co., 1949), 1:131, item 447.
For your Excellency's Information, I have herewith enclosed a State of the Debts due from the United States, with the necessary Estimates for the current Year as near as they can be ascertained at present; Copies whereof are transmitted to the several States. (1) Also a resolve of the 23d Instant, directing the Board of War to take effectual Measures for the Removal of all public Stores, Beef-Cattle, and also Provisions & Forage collected or stored on the Peninsula between the Delaware & Chesapeake Bays, and on the Jersey Shore adjacent to the Delaware; which may probably fall into the Hands of the Enemy in Case of an Invasion.(2)
You will also receive enclosed a Letter from General Gates addressed to Congress, which they have thought proper to refer to the Commander in Chief.(3)
I have the Honor to be, with the greatest Respect, Your Excellency's, most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 See Huntington to the States, April 21, 1781.
2 JCC, 19:436. See also Huntington to Certain States, April 9, 1781.
3 The enclosed April 24 letter from Horatio Gates contained the general's plea to be cleared of the "Vague Accusations" against him in circulation since October 1780 when Congress had ordered an inquiry into his conduct "as commander of the southern army," stemming from his command during the battle of Camden. See JCC, 18:906, 20:438. Gates' letter and a similar one from him to Washington of April 29 are in the Washington Papers, DLC.
For Gates' plight and the renewal of this request just three weeks later, see Huntington to Gates, October 16, 1780, and May 22, 1781.
The president has just receivd a Letter with information that a considerable Body of troops are on Board at New York, likewise Genl. Clintons baggage. They had been on board some days, & it is conjecturd by the writer of the Letter that they waited for a reinforcement from Europe. He adds that about 40 Vessels under the Convoy of a 50 Gun Ship & two frigates arrivd at Sandy Hook last Saturday. We have good reason to believe these Vessels saild from Charles Town with abt 160 Troops belonging to the Regts at New York.(1)
I have not time to add more than that I am Dear Sr, Yours Danl Carroll
1 See also Samuel Huntington to Matthew Tilghman, this date, note 2.
I do myself the Honor of transmitting to your Excellency the enclosed Copy of a Letter from Ebenezer Hazard.(1)
You will observe by the Journals of Congress under the 20th of July 1778, Encouragement given to this Gentleman to collect Materials for a History, and a Recommendation to the several States to aid & assist him in such Collection.
If any of the Manuscripts &c to which his Letter refers, will in your Excellency's Opinion be useful or worthy of Notice in the Pages of History, I am perswaded you will be so kind as to forward them agreeable to his Desire, whenever Leisure from more important Concerns shall permit. It may be proper to send them under Cover addressed to the Secretary of Congress, as Mr Hazard, being Surveyor of the Post for the eastern Department, is rather an itinerant than a Resident in any particular Place at present.
I have the Honor to be with the highest Respect, your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
1 For the enclosed April 7 Letter from Hazard to Huntington soliciting assistance in getting access to "various Manuscripts, Copies of Treaties, Commissions, Letters, and other Archives" relating to the Cherokee Indians which had recently been captured during Col. Arthur Campbell's expedition against them, see Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:562-63. For Hazard's project to publish a "Collection of American State Papers," see these Letters, 10: 680-81.
Your Favour of the 21st Instant I have had the Honor to communicate to the United States in Congress assembled. I am directed to inform you that it was by no Means their Intention in the Recommendation therein referred to, to hold up your Situation as desperate, much less to preclude the Idea of Resistance. The Intelligence they had received led them to apprehend that it was in Contemplation with the Enemy to take Post at New Castle, for the Purpose of a grand Forage on the Peninsula between Delaware & Chesapeake Bays.(1)
The Attention due to the general Interest required that immediate & effectual Precautions should be taken to disappoint such an Expedition of its Object; With this View it was recommended to remove from the Reach of the Enemy all Provisions & Forage which would not be necessary for the Consumption of the Inhabitants, a Precaution pointed out by the very Nature of the Case, which was the more eligible as it tended to prevent the Invasion as well as to render it abortive, and which had been adopted in similar Instances without Objection or Complaint.
The Intelligence since received by Congress of the Designs of the Enemy has been so far from rendering the first Plan inexpedient or unnecessary, that it has determined them to give it greater Promptitude & Efficacy by their Resolution of the 23d Instant, of which a Copy is enclosed. The Extent & Strictness of its Execution, as well as of the preceding Act, must no Doubt be governed by Circumstances and by the Discretion of the Executives & the Board of War.
Whatever Respect may be paid to these Recommendations, or whatever may be the Event, Congress will have done their duty.
Your Determination to exert yourselves to the utmost for your Defence, and your Confidence in the Bravery & Affection of your Citizens afford Congress the highest Satisfaction, and they perswade themselves that a Reconsideration of the Steps taken for removing
By order of Congress, Sam Huntington President (2)
1 ln his April 21 letter to Congress, written in his capacity as chairman of the "Special Council" for the Maryland eastern shore, Tilghman had protested Congress' call for the evacuation of provisions and forage from Maryland to forestall an enemy invasion rumored to be aimed at New Castle, Del., for which see Huntington to Certain States, April 9, 1781. That congressional recommendation, Tilghman complained, was an insult to the state, an act which seemed to preclude the very "Idea of Resistance." "Unhappy indeed is our Situation," he went on, "if nothing more is necessary to compleat our Captivity than for the Enemy to take post at New Castle."
Tilghman's contentious letter was read and referred on April 26 to a committee consisting of James Duane, James Madison, and John Sullivan. The present letter was submitted to Congress, adopted, and referred to the Board of War the following day. See JCC, 20:446, 455; and PCC, item 78, 22:463-66. See also Daniel Carroll to Tilghman, April 28, 1781. For the sensitivity of this "Special Council" to its prerogatives, which also became a matter of controversy between this body and the regular Council of Maryland at this same time, see Md. Archives, 45:406-8
2 Huntington also sent Tilghman the following undated note, perhaps a day or two later, conveying a fresh warning of an anticipated invasion. "By a confidential person we are informed that it may be depended on as a certainty that a very considerable embarkation has taken place in New York and has been ready for sailing for some days with which gen Sr H Clinton is going. NB. the foregoing Intelligence was receivd the 27th of April, since which no farther accounts have been receivd, by Sam. Huntington." Red Books, 8:30, MdAA.
Memorandum of an Agreement entered into this 27th of April 1781 Between the Honble The Delegates of the State of Virginia on the one Part, and Ebenezer Cowell of the City of Philadelphia on the other. (1)
The said Cowell doth hereby undertake to Cut and put in good Repair two Thousand Rampart Muskets, the Property of the Said State,(2) in the same Manner, and of the same length as those now Shewn in the War Office, at the rate of Seven Shillings and Six Pence Hard Money, or the value thereof in Paper Money at the Time of Payment.
And the said Cowell doth hereby engage to finish Twelve Hundred of the said Muskets in Fourteen Days from this Time, and deliver the same to the orders of the said Delegates to be transported to the said State of Virginia-and the Residue before the day of Payment.
And the said Delegates do hereby engage to Pay the said Cowell or order the said Sum of Seven Shillings and Six Pence Hard Money or
Theok. Bland
M. Smith
Ebenezer Cowell
Oct. 10th. 1781. It appears to Me by a Certificate given by Mr. George Nicolson (3) unto the above Mr Ebenezer Cowell that this Contract has been on his part duly, and fully complied with, as will appear by the said Certificate in My possession.
Thomas Pleasants Jr C. A for the state of Virga. in Philadelphia
1 For Cowell's credentials as a gunsmith, see ibid., p. 87n.1.
2 The preceding day Congress had ordered two thousand rampart muskets in possession of the Board of War to be repaired and transported "with all possible despatch" to Virginia and North Carolina, "charging to the said states respectively the value of the muskets, with the expence of repairing and transporting them." See JCC, 20:450.
3 Nicolson and Thomas Pleasants, who prepared this October 10 testimonial, were Philadelphia assistants of Virginia commercial agent David Ross. Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:87nn.5, 6.
Having discovrd that there were a considerable number of Rampart Arms belonging to the U.S. at this place, which have long lain dormant, (having been supposed useless for the Field,) we have found on enquiry that with a small alteration, and fixing Bayonettes to them they are capable of being renderd exceeding good Field Arms; & knowing the necessity of the State for a Supply of that article we have been extreemely desireous to have them alterd and Sent on with all possible dispatch; we flattrd ourselves that this might have been done expeditiously by the Intervention of some Virginia Merchants who had money in this City which they offerd to dispose of for the purchase of the Arms from the Continent; to have them fitted and transported at their own expence, and on their
We are with the greatest respect Yr. Excy's most obedt. Srts James Madison Junr.
Theok. Bland
M. Smith
[P.S.] We have enclosed yr. Excy. a Copy of the agreement we have been necessitated to enter into in order to ensure and expedite a measure which we are Sensible is of the utmost importance to the State.(3)
1 For the failed negotiations with the "Virginia Merchants," see Virginia Delegates to Virginia Merchants, April 24, 1781.
2 For the "Alternative" adopted, see the preceding entry, especially note 2. Although there is no mention in the journals of Maryland's share of "the remainder," it is clear that the Maryland delegates had already obtained an order for 500 rampart pieces, for which see Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, April 24, note 1. For the arms destined for North Carolina, See JCC, 21:923-25; and William Sharpe to George Washington, September 1, 1781.
3 See the preceding entry.
I did myself the honor of addressing a few lines to you by Messrs. Goldsborough and Emory,(1) Since which the President received your Letter, to which Colo. Maylan the Bearer Carrys an Answer.(2) From the Character of this Officer, and the Contents of the letter addressed to you by the Board of War. I flatter mySelf the execution of the Resolves of Congress will not be attended with any disagreeable Circumstances. I am, Sir, Sensible that the Step taken by Congress on this Occasion, is of a very Serious Nature, even tho' Nothing Should be attempted to be Carried into Execution, I Saw it in that light from the Beginning and gave Congress every information in my power, I was almost alone on the propriety and Necessity of the Measure. There is Some reason to believe, that Considerable Quantitys of Flour are Stored on the Waters of Delaware, part of which may have been purchasd for the use of the Enemy. This I think was a strong if not the principal inducement with Congress, for the resolves they entered into.
The enclosed paper contains Some important intelligence.(3) The Extracts of the Letter of the 22nd of Feby. are from Mr. Carmichael those from Holland of the 23d of Jany. from a Correspondent of his at the Hague. The picture Mr. Carmichael gives, of the State of affairs in Europe, is upon the whole pleasing.
The President will give you by this opportunity the latest intelligence from New York,(4) a Considerable Body of Troops were imbarkt. last week, General Clintons Baggage on Board, about 40 vessels under the Convoy of three Frigates are Said to have arrived at Sandy Hook last Saturday. Some Officers lately arrived in a flag from Charles Town, inform us, that a fleet Consisting of the above Number of Vessels, with the Chatham of 50 Guns, and two Frigates, left that place three days before the Flag Sailed.
It is therefore probable the fleet Mentioned to have arrived at New York, is the Same which left Charles Town.
I have the honor to be Sir, with great Esteem, Yr. Mo. Obt. Servt. Daniel Carroll.
1 See Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, April 24, 1781, note 4. For the Special Council for the Eastern Shore's April 13 instructions to Messrs. "Gold. and Emory" to transport arms and ammunition from Philadelphia to Talbot Co., Md., see Md. Archives 43:396-97.
2 For Tilghman's contentious letter of April 21 and Congress' response, see Samuel Huntington to Tilghman, April 27, note 1.
3 The Pennsylvania Packet for this day included extracts from C. W. F. Dumas' January 23 letter from the Hague and William Carmichael's February 22 letter from Madrid, both of which had been read in Congress on April 27. See JCC, 20:452, and PCC, item 88, fols. 123-26, item 93, 1:491-93. Carmichael's letter is also in Wharton Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:265-66.
4 See the following entry.
Desirous that you might have the latest intelligence respecting the Embarkation at New York, I this morning requested the President of this State to give me what information he could on that subject. The Enclosed is his Answer.(1) I have nothing to add to what I wrote Yesterday, only that I am just informed a Packet is arrived at New York which sailed from England in Feby.
I am, Sir, with great respect & Esteem, Yr. Mo. Obt. Sert. Danl. Carroll.
1 The enclosed "Answer" from Pres. Joseph Reed, which follows Carroll's letter to Tilghman in the Ridgely Transcripts, reads: "The Presidents Complimts. to Mr. Carroll and acquaints him that his Intelligence from New York Seems rather to intimate that the proposed Embarkation is at least postponed and may most probably be laid aside. The preparations have Slackened for Several days, but as this may be a Feint to throw us off our Guard, we have not altered the orders given in this State in Consequence of the advise received last week."
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, a Resolve of Congress of the 20th Instant, recommending to the several States therein named, to make good the Depreciation of the monthly Pay to the Officers & Soldiers belonging to Colonel Moses Hazens Regiment, that are considered as Part of those States Quotas, in the same Manner they have made good the Depreciation to the Officers & Soldiers in the Battallions belonging to the Line of those States respectively.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c, S. H.
1 The enclosed resolve was adopted at the recommendation of the committee to which a March 1 memorial from Col. Moses Hazen had been referred on March 23. See JCC, 19:297, 427-29; PCC, item 152, 10:9-16; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21 :326-27.
I am directed to lay before your Excellency the enclosed Act of Congress of the 25th Instant with the several Papers to which it refers, and you are requested to cause Enquiry to be made into the Charges exhibited against Captain Ashby and Justice to be done in the Premises (1)
It gives me Pain to hear of such ungenerous & inhuman Treatment towards our Brethren & Friends in cruel Captivity. From your Excellency's Justice & Humanity I am fully satisfied due & effectual Enquiry will be made into the Transaction referred to, and that you will transmit to Congress the result of such Enquiry as soon as may be.
I have the Honor to be &c
1 Capt. George Ashby, a privateer from Salem, Mass., had captured a schooner carrying supplies from Charleston, S.C., for American prisoners held at St. Augustine. He stood accused of confiscating money, mail, and articles of personal property destined for the prisoners, despite having been informed of the ownership and identity of the goods and persons involved. The "several Papers" accompanying the enclosed congressional resolve were undoubtedly the depositions sworn against Ashby by Thomas Johnson and James McQueen, the captain and a passenger from the captured schooner, and a letter from former delegate Thomas Heyward to Gen. William Moultrie forwarding the depositions to Continental authorities for investigation. See JCC, 20:437-38; and PCC, item 158, fols. 489-95. There is no record of any response from Hancock concerning Ashby in the papers or journals of Congress.
You will receive enclosed, a Resolve(1) of Congress of the 27th Instant, directing Mr J. Bradford to deliver to your Order, all the Duck in his Hands belonging to the United States proper for Tents.
I have the Honor to be &c &c S. H.
1 The enclosed resolve was adopted pursuant to an April 26 recommendation of the Board of War, in response to a complaint from Pickering that he had been unable to procure tent cloth from Bradford at Boston despite a congressional resolve of the previous October, for which see JCC, 20:452-53; and Huntington to Pickering October 23, 1780.
Huntington also sent a copy of the same resolve this day with a brief cover letter to Continental agent John Bradford. See PCC, item 15, fol. 281.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed a Resolve of Congress of the 26th Instant, authorizing the Quarter Master General to appoint Col. Champlin of Newport as Barrack Master to the French Army agreeable to the Sentiments expressed in your Letter of the 21st Instant. (1)
Also a Resolve of the same Date with the above mentioned, affixing the Pay of Captain Lieutenant of Artillery, and of Lieutenants & Sergeants of Infantry agreeable to the Resolve of the 27th of May 1778.(2)
By the enclosed Resolve of the 17th Instant your Excellency will be informed that Mr. J. Moylan is appointed Clothier General.(3)
With the highest Respect & Esteem, I have the Honor to be, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 For Col. Jabez Champlin's appointment, see JCC, 20:446, PCC, item 152, 10:89-92; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:487-88.
2 JCC, 20:446.
3 For John Moylan's appointment and acceptance of this post, See JCC 19:401-2, 20:505; and PCC, item 78, 16:191-93. Huntington also sent a copy of the enclosed resolve to Moylan with a brief cover letter of this date. PCC, item 15, fol. 281.
Your's of the 7th was handed to me a few days ago by Mr. Newman who is to call on me this evening for an answer. 700 dollars were inclosed in it. As I cannot get any wire of the description you direct; nor indeed any but a little fitted for bolting according to the flour model, and that at a price more than double the old one I have declined laying out the money. Should you be in great want & willing to give so high a price, the Messenger for Mr. Sym's Chariot will bring your orders and take charge of the Sifters.
I am well pleased to find my brother Wm. has turned his thoughts seriously on the law, but I much fear his preparatory studies are not sufficiently ripened for the purpose. If he could place himself in a situation for alternately pu[r]suing both, it would be adviseable to do it, and it would be an additional advantage if he were within the reach of some respectable Court where he could be learning the rules of practice. It is of great importance that no time be lost.
The papers which I inclose with this comprize all the late intelligence from abroad. Our affairs in Europe wear on the whole an encouraging aspect. You will have heard of the advance of the Marquis's Corps for your Support. It will soon be followed by the Pennsylvania line. Another embarkation is certainly on the point of sailing from N. York. Clinton it is said is to command it. Deleware bay, is given out as the destination. It is more probable the event will shew the real one to be Chesapeak or Charleston.
Notwithstanding all our precautions the paper money still goes on depreciating. The old is 180 or 190 for 1. The new 21/2 for [1].
Our fine Ship the Confederacy was lately taken and carried into N. York by a British 44 & a frigate. She surrendered without a gun being fired. She was returning from the W. Indies & had a great deal of valuable & useful property on board belonging to the Public.
I shall write again by Mr. Sym's Chariot and send you another cargo of News' papers.
I am yr. dutiful Son, J. Madison Junr.
I do myself the honor of enclosing a paper of last Saturday. The interesting intelligence containd in the extracts of the Letters of the 22d of Feby, & 23 of Jany deserve Credit.(1) The 1st is from Mr
It is said a packet is arrivd at New York which sailed from England some time in March-& that intelligence has come by her that the Russian Minister had left London & the British Petersburgh-& further that on the Arrival of this Vessel, Genl. Clintons baggage was relanded. I give this intelligence on report.
I have the Honor to be with great esteem, Yr Excellencys Most Obt Serv. Daniel Carroll
1 See Carroll to Matthew Tilghman, April 28, 1781, note 3.
The inclosed paper will give you the substance of the latest intelligence Congress have received from Europe. The countenance given by Russia to the united provinces must be productive of very happy effects, it encourages them to enter into the war with alacrity and to prosecute it with vigor. This of course raises up another powerful enemy against G. Britain and enables our generous Ally to give us more substantial aid, than he could otherwise have done. Our affairs at the Court of Madrid wear a more pleasing aspect than they have yet done and we have reason to expect a more earnest friendship from that monarch than he has yet manifested toward us.
The troops and Ships destined for our aid were expected to sail in all the Month of March, the exact numbers of either we are not informed of, but we are encouraged to expect both will be respectable.
We are directed by Congress to communicate to you the complaints that have been made, of a number of the british Officers being suffered to remain in Charles Town on parole when the enemy extend this indulgence with a very sparing hand to our Officers, that you should enquire into the matter and rectify whatever improprieties may have arisen in conducting this business.
It is also the wish of Congress that you would endeavour to negociate an exchange of prisoners and relieve as many of ours as you possibly can, from the horrors of so severe a Captivity as they experience.(1)
You may possibly conceive some embarrassments will arise in negociating this business, least what may be done by you, might
We are sir, with much Esteem & regard, Yr. most Obedt. servts. By Order of the Committee John Mathews Chairman
1 It is not clear from the journals when Congress may have "directed" this committee (to correspond with the commander of the southern department) to instruct Greene to investigate "complaints" concerning parole for American prisoners. For his express power "to negociate an exchange of prisoners," however, see Samuel Huntington to Greene, October 31, 1780. In this same vein, Mathews had coincidentally been appointed on April 28 to chair a committee reviewing an appeal from South Carolina and Georgia prisoners for Congress to establish a line of credit in Charleston upon which they could draw to repay debts and to purchase "Necessaries." On May 2 Congress assigned 600 hogsheads of Virginia tobacco for that purpose and on May 25 it extended the policy to prisoners in New York as well as Charleston. See JCC, 20:458, 468, 534; and PCC, item 158, fols. 481, 485-87.
2 In a letter to Congress of May 10 Greene enclosed a copy of a cartel for the exchange of prisoners in the southern department which had been the subject of negotiation for some time. In his letter Greene estimated that fully "one third of the force" employed by Britain in the south "are deserters from our Army, & prisoners enlisted from our Captives." He recommended that Congress declare that all prisoners of war who "engage in the enemies service...shall be treated as Deserters if taken in Arms against us." See PCC, item 155, 2:67-69, item 172, fols. 137-42.
3 For this extract of a March 30 letter to Gen. William Moultrie from Col. Nisbet Balfour, British commandant at Charleston, see Madison, Papers (Hutchinson) 3:93-94nn.6, 9.
By the latest Advices from Spain the Affairs of America have a favorable Aspect at the Court of Madrid, tho' Mr. Cumberland was still permitted to be there under the ostensible Pretext of obtaining the salubrious Air for the Health of some of his Family, and, among
By every Account from the Southward we have further Confirmation of the severe Sufferings of the British Army in the Battle near Guilford Court House. General O Harra it is said is dead of the Wounds received in that Action.
By late Advices from Holland we are assured, the Dutch have sent a Courier to the Court of Petersburgh to inform them of the hostile Proceedings of Great Britain in Consequence of the States General acceding of the Treaty of Neutrality, and to request the Stipulated Succours, and this Day a Vessel under the Flag of the United Provinces arrived in this Port, but I have not yet received any Intelligence from her.
I hope before this some Delegates from Connecticut are on the Way to Congress, as I am once more left alone from the State, and shall not be able to attend any considerable Time longer myself.
I have the Honor to be, with perfect Respect, Sir, Your most obedient humble servant, Sam. Huntington
I take up my pen to let you know I have not forgot you. I should have wrote you oftner, had not the conveyance been so precarious, but having now a safe one I readily embrace it. I am at present in usual health and hope these will find you and the rest of the family well. Mr. Adams (1) was in a great strait how to return to New England on account of some body to go with him & I consented to let Daniel go with him & he is to return here again & as soon as he returns I shall set out for New England that is as soon as the horse has rested a few days. I don't know that I was ever in a place more disagreeable to me than this, nor even so much.
The enemy are sending reinforcements to the Southward & I hope a kind Providence will disappoint them in their undertaking, and blast them in their attempts against us. Cornwallis has made out to get clear as I was always afraid and said he would. After their action of the fifteenth of March last in which he suffered very much, he retreated toward Willmington in North Carolina through a tract
The little State of Georgia exerts herself greatly, there is near one quarter part of her male inhabitants now in Arms and exerting themselves to drive the enemy from their Country, they have been frequently successful.
Colonel Palfrey has never been heard of nor the Vessel in which he went; it is to be feared the Vessel is foundered and all on board have perished. She was a new and strong Vessel, never at sea before. She had a number of passengers on board.
It is reported here that the Confederacy is taken and carried into New York. She was a Continental Frigate & the best that ever the United States ever had, she was coming from Hispaniola & was in part loaded with cloathing for the Army. There has been another report, that she was retaken and carried into Rhode Island, but I fear this last account is without any good foundation.
Give my love to your mother your brothers and sisters. I wish you and they may the Divine presence and Blessing attending each of you in all your lawful undertakings, and may we finally be admitted into the relms of Eternal day through the merits of the great sacrifice of attonement. Farewell. Artemas Ward
1 That is Samuel Adams. See Adams to Elizabeth Adams, March 15, 1781.
2 That is Thomas Sumter and Andrew Pickens.202 APRIL ? 1781
I have this day recd. yours of the 17th. Under all the Disappointment of my Expectations formed upon your past of the 7th & 9, and under all my extreme bodily Pain from an almost fatal accident, I could not but smile very much at your Pregnancy with a very spacious Curse-capable of striding between Philada. & Boston. Indeed my zealous patriotic Friend, you will have your tortured Feelings yet for a Time. The floating Paper will have its Course. And you among others, must either refuse it or suddenly invest it after taking it or become the Victim of the Circumstances of the Times. It was merely to prevent this latter, that I became lately a Speculr. partly on my own account and partly for that amiable Gentleman whose Business you have in hand, and whose Dependence on your Care is rather increased than diminished since you left us. His unavoidable Connexions with the Indiscrete leave small Room for those many Satisfactions which his own Sense, Prudence & Discretion might naturally originate & govern. We stand in the Path to be scratched by that Alecto (2) which you was wishing to conjure up. But we stand in that Path compulsively. He will write at a more convenient Time expressive of his Sense of your kind Care.
Mr. Adams will give you the State of our affairs. They are in good Train abroad; And Congress have sent so plain a Recapitulation of Things to the States as to show how and how only we may be well arranged at home. For my Part, I know not what more can be done than making a periodical Querie "what is yr. Return to such and such a Requisition?" "The Confederacy hangs on yr. Complyance." You have so repeatedly asked for the Comments that I cannot refuse them tho I think my satisfying you tends to keep alive what was very much extinguished. I wish you to be attentive to this Idea, and to return me the Paper by a good private hand. I desire to keep it.
I have sent the July Journal. Poor Palfrey is gone to London.(3) I am very much deranged by that as I have a Bill of 1050 Livs. which I was going to transmit to his Care & Taste for the use of our amiable Friend, and his lame Brother.
Should it be so that you fail in yr. Endeavors for me till this arrives put into Mrs. L's Possession what she may appear to desire of it when you can find Leisure to call upon her.
With much Regard, yr. Frd. & Servt. honestly, JL
1 Lovell clearly dated this letter "April 31st," but whether he actually wrote it on the last day of the month or on May 1st can only be conjectured.
2 That is, Allecto, one of three Furies of Greek mythology.
3 Lovell was mistaken in reporting that William Palfrey had been captured and taken to England, for his ship was lost at sea during his voyage to take up his post as the newly-elected American consul in France.
I wrote to you yesterday by Express,(1) since which I have receivd yours of the 24th. Least my Letter shoud be sent to the Ridge I enclose a paper of Saturday.(2) Mark No. 1 contains an extract from Mr Carmichaels Letter-No 2 is from a Correspondent of his at the Hague. I must refer you to what I wrote the Governor.
I am Dear Sr. yours &c., Daniel Carroll
1 Not found.
2 That is, the Pennsylvania Packet of April 28, for which see Carroll to Matthew Tilghman, April 28, note 3.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, the Copy of a Resolve of Congress of the 27th of April, recommending to the several States to which they belong, to make up the Depreciation of Pay to the Officers & Men now or late of the Regiment of Artificers commanded by Colonel Baldwin.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S.H.
1 Actually the enclosed congressional resolve was adopted on April 28, pursuant to a Board on War recommendation concerning a memorial from the officers of Col. Jeduthan Baldwin's regiment read in Congress and referred to the board on April 27. See JCC, 20:452, 462; and PCC, item 42, 6:43-45. See also Huntington to Certain States, April 29, 1781.
You will receive enclosed, the Copy of a Resolve(1) of Congress of the 27th Instant, authorizing the Superintendent of Finance to appoint Attornies to prosecute or defend in his official Capacity, also
1 For the adoption of this resolve, a product of Morris' negotiations with a congressional committee over the stipulations he had made as a condition to accepting the office of Superintendent of Finance, See JCC, 20:455-56; and Morris Papers (Ferguson), 1:16-19, 184-85. See also Huntington to Morris, April 25, 1781.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, a Letter from Mathias Halsted with several other Papers, representing the Misconduct of John Adam Deputy Commissary of Prisoners, which they have thought proper to refer to the Commander in Chief, that due Enquiry may be made respecting the Transactions of this Officer, and the Facts complained of & stated in those Papers.(1)
I have also enclosed the Copy of a resolve of the 27th Ulto recommending to the several States to which they belong, to make up the Depreciation of Pay to the Officers and Men now or late of the Regiment of Artificers commanded by Colonel Baldwin.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with very great Respect, Sir, Your Excellency's most obedient & humble servant,
Sam. Huntington President
P.S. Your Excellency's dispat[c]hes of the 21st & 26th of April have been receivd.(3)
1 Huntington's enclosures included an April 21 letter from Mathias Halsted to Abraham Clark, four affidavits and depositions of March 20 and April 7 sworn before Halsted and David Miller, Essex County, NJ., justices of the peace, and an April 27 congressional resolve, all of which are in the Washington Papers, DLC. Upon receiving the material Washington immediately ordered Adam's arrest and an inquiry into the bribery and profiteering charges lodged against him, but when Halsted and his other accusers subsequently refused to testify for the prosecution, the charges were dropped for want of evidence. See JCC, 20:452; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:73-74, 76, 213, 423-24.
2 See Huntington to Certain States, this date.
3 The former Huntington had already acknowledged in his April 29 letter to Washington; the latter is actually one of April 25, for which see PCC, item 169, 8:101, and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:503-4.
Since my last we have had despatches from our Minister at the court of Madrid as late as the 22d February, which contain a minute detail of his negotiations at that court. They do him infinite honor. I wish it were proper for me to communicate them to you: I am sure the perusal of them would not only afford you great pleasure, but give you a very high opinion of his abilities. Our affairs at that court are in such a train as promises a favorable issue, and I have reason to believe, from the best authority, that none of the European powers discover a disposition to favor Great Britain, except the Emperor and Queen of Portugal. The former, I have reason to believe, made offers of his mediation to the court of Spain, which were not very favorably received. The Northern Powers will certainly support the Dutch. The two extracts of letters of the 22d February and 23d January, published in the paper of the 28th of April, under the Philadelphia head, are from the best authority, and the intelligence may be relied on. It is reported here that General Phillips has taken possession of Williamsburg, and that General Greene has turned off towards Camden. The first is what I have long expected; the latter, I must confess, appears extraordinary, and is what I cannot reconcile to any principle; and though I have the best opinion of his judgment and military skill, I cannot help thinking that Ramsay's Mill, on Deep River, is the most convenient position he could have taken to watch the motions of Lord Cornwallis. I am now very impatient of some one's coming on to relieve me, and am determined to wait no longer than the beginning of next month, and at all events will leave this before the middle of it. Present my love to my sisters, Nelly and the children. Remember me properly to all our friends, and believe me, with the most sincere affection,
Dear sir, your most obedient servant,
Sam. Johnston.
P.S. Let my brother see my letters and the newspapers.
On the receipt of your request as to the map I procured a copy with one of the pamphlets & have put it under the care of Col. Febiger who will have it conveyed. It is effectually secured against in Jury on its passage.(1)
I inclose your Excellency a letter from Mazzei although indeed its contents are of no great moment. I have not recd. the antecedant one referred to in it.(2) The Executive have probably received more particular information from him relative to the object of his mission.
Congress have recd. a good deal of information from Europe within a few days past. I can only say in general that it is favorable. Indeed whatever consideration the powers of Europe may have for us, the audacious proceedings of our Enemy in all quarters must determine them to abridge a power which the greatest dangers & distresses can not inspire with moderation or forbearance.
I hope your Excellency has recd. my letter inclosing a copy of a plan reported to Congress for arming them with coercive authority.(3) Your first leisure moments will I flatter myself favor me with your idea of the matter.
With great respect I am Dr Sir Yr. Obt. friend & servant. J Madison Junr.
1 Jefferson had requested a copy of a map sold with Thomas Hutchins' A Topographical Dessnttion of Virginia, Pennsylvania, Maryland and North Carolina (London: J. Almon, 1778), for which he had sent Madison £150 on April 7. See Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:585n. The map, covering the area west of the Alleghenies, was issued separately from the pamphlet, which had been advertised in the April 7 issue of the Pennsylvania Packet. For Hutchins' appointment as geographer to the southern army, see Charles Thomson to Washington, May 10, 1781.
2 That is Philip Mazzei's letters of November 30 and December 7, 1780, for which see Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 2:211-16, 229-30.
3 See Madison to Jefferson, April 16, 1781, note.
I received your letter of the 25 of last month. I have not been unmindful of the promise I made; In short it has hardly ever been out of my thoughts, and the more because I fear my endeavours will not be successful. Congress have ordered my accounts to be settled up to first of March last and have acknowledged the public endebted to me to that day in the sum of five thousand some hundred dollars specie value.(1) But when they will be enabled to pay me I know not. The requisitions from the states are so little attended to and the exigencies of the war so great & so pressing that I do not know how to act. They would freely grant a certificate payable at a future day expressly in specie with an interest in the mean time at six per cent per An. of the same value. My tenant on whom I depended has acted & continues to act agreeably to law as a knavish scoundrel. I should be exceedingly glad to have the lot and shall be much mortified at missing it, but cannot wish you to suffer inconvenience
I am your affectionate, Chas Thomson
1 Thomson's claim was among those contained in the "general account of salaries and arrearages due to the civil list" considered on April 3, 1781. Although Congress at that time endorsed "the principles upon which the said accounts" were settled in the treasury, it made immediate provision only for "the balances due to the under-secretaries and clerks in the several offices and boards as specified in the general account." See JCC, 19:343, and PCC, item 34, fols. 267-69.
We enclose herewith a letter from Oliver Pollock Esqr.(1) which will inform your Excellency of a very large claim which may soon be expected on the Treasury of Virginia.
Mr. Nicholson Agent for Mr. Ross arrived here yesterday. We fear it will not be possible for him to get some of the most essential articles even if an exchange of his funds can be negociated, and that the difficulty of such an exchange will be a great obstacle to his getting such articles as are to be had. As far as our efforts can avail him they will not be spared. We had previous to his coming taken some measures which we flatter ourselves will yield about 2000 good muskets in about two weeks. The transportation is not included otherwise than by a naked order of Congress and must now be referred to Mr. Nicholson.(2)
The 1100 Stand belonging to the State have at length gone forward with most of the other Articles brought hither with them.(3) The 8th of this month is the day fixed we understand for the march of the Pennsylvania line from York Town.
The report from N. York is that Clinton is disembarking his troops.
We also inclose herewith an extract of a letter from Genl Washington (4) which needs no comment.
We have the honor to be, with the highest respect & regard, Yr. Excelly's obt. & hmble servts. J. Madison Junr.
Theok. Bland
M. Smith
1 Not found, but for Pollock's claims against Congress and the state of Virginia for supplies sent from New Orleans to George Rogers Clark in Kentucky and the northwest territory, see ibid., 3:99n.1; and James A. James, "Oliver Pollock, Financier of the Revolution in the West," Mississippi Valley Historical Review, 16 (June 1929): 67-80.
2 For George Nicolson's mission in Philadelphia and the steps the delegates had taken to provide "2000 good Muskets," see Jefferson, Papers, (Boyd), 5:458 59; and Virginia Delegates Memorandum, April 27, 1781.
3 That is, the goods from Le Comite, for which see Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, April 24, note 2.
4 Not found, but undoubtedly Washington's letter of April 25 read in Congress on the 30th, for which see JCC, 20:463; and Samuel Huntington to Washington, this date, note 3.
You will no doubt think it something singular, that the inclosed should be of so old a date,(1) and handed to you with this, but the reason of it is, that it was meant to go by Govr. Rutledge, who intended paying a visit at Head Quarters, but being taken ill, tho' expecting daily to be in condition to prosecute his journey, finding that not likely to be soon the case, I have requested Mr. Duane to be the Bearer of it.
Our last accounts from Europe are very flattering, particularly from Spain. From some circumstances that have lately taken place at that Court, it seems more favourably disposed towards us, than it hath hither to been. And as soon as some late determinations of Congress, can arrive there, we have little room to doubt, but what our expectations in that quarter will be fully compleated.
The decisive measures pursuing by Holland, supported as they are, by the strongest assurances from Russia, places the war in Europe on the most formidable footing against G. Britain Although the Emperor of Germany puts on the appearance of war, (and as, is generally supposed, in favor of G. Britain) Yet it is most likely he will be too much overawed, to enter seriously into it.
How unfortunate is it, that with all these bright prospects in our favor, we have little or no ability to profit by them. However, as you will see Mr. Duane, and who proposes making a full communication to your Excy. of the present state of our affairs, I shall forbear to ingroce your time, with any further observations on that subject.
The inclosed extract of a letter, sent us by Genl. Moultrie, will shew yr. Excy. what a deplorable state our unfortunate prisoners at Chs. town are likely to be reduced to, unless some thing can be immediately done for their relief. We are further informed Ld. Chs. Montagu, has enlisted between 5 and 600 of our Continentals, & was daily engaging more, all intended for the West India service, so that, they must be for ever lost to us. The Committee of correspondence, by order of Congress, have written to Genl. Greene on this subject,(2) to take the most effectual measures to effect an exchange, as far as his powers extend, but its likely he will want some instructions from you on the business.
I have the honor to be, with the highest respect and sentiments of the most sincere Esteem, yr. Excys. most Obet. servt.
Jno. Mathews
1 Undoubtedly Mathews' letter to Washington of April 16, for which see Washington's June 7 acknowledgement and reply in Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:1 76-77.
2 See Committee of Congress to Nathanael Greene, April 30, 1781.
I Take the Liberty of inclosing your Excellency a Motion which I intend making in Congress provided it meets with your approbation.(1) I have reasons for this Motion which were not proper in my Opinion to Lay before Congress but which I beg leave to lay before your Excellency. I Suppose it at Least possible That our reinforcement from France may be followed by a Superiour Naval Armament which may Arrive before any thing decisive can be Effected; Should this event take place we shall find ourselves unable to regain a Single Post the Enemy now possess & consequently the Campaign must be lost, unless by Some diversion we can reduce that force at Least to an Equality; & this in my Opinion cannot be So effectually done as by making a Diversion in Canada as they canot reinforce but by water; & This will demand a Convoy of Capitol Ships, but Should not this Event take place namely a Naval Superiority on their Side no injury can Arise from making the Necessary preparations as this will make a diversion in favor of our intended plans in this Quarter and Enable us in case of Disappointment to turn the feint into a real attack. I am clearly of opinion that our whole force Should be employed to regain what we have already lost so Long as there remains a probability of Success: but when the possibility of that Success ceases to Exist we ought not to loose the Campaign & neglect to Conquer Posts completely in our power: because we are unable to gain those we prefer. In Short I am for doing something in case it Should become impossible to do what I most ardently wish, viz regaining the Posts already lost & I submit to your Excellency whether even this will be possible unless the necessary preparations are previously made. These in my opinion may be made without much Expence. The Eastern States may be called upon to Embody some Battalions & make other necessary preparations which in case of a Naval Superiority may be employed against New York & Enable us to Detach from the Main Army to the Southward. I beg your Excellency to Excuse the Length of this letter as it was only my intention when I began to give the hints without going into a Long
I have the honor to be with the most respectful attachment, Dear General your Excellencys Most obedt Servant, Jno Sullivan
E N C L O S U R E
To the Honble the Delegates of the United States in Congress Assembled.
Gentlemen when I consider how much this Country has suffered by languid efforts; which instead of expelling the common enemy, have only served to exhaust the treasures of the United States; prolong the war and discourage the Citizens by a series of misfortunes. When I consider that the enemy are now entirely possessed of two States; occupy important posts in several others: and hold uninteruptedly the Province of Canada; containing more territory than all the thirteen United States: and that this Province, which almost encircles them, must from its situation, and by the natural increase of its inhabitants, soon become sufficiently powerful in conjunction with the naval force of Britain, to deprive us of those privileges for which we have so long contended. That a peace ratified by Great Britain at this time, should even every post in the United States be given up to Congress: must finally end in the destruction of our liberties; for a long continuance of peace would only serve to render a conquest over us more certain. As it has ever been allowed that all forms of government which must Eventually end in the ruin of itself ought not to be adopted; so that situation which will in time bring destruction upon those who hold it; ought at all events to be avoided. Should peace be restored even upon the terms before mentioned, the increase of inhabitants in every part of America will undoubtedly be in proportion to the extent of territory in each; and the Province of Canada will undoubtedly from its great extent, the goodness of its soil, and the advantages of its exterior and interior fishery and navagation: have almost as great an increase of inhabitants as the whole of the United States together: of course an uninterupted peace for a number of years, will only serve to accelerate the conquest of them, upon the commencement of hostilities, for Britain will only have to put her naval force in motion and the whole of these States from their situation with respect to Canada will be immediately invested by land and Sea. But should we be compelled to make peace upon terms less favourable, and the enemy be suffered to keep possession of every part of America which they now hold; a long continuance of peace will ensure to Britain without difficulty, that conquest which her arms have hitherto been unable to accomplish.
These considerations induce me to propose to Congress an immediate invasion of Canada, as the only means of relieving the Southern States, securing the liberty, and independence of the whole; and obtaining a peace upon terms favourable to their interest, to accomplish which no great expence of men or money will be requisite. As the inhabitants of Canada since our Alliance with France are well disposed to second us in the attempt; as that Country abounds in flour and other articles of subsistance for the Army; and the possession of the lower part of Canada will of course reduce every fortress of the enemy on the Lakes, and compell their Indian allies to sue for peace. As a road is now cleared within thirty miles of St Johns and 45 of St Dennies and may be compleated in fifteen days, I would propose that the Duc de Loison's legion, the New Hampshire line, and Hazens regiment, with some batallions of militia from the New England States, and Vermont, not exceeding 6000 in the whole be detached upon this expedition by the first of August next. That cattle only be furnished and sent on as there is a sufficiency of flour in Canada for support of the Army, while there. That the military and ordinance stores be sent from the most convenient posts in the New England States; and that the commanding Officer be impowered to inlist such volunteers in Canada as he may find necessary for making a sudden and complete conquest of the Country.
<Should this plan be approved by Congress and the Commander in Chief and be thought by others difficult to be carried into execution, though I have no wish to solicit for myself any military employment; I now offer Congress to undertake the Command and to be answerable for its success (unless prevented by some unforeseen stroke of providence or unexpected arrival of a large reinforcement from Britain) provided Congress will for the time restore me to that rank in the Army which an ill state of health compelled me to relinquish and which I should willingly yield up when the Expedition is completed.>
I have the honor to be, very respectfully, Gentlemen, your most Obedient & huml Sert. Jno. Sullivan
1 For Sullivan's decision not to submit the enclosed "motion" to Congress, upon receiving Washington's May 29 response opposing the proposed Canadian invasion, see Sullivan to Washington, June 11, 1781; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22: 1 3 1-32.
In your letter to me of the 1st instant, you refer to your Letter of the 26th ulto. as covering an Estimate &c. I cannot recollect the last
I have receivd your Letters of the 6th & 9th of April, but none of the 26th of that month.(1)
You will please to examine & Inform me where the error or mistake is, or favour me with a Copy of yours of the 26th ulto.
Sam. Huntington
1 The evidence in PCC suggests that no letter from Blaine of April 26 ever existed and that in referring on May I to one of "the 26th ulto." he actually had in mind his letter of the 6th. Huntington could not locate the document Blaine described on May I as "An Estimate of the Sums due in my Department," but with his April 6 letter Blaine had enclosed an "Estimate of Money due to the several Deputy & Assistant Commissaries of Purchases" which fits the May I reference. Furthermore, Blaine's May I complaint that Congress had not yet considered the "Estimate" submitted to them would have been totally unjustified had it been sent as recently as April 26 rather than on the 6th. See PCC, item 165, fols. 401-14.
I enclose the paper of this day principally that you may see the Step the Executive of this State has taken with respect to the rate of Exa. of the Old Continental money, which has occasiond Considerable uneasiness of this City(1), insomuch that the President & his Council have thought proper to publish their motives & reasons in a handbill, which I cannot obtain to Send by this Opportunity. I There is reason to believe, that in Consequence of the measure adopted by the Executive, old Continental money to a Considerable amount has been forwarded to the Southward to be dispos'd of immediately-Jersey having likewise proclaim'd the rate to be 150. As many individuals in our State, notwithstanding, this money is not Current by Law, may be injurd for want of Notice, I was Induc'd to give you this information to be made publick if you think proper. The Exa. before this measure was abt 225. If the old money passes for any thing after this Bustle over it is probable it will be considerably more than double the Exca. just mentiond. A few days will determine.
I write this in a hurry & conclude Dear Sr., with great esteem,
Yr. Mo. Obt Sert, Danl. Carroll
1 Pennsylvania had been accepting Continental currency in payment of taxes since December 1780, at a rate of exchange declared by the Pennsylvania Council the first week of each month. In its May 2 declaration, the council had dramatically raised the rate between Continental dollars and specie from 75:1 to 175: 1, primarily to ward off a rising tide of Continental currency from New Jersey where the exchange rate had recently been set at 150:1. Council resolutions of May 2 and 4 setting forth this declaration were published in David C. Claypoole's Pennsylvania Packet of this date.
For the May 4 explanatory statement issued by Council President Joseph Reed elaborating "their motives & reasons in a handbill"-In Council, May 4, 1781 (Philadelphia: F. Bailey, 1781)-see Evans, Am. Bibliography, no. 17,288, and the Pennsylvania Packet issue of May 8. See also Virginia Delegates to Thomas Jefferson, this date.
In compliance with your request I have procured and now send you a copy of the Constitutions &c. published by order of Congress.(1) I know not why the order in which they stand in the Resolution was varied by the committee in binding them up. The encomium on the inhabits. of Rhode Island was a flourish of a Delegate from [that] State who furnished the Committee with the acct. of its Constitution, and was very inconsiderately sufferd to be printed.(2)
I am Dear sir, Yr sincere friend, J. Madison Junr.
1 The preceding December Congress had appointed a committee consisting of Thomas Bee, John Witherspoon, and Oliver Wolcott "to collect and cause to be published 200 correct copies of the declaration of independence, the articles of confederation and perpetual union, the alliances between these United States and his Most Christian Majesty, with the constitutions or forms of government of the several states." See JCC, 18:1217. For the edition printed at this time by Francis Bailey, in which the state constitutions preceded the Declaration of Independence, see Evans, Am. Bibliography, no. 17,390. For various subsequent editions of The Constitutions of the Several Independent States of America, See JCC, 21:1201-3.
2 This "encomium on the inhabitts. of Rhode Island" was apparently the work of James M. Varnum, the only Rhode Island delegate in attendance from the creation in December 1780 of the committee appointed to compile the enclosed collection and May 5th. Varnum's "flourish," which appears immediately after the "Charter of Rhode-Island" in Bailey's compilation, reads as follows:
"Since the commencement of hostilities by Great Britain, the state of Rhode-Island and Providence plantations has not assumed a form of government different from that contained in the foregoing charter. For in that, the king ceded to the governor and company, all powers, legislative, executive, and judicial, reserving to himself, as an acknowledgement of his sovereignty, a render of the fifth part of the gold and silver ore that should be found within the territory. The governor, chief magistrates, and legislators are chosen by the freemen as usual, and all judicial and executive officers are annually elected by the governor and company, or upper and lower house of assembly. All processes original and judicial, formerly issued in the king's name, but they now issue in the name of the governor and company. The oaths of allegiance and of office are made conformable to the principles of the revolution. The governor, in his legislative capacity, cannot give a negative to any act of the two houses; but, in common with the other magistrates, has one voice only.
"The state is divided into five counties, in each of which there is a court of common pleas and general sessions of the peace held twice every year, for the trial of all causes not capital, that arise within their limits; from which an appeal lies, to the superior court of judicature, court of assize and general jail delivery, whose jurisdiction extends over the whole state, and who also sit twice a year in each county. The constitution admits not of religious establishments, any farther than depends upon
The Executive of New Jersey in consequence of authority vested in them by the Legislature for that purpose, by an Act of the 27th Ulto. established the rate of exchange between the old Continental currency and the bills issued pursuant to the Act of Congress of the 18th. of March 1780, to be 150 for 1. The Speculation arising from this measure to the prejudice of this State with the other reasons stated in the inclosed publication by the Executive Council led to their act of the 2d instant therein referred to declaring the rate between the two kinds of money abovementioned to be 175 for 1.(1) The effect of this declaration has been a confusion among the people of this City approaching nearly to tumult, a total Stop to the circulation of the old money, and a considerable Stagnation and increased depreciation of the new. The difference between the latter and hard money is at present vibrating from 4 to 1 downwards. Should the circulation of the former therefore revive, its value cannot exceed 1/700 of that of hard money. The opportunity which this circumstance gives and which we have reason to believe many are already taking measures to improve, of fraudulent speculation not only on the Citizens of Virginia, but on the State itself, is so obvious & alarming that we thought it our duty to set an Express in immediate motion to put you on your guard against the mischief.(2)
The inclosed list of prisoners taken by Capt. Tilly has been communicated to us by the Minister of France in consequence of our application.(3) We shall select such of the names as have already been mentioned by your Excellency as obnoxious & dangerous to the State, and put them into the hands of the Minister, who as well as the French Commander is entirely disposed to secure the State from all further apprehension from their malice. If there are any other names which you would wish to add to your former list we beg to be informed of them by the first opportunity. If there are any of the Prisoners who are not considered as objects of much dread, particularly of those who hold commissions we believe our Allies would chuse not to be deprived of the use of them as subjects of exchange.
We have the honor to be with the highest respect & esteem Yr. Excellency's obt. & humble servts., (By order of the Delegation) (4)
J. Madison Jnr.
1 See Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, this date, note.
2 For the effect of this collapse of the Continental dollar in Virginia, see Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:109n.6.
3 The "inclosed list of prisoners" has not been found, but for the delegates' "application," see Virginia Delegates to La Luzerne, April 2; and Madison to Jefferson, April 3, note 6. See also ibid., p. 69n.2.
4 Theodorick Bland and Meriwether Smith were the Virginia delegates attending Congress with Madison at this time.
I wrote you a few lines last Saturday (1) informing you that large Sums of the old Continental money were sent to the Southward to be got rid of immediately in consequence of the Step taken by the Executive of this State. The enclosd paper (2) contains a publication of the President & Council explaining their motives. The confusion still Subsists in this city, I believe little or nothing can be bought here at present for the old money at any rate.
I believe I lately enclosd to you a return of some Cloathing which had been forwarded to Genl. Greens army. I have now the pleasure of informing you that two Vessels are arrivd to the Eastward with cloathing from Cadiz. A great part of this Supply will probably be applied to yr. Troops Under Genl. Washington. Before this arrival, Several articles were orderd as underneath.
I do not remember whither I have requested you to Send me the act of Assembly passd last Session in favor of the Baron de Calbs family. Col. Du Baisson calls upon me frequently on that Subject. The Rampart arms & two Field P[iece]s are ready. I have reason to believe their will be a very considerable importation of Arms soon-& mention it that you may consider whether an application for a Share of them wou'd not be proper, and answer better than takeing the rampart pieces unless they are wanted for boats.(3)
I have the honor to be Dear Sir, with great esteem, Your Mo. Obt. Sert. Daniel Carroll
Commander in Chief has orderd the above articles to be sent forward with 1000 Stand Arms-2000 Arms will probably be sent from Springfield for the S. Army.
1 See Carroll to Lee, May 5, 1781.
2 The Pennsylvania Packet of this day, for which see ibid., note.
3 For the Maryland Council's May 30 response on this point, see Md. Archives, 45:450.
Since you left us no great matters have been concluded in Congress except that Mr. Morris has agreed to accept the Appointment in agitation when you went away to Congress having agreed to his Terms in Substance.
Two Ships are Arrived at Boston with Cloathing for the Army purchased by Mr. Jay at Cadiz. We have likewise received Letters from that Gentleman & Mr. Carmichael. The general disposition of the European Powers are favourable to the common cause as far as I am capable of Judging from such Circumstances as have come to my knowledge.
From a variety of intelligence it would appear that General Clinton means to make a Grand Movement so much that many think he will evacuate New York altogether. In favour of this Opinion they say two Ship loads of the Inhabitants have sailed for Halifax, that others have bespoke passages and that some of the principle Inhabitants have sold their Estates at a price greatly under the Value. It is certain that a great number of Refugees from Jersey have returned and thrown themselves on the Mercy of Government.
The Council of this State a few days since rated the State Money, one dollar of the New equal to 175 old Continental. This has produced great convulsions and in some measure stagnated the Currency of all kinds of paper. Those who receive it make the difference of four State Specie as it is called for one Silver dollar, God knows where it will end. The Assembly is called to meet the latter end of this Month.
Pray dont neglect to extend all your influence for my relief. I would come off at any event but I am of too much importance for without me they could not make a Congress. Maryland is still unrepresented and so is every State to the Eastward of Jersey. I expect you will have hot work this Summer. I wish much to take a chance among you for here I am of no other use but that of filling a blank. I hope soon to have the pleasure of hearing from you. In the
I had the pleasure of receiving your letter of the 5th of last month yesterday, under cover from Mr. Neilson, who informs me that Edenton was abandoned by the inhabitants. I am much concerned for them on this occasion, as they must have sustained great loss and inconvenience in their flight, though I flatter myself their apprehensions were greater than their danger. I by no means blame them for taking early precautions for the security of their propery, but I don't think any force could at that time have been employed against them which they might not have found means to repulse; they, however, must be the best judges of this matter, and I have no doubt but every thing was done that was proper on the occasion. Two ships have lately arrived at Boston from Cadiz with clothing for the army. The blockade of Gibraltar is still continued, covered by a fleet of thirty sail of the line. We every day expect the second division of the French fleet, though we have no certain advice of their having sailed. The Dutch are making very vigorous exertions in putting their marine on a respectable footing, and it is very generally thought that they will be effectually supported by the Northern Powers. None of the powers in Europe discover a friendly disposition to Great Britain, except the Emperor, who is kept in check by the King of Prussia. All Europe have their eyes on America, and particularly the Southern States. Much will depend on our exertions and success. The great and sudden fall of the old Continental money has occasioned very great convulsions and dissatisfaction in this city, and has reduced all paper currency to a very doubtful state, very many refusing to have any thing to do with it. We have no official accounts from General Greene or the Southern Army since the beginning of last month. Report says he has turned his face towards Camden-if so, I doubt not he had good reason for his conduct. Mr. Robert Morris is appointed to superintend the finances of the United States. Great matters are expected from this gentleman's abilities. The finances of no country were at any time more deranged or more in want of wisdom and political knowledge to make them effectual. Present my love, &c., &c., &c.
Your most obedient servant, Sam. Johnston.
I wrote you a few days since by an express to the Governor of Virginia,(1) informing you of the downfall of the old continental dollars of this city. They still lie prostrate, nor is there the least probability of their ever rising. I must repeat my request that you will either come or send some one to relieve me. I should have left the State unrepresented had not so many others been in that situation. All the States to the Eastward of Jersey, and the State of Maryland, are without a vote in Congress, so that some of the most important business cannot be determined on agreeable to the Confederation. The scarcity of current cash makes it difficult to keep the several departments in motion. The pernicious practice of selling foreign bills at little more than half their value, is, for very substantial reasons, laid aside. My particular necessities must be too obvious; I therefore say nothing on that head. We had the misfortune to lose the Confederacy, with a very valuable cargo of clothing and other effects. Two ships, however, with about three thousand suits of clothes from Cadiz, are arrived at Boston. We have, by a great variety of untoward circumstances, been remarkably unfortunate in the transportation of supplies which have been procured from Europe. Mr. Jay has transmitted a full detail of his negotiations at the court of Madrid. They do great honor to his abilities, and promise a favorable issue, indeed, so far as I can collect from such intelligence as I have had access to, there are none of the courts in Europe who discover a disposition favorable to Great Britain, except the court of Vienna; and I think we and our friends have little to apprehend from that quarter. General Clinton's movements at New York still wear a mysterious appearance. They can only be explained by the event. Every circumstance concurs to confirm the opinion that their principal operations will be to the Southward; and appearances are not altogether against the probability of the total evacuation of New York, should our allies be superior in these seas. I think we shall soon do their business; if otherwise, we must be satisfied to stand on the defensive. There have been no official accounts from General Greene of late. I am very impatient to hear from that quarter. Remember me to your brother, W. Hill, and all our other friends. Should you see Hooper, show him this letter; I would have wrote to him, but don't know where he is, for I have not heard a word from him. I am, with the most sincere respect and esteem, Your most obedient servant, Sam. Johnston.
1 Not found.
I was not yesterday favored by any Line from you. I have met with severe Injury lately by a Fall as Mr. Adams will doubtless have told you. Should the Weather be fine Tomorrow I may be able to get up to the State House, tho with Pain.
Nothing can exceed the Confusion here as to money. The Bearer Mr. Payne will give you the Particulars. I shall confine the Subject to my own Condition. How is a Delegate here to be supported? Will Mr. Partridge or Osgood bring Mass. State Money? It passes not here. Will they bring old continental? 1200 are given for 1 Spanish, 4 Pensylvania 5, 6, 7 and more for 1 Spanish. Neighbour Wood mends a Watch for a Clerk of the Board of War, and demands 5 hard or 7 State Dollars which according to Council is 7 times 175=1225. Mr. Adams pd. his Washwoman 45 pr. Dozs. May 1. I was confined to my Bed and on May 5 must pay 105 for every 45. These Things make no odds to me where the State pays the Expences. But I am paid 1 1/2 dollar per day for Time & Service, at 40, 75, 100 and I pay it away here not according to Law but Practice at 700 up to 1200. I want a Suit of Cloaths and a Peice of Linnen: But as the Purchase of them would ruin my Family at one Stroke I only have two Patches in the Elbows of my Coat and a new Seat to the Small Cloaths for which I pay 8 State or 1516 which as it is charged to me by the State is perhaps a Fortnight's Pay for Time and Service, tho it is not in Fact here 1 ½ Dollars.
To avoid this Ruin I tell my Family to buy Coin, But they are afraid my Character will be injured if it should be known that I am not satisfied with Paper. But while I aim only at saving myself from Destruction I fear not Censure. Now I go further and ask would it not be better for the State to furnish Coin which may be had for less among you than 100 for 1 than to lay at the mercy of Pensylvania Exchange. Mrs. Millar bruits abroad that Mr. Adams paid her 11 State at 75 instead of 11 hard or the current Exchange of that Sum. I do not think Mr. Adams ever supposed he was on such a Lay as the latter. Be that as it will I knew I was to pay 7 hard Dollars or the Exchange and I have accordingly paid, tho never to the Height of what Silver actually sold at; when I pd. 90 I could sell it at 93, when I paid 130 I could sell at 135 and so on.
But Things are now come to an Extremity. On the 1st of May Exchange was counted to me 180 when I know absolutely that 190, 195, & 200 were actually paid; but if that Exchange was more than twice what it would have cost the State to supply me with Coins what must it amount to if I am to go on paying in paper-now that Exchange is what I have before described? Shall I pay 8400 dollars per Week? If I shd. The Family will not think I do them the same
I have drawn for 12000 dollars, in your Favor. I know not whether any authority hath been renewed by which we may draw. We are not favored with any such since April 24 1780 which I suspect is obsolete. But as Resolves do pass respecting us which we never get I chuse to suppose Something has passed respecting our Support.
I find I have been too long at the Pen. I must to bed. I am in great Pain. This must suffice for Doctr. Holton and Mr. Adams as well as for you.
Most affectionately, J. Lovell
[P.S.] I find I have mentioned nothing as to the Disposal of the Draught. Please to let Mrs. Lovell have what she chuses and turn the rest into Coin the soonest you can. I keep my Family in a continual State of Suffering because I have no Conceptions but that my Account for Time & Service will be settled in a Way the most injurious to me so far as respects all my personal Expences here which do not enter into the List of those intended by the Court to be publickly discharged. I have already explained this. You have felt it tho your Children have not. But none of my Colleagues can feel it so much as I and my Dependents, because none of them have drawn for more than those Expences which stand charged to the public, or for very little more: so that their Pay for Service may be avaredged, and discharged at the Exchange of the Week of Settlement. All the Stuff about Money is contrary to my natural Disposition. I began as early as 19 to have a Contempt of Wealth, and if I afterwards got so far as to take Thought for the Morrow I never suffered anxiety about the third Day. This Discussion now therefore is forced upon me against the Grain.
I inclose some Letters for your Information. You will leave that to Hacker open in Palfreys which you will seal and inclose in that to Mess S & D (1) which you will also seal and deliver to Capt. Smith or any other Capt. bound to France. I am distressed about Palfrey. The Ship was villainously crank.
Ryan is going to settle in Virginia-is gone, I believe. He left the enclosed a few days ago.
1 Apparently Messieurs Samuel & John H. Delap.
Your Favor of the 26. of April reached me yesterday. Your Troops are coming on "in large numbers." The General informs you that Tents &c. will be much wanted; and the Court will make their "usual Exertions." Indeed Doctor I am persuaded that in a comparative View Massachusetts will appear to have been among the most vigorous States; but we are at this moment in the most disgraceful and hazardous Situation from the Backwardness of every individual State. Foreign Troops are to garison West Point because foreign Troops can feed themselves, and are paid. Our Quarr. Mastr. genl. has been obliged to sell some of his provision to enable himself to transport the rest to a Skeliton of an Army in Want of the very Pounds of meat or Flour which he has been forced to part with. If you know of a Compliance with one Requisition of Congress, in Time & Quantity, do let me have it that I may show it to the Delegates of the 12 States who cannot produce a single Instance.
We are in an Uproar here about the Money. Sailors with Clubs parade the Streets instead of working for Paper. The Beer houses demand hard for a Pot of Drink; and all this because the Council have published that the difference between Silver and old Continental was 175, the latter having been sold 180 & 200 for one several Days. Did Massachusetts sink its Quota by the 1st of April? Some States had not then begun to sink a Shilling.
You say Mr. Partridge and Mr. Osgood are coming on: I ask with what money in their Pockets? That of our State is not counted money here. The old continental is dying by Yards not Inches. And if my Friends purchase Gold with their State money, They become Speculators, say all the Villains who have created the Necessity. Are you not aware of the Perdition that awaits my Family while the Paper System goes on. I take a Thousand Dollars here whether in old or 5 & 5/7 State I draw for 1000 or 25 State. I lose the Interest on the 25 as I have twice or thrice done on 250 and I pay above 1500 for patching my Coat, &c.
1 Lovell also wrote the following second letter to Holten this day:
"I yesterday recd. yr. favor of April 26th. I am glad to hear from you that the Massa. Troops are coming on in large numbers. Indeed Doctor the States in most Credit in Compliance with the Requisitions of Congress are very very backward and the affairs of the Continent are consequently in a most alarming Situation. I scratched a Letter and would not trust it to the Post. Perhaps I shall send it by Mr. Payne who goes tomorrow.
"I inclose a Paper which will show something of the Shock of the old Continental Currency.
"If the Weather is fair Tomorrow I think I shall be able to get up to the State House. Your Friend & h. St., James Lovell." Ibid., p. 230.
Mr. Vanderhorst (1) a gentleman of South Carolina, arrived in this city yesterday from N. York, on his parol. He was a passenger in a vessel from No. Carolina bound to this place, but taken & carried into N. York. If it would not essentially militate against your arrangements for exchange, & would not be injuring any individual, I should be extremely happy if you could get him immediately exchanged, as he could be very usefully employed.
I am Sir, Yr. most Obedt. Sert. Jno Mathews
P.S. I should be obliged to you for an answer as soon as convenient.
1 Apparently Arnoldus Vanderhorst, for whom see these Letters, 15:594.
I observed in Rivingtons paper a Letter from you Informing me that I might Draw upon you for two hundred pounds State money which Letter was Intercepted in the Mail taken at the Clove & Rivingtons Publication of it is the first Intelligence I have had respecting money for my Support for Six months past.(1) I am unwilling to say much respecting money or other affairs lest This might fall into the Enemys hands. Continental Money is received here by few persons when it is passed. A Decree of the Governor and Council has fixed it at 175 for one State Dollar & these State Dollars pass only at five for one of Silver & are Daily falling. New money from other States pass at forty for one of the old Continentals of Course four of Your Dollars will not purchase one of this State & five of them must be Employed To obtain a Silver Dollar which when purchased will not go so far in Supporting a person here as half a Dollar formerly would. The Sum you or rather Mr Rivington Informs me I may Draw for is 666 Dollars & two thirds. This upon the calculation I have before made would neat me 70 Silver Dollars & two thirds which would pay Eight Weeks Lodging for a Single person without Servant, Horse, Liquor, Wood, Candle or any other Article.
I have prevailed on a friend of mine to take a Bill on You as he is going Eastward & give me new money of this State for that of New Hampshire dollar for Dollar. This makes the 70 Silver Dollars Amount to 133 & this would Last as Long as half the Sum would in 74. I need make no Comments: I am willing to Submit to any
I do not mention these things by way of Complaint it would be unjust & ungenerous to Censure our assembly or State who have Exerted themselves more than any other to Support the Common Cause but it is my duty to give Every Information necessary for them to know & perhaps My own feelings may be (Thought not falsely yet) too strongly painted in the representation.
I have the honor to be with great respect Dear Sir your most obedient Servant, Jno Sullivan
1 Weare's March 17 letter to Sullivan was published in the April 25 issue of James Rivington's New York Royal Gazette. See also Sullivan to Weare, January 21, 1781, note 4.
Having so lately and so often wrote to your Excellency we have little new to Communicate at present; the confusion respecting money still continues in this City, tho with less commotion than could be expected as in a few days the old Continental money has depreciated from two hundred to seven, eight, and some say nine Hundred for one, the new money has of course sufferd in proportion. What this Convulsion will end in, it is difficult to Surmise. In the mean time we are in infinite distress as may be easily supposed; the Currency of the old money has been stoppd for some days past and it is said to day that the new is about to share the same fate. In the midst of these misfortunes we have the pleasure to transmit to Yr. Excelly a Copy of a letter from Genl. Cornell one of the members of the board of War, who has been directed by Congress to visit the Magazines, and if possible to Send to the Southward Such Arms Cloathing and Military stores as we are in want of.(1) The Extract is as follows.
"Inclosed is a return of Clothing now on the Road and orderd to be sent immediately from this Place to the care of the board of War, for the Use of the Marquises detachment and the Southern Army, to which may be added one thousand Stand of good Small arms orderd forward immediately by the Commander in Chief for the use of the Militia of the Southern States as the board of War shall direct. Early to Morrow morning I shall go to fish Kill with General Knox from which Place the Genl. thinks two or three thousand Cartouch Boxes can be spared if so they will be forwarded Immediately to the Southward. I Expect to be able to forward for the same Purpose two
New Windsor April 30th 1780 [i.e., 1781]. Copy"
We have also the pleasure to acquaint your Excellency that about three thousand Suits of Cloathing are safely arrived at Boston from Spain, which our Friend the King of Spain has Enabled our Minister at that Court to procure, we are with the greatest respect, Yr. Excelly's most obedt. Serts, M. Smith
Theok. Bland
N.B. about 400 of the Rampart arms to be made into good Muskets and fixd with Bayonettes for the State as advised in ours of last week (2) are finishd and will be sent forward immediately and the others are finishing with all possible Expedition.
1 For the mission that Congress had "directed" Ezekiel Cornell to undertake, see James M. Varnum to William Greene, April 21, 1781, note 1.
2 See Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, April 27 and May 1, 1781.
It is probable you will have heard that the Answers to my Letters to Bennington were taken in the last Mail that was robbed and are published by Rivington.(1) I will send the Paper inclosed in this Letter if I can get it. The Publication I suppose will do very little Hurt to either of us. You will see by it how the Matter stands & that if Royaltown be all foreclosed they are willing to vest You with other Lands to the same Value. If this is agreeable let me know without Delay & I should think it would not be amiss to send up an Express which I would willingly bear half the Charge of in order to do some Business for me also.(2) I think I could get one to go upon reasonable terms from Princeton.
We have no News here but what is published in the Papers only the Money having received a terrible Shock I hope it will compel Congress & the States to take other Measures than they have hitherto done & rely no more upon Paper.
I have the Honour to be Your Excellency's most obedt humble Servant, Jno Witherspoon
1 For "the Answers to my letters to Bennington" from Thomas Chittenden and Matthew Lyon that were published in the New York Royal Gazette on April 21, see Witherspoon to Livingston, February 3, 1781, note 2.
2 Livingston had been granted the 30,000 acre township of Royalton by New York in 1766 and was seeking confirmation of his title to the unsold land or a substitute
Mr. Samuel Curson and his Partner Mr. Isaac Governeur junr. after St. Eustatius was taken were put on board the Vengeance Man of War, Comdore. Hotham, to be sent to England stripped of every Thing but their wearing apparel, their Books, Papers & Slaves having been taken from them and Mrs. Governeur with a young Infant turned out of Doors. Special Severity, it is supposed, has been shewn to them in Consequence of their acting as Agents to Congress. Doctor John Witherspoon junr. also who was Surgeon of the De Graaf Letter of Marque taken at St. Eustatius, is sent to England in the Alemena man of War and very hardly treated on Account of his Fathers being a member of Congress, as is supposed.(1)
Your particular attention to the Exchange of these Persons will tend to give a general Confidence to all who being connected specially with Congress are exposed to Captivity, and will also very particularly oblige the Relations of these Unfortunates who have requested Congress to mention these Circumstances to you.(2)
Your most humble Servant, James Lovell, for the Comte. of for. Affrs.
1 For John Witherspoon's efforts to obtain aid for his son, see Witherspoon to Richard Henry Lee, May 19, and to Franklin, June 15, 1781.
2 Although Franklin responded to Lovell in September that it would be difficult to arrange an exchange for Curson and Gouverneur, the release of young Witherspoon had already been obtained, and he was able to report to Witherspoon's father in November that the son had arrived safely in France and was preparing to return to America. See Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:708-9, 847.
For a detailed account of Franklin's aid to American naval prisoners in England,
I had begun to write to you, to go by Post yesterday, but fell upon a Topic not fit to be trusted in that way, and therefore covered you a news Paper under a few Words of Intelligence. I had a private Occasion to write afterwards to Mr. Gerry somewhat largely about money, and therefore do not add any Thing to the inclosed Scrawl, persuaded that he will converse with you respecting my Letter and the Positon of your Delegates here.(1) But I must not refrain from adding that their private Embarrassments are but a small Clue towards explaining their public. Congress without their money Presses, depending on the punctual Supplies of the States are, at this critical Period of the Campaign, as a Set of Clockmakers from whom an Orrery or Microcosm is expected tho' their Hands are evidently struck with the dead Palsy.
I shall trouble you not again with any private Concerns. If I can hobble up Street I will endeavor to make the Backwardness of the Printer of the Journals less & less a Disadvantage by giving you often manuscript Heads of what you ought to know.
Affectly. & with Esteem, Yrs. J.L.
1 See Lovell to Elbridge Gerry, May 8, 1781.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed the Copy of a Resolve of the 8th Instant requesting the State of Connecticutt to use every Exertion in their Power to remount Colonel Sheldons Regiment and equip them with such accoutrements as they can furnish to enable them to take the Field.(1)
I have the Honor to be, with very high Regard, Your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President (2)
1 See JCC, 20:490.
2 Huntington also wrote a brief letter on May 9 to John Deshon of New London, Conn., notifying him that Congress had accepted his resignation from the navy board of the eastern department as requested. See JCC, 20:482-83; and PCC, item 15, fol. 286, item 78, 7:383-86.
My engagement with Dr. Mortimer and exchanges of State paper for Continental before I left Virginia will prove a considerable loss to me as a few days before my arrival in this City a Resolution of the Executive Council respecting the Exchange had given a mortal stab to the old money (2) which now will not pass and if it does it will be at a depreciation of 200 for one as the State paper is 175 and between that and Specie there is five for one. What effect this step will have in Virginia requires no great degree of penetration to foresee. The Executive being speedily apprised of the measure will no doubt direct the Treasurer not to exchange the new for the old at one for forty untill the meeting of the Assembly that their determination May be had upon the matter and then it is to be presumed Virga. will avail herself of the depreciation and call in their quota at least at 175 for one-in short these strokes of Pensylvania and New Jersey will I think put an end in great measure to paper circulation unless it be a small quantity in aid of Specie. I beg you to inform me what steps are taking abt. the money and whether it will be for my advantage to send abt. 9000 dols. of the old money I have by me to Virginia or keep it here submiting to the loss. I need not inform you how much my Finances are deranged by this measure depending chiefly upon the old money and a little of the new Virga. one for forty for present supply. Indeed not only myself but the whole delegation are put to their shifts-leave no stone unturned I beseech you to furnish me the money left in your hand. I shall be diligent you may suppose to obtain money here for draft upon Virga. but from what I hear fear it will be impracticable unless in favour of some persons going to the Southward. I have nothing of news worth mentioning or wod. give it you. Our best wishes attend your Family & believe me, Yr. Friend & Servt. Jos. Jones
1 For information about Hunter, see these Letters, 15:235.
2 For this May 2 resolution of the Pennsylvania Council, see Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, May 5, 1781. For Jones' explanation that he did not resume his congressional seat immediately upon returning to Philadelphia because of "private matters requiring my attention," see Jones to Washington, May 16, 1781.
I do myself the honor to enclose you an Act of the United States, appointing Thomas Hutchins Geographer to the southern army, with the same pay and emoluments as are allowed to the geographer to the main army.(1)
Mr. Hutchins is a native of New Jersey, and was many years in the English service, where he held the rank of Captain and Engineer; But having suffered considerably for his attachment to the American Cause he, in the begining of the last year made his escape from England & got to France; from whence he brought a letter from Doctr. Franklin stating his sufferings & recommending him to the favorable notice of Congress as a good Officer and excellent Engineer.
Mr. Hutchins is desirous of knowing the pay & emoluments allowed to the Geographer to the main army, and as I do not recollect any resolution of Congress fixing them I take the liberty of applying to you and shall be much obliged for information on the subject.(2)
I am, with great respect, Sir, Your most obedie[nt] and most humble servant, Cha Thomson
1 For Hutchins' appointment, See JCC, 19:187, 339, 20:475-76, 738. The enclosed resolve appointing him to this post was sent to Hutchins with a brief cover letter from President Huntington dated May 8. PCC, item 15, fol. 284.
2 For Washington's May 29 response to Thomson explaining the provisions made heretofore for the support of the geographer of the United States and his assistants, see Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:130.
Your agreeable favor reachd me last week too late to be answerd by the Post, but that I may not subject myself to the reproach of Taciturnity, which my Friends in Virginia so liberally bestow on me when they have the least shadow of reason for so doing, I am determined not to let this post escape without adding my Pittance to his Budget. I need not repeat again how much you ought all to be thankfull to me for giving you such frequent tokens of my affection and (long ones too) of my remembrance amidst the Hurry of Business & pleasure which this place affords-the latter of which with a good portion of the hours alotted to sleep I often Sacrifice on the Alter of Friendship-therefore do not condemn me when you do not receive letter for letter-flash for flash-or Dash for dash-but write on-
Theok. Bland
[P.S.] Give me an accurate General detail of the transactions of the British army and of ours in your next, and particularly of the Enemy Quond my Property and that of my Father, I have heard of my man Joe, & shall I Excuse yet him again-The Minister of France has promised to have him [....]
1 This day Bland also wrote to his sister "Fanny," Frances Bland Tucker, describing for effect his "melancholy" situation in Philadelphia and himself as a man "who has
2 "Fortunate is he whom the dangers of others have rendered cautious." Alfred Henderson, Latin Proverbs and Quotations (London: Sampson Low, Son, & Marston, 1869), p. 122.
3 Bland had been preoccupied with this subject since the introduction of a March 12 committee report drafted by James Madison which proposed that Congress be conferred with coercive powers sufficient to enforce the newly-adopted Articles of Confederation, for which See JCC, 20:469-71; Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:1720; and James Varnum to William Greene, March 16, 1781, note 3. Consideration of the report had been delayed until May 2 when Bland was appointed to a "grand committee" assigned to revise it. At some time between the introduction of the report and the conclusion of his work on the grand committee, Bland apparently drafted the following queries, although the use to which he put them remains unclear.
"Is Congress capable of Legislating for 13 States, whose laws, whose Constitutions, whose adminstrations, whose genius differs in so many respects?
"Would not the first attempt to Legislate-if opposed-produce a Civil war-must not coercion be used-what powers of Coercion have Congress in their hands?
"An Coercion might be used against the states-prohibitory laws against their commerce-distraint on their property.
"But suppose the states shd. side with the Edicts of Congress & only a district oppose-the interference of one part of the state against the other wd. be unconstitutional-the coercion of Congress ineffectual. Wd. not a State standg. out against the edicts of Congress, when coercion was about to be used, strengthen itself with alliances of other states? Wd. not this effectually break the Union-or wd. it not if it found that impracticable have recourse to foreign aid-this wd. most effectually destroy not only the Union." Bland Papers, ViHi.
For the views of his colleagues, Madison and Joseph Jones, on this subject, see Madison to Thomas Jefferson, April 16, 1781.
4 That is, Maj. Gen. William Phillips, who was in command of the British troops then ravaging Virginia.
An express just setting out gives me an opportunity of enclosing this days paper. By some accident no Letter came by the Vessel from L'Orient as I am informd, not even to the Merchants who have goods on board. The Capt & an intelligent passenger say, that three fleets saild from Brest abt. the 20th of March, supposd to be destind for North America, the West & East Indies. Captn. Josiah left L'Orient the 27th of March. I will endeavour to see the passenger & be more particular by next post. I am very unwilling to write any thing I hear at second or third hand.
I have the Honor to be Yr Excellencys Most Obt Servt.
Danl. Carroll
P.S. The passenger, I am told, left Ireland not much more than 2 Mos. past, & says that a number of the Volunteer Associators having
You will receive enclosed, an Act of Congress of the 8th Instant, among other things, directing that the Chaplains of the several State Lines be arranged so as to retain in Service no more Chaplains of each Line than are equal to the Number of Brigades, that the Supernumeraries be certified to the Board of War and be no longer continued in Service &c.(1)
Yesterday a Vessel arived in this Port from L'Orient. She brings Advice that a Fleet sailed from France seven Days before she sailed, consisting of about ten Ships of the Line and a large Number of Troops on Board, supposed to be destined for America. We hope soon to receive a Confirmation of this Account with the Particulars more certain. This Vessel brings no Despatches, but from the best Enquiry I can make it appears sufficiently certain that a very considerable French Fleet had sailed from France, their Destination Number of Ships & Troops is Matter of Opinion.
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c, S.H.
1 See JCC, 20:487-88.
I arrived at this place last evening & tomorrow I intend to go to Congress.(1) I have the pleasure to find Genl Sullivan well & as Our State has had no vote in Congress for Some time past he is determined to tarry here for the present. There is nothing here so interesting as the present fluctuation of paper currency. The old continential is as low as 500 for one. Our State new emission is not known here as Pensylvania have not emitted their new emission of Continental but made an emission of their own State mony in stead of it. Connecticut did the like. So that I had the utmost difficulty to travel thro' Connecticut, York, Jersy & Pensylvania on paper mony. And being here I cant live one day on our State mony. Their own
It is said a French fleet is hourly expected in America as a vessel is arrived here that left France several days after them. And the Brittish are retreating at the Southward. I shall inform from time to time of whatever turns up that is interesting to the State or to the united States & beg the favour of a line from you per return of the Post.
I am Sir your most obedient humble Servant.
Samuel Livermore
P.S. I think on farther information that our old acquaintance & friend Paper mony is going to be ranged out.
1 For the presentation of Livermore's credentials to Congress on May 14, See JCC, 20:498-99.
2 Livermore returned to this subject in the following brief letter to Weare of May 19.
"In my last I proposed drawing on the State for one hundred pounds for reasons therein set forth; but not meeting with an oportunity to draw for that sum, I have this day drawn for one hundred & thirty three dollars & one third of a dollar.
"As this mony has been advanced by Mr. Pringle meerly to oblige me, I ask the favour of you that the bill may be immediately honourd." Weare Papers, MHi.
I have been detained here since the first of this Month for want of Money to enable me to leave the City and to pay my travelling Expences, to Virginia. Such is the State of Things in this City that it is difficult to obtain a daily Subsistance; owing to the violent Shocks the Credit of the paper Currency hath received. I hope the Evil will
I have the Honor to be, with very great Esteem, Sir, Yr. most obedt. servt. M. Smith
1 Smith was apparently writing in anticipation that the work of the "ways and means" committee to which he had been appointed on May 8 would be presented "tomorrow." The committee did in fact submit a report on the 14th, although debate on it was prolonged until the 22nd, when its recommendations were adopted and ordered distributed to the states, for which See JCC, 20:500-502, 523-25, and Samuel Huntington to the States, May 24, 1781. Smith apparently did not obtain his "travelling Expences" to attend the Virginia assembly, however, for he remained in Philadelphia until early September. JCC, 21:925, 930.
The United States in Congress have this Day received Intelligence of so alarming a Nature that they think it their indispensible Duty immediately to forward it to you; and at the same Time to assure you that upon a serious Review of public Affairs they are convinced that unless the several States immediately & punctually comply with the Acts & Requisitions of Congress the worst of Consequences must ensue.(1)
Had the States paid due Attention to the Act of 18th March 1780 and complied with the Requisition of the 26th August, the Quarter Master would have been in Capacity to do his Duty and to have forwarded the Supplies which the States were called upon to furnish by the Act of 4th November. But as that has not been done the States must now not only furnish the Supplies but they must also forward them to the Places where they are wanted. For this purpose I enclose an earnest Recommendation passed this Day upon Receipt of the Intelligence above mentioned, and flatter myself that from the Necessity of the Case, your State will strain every Nerve & exert every Power to send forward the Supplies & prevent the fatal Events which must otherwise inevitably ensue.
I have the Honor to be &c, S.H.(2)
1 Huntington enclosed herewith an extract from Washington's May 8 letter to Congress explaining the extreme shortage of provisions at several posts in the northern and eastern states, and a May 14 congressional resolve calling upon the states from New Hampshire to Pennsylvania "to forward on to such place as the
Washington's letter had been received this day and immediately referred to a committee which reported within a short time the resolve Congress adopted and Huntington enclosed with this letter. See JCC, 20:499, 502; and PCC, item 24, fols. 215-16, item 152, 10:97-100. For the discrepancy between the journals and the endorsement on Washington's letter about the composition of the committee to which it was referred, See JCC, 20:499n.3.
2 Huntington apparently did not send a copy of this letter to Pennsylvania, choosing instead to direct a slightly different version to Pres. Joseph Reed on May 19. See Pa. Archives, 1st ser. 9:124, 134, 151.
The Circulation of the old Continental Bills is at an End in this City, and the same Effect will doubtless take Place through this and the adjoining States in a few Days. The Time limited for its Circulation by the late Law of the State expires the first of June. The Limitation is already expired in Maryland as affixed by their Law, it is probable that the late Publication of the President and Council of this State ascertaining the Rate of Exchange which is contained in the inclosed Papers (1) hath had some Effect in contracting the Period limited by Law for the Circulation of those Bills in this State. I am told that the old Continental Bills may be now obtained here for Specie at the Rate of five hundred Dollars of the former for one of Silver. As it is easy to suppose those Bills will circulate no considerable Time longer in any State, at least Northward of Pennsylvania, I cannot forbear to express my Wishes that the honorable General Assembly might immediately adopt such Mode as in their Wisdom shall appear most proper to call in the Quota of the old Bills assigned to Connecticut.
Information which I have received from different Ways, saith that the Assembly have had in Contemplation not to issue any of the new Bills emitted in Pursuance of the Resolve of the 18th March 1780, this may be a wise Measure if the Exigencies of Government & of the Continent will permit the Measure. At any Rate I would hope, not more than the four tenths assigned for the Use of the United States, should ever be issued: although I am of Opinion, had the Resolve of the 18th of March been carried into Execution without Loss of Time agreeable to the Intention of it, it might have proved the best Means & procured the greatest Relief respecting the Finances that the Nature of the Case could admit; yet by the great Delay of many of the States in their Compliance, on Paper only, and all of them in Fact, in carrying their Acts into Execution, the Plan is in a great
Mr Brown the Bearer will deliver your Excellency a Pamphlet published by Order of Congress, containing the Constitutions of Government in all the States, the Declaration of Independence, Treaty with France & Articles of Confederation. I have also forwarded by the same Conveyance a Number of the Journals of Congress for the Use of the State.
The Request to obtain the Invalids belonging, to Connecticut to be stationed & employed in that State, I fear will not be obtained. The Matter is yet undetermined.(2) The Petition of the Soldiers from Westmoreland is not granted.(3) If the Connecticut Line was full without them they might obtain their Discharge.
I fear the Delegates from Connecticut have met with some Misfortune by the Way, their Chariot Wheels are long in coming.
I have the Honor to be, with every Sentiment of Esteem & Regard, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
1 For the May 2 declaration of the Pennsylvania Council changing the rate of exchange between Continental dollars and specie from 75:1 to 175:1, see Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, May 5, 1781, note. The council's declaration and a subsequent explanation of this change were published in the May 5 and 8 issues respectively, of the Pennsylvania Packet and appeared together in the Freeman's Journal of May 9.
2 Huntington was obviously confused, inasmuch as "The Matter" had been determined in mid-March and he had already informed Trumbull of Congress' rejection of Connecticut's request. See Huntington's second letter to Trumbull March 24, 1781, note 2. For a somewhat similar anomaly involving Huntington's correspondence with the governor, see note 2 to his first letter to Trumbull of the same date.
3 With his March 7 letter to Huntington, Trumbull had enclosed two January 23 petitions from the Connecticut troops at Westmoreland which were read and referred to the Board of War on April 5, 1781. Citing continuous hazardous duty since 1777 and the exposed position of their post in the Wyoming Valley, the Westmoreland troops had requested release from their assignment. No recommendation from the Board of War or formal action by Congress on these petitions has been discovered but for Trumbull's letter and the enclosed petitions, See JCC, 19:353; PCC, item 41, 10:538-41, 544-47, item 66, 2:188-89; and Susquehannah Co. Papers, 7:79-82.
My official Despatches to your Excellency which accompany this will shew the alarming Situation of the Army and Posts to the Northward on Account of Provisions. I have long since been convinced that the present Method of Supplying the Army with Provisions by requisitions on the several States, a Method dictated
Congress in the mean Time are endeavoring to devise other Means if possible more eligible to feed the Army, to be put in Practice as soon as possible, but without Money nothing can be done. The Delegates from Connecticutt who lately left Congress will be able to represent the distressing Situation of public Affairs from the State of our Finances, yet at the same Time from all Accounts we can collect there are plentiful Resources in the Country.
By our last Intelligence from the Southward General Greene with his Troops were before Cambden. That Post is fortified with strong Redoubts it is said, but no regular Fort. The Enemy about seven hundred. Whether General Greene will be able to reduce the Post Time will discover. It is to be feared he hath not heavy Artillery sufficient and at any Rate he will not think it prudent to continue a long Siege in that Climate at this Season.
I have the Honor to be, with very great Esteem & Respect, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble servant,
Sam. Huntington
By a Letter of the 1st, this Moment recd.,(1) I find that my amiable & respected Friend is under the mistake of supposing the Enemy in Possession of one of her former which has reached me, and that I have neglected to answer some others. She will know better before this reaches her. The Enemy have the one which attended Mr. Cranche's:(2) So that I have no Knowledge of the Mode He or She particularly pointed out for forwarding the Goods in my Possession.
I have had the Satisfaction of knowing that Mr. Hugh Hughes has well guarded, by boxing, what I committed to Doctr. Winship and I have this day desired Mr. Brown, who setts off with a Light Waggon, to take the Box from Mr. Hughes and deliver it to Mrs. Lovell who has my former Directions about the Contents which are for different Persons. I was not able to send by Mr. Brown your large Box or the China. He goes greatly loaded from hence, but as he drops part of his Charge at Head Quarters, he can conveniently take what I have mentioned, at Fishkill, if it has not yet been sent on by the Kindness of Mr. Hughes.(3) The Enemy have published one Letter from Mr.
I have endured much pain lately from a Fall; I shall not soon be free from the ill Effects. But I have been very stoical, For it would have been a Shame to groan at what happened, while I reflected that neither Back nor Limb was broken, nor any Joint absolutely dislocated. Portia will however do me the Justice to think that neither Pain or afffliction shall make me neglect Endeavors to render her Service in finishing the little Business of sending on her Invoice or rather her Goods. I have written for the Invoices agreable to her Hints.
I imagine that some of the articles supposed missing are in the Band Box, and that Mr. Wibert may find some Things within his Package of Cloth, which was in so good order as not to need opening. I have so thoroughly packed the Case for Transportation, that I do not incline to make a Scrutiny anew of the Contents.
Dr. Lady, Yrs. JL
1 Not found.
2 Also not found, but see ibid., pp. 111-12, 115n.2.
3 See Hugh Hughes to Abigail Adams, May 21, 1781, ibid., pp. 119-20.
4 That is John Adams' December 28, 1780, letter to Samuel Huntington, which had been published in the New York Mercury, April 19, 1781, extraordinaire.
5 That is, Charles W. F. Dumas, whose January 23-25, 1781, letter was read in Congress on April 27. See JCC, 20:452; and PCC, item 93, 1:491-95.
Mr. Brown went from hence this morning; and has in his Light Waggon a Case, formerly a Bottle Case, which he is to deliver to Mrs. L____who is not to open it till she hears further from me. The Case is for you; containing only yr. property, except 4 Journals and 9 Pamphlets for Mr. Secretary Avery. You will find therein such an addition to what was sent by Doctr. Winship (and which will also now be delivered by Mrs. L____ if not before in yr. Possession) as will compleat yr. Invoice, except the Chintz, the fine Linnen, your Whip, and a Yard of the coarse Linnen which is to be accounted for when you hear further about the Chintz. A small Ps. of the worst of yr. blue Cloth is put in the Case as a Sample of the uncommon Injury which moisture & Heat effected. I am long without any of yr. Favors.
I suspect some private hand has them on the Road. You have Letters from the General and will see an Officer sent by him so that I need not say any Thing (1) only "for God Sake believe what is written & said by them."
I attend Congress, but I am a Cripple & in great Pain. I think, however, that I shall speedily get the free Use of my Hip as the Weather grows warm.
Our Intelligence from the Southward is far, very far from pleasing. Cornwallis is on his Way to Hilsborough and Philips with all the advantages of Water Transportation is contriving a Junction.
Affectly. Yrs. JL
1 Lovell is undoubtedly referring to the mission of Gen. William Heath, who under orders of General Washington was to deliver letters and his personal pleas for "supplies for the Army" to the New England governors. Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:63-66.
Congress have received letters from the Marquis De la Fayette and Govr. Jefferson dated the 8th and 9th instant (1) by which we are informed that Genl. Philips, after great destruction of Tobacco, Ware houses &c, advanced to Manchester on the South bank of James's river opposite to Richmond and summoned the Marquis and required him to be answerable for some vessels Iying in the north side of the river, about the same time Arnold with 600 troops passed the river a little below who being furiously attacked by about 30 of Nelsons horse, Arnold retreated and recrossed the river with the utmost precipitation and disorder. Genl. Phillips then retreated d[own river?] and embarked his troops. I believe on the 5[th the] enemy relanded on the south side of James [River and by?] the 8th were beyond Petersb[urgh...] (2) to join Lord Cornwal[lis...](3) Wilmington and Halliftax ...].(4)
On the 26th of last month Genl. Greene was before the enemies post at Camden which he discovered to be much stronger than was apprehended. It is probable we may gain the post; but I fear a plan is formed to intercept Genl. Greene on his return from that place-time only can discover the enemys disign or the event of the var[ied] and complicated opperations to the southward.
We have alarming apprehensions for want of provisions for the northern army. The Executive of this State gives no reason to expect any farther supply until the Assembly meets-on the 24th of this month. They have resolved to emit no more of their £500,000 before they have the directions of the Assembly.
By Capt. Josiah who sailed from L'Orient on the 26th of March we are informed that the Frigate Alliance with the Fayette loaded with Cloathing &c under convoy were to sail the next day. He also says that a large French fleet sailed from Brest on the 20th March-one squadron of which was destined for America-one for the west Indias & one for the East Indias. This division of the fleet must be only, conjecture at L'Orient.
I am in pain for the Cloathing &c. The enemy have three Frigates cruising off the capes of Delaware. [I hope?] Mrs. Duane will excuse the liberty when I [attempt?] to make [my] best compliments to her & [to your family?]. [I am,] dear Sir, very respectfuly, Your most Obt Humble Servt. Wm. Sharpe
1 Copies of Lafayette's May 8 and Jefferson's May 9 letters to Congress were enclosed in the Board of War's May 13 letter to Washington, all of which are in the Washington Papers, DLC. Although the former were read in Congress this day, neither is in PCC. See JCC, 20:49.
2 Three or four words missing.
3 Three or four words missing.
4 Three or four words missing.
The late Scale of Depreciation as laid down by the Presidt. & Council of this State has thrown every thing into Confusion; no Money except hard will pass in this City but at the most ruinous rate. Our Northern Army is Starving, & Congress have it not in their power to remove one hundred barrels of Flour.
I received from the Treasurer of our State Three hundred & forty pounds of the New Emission in Consequence of an Order from the Gov. & Council, (2) part of this Money I exchanged for Continental being told it was Money that was prefered in Phila. to any other paper. On my way up I met Numbers of Speculators from Phila with quantities of Continental to pass it off in our State. How they succeeded I know not, but that, nor any other paper will now pass in this City but at the most Destructive rate. I have therefore returned the Continental To Mr Stone in hopes the Assembly will give directions to the Treasurer to receive this Money in exchange for Bills of the New Emission. I should also have returned the New Bills (for I cannot pass them here) but they are too bulky. What the Maryland Dilegates will do for want of Money I do not know, there is but one Mode by which they can be supplyed ie, to order a quantity of Superfine flour to be Manufactured at the Head of the Bay, Superfine flour will command hard Money. Should this plan be adopted by the assembly or the Governor & Council Mr. Joseph Gilpin will execute it with dispatch. Coll. Hollingsworth has too
Our affairs are in a most wretched situation. Congress is at its wits End, everything at a stand and unless the French fleet & Army arrive very soon we shall in all probability be in the most deplorable situation.
The Navigation of the Mississippi has prevented us from procuring Supplies from Spain, Congress have relaxed & made this point in the Ultimatum Negotiable, but too late for any Supplies for this Campaign. The Emperor has offered his Mediation. I fear that there is too good an Understanding between the Courts of Vienna & London.
We have received no late advices from Europe. With my respectful Compliments to Mrs Hall I am, Dear Sir, Your affectionate friend, Daniel of St. Thos Jenifer
[P.S.] The Back Lands as a fund will be attempted in a day or two.
1 For former congressional delegate Hall, see Bio. Dict. of Md. Leges., 1:381988.
2 For the Maryland Council's April 28 order to the western shore treasurer to pay Jenifer $1,500 "on Account," see Md. Archives, 45:419.
Mr. Livermore arrived here three days ago (2) and gave me the first Intelligence of you since you left Morris Town. I wrote on the 20th of Feby. and the 27th, the 5th of March(3) and I believe oftner without getting a Line from you or being able to know whether you were alive.
I find that yr. Case of Lancetts was left at Fishkill with some other Things among which it was packt. I imagine it will reach you by this conveyance, as Mr. Brown the Express has promised to take those Things on from Fishkill to Boston and I formerly wrote Mrs L____ how to forward to you the Instruments on her receiving them. I long ago told you that I could not make confidential Communications but by private Hands. I sent my first Letters to Presidt. Weare agreably to yr. Request.
Mrs. Cordis's Father is most dangerously ill here, if he is alive. I have been so bruised by a Fall into the Cellar of a new House which I mistook for the Opening of an Alley on a very dark drizly Evening that I have not been able to go to see Capt. Russel nor have I heard
I will not miss any good Oppy. of sending on yr. Box of Goods. I have not yet had one tho' I have been watchful.
Yr. Friend affect. J L
1 Although clearly dated "May 25," this letter was certainly written on May 15, "three days" after the May 12 arrival of Samuel Livermore in Philadelphia, which Lovell reported in his opening sentence.
2 After arriving on May 12, Livermore attended Congress on May 14. See Livermore to Meshech Weare, May 13; and JCC, 20:498.
3 None of these letters has been found.
The late scale of depreciation setled by the Presidt. and Council of this State, has had such an effect upon the Minds of the people at large in this City, that no paper Money will pass but upon the most ruinous terms; nor will it be in our power to continue here without Your Excellency and the Council can fall upon some other Mode of Supply than that of Paper Money.(1) We know of but one, and that is to direct the Grinding up some Wheat at the head of the Bay into Superfine Flour: this Article will command hard Money without which, nothing can be done at this place. Mr. Joseph Gilpin would undertake this business and execute it with dispatch. Coll. Hollingsworth the Commy Genl. has too much on his hands to allow him to pay proper attention to this Mode of Supply, besides he might be from the head of Elk when the Order might reach that place, and our situation is such that delay would be distressing.
We have the honor to be with the highest esteem, Sir, Your Excellencys Most Obedt. Servants, Daniel of St Thos Jenifer
Daniel Carroll
1 For the Council's "other Mode of Supply," see Maryland Delegates to Lee, May 30, note 2.
Since my Last I have had the pleasure of being Joined by Mr Livermore; he had much difficulty in getting here with the assistance of paper money (only) and finds himself unable to pass it here
I have been favoured with your Excllencys Letter and considered it carefully.(1) I am glad to find that the Publication by Rivington of the two Letters has done no Manner of Hurt.(2) The most part do not seem to understand them, or to give themselves any Concern about the Subject of them. Of those who do understand them I have not met with any Person who finds the least Fault. It seems by the Letter, that it is still uncertain whether your Part of Royaltown has been so far granted away as to be incapable of being recalled. I do not think it probable that they could turn your Land into Money easily at any tollerable Price & therefore I think in Case it is gone it would be best to accept of the offer they make in a certain Manner. It would certainly not be proper for you to apply in your own Name to the Official Persons of that Government but you might make out a List of names of Persons who could release to you which used to be the Way in old Times of taking out Grants and if you communicate them to me I would send them to Mr Leon or Mr Tichener (3) or Some Persons who would take Care of the affair.
Probably the Matter may bear a Delay of 10 Days & therefore as I return to Princeton the End of next Week by Agreement with Mr Houston (4) I shall converse with You on the Subject.
I am Your Excellencys most obedt., humble Servant,
Jno. Witherspoon
1 In his May 10 letter to Witherspoon, Livingston stated that he preferred to keep possession of his Royalton lands or sell them rather than to make an exchange for "an equivalent," and asked Witherspoon's assistance, because "you have a correspondence with individuals of influence" in Vermont. William Livingston Papers, MHi.
2 See Witherspoon to Livingston, February 3 and May 8, 1781.
3 Witherspoon is probably referring to Matthew Lyon and Isaac Tichenor. For his correspondence with Lyon, see Witherspoon to Livingston, February 3, 1781, note 2. Tichenor (1754-1838), a former student of Witherspoon's at the College of New Jersey, had moved to Bennington in 1777 as an assistant commissary general of purchases. He served in the Vermont legislature, 1781-85, and was a Vermont agent to Congress, 1782-89. DAB; and Richard A. Harrison, Princetonians, 1769-1775 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980), pp. 528-36.
4 That is, William C. Houston, with whom Witherspoon often alternated attendance at Congress and faculty duties at the College of New Jersey. Although he had returned to New Jersey at the beginning of the month, Houston wrote the following letter to Governor Livingston from Trenton on May 18, reflecting his continuing concern with congressional responsibilities while away from Philadelphia.
"Sir, Herewith I take the Liberty of committing to your Care the Journals of Congress for November and December last. Ever since the State was pleased to honour me with an Appointment to Congress, I have been careful to send the Journals from Time to Time as soon as they were published, and I early wrote proposing that the Copy sent for each County might be lodged in the Clerk's office thereof, as the most proper Place of deposit. If they ought to be sent, they ought to be preserved. How far the Idea has been approved, or carried into Practice, I do not know. A Copy for the Council and one for the Assembly has also been constantly sent, that they might have a File of them for Use.
"I am sorry I cannot [send] those for the past Months of the present Year. None are yet published, and for one plain honest Reason that we have not Money to pay the Printer. The President, however, will have transmitted to Your Excellency, in Manuscript, all the most material Proceedings.
"A Collection of the Constitutions of the several States was some Time since published by order of Congress, and I received 10 Copies as the Quota of New Jersey, which I intended to have forwarded by this Time. But some Difficulty having been started by the Committee who superintended the Publication, I do not know whether I shall not be called upon to return them. I must therefore wait at least for Explanation, before I can venture them forward. With much Respect I am Your Excellency's obdt. Servt. W. C. Houston." Livingston Papers, NN.
Having returned to Congress a few days only (1) and private matters requiring my attention for great part of the time I have not been able regularly to attend to Business or to acknowledge the receipt of your favour(2) transmitted to Philadelphia after my leaving it and sent after me to Virginia by Mr. Madison. The moment for successfull operations agt. our Enemies was certainly immediately after the disaster in Gardners Bay when had it been embraced the Post at Portsmouth and the Troops' under Arnold as well as the British Ships then in Virginia must have fallen an easy conquest to our united efforts for which purpose the State was I believe in readiness. Abortive as the project has proven we yet hope for the best and that still it may be in the Power of our Ally to give us effectual aid in Chesapeake and believe me at no time was it more necessary than at present when all the lower Country of our State from its great
1 The date that Jones "returned to Congress" is not noted in the journals, but he is recorded as voting on Monday, May 14.JCC, 20:503. For his return to Philadelphia the previous week, see Jones to James Hunter, May 10, 1781.
2 For Washington's March 24 letter to Jones, see Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 21:371-74.
3 See the following entry, note 2.
I am favored with yours of the 11th Instant covering the Extract of Intelligence received from Colonel Dayton which proves to be premature.(1)
Enclosed is the Copy of a Letter this Moment received from a confidential Person giving the latest authentic Intelligence received relative to the Movements of the British Fleet,(2) though a Report prevails that they have since actually sailed, but the Truth of this Report remains to be more fully ascertained.
I have the Honor to be, with the most perfect Respect, your Excellency's most obedient humble servant,
Sam. Huntington
P.S. Your Excys dispatches of the 1st, 8th, & 10th inst. have been receivd.(3)
1 For Washington's May 11 letter and the enclosed intelligence from Col. Elias Dayton dated May 9, see PCC, item 152, 10:115-20; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:72-73, 76.
2 The enclosed letter of May 14, with a May 12 report from an unidentified person at Shrewsbury, NJ., concerning the imminent embarkation of British ships at New York for the Chesapeake, is in the Washington Papers, DLC.
3 Washington's letters of May I and 8 are in PCC, item 152, 10:93-100; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:20-22, 59-61; but no letter to Huntington of May 10 has been discovered. Washington did write a circular letter to the New England states on May 10 (ibid., pp. 68-69) soliciting provisions for the Continental Army, whose distresses and hardships were discussed in his May 8 letter to Congress, but if Huntington is referring here to a copy of that circular letter, none has been found in the PCC.
Doctor Putnam whose Letter is inclosed, by the Uniformity of his Attachment to our public Cause, merits your Patronage; and I inclose also for your Information some former Proceedings of Congress in which this same Gentleman is interested; (1) requesting Sir that you would obtain a Knowledge of the Proceedings consequent upon Efforts which Mr. Gerard has undoubtedly made to obtain Compensation for the Sloop which Count D'Arbaud restored to the Governor of Antigua after it had been taken by Doctor Putnam & others.
Your most humb Servt. James Lovell
1 For the case of Dr. Benjamin Putnam, who had been seeking recompense from the French government for a British sloop he had captured and carried into Guadeloupe, only to have it seized by the French governor, the comte d'Arbaud, and turned over to the British governor of Antigua, See JCC, 15:1022-24; and PCC, item 90, fols. 115-22, 139-51, 160-67.
I was Last Evening honored with your Excellencys favor of the 11th Instant.(1) I am sorry that the report respecting promotions has been so long Delayed, but this delay has not been Occasioned by any Difference in Sentiment between your Excellency and the Committee. Your reasonings were attended to & there remains no Difference of Sentiment between us though perhaps Congress may make some alterations Disagreable to us all.
The Report has Long Since been made to Congress & two Days have already been Spent in Considering it & I flatter myself that this Day will bring it to a Conclusion.(2) The Situation of Colo. Tilghman and other Gentlemen of that Line has opened a Field Extensive Enough & Occasioned Much delay. I hope however to obtain Such a determination as will do Justice to the feelings of Those Gentlemen who have Merited so Much from the public.(3) I Lament exceedingly the Distresses of our Army, the deplorable Situation of our Public affairs and tremble for the Event. Mr. Robert Morris has Accepted the office of Minister of Finance upon which I Sincerely congratulate your Excellencey & my Country.
The appointment of the other officers is delayed for reasons which I cannot comprehend. The ostensible one respecting a Minister of War is that There is no man Existing upon whom Congress can agree.(4) Many of the Members Say that if your Excellency or the principal officers would recommend any person they would immediately proceed to the Choice of that officer-& I presume that of Marine as also that of Foreign affairs would follow of Course. We have no News worthy your Excellencys attention.
I have the honor to be, with the most perfect respect, Dear Genl your Excys mos obedt. Servant, Jno. Sullivan
1 See Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:70-72.
2 The plan was adopted on May 25. See Samuel Huntington's second letter to Washington of May 28, 1781.
3 In the plan adopted on May 25, Washington's aide Tench Tilghman was commissioned lieutenant colonel with date of rank from April 1, 1777, and aides-decamp were made eligible "to command upon detachments" at the discretion of the commander in chief or department commanders. JCC, 20:541. See also Committee of Congress to Washington, March 9, 1781, note 3.
4 See Sullivan to Washington, March 6, 1781, note 4.
In Consequence of the late Representation which you have thought proper to lay before the United States in Congress assembled, and in Order to provide a more effectual Remedy for the Abuses practised by the Brittish, Congress have adopted the Resolve of the 17th Instant, a Copy of which is herewith transmitted for your Information.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c, S.H.
1 For Congress' response to the May 9 "Representation" from La Luzerne at issue here, see the following entry.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, the Copy of a Resolve of the 17th Instant, recommending to the several Legislatures to enact Laws making further Provision (as specified in the Resolve) to guard against the Abuses and deceitful Practices of the British, by making Use of Papers & Clearances they may take in American Vessels.(1)
The Measures recommended in this & the former Resolve of the 11th of November 1780 become the more necessary, as our Allies have not only suffered by the Deception of the British, but in several Instances our own People in the West Indies have also suffered from the French, under the Apprehension that they were British, for Want of Evidence & proper Documents to evince the contrary.
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S.H.
1 French officials in the West Indies had been frustrated by the British use of captured "Papers & Clearances" to impersonate American ships officers and spy on French ports, and found that the practice continued even after Congress had resolved the previous November to require "minute" descriptions of the officers of American privateers to prevent the deception. In a May 9 letter to Congress, the French minister La Luzerne complained that the previous resolve was not being enforced and that it would not accomplish its intended purpose unless broadened to "extend to merchant vessels, and in general, to all ships sailing from this continent." The enclosed May 17 resolve, adopted upon the recommendation of the Board of Admiralty to which La Luzerness memorial had been referred, was designed to secure compliance with the French request. See the preceding entry; JCC, 20:491, 513-14; PCC, item 95, 1:204-7; Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:406; and Huntington to La Luzerne, November 13, 1780.
We immediately upon receipt of the Letter you honord us with by Mr Croxall, laid it before Congress, who refered it to a Special Comittee. We have some reason to believe, the measure proposd cannot be carried into execution, as a report on an application to send provision to Charles Town for the prisoners there was rejected. It is therefore probable, the report will go no further, than that the State may send Tobacco for the purposes mentiond. The Board of War having wrote to Genl. Washington to know of Sr. Hy. Clinton whether Tobacco woud be receivd at Charles Town to be disposd of for the use of the prisoners, his answer may likewise determine whether it woud be receivd at New York. We hope to be able to inform you of the determination of Congress by the post (1) & have the Honor to be, with great esteem, Yr. Excellencys Most Obt Serv,
Dan of St Thos Jenifer
Danl Carroll
P.S. We return to the Treasury by Mr. Croxall, the money which was drawn for us-as we can make no use of it here.
1 In their letter of May 10, Lee and the Maryland Council sought Congress' approval "to send a Quantity of Bread, Provisions and Lumber to New-York" to discharge the debts of Maryland officers who were held prisoner there and on Long Island. The bearer, Charles Croxall, would serve as the state's agent in New York. The letter was read in Congress on May 17 and referred to a committee of three. See JCC, 20:515; and PCC, item 70, fols. 465-68. For the Council's May 10 letters to Washington and Croxall, see also Md. Archives, 45:431-32. The May 2 letter from the Board of War to Washington to determine "whether Tobacco woud be receivd at Charles Town" is in the Washington Papers, DLC. His May 16 reply is in Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:93. The committee assigned Lee's letter reported on May 25, whereupon Congress ordered the Board of War to seek permission to send tobacco to New York and Charleston ''sufficient to discharge the arrears due from the American prisoners."JCC, 20:534. See also Maryland Delegates to Lee, June 12, 1781 (1).
A few Days ago I was favoured with yours of the 27th of April by your Brother (1) and do truly feel myself sensibly obliged by your Attention to my Affairs. Your Brother will soon I expect be able to discharge Mr Turbervilles Account only the Interest Bills & indeed all Bills on Europe here Sell very low. They do not bring at present above 5/ this Money a Dollar. I beg you would make my Compliments to Mr Turberville & thank him for his ready compliance with my Desire-The rather this is necessary because from some thing
You must have heard before now of the dreadful Blow which Paper Money of all Kinds has lately received. It is lamentable to think how our Operations are hindered, our Army distressed and our Friends missed by our trusting to Paper Money. Just now My son in law (3) has met with a Stroke of that kind. When he left Virginia he sold his Furniture on Credit has been paid in Paper and his Brother bringing two Weeks ago several thousand Pounds continental Money it perished in his hand in one Week & would not now enable him to travel 50 Miles.
A Committee of Congress of whom I am one have been making a last Effort for putting an End to the Use of Paper but though some of the parts of our System have been adopted I am affraid it will be finally defeated by those still hankering after the partial use of that Deceiver. It is probable you will have the News upon this and other Subjects Sent you fully by your Brother. Some Dispatches came to the Minister of France to Day of which we shall know the Contents on Monday-if there be any thing particularly interesting that can be communicated I shall either write it to You by the Post or tell him that he may write it.
We have got one New Delegate from N.H.(4) but I cannot as yet tell much about his Principles or probable Conduct. Mr. Duane is gone & New York is not represented neither is Connecticut, Rhode Island nor Delaware a Piece of Neglect wholly inexcusable at this Time.
The President of Congress asked Leave lately to go home and a Day was fixed for the Choice of another. The Ballots being taken upon that Day no one had more than two Votes so that we requested the President to continue & it was postponed sine die and I think it probable he will continue till the Fall.(5) I believe if your Colleague Mr Jones would have agreed to serve he would have been chosen. If a New Attempt is made I think either he or Mr Jenifer of Maryland will be the Man. We are all at present very anxious about the Situation of your State & impatiently looking for a greater sea force.
I am D Sir your &c, JW
1 That is, Arthur Lee, who had returned to Philadelphia to settle his accounts with Congress. JCC, 20:522, 574-76; PCC, item 78, 14:433.
2 For the imprisonment of Witherspoon's son, who was released by the British in September after the intervention of Benjamin Franklin, see James Lovell to Franklin, May 9, note 2; and Witherspoon to Franklin, June 15, 1781.
3 That is, Samuel Stanhope Smith.
4 That is, Samuel Livermore.
5 Thomas McKean was elected to succeed Pres. Samuel Huntington on July 10 after Samuel Johnston was chosen but declined to serve. See JCC, 20:490, 492, 724 732-33.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, Copies of four Acts of Congress, viz, one of the 10th Instant with the Memorial of Udney Hay to which it relates;(1) one of the 14th(2) and two of the 15th for your Information.(3)
I have the Honor to be, with very high Regard, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 See JCC, 20:464, 491-92; and PCC, item 41, 4:265-66, 281-82. Udny Hay's April 28 memorial requesting a determination of his rank, and the enclosed May 10 resolve ordering Washington to convene a board of officers to report a recommendation on Hay's claim, are in the Washington Papers, DLC. For Washington's August 18 response to this directive and the August 16 report of the board of officers convened in response to Congress' order, see PCC, item 152, 10:219-23; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 23:18. The board's recommendation, "that Udney Hay Esquire ought to enjoy the rank and emoluments of a retiring Lieutenant Colonel," was offered as a motion in Congress by Ezra L'Hommedieu on September 25, 1781, but there is no indication in the journals that any action was taken on the motion. See /CC, 21:1014n; and PCC, item 36, 1:365.
2 See Huntington to Certain States, May 14, 1781.
3 For these resolves, concerning cannon for Rhode Island and the status of officers of the southern medical department in captivity, See JCC, 20:505-6.
The various accounts we frequently have here, & the want of information from you, puzzles us exceedingly; a thousand conjectures are formed, but your true situation we can learn nothing of. A Man arrived here yesterday one Jennette, who says he left you before Camden on the 27 Ulto. & that it was expected that place would surrender to you in the course of four or five days. This will serve you as a specimen of the reports I have above alluded to. You may readily suppose our anxiety is not small, when we receive such intelligence, to hear something from the fountain head. We so frequently receive similar intelligence which is soon again contradicted, that we are grown callous, & believe nothing, but what we get officially. I hope we shall soon hear from you, & be relieved from this cruel state of doubt & uncertainty; and I flatter myself when it does arrive, it will be pleasing; tho' I must confess, we have little reason to expect st.
Congress have at last put the means in Genl. Waynes hands to march, (1) & I have no reason to doubt, but what he is this day on his march. Had this been done six weeks ago, (which might as well have been then done, as three days ago) he would 'ere this have been with you, & in all probability prevented the present movements of the enemy. But whilst we have men at the head of our affairs, who are uniformly opposed to the least deviation from the plain John trot mode of doing business, whose souls are confined within the compass of a nut shell, & who like Dean Swifts' Peter, Jack, & Martin, tremble at the very Idea of doing any thing that is not strictly injoined them by their fathers Will tho' the salvation of the country depended on it.(2) I say whilst we have such Quidnunc politicians to manage our affairs, we must expect nothing vigorous, or decisive, being done. However they have at length in one instance blundered across the Rubicon (but I believe most of them did it with their eyes shut, as Children do, when they walk in the dark, for fear of meeting the Devil in their way.) I mean the vote that was passed, giving powers to Genl. Wayne, to press provisions on his march, whenever he wanted them. Perhaps you may laugh at my making such a fuss about this affair, as your army is fed by scarcely any other means. But remember there is no such power literally given to Congress by Confederation and to act up to the spirit of it, is a doctrine supposed to be big with many evils, therefore reprobated. I conceive it to be a great point gained, to drive them from this ground; it looks like conceeding the point, & that necessity will oblige them, to interpret the powers given by the Confederation in their utmost extent, & in my opinion, ought upon some occasions, to be strained to answer the great purposes of war. But I apprehend, when these Doughty heroes, have opened their eyes, & looked back,
The backwardness of the States, in executing the requisitions of Congress, is intolerable, & when they do, it is in such a loose, discordant manner, that their small exertions produce little good, from whence principally arises our embarrassments. It therefore appears to me absolutely necessary, & for the true interest of the union, that the several states, should give to Congress Dictatorial powers during the war, & instruct their Delegates, to take the most vigorous measures for prosecuting the war. This power is certainly more safely lodged in the hands of such a body as Congress, than any other. The only objection I have to it, is, that I am afraid, they will want spirit to do their duty, but this may be remedied by spirited instructions. Something like this must soon be done, or as I am clearly convinced our affairs will grow from bad to worse, which must end in our utter ruin. Those states that are in perfect tranquillity, & feel nothing of the effects of the war, will I know, be averse to such a measure, therefore I despair of it's being done, but they will too late find, when the house falls, they will inevitably be crushed in its ruins. We must either stand or fall together. However they may amuse themselves with the Idea of sacrificing some for the good of the whole, the hypothesis will prove fallacious, divida et empera, is an axiom that will prove as certain, as it is old.
I am My Dr. sir, with sentiments of the most sincere Esteem & regard, Your most Obedt. servt. Jno. Mathews
1 See JCC, 20:516.
2 An allusion to Jonathan Swift's satire on the Catholic, Anglican, and Dissenting churches, in section 11 of A Tale of a Tub.
Colonel Derricks will have the Honor of delivering you this.
He is a deserving young Gentleman who hath served some Years in the American Army with Honor & Reputation, but by the late Arrangement of the Army he is out of Service and returning to Holland. (1)
Besides his Connections with several Families of Distinction and Influence in Holland who have shewn strong attachments to the Interests of America, his own personal Merit and the Zeal which he hath manifested in our Cause will, I am perswaded, sufficiently recommend him to your favorable Notice and Attention.
I have the Honor to be, with very high Regard, sir, Your most obedient & most humble servant, Sam. Huntington
1 For the American career of Jacob Gerhard Diriks and Congress' settlement of his compensation for his efforts to promote a Dutch loan, see these Letters, 15:161n.
I hope you are not still without later Dates from Mr. A's Hand, than what we have-Oct. 24.(1) I conclude he was well about the last of Febry. because Mr. Carmichael under Date of March 11th sends us Mr. A's Plan of a Loan to be opened at the House of Nieufville & Son March lst.(2) We have no Vessels from Holland. Accept of my Conjecture as a Proof of my uniform Wish to contribute to your Ease of Mind & genuine Happiness.
I have sent an open 3plicate to Mr. A____ for Mr. Moylan respecting yr. Invoice.(3)
Free from Pain, I shall however limp for many a day.
1 A number of letters from John Adams dated from August 14 to October 24, 1780, had been read in Congress on January 29, 1781. See JCC, 19:96.
2 William Carmichael's March 11, 1781, letter conveying news of John Adams' plan for a Dutch loan of one million florins was read in Congress this day. See JCC, 20:519; PCC, item 88, fols. 135-36; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:279-80.
3 Not found.
Arbuthnots Squadron went from Chesepeak to New York about 3 weeks ago-and on Monday evening last sailed out with some Transports said to have 2000 troops on board. On Friday evening last they were seen near the Capes of Delaware. Their destination is not known. The objects to induce them up this river are nearly as
I suppose that Genl. Wayne has not marched before this time from York Town. The second Division has not arived, tho it is said they sailed from Brest on the 20th March. I fear they will touch at the West Indias & delay there some time, nor has the clothing & Stores arived. It is said they were to sail from L'Orient the 27 March. No word of the Shelala, on board of which was Colo. Palfrey, ariving in Europe. It is supposed she foundered at Sea, Colo. Laurens arived safe in France, but no letters from him nor Doctr. Franklin. By letters from Spain dated 22 Feby & the Hague dated we are informed that the Dutch were making great preparations to avenge themselves on the enemy. That the Northern powers would aid the Dutch. That the King of Prussia & the Emperor had a watchful eye on each other. That our affairs in Spain wear a more flattering aspect than formerly, only one thing stood in the way of something conclusive. Mr. Cumberland was about to leave Madrid. About 2000 Suits of cloaths has arived at Boston from Mr. Jay. The seige of Giberalter continued. Nothing has transpired whereby we can say, what operations Count D Estaing will be engaged in this campaign. It is expected he will be in the West Indias. A Frigate has arived with an Admiral on board to succeed M. Ternay.
The entire use of paper money is nearly at an end. The old is nearly dead-and the new paper here from 6 to 10 for one of specie. I expect all our paper has fallen or will fall entirely in the Southern States-then we shall have to barter. Specie we have none. We have heard of Genl. Greene's disappointment before Camden on the 25th ulto.(1) It is reported that Cornwallis has passed Hallifax on his way to join Phillips.
The comr-in-chief is much embarrassed for want of provisions.
May 22d. Count de Rochambeaus son has returned with dispatches-none appears yet from Docr. Franklin nor Colo. Laurens. Some circumstances induce me to be of opinion that the second division will stay some time in the W. Indias. I wish I may be mistaken.
I hope that Mr. Hill is before this time on his way up, to relieve me. We feel infinite pain for our distressed country. We have got the board of war engaged to repair 2000 muskets & send them forward to our State. You know that with our utmost efforts, this measure may fail.
I am very sincerely, My dear Sir, Your most obt. Humble Servt. Wm. Sharpe
P.S. Letters from Spain say that Mr. Cumberland has returned to England having failed in his object, & That the Emperor is proposing his mediation between the beligerent powers.(2)
1 That is, at the Battle of Hobkirk's Hill, for which see the following entry, note 2.
2 This day Sharpe also wrote a nearly identical letter to Nathanael Greene, with the exception of the following paragraph. "I cannot help ever adminng the firmness and perseverance of your little army who are constantly exposed to weariness, famine, nakedness and the sword. I am pained to my heart for your fatague, trouble and anxiety for the defence of that country. I am not less pained, that you are so little supported from No. Carolina. I flatter myself the enemy's victory on the 25th will eventually be similar to that of Guilford Ct. House." Park Collection, NjMoHP.
I have receivd your favor of the 18th instant & hope by this you have got rid of yr fever. I shall by the first good opportunity send the hat, & Stuff for yr great Coat. The Best Beaver hat cannot be got under £6 to £6.10 Gold. I shall at the same time send you an acct. of the disposition of Your money.
A French frigate is arrivd at Boston. Monsr. Barraus came in her to take the Command of the Squadron at New port in the room of Monsr. Ternay. Genl. Washington writes that he was upon the point of Setting out to meet the Count de Rochambau & Monsr. Barraus to Settle the plan of operations for the Campaign.(1)
The enclosed paper contains the Substance of Genl. Greens Letter.(2) Underneath are mention'd the Officers Killd & wounded of the Maryland line.
I am with great esteem, Yr. Excellencys Most Obt Ser,
Danl. Carroll
[P.S.] Did I ever inform you that I forwarded the Letter for Miss Morris? There is reason to believe abt 2000 British have left N York for the Southward tho' no official information of it.
Lieut. Col. Ford-dangerously wounded-elbow.
Capt. Wm Beatty-Killd.
Cap J Smith (3d Md). prisoner.
Capt. Lieut Bruff-wounded in both ancles.
Lieut N Gassaway slightly wounded.
17 Privates Killd-96 wounded-130 Missing (part since heard of)-of the Virga & Maryland Brigade & Militia.
1 For Washington's letter of May 17 announcing his plans to meet with the comte e Rochambeau at Wethersfield, Conn., see Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:97-98. For the results of the conference, see ibid., pp. 102-7, 119-22; and Freeman, Washington, 5:285-90,
2 Nathanael Greene's letters of April 22 and 27 had been read in Congress on May 21. See JCC, 20:519; and PCC, item 155, 2:39-50. His letter of the 27th describing the April 25 action at Hobkirk's Hill, near Camden, S.C., was summarized in this day's issue of David C. Claypoole's Pennsylvania Packet.
By the enclosed Copy of a Resolve of the 21st Instant you will be informed it is the Sense of Congress, That as from the Situation of public Affairs a Court of Enquiry cannot speedily be held, you are at Liberty to repair to Head Quarters and take such Command as the Commander in Chief shall direct. (1)
While I lament those Impediments which prevent such immediate Enquiry as I am perswaded you would wish to take Place, I presume that the Zeal & Attachment you have at all Times manifested for the Service and Interest of the Confederacy will not suffer her to be deprived of the Services of an experienced and able Officer at this important Crisis.
I have the Honor to be, with very high Regard, sir, Your most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam Huntington President
1 Gates was unhappy that his career had been in limbo since his defeat at the battle of Camden, and he had come to Philadelphia in April to complain of the delay in convening an inquiry that might clear him. His complaint had been referred to Washmgton on April 26, and on May 18 a second complaint along with Washington's response to the previous letter was referred to a committee consisting of Samuel A. Atlee, John Sullivan, and James Mitchell Varnum. The enclosed May 21 resolve embodymg the committee's recommendations was designed to permit Gates to resume active duty, but as he was merely seeking exoneration rather than a return to duty he immediately declined the offer. See JCC, 20:515, 521-22,527; PCC, item 154 2:355-60; Huntington to Washington, April 26, 1781, note 3; and Paul David Nelson General Horatio Gates (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1976), pp. ?58-59. For Congress' response to Gates' rejection of this offer, which apparently included a motion by Varnum for repealing the original order for an inquiry into Gates' conduct in the southern department, See JCC, 20:533; Huntington's first letter to Washington of May 28; and Richard Howly to Gates, June 13, 1781.
On my arrival at Congress I found no delegate from New York nor has any been here since, consequently no mention has yet been made of Vermont.
As to the business of the States I can with pleasure inform you that congress are coming into a new plan of raising mony & a more frugal plan of spending it.(1) The general voice seems to be to emit no more paper, to call in what is emitted as fast as it can conveniently be done, to loan, to tax in hard mony, to furnish the army with provision, cloathing, stores &ca. by contract &ca &ca. I dont mention these things as done, but as in contemplation. Continental debts to be liquidated in hard mony & put upon interest if agreable to the creditor. As to our southern army they have a hard time on't, but they behave well. A letter from Genl. Green of the 27th Apr. mentions an engagement of the 25th wherein he took above 50 prisoners altho it was a kind of drawn battle, this was near Camden. A strong reinforcement of sea & land forces is expected from France. Upon the whole I think things look pretty well, but there must be the utmost exertion to keep up the spirit of raising men & supplys &ca.
I have drawn the 19th instant for 1331/3 dollars being the only sum that offerd and must continue to draw on the State, but should be glad to hear the sense of the Court upon the subject.(2)
Brigadier genl. Marian has taken a British Fort at the southward calld Fort Watson with 114 prisoners.
I am Dear sir With esteem Your Honours most obed. Servt.
Samuel Livermore
1 Additional measures for "ways and means to carry on the present campaign" were this day adopted by Congress and transmitted to the states in Samuel Huntington's May 24 letter to the States. JCC, 20:523-26.
2 See Livermore to Weare, May 13, 1781, note 2.
I have this morning committed to a Doctor Putnam who sails from hence in the Hermione two Letters (1) which the Writer of one of them thought would be safest on the Water-Passage to you.
I recd. a Letter from Mr. Carmichael two days ago dated March 11th with a Plan the Success of which he could not foresee. I had copied the Plan for Genl. Ward's Use. I find he wanted it to send to
I promise myself that Genl. Washington's Letter to Col. Harrison published by Rivington will make the Enemy heedless and rash. But what Benefit can their foolish Conduct afford us if we allow ourselves to remain so incapable as we are at present of reaping in such a Field.
Is Brother Gerry sick? I have not had a Line from him a long Time. I will yet hope he is well.
I am greatly altered for the better, and am convinced that bathing or even a partial Sprinkling with cold Water will shortly restore my Hip to free Exercise.
A most cordial Letter from the King of France in answer to our Representation last Novr. The Cheval De la Luzerne has not yet so far decyphered his recd. Packets as to go into Detail with us.(3)
Yrs. affectly. J L
[P.S.] You are little attentive to Pounds Shillings and Pence on your own private account, but you must consent to think a little for your Colleagues here. With what Kind of Money can we be furnished so as that neither our Constituents nor we shall be evidently sufferers by Exchange? I think only with hurd.
Mr. Russell was yesterday buried. Tell Edes I have his Letter of the 7th recd. yesterday directed to you or me, and that I will attend carefully to the Contents; but the Business is not so forward as he thinks.
1 These letters have not been identified, but see Lovell to Benjamin Franklin, May 17, 1781.
2 Artemas Ward's letter to Adams has not been found, but for the March 11 letter from William Carmichael, see Lovell to Abigail Adams, May 21, 1781, note 2.
3 Louis XVI's March 10 letter, promising assistance to the United States, was laid before Congress on May 23. The chevalier de La Luzerne then communicated more detailed intelligence on French plans in May 25 and 26 memorials to Congress and during an interview with a committee of Congress, which was summarized in a report submitted on May 28. For the letter, memorials, and committee report, see JCC 20:527, 533, 556-69.
I am to thank you for your Favor of the 7th. The Militia at the Southward have behaved very ill at Times and most gallantly also in Turn; and Govr. Jefferson says they have had their Triumph in seing picked British Regulars run like Sheep before very inferior Numbers of our Men.(1)
I have already mentioned to Mr. Adams his Namesakes Plan of a Loan in Holland and our Receipt of a most cordial Letter from the King of France upon the Representation of our Finances last November. We have not yet the Detail of his friendly Intentions. They are communicated in Cyphers.
I think Cornwallis will certainly join Phillips, but I hope Gl. Green will succeed at Campden. Yr. Friend & humb Servt.
James Lovell (2)
1 Gov. Thomas Jefferson had reported in his May 9 letters to Congress and to Washington that the British troops at Petersburg had "broke twice and run like Sheep." See JCC, 20:499; and Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 5:621, 623-24.
2 Lovell also wrote the following letter this day to Nathaniel Peabody.
"I wrote you last week that Mrs. Cordis should be apprized of the Danger in which her Father lay. Tho he seemed to revive after that Date yet he continued no longer than Sunday last and was interred last Evening in Market Street Church-yard. He has known much Trouble for 2 Years. The Injury I recd. by a Fall on the Night of the 24th of April prevented my visiting her Father and obtaining a confidential Account of his Circumstances; and he appeared very averse to giving it to those about him while he was able. He was speechless when I became strong enough to reach his Lodgings.
"I have already expressed to you my Surprize at not having a Line since you left Morris Town." Miscellaneous Folders, NN.
As I expect to leave this early tomorrow-morning, I have sent to your Quarters the Several Letters, which you handed to me respecting the dispute between you and Mr. Burke.(1)
After exchanging Papers with Mr Shiell we have had Several interviews on the Subject of difference Subsisting between you, which was freely discussed on both Sides. We were very Solicitous to put an end to the Controversey in a manner, consistent with both your Honors, without cause of triumph to the Enemy, or the loss of either of your Services to the Public.
I therefore declared I was authorized to Say, that Mr Burke was not the person intended to be described by you in your Letter to
I am Sir, your Humble Servant, Alex McDougall
1 For this "dispute," see Sullivan to McDougall, January 27, note 1, and March 16, 1781.
Your dispatches of the 22 & 27 Ulto.(1) were very welcome to us, not having heard from you for so long a time before. The accounts we heard from time to time, served only to confuse, instead of inform us. I lament with you the unfortunate turn in the action of the 23d [i.e. 25th] Ulto. It must have been a most mortifying circumstance to you to have such a victory snatched out of your hands by the blunder of a single man. It was not only the immediate advantages resulting to us, that we are to look to, but the eclat that would have been given to our arms abroad, this would have been of still more importance. However, we must look for better fortune another time. I dare not flatter myself so far as to say, I shall yet hope to hear of the reduction of Camden; but I will rest satisfyed with this assurance, that every thing that can be will be done for the best.(2)
Congress this day received a very affectionate and friendly letter from the King of France.(3) He gives us every assurance of the most
Genl. Wayne marches from York town tomorrow but I am afraid he will be too late to render you much service. Should Cornwallis, & Phillips, form a junction (which I believe there is little doubt of) & be reinforced with the detachment now gone from N. York-2000 men-I imagine all your feeble efforts must be at an end, & you must seek an Asylum in some other quarter.
Genl. Washington is now at Weathersfield, holding a conference with the French Genl. & Admiral. Govr. Rutledge sets of[f] for Head quarters tomorrow, where he purposes making but a short stay, & then to return immediately to join you. I most sincerely wish you uninterrupted health, & may the Supreme Disposer of human events, crown your generous endeavours with deserved success. And believe me to be My Dr. sir, with the most sincere Esteem, Yr. most Obedt. servt. Jno. Mathews
1 See Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, this date, note 2.
2 Greene's fate at the battle of Hobkirk's Hill near Camden, S.C., on April 25 was also discussed in a letter of this date by Maryland delegate Daniel of St. Thomas Jenifer to an unknown correspondent, from which only the following extract has been found. "Gen. Greene's not succeeding before Camden will in some measure dispirit our men, and perhaps prevent future confidence, and the British will be highly elated, altho' we did not lose more in killed, wounded and missing than 160 men, and have taken near three hundred at their different outposts in S.C., including 50 taken by Col. Washington's horse at Camden. Gen. Greene informs Congress that he should have gained a complete victory had not two companies of the First Maryland regiment been thrown into disorder, which occasioned Col. Gunby to change his position. The Second regiment, conceiving this movement to be a retreat, followed. The confusion it occasioned obliged the General to order a retreat. He lost neither arms, ammunition or baggage, and says that it would make no alteration in his plan....Mr. Morris has accepted the office of Financier. The principal part of his plan is a Grand Bank. I am in great hopes of relief from his ability and industry....I fear that the late Fleet that sailed from New York is before this time arrived in our Bay with 2000 soldiers. The Southern States I fear will be ruined by piece meal. If this happens [which God avert] the Northern will soon share the same fate....Gen. Washington left headquarters on Saturday to meet the Count de Rochambeau, to settle the plan of operations for this campaign...." Stan V Henkels Catalog, no. 683 (April 5-6, 1892), item 331.
3 See James Lovell to Samuel Adams, this date, note 3.
Mr. Nicholson we presume will communicate to your Excellency or his principal the state of the business committed to his care. He has we believe been greatly embarrased for want of money and it has not been in our power to afford him assistance although our endeavours have been exerted for the purpose.(1)
The Chevr. Luzerne has received within a few days past Despatches from his Court. The contents of them have not yet transpired but we expect they will in a day or two be communicated to Congress-no doubt but from the present state of affairs in Europe they must be important and interesting to America. Mr. Carmichael writes the Com. of Correspondence that Mr. Cumberland had left Spain and returned to England through France but notwithstanding his negociations are at an end in consequence of his departure.(2) Mr Carmichael conjectures conferences will be soon opened for the accommodation of the disputes between the belligerent Powers under The mediation of the Emperor-he gives this as his conjecture and not from official authority.
Ct. Rochambeau in consequence of advices recd. by his Son who arrived in the Ship that brot. over the Admiral to take command of the French Fleet at Rhode Island requested a conference with Genl. Washington-they are now together and the operations of the ensuing Campaign will we expect be digested and we hope the Forces of our Ally be put in motion. We are really reduced to extremities for want of money-the State paper passes under great depreciation and not willingly received by the people. Specie appears to be the money chiefly in circulation-how the State will furnish us with that Article we know not unless the assemb[l]y will authorize Mr. Ross their Agent to purchase flour for the southern department & exchange it for the Specific supply of Maryland So far as to answer our exegencies. The Maryland Flour may be delivered at the Head of Elk and we apprehend disposed of for Gold & Silver-unless Something is done to furnish us with money to bear our reasonable expences in this place we must sell what little property we possess here or return to Virginia. Your Excellency will pardon our giving you the trouble of representing to the Assembly any Matter that particularly respects ourselves but our present situation will we hope apologize for, Yr. obed. Servts.
Jos. Jones. Theok. Bland
James Madison Junr M. Smith
1 See Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, May 1, 1781, note 2. George Nicolson, who was in Philadelphia to obtain arms for Virginia, subsequently submitted an estimate for the purchase and repair of arms which Bland, Jones, and Madison endorsed on May 30 and submitted to Congress for an immediate advance "on Account of the State of Virginia." The application was approved the following day, and the Continental loan officer for Pennsylvania was ordered to issue a warrant to Nicolson "for ten thousand dollars of the new emission." See JCC, 20:582; PCC, item 78, 19:377-80, and Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:134-35.
2 For William Carmichael's March 11 letter, see James Lovell to Abigail Adams, May 21, note 2. For Richard Cumberland's mission to Spain, see James Madison to Joseph Jones, December 5, 1780, note 3.
I do myself the Honor of transmitting for your Excellency's Approbation, the enclosed Copies of Despatches from General Greene, from No 1 to 6,(1) if the Information hath been already communicated (which is probable) by General Greene, the Trouble of perusing these Papers will be unnecessary, the Expence of transmitting them is inconsiderable.
By the latest Accounts from Virginia & North Carolina, General Phillips was near Petersburgh and Lord Cornwallis at Hallifax.
I have the Honor to be, with the greatest Regard, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
P.S. Your Excellency's Despatches of the 17th have been duly received.(2)
1 These six numbered enclosures, all of which are in the Washington Papers, consisted of letters from Nathanael Greene to Congress of April 22 and 27; from Francis Marion to Greene of April 21 and 23; "Terms of Capitulation" received by Marion in the capture of Fort Watson on April 23; and two April 26 troop returns enclosed by Greene with his letter of the 27th.
2 Only one May 17 letter from Washington to Congress is known. See JCC, 20:519; PCC, item 152, 10:107-10; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:97-98.
My long & Steady attendance in Congress for Sixteen months past, makes it necessary for a relaxation of my mind & restoration of my health that I retire for some time at least, and if agreeable to the
By my Absence there will be but two members remaining, and they mean to Attend only one at a time, this in the course of a few days will deprive this state of a representation unless an Appointing of one or more members Speedily takes place. (1) I continue of the same Opinion as heretofore that three members are preferrable to five, provided such can be found who will devote their time to that service, and unless they do I am clearly of opinion you had better have none; but in this I do not Suppose that one member is to attend alway & the other two Alternately which hath long been the case; few constitutions can bear such constant attendance, some relaxation is Necessary.
With all due regard & Esteem, I have the honour to be, Sir, your Obedt. humble Servt. Abra. Clark
1 The difficulty of keeping New Jersey represented in Congress at this time was also the subject of a May 19 letter from New Jersey delegates William C. Houston and John Witherspoon to the "joint meeting," from which only the following extract has been found.
"The subscribers [i.e., William C. Houston and John Witherspoon] beg leave to represent to the joint meeting that Mr. Paterson elected a delegate to Congress in December last did not accept the delegation and that Dr. William Burnet by accepting an office in the medical line has vacated his seat. It is therefore submitted to the meeting whether it will not be necessary to elect two new delegates in the room of the two who do not serve. It is of the utmost moment that the state be constantly represented and at the same time it must appear that the burden must be too great especially if Mr. Clark do not attend constantly as was expected by the subscribers both in point of health & other business. We have therefore little doubt that our request will be granted...." Robert F. Batchelder Autographs Catalog, no. 35 (December 1981), item 183.
You will receive enclosed, the Copy of a Resolution of the 15th Instant, containing the Appointment of the principal Officers in the medical Department for the Southern Army (1)
You will observe that all such Officers of the medical Department appointed under the former Directorship of Doctor Oliphant who are now in Captivity in South Carolina and Georgia, and have the Charge of the Sick in those States, are continued in their respective Offices &c, but to extend no farther than to the Troops & Hospitals within the Enemies Lines.
Your Despatches of the 22d & 27th of April have been received.(2)
I have the Honor to be &c &c S.H.
1 The enclosed May 15 resolution announced the appointment of the following officials: "Dr. David Oliphant...deputy director; Peter Fayssoux chief physician of the hospital; James Brown chief physician of the army; Robert Johnston and William Reed [Read], hospital physicians."JCC, 20:506.
This day Huntington also sent copies of this resolve with brief cover letters to the Director General of the Medical Department, Dr. John Cochran, and to Drs. Oliphant, Fayssoux, Brown, Johnston, and Read who were named in the resolve. See PCC, item 15, fols. 293-94.
2 For Greene's letters, which were read in Congress and referred to committee on May 21, see Daniel Carroll to Thomas Sim Lee, May 22, 1781, note 2.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, several Resolves of Congress of the 22d Instant, upon the Report of a Committee appointed to devise further Ways & Means to carry on the present Campaign.(1)
As the Measures proposed in these Resolves are the Result of Necessity after due Deliberation, it is expected the Necessity as well as the Importance of those Measures will have a suitable Impression upon the States universally, and excite them to a vigorous and punctual Compliance.
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S.H.
1 For the report of the committee on ways and means, whose recommendations were debated on May 14, 15, and 17 and adopted on May 22, See JCC, 20:487, 500-504, 507, 515, 523-25.
Huntington also sent copies of the enclosed resolves to Superintendent of Finance Robert Morris and to General Washington this date. PCC, item 15, fols. 291-92. For Morris' discussions with Congress at this time concerning Continental fiscal needs, see also Morris, Papers (Ferguson), 1:76-78.
I am directed to transmit your Excellency the enclosed Copy of a Resolution of the 26th Instant, together with the Copy of General Greene's Letter therein referred to.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c S.H.
1 Congress had resolved to send to the six northernmost states Gen. Nathanael Greene's April 22 letter describing "the dangerous situation of the southern states" in order to impress them with the urgency of immediately completing the troop quotas assigned them in October 1780. See JCC, 20:519, 548; and PCC, item 155, 2:39-46.
It is with Pleasure & Satisfaction that I obey the Directions of Congress in transmitting the enclosed Resolve of the 24th Instant, and assuring you, Sir, that they will take proper Measures to discharge the Engagements you have so generously entered into with the Merchants of Baltimore to obtain Supplies for the Detachment under your Command.(1) This is but one Instance among the many Proofs you have given of your Zeal and Attachment to the Interest of these United States.
Your Letter of the Instant covering Despatches to the Commander in Chief hath been received, and the Letters addressed to him forwarded agreeable to your Request.(2)
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S.H.
1 For the enclosed resolve and Lafayette's April 22 letter to Huntington informing Congress of the arrangements he had made with the merchants of Baltimore to outfit his troops on their march through Maryland, See JCC, 20:451, 471-72, 531-32; PCC, item 156, fols. 127-30; and Lafayette, Papers (Idzerda), 4:53-54.
Huntington also sent a copy of this enclosed resolve, and the thanks of Congress to the Baltimore merchants for their reception of Lafayette, with a brief letter of this date to Gov. Thomas Sim Lee. PCC, item 16, fol. 3.
2 For Lafayette's May 18 letter to Congress and enclosure of May 17 to Washington, see PCC, item 156, fols. 137-38; and Lafayette, Papers (Idzerda), 4:108-9.
By the enclosed Resolve your Excellency will be informed that the Convention Troops are to be removed from their present Stations.
In Consequence of this Resolve the Board of War have ordered them, the Commissioned Officers to East Windsor in Connecticut, the non commissioned Officers and Privates to Rutland in Massachusetts. (1)
Would it not be preferable to have them exchanged if it could be effected on reasonable Terms, rather than to continually increase the enormous Expence incurred by supporting, marching, countermarching & guarding such of them as have not escaped.
You will also receive enclosed, a Resolve of the 21st Instant respecting Major General Gates. It may not be improper to inform your Excellency, that in Consequence of this Resolve, the General in a very decent Letter to Congress informed them that he could not be useful in the Field or think of going into Service in his present Circumstances. It were to be wished some Mode might be devised to relieve him from his present anxious though inactive Situation.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Respect, Your Excellency's most obedient & very humble servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 The Board of War had experienced difficulty since February implementing a congressional order for removing the Convention Army prisoners from Virginia to a place of safety; and on May 22 had requested a conference with a committee of Congress to discuss the subject. According to the report of the committee appointed to confer with the board submitted the same day, Massachusetts rather than Pennsylvania was to be the prisoners' destination, but when the Massachusetts delegates objected to the recommendation a compromise was adopted simply authorizing the board to remove them "to such place as they think most conducive to the good of the union in general." The board then decided to divide the Convention prisoners between Connecticut and Massachusetts out of deference to the latter's objections. See JCC, 20:522, 526-27, 529 30; PCC, item 148, 1:377-78; and Huntington to Thomas Jefferson, March 4, 1781. However, when Washington learned of this decision, he too objected, recommending that the prisoners be halted in Pennsylvania, and Congress endorsed Washington's suggestion on June 12. See Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:167-70; and JCC, 20:629-30.
2 For the enclosed resolve concerning Gen. Horatio Gates, see Huntington to Gates, May 22, 1781, note.
Your Excellency will receive herewith enclosed, an Act of Congress of the 25th Instant containing the general Principals to be observed in Promotions in the Line of the Army.(1)
This Plan hath been adopted upon mature Deliberation, to be observed as a general Rule in Promotions, as subject to the fewest Objections of any that could be devised (though not altogether free from them) under the peculiar Situation & Circumstances of the federal Army, raised & recruited from so many distinct soverign States.
Your Excellency will also note the Promotion of Lieut. Colonel Tilghman and Major McHenry, as also the Provision made for Officers who are hostages & for Aids de Camp as specified in this Act.
For your Excellency's Information I have also enclosed a Resolve of the 26th Instant, ordering a Copy of Major General Greene's Letter of the 22d of April to be transmitted to several of the States.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with very great Respect, Your Excellency's most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam Huntington President
1 For the adoption of the enclosed resolves, which endorsed the recommendations of a committee appointed to consider concerns voiced by Washington in a letter of December 20, 1780, see JCC, 19:1, 104, 242 46, 20:491, 53941; Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 20:501-5; and John Sullivan to Washington, January 2, March 9, and May 17, 1781.
Huntington also enclosed these resolves with a nearly identical letter of this date to Nathanael Greene. Sparks Manuscripts, MH-H.
2 See Huntington to Certain States, this date.
I thank you for your favor of the 25th. The Enemys Cruizers being in our Bay & Rivers I conceived would prevent the General assemblys meeting so soon as the Exigency of our affairs required. It is now Neck or nothing. Every exertion must be used this Campaign to prevent the Southern States being overrun. Every dispersion of the Enemy has its effect, & altho the prize be small yet it encourages interprize.
Yesterday & to day arrived from the Havanah Eight Sail of Vessels with Hard Money. The Merchants I am told pay very little regard to the embargo Law, indeed the State has not Money to purchase the third of any Vessels Cargo even were it to be offered to the President & Council.
The Pennsylvania Line I believe is now on their March. General Wayne was obliged to Order a Platoon to fire on part of the right Wing who refused to March four of the Mutineers were killed one man it is said had 23 Balls through him.
Your Delegates are without Money or Credit. What are they to do, none but hard will pass at this place unless it be on the most ruinous terms. There is but one way that I know of by which they may be supplied, & that is by ordering some wheat, at the Head of the Bay to be Ground up into Superfine Flour. Mr. Joseph Gilpin promissed me on my way up to execute a Commission of this sort, were he to be empowered by the assembly or The Governor & Council.(2) Col. Hollingsworth has too much on his hands to give proper attention to this business.
There never has been a time when Men of abilities were more necessary in Congress than at present, therefore I wish that proper attention may be paid to the Delegates Letter by this Post to the General Assembly.(3) We are not at liberty to disclose particulars, but the sooner an addition is made to the Delegation the better as delay cannot be admitted. Altho at every Post want prevails, yet I flatter myself that our affairs will soon look up & that supplies will soon be had.
I wish you and your little Woman health and happiness and am very truly, My dear friend, Your affectionate Servt,
Dan of St Thos Jenifer
[P.S.] Mr. Cumberland was about leaving Madrid the 9th of Mar. I think his stay there was rather too long for the United States. Mr Carroll is not very well.
1 Apparently a member of the Maryland House of Delegates.
2 See also Maryland Delegates to Thomas Sim Lee, May 15, 1781.
3 Not found.
To the PRINTER of the FREEMAN's JOURNAL.
I have observed, in the first paper which you emitted,(1) a solemn declaration that you would conceal the name of the author of any piece which might be handed you for publication, except in cases of torture or the obligation of civil law; and all this under the specious pretence that it was the liberty of the press. It was pretty evident at first view, that you, sir, had intended, or, at least, was calculated to be a vehicle for communicating to the world pieces from tories and British emissaries; pieces scurrilous and ludicrous; pieces containing misrepresentations and falshoods against public bodies, public measures, and individuals. I believe, sir, I have not been mistaken.
Among many other ill-natured things, to say no worse of them, I have observed a very illiberal attack on the conduct of Mr. Duane during the present contest, by a certain Lucilius or Plain Truth of your acquaintance.(2)
To answer all the little scurrility that is contained in those pieces, is far beneath the man of candour or a liberal pen. You or Mr. Plain Truth, as he is very improperly called, hath represented Mr. Duane as a tory, a British emissary, duplicity in his conduct, "a secret enemy, endeavouring to confound, embarrass, protract, and defeat the best concerted plans and measures for maintaining the independency of America." Now, Sir, as you are the proper vehicle, please to ask Mr. Plain Truth, alias Falshood, the following plain questions, viz. Did not Mr. Duane propose, and, in conjunction with the council of safety, execute some of the boldest measures against tories and traitors in the state of New-York, in the latter end of 1776, when our affairs were a gloomy aspect? Is not the legislature of the state of New-York composed of whigs and men of sense? If Mr. Duane is a tory, &c. would not the legislature of New-York have discovered it, and left him out of their delegation? Is not Mr. Duane at the head of
Can any man be a real friend to his country, who will wantonly, without provocation or the colour of foundation, sport with the character of men in public stations, who are using the utmost stretch of their abilities, spending their fortunes, and sacrificing their domestic ease and happiness in supporting the rights of this devoted country, and who are using their utmost efforts to bring the contest to a happy and glorious issue? Does not such conduct weaken the hands of our rulers, and strengthen those of the enemy?
CANDOR.(4)
1 That is, the April 25, 1781, inaugural issue of Bailey's Freeman's Journal
2 James Duane had been the object of three scurillous attacks published in the May 9, 16, and 23 issues of The Freeman's Journal over the pseudonyms "Plain Truth" and "Lucilius," in the course of which he had been labelled "a cunning, artful traitor," in league with "his chosen associates Joseph] Galloway, [Andrew] Allen, [Robert] Alexander, [Silas] Deane, [and Benedict] Arnold." Much was also made of the coincidence that Duane had returned to New York from Philadelphia the same day the first attack had been printed ("Flight is a confession of guilt, as well as cowardice"), and he was even charged with positioning himself to profit from the war with Britain regardless of the outcome-"If we succeed in our independence, [he] will be a great and wealthy member of these States; should we fail the British funds must be exhausted to yield him an adequate reward."
These charges, which Duane formally defended himself against before the New York legislature in late June, and which provided the focus of an intermittent debate between Duane's detractors and supporters in the Journal's pages from May 9 to
3 Thus in Bailey's text.
4 Candor's identity has not been discovered. "Plain Truth," who responded to Candor's defense of Duane in the June 6 issue of The Freeman's Journal, referred to him as a "Member of Congress," a conclusion strongly suggested by the essay's content.
I wrote you on the 22d instant (1) by express going to the Marquis De la Fayette. In full confidence that Docr. Fassaux will hand you this, I will venture a few hints which are necessary for you to know, and may perhaps be communicated more at large by the commander in Chief or some other person.
We have lately recieved dispatches from France.(2) The second division is not to be sent, but an augmentation so as to give the new Admiral de Barrass the superiority; and a powerful diversion is intended in the West Indias. This change took place in consequence of the Dutch war which must be cherrished by France. A subsidy of six millions of Livres is given, part will come in cloathing &c and part to be a fund under the direction of the Comr-in-Chief. I entertain a hope that Mr. Morris is in the way to restore public credit. G. W. has had a conferrence with compte R[ochambeau] on military operations. The enemy have forbid any communications with New York by Flag or otherwise-many conjecture that an evacuation is intended, I am not yet brot. into that opinion.
The Empress of R[ussia] and the Emperor have offered their mediation between all the beligerent powers. It hath been accepted by the Court of L ____n with an apparent degree of eagerness. France waits the consent of their ally before a negociation can begin, conferrences will in all probability open within a few months.(3) In the meantime Military operations will be carried on with the greatest vigor against us. In order to make an advantageous peace we ought to be in condition to prosecute the war. Important events are suspended in which the southern States are infinitely interested. Congress will doubtless use their utmost address to Stimulate the States to suitable exertions.
May you my dear Sir and your little army be preserved to enjoy the fruits of your labor and anxiety in a permanent and an honorable peace.
With perfect respect & esteem I am my dear General, Your Most
Obt. Humble Servt. Wm. Sharpe
1 That is, his letter to Greene of May 21, for which see Sharpe to Thomas Burke, May 21, 1781, note 2.
2 See James Lovell to Samuel Adams, May 22, note 3.
3 This May 26 intelligence from the French minister regarding offers of mediation from Russia and Austria had been read in Congress this day. Samuel Huntington to the States, June 1, 1781.
Though the Distresses of our Army, the Success of the Enemy in the Southern States; The certainty of the Second Division not coming to America; and the Disposition of the Soverigns of Russia, and Germany, to dictate a Peace; when the uti possidetes if admitted would operate to deprive us of very important parts of the united States: Yet I cannot forbear congratulating your Excellency on the general Complextion of our affaires which in my Opinion wear a more promising Aspect Than they have done for many years.
The Reinforcement from France though far short of what was intended, will (I trust) Enable us to undertake offensive operations by Land & Sea. The Generous Donation of his most Christian Majesty with the Measures adopted by Congress & by our Financier will Enable us to pay and Supply our Army. The Cloathing Arrived & now on its passage will Enable us to Cloathe our Army. The Measures adopted by the French Court will furnish us with the necessary Munitions of War. The Exertions of Mr R. Morris will in a few Days give you a permanent Supply of provisions Independant of The Supplies Expected from the States. The Late important discoveries made by Congress have at Length convinced them that Honesty is the best policy; This will restore our Lost credit. The prospects of a peace being Dictated to us by an Armed neutrality will rouse Congress and the States to Exertions which may put us on a footing to negotiate on Terms of Equality. The Scrupulous adherence of his Christian Majesty to the Terms of the Alliance, The favorable Disposition of the Spanish Court; and the interest which the powers of Europe have discovered in our becoming an Independant Nation promise us Every thing in a Negociation which our Exertions & their political Interest may Dictate. But amidst all those flattering prospects we are now called upon to make our Last desperate Struggle to pave the way to that peace and Independance for which we have so long contended. Congress do and I am convinced the States will feel the Necessity to Exert Every Nerve at this critical moment and I do not Entertain a Doubt of the Success. The rule of promotions has with much difficulty passed;(1) which though not in Every respect agreable to my mind is much better
1 See Sullivan to Washington, May 17; and Samuel Huntington's second letter to Washington, this date.
Yesterday's Post brought me your Letters of the 10th & 14 with a Copy of March 17, on the Subject of which I shall be particular when I have a proper opportunity.(1) I have a Friend to whom I communicate most unreservedly all the Occurrences which tend to govern my Pleasures & my Pains; your Letters will of Course be submitted in that mixt View. I have already hinted their Influence in the latter; so that there is a Chance of some Eclaircissement before I can convey them in whole, should you meet each other.
"You have a very small personal acquaintance with the Lady whom you esteem & commisserate (2)-you have as little personal acquaintance with the Gentleman connected with her." Had you (greater) with both, you could not fail to think more highly of the former, and not so well or so ill of the latter as you seem at present to Think, if I, who am perfectly intimate with them, may conclude from the Communications which you have lately made to me.
When I write again on this Subject I shall transmit some anecdotes which you will think interesting to your Friend abroad. I believe I have already told you to see S.A.(3) as a preparative.
I please myself with imagining you had Letters by Capt. Porter who appears to have reached Boston the 13th in 27 Days from France. We are still without a Line from Mr. A or Mr. D since Octr.(4)
I shall be attentive to Mr. Cranch if an Occasion offers to Fishkills.
I need not betray the Secrets which I am enjoined to keep. Your Eveship ought to be satisfied with what the Printers are pleased to give to the good People of Boston-Town. Glory or Shame, great in Degree of either Kind, depends upon the Behavior of the Americans in the coming six months, but more especially in the two first. I shudder verily at the Thought. Is it not almost a Resurrection from the Dead that I am looking for?
And now, avaunt ye Emanations of an honest Pen! Come to my aid ye Products of Insincerity! It is not the candid but the sentimental to whom I send you.
I have the Honor to be with the most perfect Consideration, Your Excellency's most obedt. & Devoted humble Servant,
James Lovell
P.S. By way of Nota Bene, Excellency in English is of both Genders.
1 For Abigail's letters, see ibid., pp. 91-93, 111-13. For Lovell's response at "a proper opportunity," see Lovell to Abigail Adams, June 16, 1781.
2 That is, Lovell's wife, Mary. Lovell is quoting from Abigail's letter of May 10.
3 Samuel Adams.
4 That is, John Adams and Francis Dana.
I have yr. Favor of the 17th doubly and trebly agreeable as it proved your own Health Mr. Gerry's and his success. I had really fixed him to a sick Bed.
You will be anxious about our Intelligence from Europe. We have much but I am too greatly overcome by the Heat, to sweat over the Consideration of what I ought to communicate to be consistent with an Obligation to Secresy imposed at this Time with a propriety not always connected with that Injunction in our continental Assembly. However, I may tell you that your own Printers have given you quite enough to show you that the Wheel of Time will not afford you another such six months as the Coming. Political Glory or Infamy of a lasting Kind is most assuredly depending on them, more especially on the two first of them, in which there must be an almost universal Change of Manners. Every Requisition already made must be fully complied with, and even more must be in forwardness. Let not the former Calls of once for all make us callous on this Occasion. The Execrations of Posterity will fall more justly perhaps on the Inattention & Negligence of the States distant from the immediate Carnage
Yr. Anxious Frd. J.L.
Oh this stagnated Air of Philada. I cannot write to Mr. Adams am happy to hear he is well at home.
The two circumstances relating to the proposed duty on trade mentioned in your favor of the 1st instant (1) were subjects of discussion when the measure was on the anvil.(2) It was evident that the disposition of the States to invest Congress with such a power wd. be influenced by the length of the term assigned for the exercise of it. It was equally evident that no provision would satisfy the present creditors of the U. States or obtain future loans that was not commensurate to all the public engagements. In order to reconcile these points the duration of the impost was limited, but limited in so indefinite a manner as not to defeat the object of it. Should the increase of trade render the duty more productive than was estimated it must the sooner extinguish the public debts & cease. The application of Congress for such a power supposes indeed a confidence in them on the part of the States, greater perhaps than many think consistent with republican jealousy, but if the States will not enable their representatives to fulfill their engagements, it is not to be expected that individuals either in Europe & America will confide in them. The 2d objection you mention was also a subject of much discussion in Congress. On one side it was contended that the powers incident to the collection of a duty on trade were in their nature so municipal, and in their operation so irritative that it was improbable that the States could be prevailed on to part with them, and that consequently it would be most prudent to ask from the States nothing more than the duty itself, to be collected by State officers & paid to a Continental Receiver, and not the right of levying & collecting it by officers of Congress. On the opposite side it was urged that as Congress would be held responsible for the public debts it was necessary & would be expected, that the fund granted for discharging them should be exclusively & independently in their hands, that if the Collectors were under the controul of the States the urgency of their wants would be constantly diverting the revinue from its proper destination, that if the States were willing to give up
A report of an intended evacuation of N. Y. has again sprung up. The rumor of Clintons being in the Bay corresponds so well in point of time with the last embarkation that I fear you lent too incredulous a ear to it. Genl Wayne has certainly moved at last after bringing the competi[t]ion b[etween] discipline & the mutinous spirit of the troo[ps to an] issue. Fortunately the former gained a complete triumph. If Virga. can maintain her opposition a little time longer, I flatter myself the direction of our general force will be more favorable for her than it has been. If the war centers in the S. Department on the part of the Enemy, it certainly must on our part. A number of arrivals have taken place within a few days from the Havannah. It is sd. near 200,000 Dollars make a part of their Cargo. The enormous price of flour produces this ballance in our favor. What a prodigious sum we are losing from the delay of the States to authorise the collection of the 5 Per Ct. on Trade, the plan not permitting it in one State till all shall have Concurred in it. It appears probable that Pensacola is by this time in the hands of the Spaniards. Adieu. J Madison Jr.
1 That is, Pendleton's letter of May 21, for which see ibid., pp. 127-28.
2 See Madison's Motion on an Impost, February 3, 1781.
The letter from the King of France being directed to be sent you by the President,(1) it is unnecessary for me to say anything about it-let it speak for itself.
All the southern news is contained in the inclosed papers, which, when you have perused, be pleased to inclose, & forward with the inclosed letters.
The affairs of America are truely critical. If the States strictly comply with the late requisitions of Congress, we may be yet a happy people, if not
I have the Honor to be, with the highest respect and Esteem, yr. Excys most Obedt. servt. Jn. Mathews
1 See Samuel Huntington to the States, June 1, 1781, note 1.
If Ever a People were called upon for vigorous Exertions, by the pressing Situation of their affairs & Entreated to make their Last Struggle against an implacable Enemy, The Americans at this moment are in that Situation: we are now upon our last Campaign; if vigorous Exertions render it Successful we Shall Sit Down, Quietly in the Enjoyment of that Independance for which we have so Long contended but if Languid Efforts render our attempts unsuccessful we are ruined past relief.
The Emperour of Germany & Empress of Russia have offered their mediation to the Beligerent powers; The Acceptance is inevitable. France and Spain have given Answers which will work a delay but can by no means preclude a Compliance with Their demand. To have a peace dictated to us when our Army is in the most feeble Situation, in the greatest want of provisions through the want of Exertions in the States: when the Enemy are possessed of two States and are carrying their Conquests into others; when prescribing the uti possidetis as a Basis of Accommodation would forever ruin the united States would be a misfortune far beyond what the Calamities of war could possibly produce. To avert the danger and to obtain a Peace upon honorable Terms Every Exertion must be used to push with vigor This Campaign (which will probably be our Last). The King of France to Enable us to Act with vigor has made us a Donation of Six Million of Livers. This will put our Finances on a respectable footing. The Exertions of Mr Robert Morris our financier with the plans pursuing by Congress will render them Still more so. Arms, Ammunition and Cloathing are provided by the French Monarch which will Soon be here. The King of Spain is also Supplying with Cloathing & will furnish Some money. A reinforcement from France which though not So respectable as we could wish will we flatter ourselves with our own Exertions render us Superiour
The Scrupulous adherence of the French Monarch to his obligations, The favorable Disposition of the Court of Spain toward the united States & The Political Interest of the European powers in rendering us Independant will all operate to procure us That Freedom & Safety for which we have Spent So much blood and Treasure.
We cannot under the present Situation of Affairs avoid Entreating you & through You the assembly of New Hampshire to use Every possible Exertion to Take advantage of the present State of facts, profit by the assurances which we have received & thereby avoid the Consequences which Languid Efforts must certainly produce. We have the Honor to be very respectfully Dear Sir Your most obedient Servants. Jno. Sullivan
Samuel Livermore
I thought about this time to be making preparations for leaving this place, but none of my colleagues appearing to relieve me, several States being unrepresented in Congress, and affairs of the first magnitude being now on the tapis, I thought it inconsistent with my honor to leave the State unrepresented at so interesting a period. Notwithstanding my anxious impatience to return to my family, I have determined to stay till I am relieved, or at least till the States are more fully represented in Congress. I don't doubt but you and my sister will offer such reasons to Mrs. Johnston as will reconcile her to this measure. I hope she will keep up her spirits and if I should not return before the sickly season, I wish you would prevail on her to take the children down to the sea-side, if it can be done with safety; but as I have hopes of returning before that time, it will be unnecessary to say any thing on the subject till the season approaches. The uncertainty of a letter's getting safe to you, lays me under great restraints. I can only mention in general that the King of France has given us under his own hand very lately, the most unequivocal assurances of his friendship and support, and is at this time exerting his interest and influence at the different courts in Europe to bring our affairs to a happy and speedy conclusion; and I have in my own mind the most perfect confidence in these assurances. We shall suffer much in this campaign; it will be very bloody, but I
Yours, &c., &c.
Congress was this day informed by a Letter from the Marquis de la Fayette,(1) dated at Richmond the 24th, that Lord Cornwallis and his Army consisting of Tarltons Legion, Hamiltons Corps, 23, 33, & 71 Regiments, a Hessian Regiment, light infantry, and guards, and 200 Tories with 6 field peices had joined General Arnold at Petersburgh the 20th. Inst. That he the Marquis had but 900 Continentals besides Militia to oppose to this force which would oblige him to act on the defensive. He further informs, that a British Fleet of Transports convoyed by three Frigates had arrived at Hampton; that on the 22d, 12 Sail of ships a Sloop, and a Schooner, got under way opposite James Town, the Ships full of Men and Horses, the 24th a body landed from the Ships at Westover, and the same day Lord Cornwallis moved from Petersburgh toward Richmond: to this disagreeable intelligence, Congress has received advice from the Westward that an expedition from the Lakes against Pittsburg is meditated.
We expected by last Post that your Excellency would have informed us what prospect you and the Council had of making remittances for our Subsistance.(2) We are without Money, and almost without Credit; and without a timely supply it will be impossible for us to continue in Philadelphia.
We have the honor to be with Sentiments of the highest respect and esteem, Sir, Your Excells. most obedient hble Servts.
Daniel of St. Thos. Jenifer.
Danl Carroll
P.S. By private information from New York, the Troops that embarked at that place for Virga. were the Granadiers, 42 Regiment, Anspachers, & Bartons Jersey Battallion.
1 Lafayette's brief covering letter and its enclosure-a copy of his "official" letter of May 24 to Washington-were read in Congress this day. See JCC, 20:580; and PCC, item 156, fols. 141-47. He also wrote two personal letters to the commander-in-chief on the 24th; all three are in the Washington Papers, DLC.
2 This day the Maryland Council had informed the delegates that it would "forward as soon as possible a Quantity of Flour to be vended in Philadelphia," with the proceeds to be reserved for their use. On June 4, however, the Council further explained that the assembly had applied the flour to the purchase of troop clothing, but reassured the delegates, in response to this letter, that one hundred hogsheads of tobacco would be shipped immediately to Philadelphia...there to be disposed of...for a sufficient Sum of Money for your Purposes." See Md. Archives, 45:450, 461.
I am this moment informed that Mr. Rutlige is going to Head Quarters and have stolen out of Congress to give you a few lines to impress upon you the necessity of taking some immediate step for the succour of the southern Departmt. The Marquis's Letters (1) will inform you of his situation and will of itself without being enforced by me shew the distress that must soon fall upon our State if not speedily succoured. For some days I have waited with impatience to hear from you not doubting your anxiety for the southern States had determined you to measures for their support as far as you have the means in your Power. This expectation and an opinion entertained that you must be fully informed of the late intelligence from Europe has delayed my writing to mention those matters. The proposed mediation of the Imperial Court cannot be declined by the belligerent Powers although Delayed by France and Spain for a Short time to know the dispositions of the States. The most powerfull exertions are necessary not only to give weight to the Negociations of our plenipotentiary but to recover our lost territory to prevent the difficulties of the proposition of uti possidetis. Congress are giving the necessary communications to the States and are endeavouring to stimulate them to emulation at this conjuncture which more than ever calls for our own exertions in consequence of our disappointment from France. The aid in money though will it is
Yr. aff hum. Servt. Jos. Jones
1 See the preceding entry, note 1.
2 In his June 7 reply to Jones, Washington stressed that "powerful objections" prevented his return "for defence of that Country, where all my property and Connexion's are," and that the impending juncture with French troops in America compelled him to ensure "temporary evils" while preparing to act "on the great scale." Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:178-79.
3 For this May 31 "proposition," see Samuel Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781.
I am directed to inform you That Congress have received undoubted intelligence, both from their Minister at the Court of Versailles, & the Minister of France in America by order of his Court That the Courts of Vienna & Petersburgh had offered their mediation to the belligerent powers for the re-establishment of peace.(1) That these overtures had been eagerly embraced on the part of G. Britain. That France had declined her full acceptation thereof untill the concurrence of her allies could be obtained for that purpose, at the same time observing, that should she again be pressed on this head, she would be obliged to enter into a previous plan of
(Thus are we likely to have obtruded upon us by the intervention of two such formidable powers, the hard necessity of acceeding to these overtures at a time when these states are in a less eligible situation to enter into negotiations for peace, than at any other period of the War.)
The intervention of such formidable powers will undoubtedly prove an event the most favourable to these united states if by a great & timely exertion we sufficiently reduce the force of the enemy now operating in our country. But should languor & inaction subject us to the contempt of the negotiators all the consequences will be chargeable upon ourselves.(2) This is a conjuncture that calls for the most serious consideration of these states.
(It is therefore become a question whether we are determined to support this union upon the true principles of the confederation, by rejecting every idea of a diminution or not. If the first is to obtain, Congress are decided in their opinion that there is not a) Congress have not a doubt in their minds but that each State in the Union is determined to support the Confederacy that has been so solemnly entered into, through every difficulty, & hand it down unimpaired to their posterity. Under these impressions Congress can with confidence call on their Constituents for such exertions as are proportionate to the truely critical situation of our affairs. The plan of operations for the present campaign having been preconcerted on the principle of obliging the enemy to abandon their posessions in every part of these states; therefore(3) an unequivocal complyance with the demands heretofore made by Congress for provisions, men, and money, are what we have at present to ask for. Should these means be expeditiously and punctually put into our hands, we have the most pleasing prospect of putting a speedy & happy issue to the war; by driving the enemy from their present possessions in every part of these states; but at all events, to confine them to the Sea coasts; in order to give as little room as possible to the enemy's claim of uti possidetis, which will undoubtedly be most strenuously insisted on by them in the course of the negotiation-a claim totally inadmissible on our part. Of course, then, nothing should be left unessayed by these states, to prevent the embarrassments that such a claim must inevitably produce. Of consequence it is become indispensibly necessary, by our immediate-& under Providence-successful efforts, to place ourselves in such a situation, as to enable our negotiators to speak a firm & decided language, becoming the Characters of the Ministers of Free, Sovereign, & Independent States. We conclude with observing, that from the foregoing communications we are so thoroughly convinced of the most strenuous exertions of every State in the Union to accomplish the great objects herein pointed out, that
By order of Congress
Sam. Huntington President (5)
1 For the adoption of this letter, which was drafted in response to a May 26 "Memoire" to Congress from La Luzerne announcing receipt of a mediation offer from Austria and Russia, See JCC, 20:585-87; PCC, item 25, 1:209-11, item 95, 1:226-33; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:440-47. See also James Lovell to Samuel Adams, May 22, note 3; and William Sharpe to Nathanael Greene, May 28, 1781, note 3.
2 This paragraph to this point is in the hand of Charles Thomson.
3 This sentence to this point in Thomson's hand.
4 For Huntington's belated admonition that the contents of this letter were to be kept secret, see Huntington to the States, June 2, 1781. The president also sent copies of these letters to the commander in chief the following day, for which see Huntington to Washington, June 3, 1781, note 3.
5 Added by Huntington upon transmission to the states.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, an Act of Congress of the 31st Ulto, earnestly recommending to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, immediately to raise & equip for the Field, four Battallions of Infantry, a Company of Artillery & a Corps of Horse. By the same Act, Delaware & Maryland are also requested immediately to raise & equip for the Field a Number of Troops. (1)
Since passing this Act, Intelligence received of the Progress of the Enemy in Virginia, and the distressed Situation of a Sister State, the great Inferiority of our Continental Troops in Virginia under the Command of the Marquis de la Fayette, render the reinforcements requested more pressing and necessary, and require the greatest Exertions to hasten them forward. It is earnestly wished & hoped, under present Circumstances, Volunteers will offer themselves without the least Delay, and join our Troops in such Numbers as immediately to check the Progress of the Enemy, and effectually repel them in due Time.
I have the Honor to be, &c &c S.H.
1 For the adoption of the enclosed "Act," which was drafted by a committee consisting of Samuel J. Atlee, Theodorick Bland, and James Mitchell Varnum appointed on May 29 in response to a motion by Bland, See JCC, 20:574, 577, 579, 582-84.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, an Act of Congress of the 30th Ulto, by which you will observe I am directed to lay before you, a Copy of the Memorial of Joze da Fonseca Soarez de Figuerido, a Subject of Portugal, and the Proclamation issued by Congress May 9th 1778 which are also enclosed.(1)
It is also recommended to the Executive of Massachusetts to give all such Countenance, Protection and Assistance to the Memorialist in his Attempts to obtain legal Satisfaction for the Injuries alledged in his Memorial to have been done to him in his Person & Property by Captain Samson, as becomes the United States respectively to give to the Subjects of neutral Powers who shall complain of a Violation of the Rights of Neutrality.
I have the Honor to be &c &c, S. H.
1 Joze da Fonseca Soarez de Figueiredo, captain of the brig Nossa Senhora do Livramento e Senhor do Bomfim belonging to Lisbon merchant Joaquim Pedro Quintella, had been captured by the Massachusetts privateer Mars, Capt. Simeon Sampson, with a cargo of salt and wine bound from Portugal to Ireland. Taken to France, Captain Figueiredo lodged a protest before the Admiralty of Nantes but was advised to proceed to America to seek redress from the United States. His petition was referred on May 26 to the Board of Admiralty, whose recommendation that the case be referred to Massachusetts was adopted by Congress on May 30. See JCC, 11:486; 20:542, 578-79. Captain Figueiredo's undated petition to Congress is in PCC, item 42, 3:65-68.
My Letter of yesterday addressed to your Excellency, and which accompanies this,(1) contains such important Intelligence that Congress have thought it indispensible to communicate the same to the Legislatures of the several States through their respective Supreme Magistrates as soon as possible; at the same Time the Intelligence is of a Nature that ought to be kept secret as may be at present. I am therefore directed to request that effectual Measures may be observed to prevent Copies or Extracts of the Letter of the 1st Instant from being taken or published.(2)
I have the Honor to be, &c &c S. H.
1 See Huntington to the States, June 1, 1781.
2 For the adoption of this prohibition, See JCC, 20:588.
By the enclosed Order of Congress of the 29th Ulto, I am directed to lay before your Excellency the Letter of the 9th Ulto signed A. Fowler &c with the other Papers referred to, which are herewith enclosed. (1)
Col. Broadhead is now in this City. The Complaints of the Inhabitants in the Vicinity of Pittsburgh respecting his Conduct are very great, and his with Respect to them are not small. It seems necessary that due Enquiry be speedily made respecting those Matters and in such Manner as that Justice may be done.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with very great Regard, Your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington President
1 See JCC, 20:571-72. The enclosed May 9 letter from Alexander Fowler, Robert Campbell, John Irwin, Thomas Smallman, Devereux Smith, and Edward Ward, and "April " deposition of David Tait are in the Washington Papers, DLC.
2 For the background of the campaign to oust Col. Daniel Brodhead from the command at Fort Pitt, see Huntington to Washington, April 20, 1781, note 1. For additional documents related to the case, see Huntington's second letter to Washington of June 6, 1781.
The letter from the delegation to yr. Excellency (1) will apprize you of the Situation of Public affairs at this time, and of our endeavors to promote every thing that can give energy to the operations of the Army in defence of our distressed Country. I shd. not therefore have troubled yr. Excellency with the perusal of this which relates to myself, did not my own peculiar Situation render it necessary & had I not reason to conjecture from the several late ineffectual applications I have been driven through dire necessity to make, that my letters may have miscarried.(2) I can hardly suppose them to have passed unnoticed. The long expected and long wishd for remittance which was to have come through the hands of Mr. Braxton has afforded us no relief & has evaporated into smoke.(3) My Finances are as well as my Credit entirely exhausted, my Private resources in Virginia Cut
1 See Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, this date.
2 For earlier financial appeals from Bland and the Virginia delegation, see Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, November 5, 1780. On June 19 the Virginia legislature, then meeting in Staunton, directed the governor and council to remit the delegates' allowance immediately by "purchasing and transmitting to them tobacco or hemp, or by pursuing such other modes as to them shall appear most effectual." See Journal of the House of Delegates of the Commenwealth of Virginia [May 7-June 23, 1781] (Richmond: Reprinted by T. W. White, 1828), pp. 23, 28.
3 See Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, this date. For further information on Carter Braxton's "remittance," see Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 2:269, 3:13940.
I have herewith enclosed for your Information, the Copy of an Act of Congress of the 31st Ulto, recommending to the States of Pennsylvania, Delaware & Maryland immediately to raise & equip a Number of Troops; the more immediate Design of which is to repel the Enemy now in Virginia.(1)
I am also to inform you we have received authentic Advice, that the Emperor of Germany & Empress of Russia have offered their Mediation between the Belligerent Powers, which was embraced with apparent Eagerness on the Part of Great Britain, and will probably be accepted on the Part of France & Spain, and we are called upon by our Ally to prepare for Negotiation as soon as possible.
This important Intelligence we have communicated to the several Governors, with Caution that it be not disclosed at present, and a most earnest Recommendation that the States make the most
A powerful french Fleet under the Count de Grasse is arrived at Martinque & gave the British Fleet who were waiting for them, a severe Drubbing near that Island on the 27th of April; since which the French have made a Descent on St. Lucia & we may soon expect farther Intelligence from that Quarter.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Respect, sir, Your most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam Huntington President
1 See Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781.
2 For de Grasse's success in beating off Rear-Admiral Samuel Hood's awaiting fleet near Martinique, see Jonathan R. Dull, The French Navy and American Independence (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1975), p. 238. However, his "Descent on St. Lucia" had been dropped in favor of an attack on the less heavily garrisoned island of Tobago, which had just surrendered to his forces on June 2.
I have been honored with your Excellency's Letter of the 28th Ulto, previous to which Congress had adopted the Measures contained in their Act of the 31st Ulto, Copy of which is enclosed, for sending Assistance to repel the Enemy in Virginia.(1) No Means in the Power of Congress will be left unessayed to give you all necessary Aid. I am informed some Arms are now on the Way for Virginia, and the Board of War are still using their Endeavors, not without Prospect of Success, to procure more Arms to supply such Troops from Maryland & this State as may be raised & march to join the Marquis de la Fayette.
Enclosed are Extracts of Intelligence from the West Indies which you may not have received.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with very great Respect, Your Excellency's Most obedient Servant, Sam. Huntington
1 See Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781. For Jefferson's May 28 letter to Huntington, see Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 6:25, 32-33.
2 Huntington's enclosure, an extract from a May 3-8 letter announcing Admiral de Grasse's arrival in the West Indies and French preparations for an attack on St. Lucia, is in Cal. of Va. State Papers, 2:84-85.
Your Excellency's Letter of the 27th Ulto hath been duly received, (1) previous thereto Congress had adopted the Resolution of the 31st Ulto, recommending to the States of Pennsylvania, Maryland & Delaware respectively to raise and equip a Number of Troops. The more immediate Object Congress had in View from this Resolution (Copy of which is enclosed) (2) was to give speedy Assistance to those Parts of Virginia at present invaded, or exposed to Invasion by the Enemy, but the Troops are to be wholly subject to your Direction.
I have also herewith enclosed for your Information, a Copy of my circular Letter of the first Instant addressed to the several supreme Executives, accompanied with a Request that the Intelligence it contained might not be disclosed at present.(3) Governor Jefferson's Letter which your Excellency will receive by the same Messenger who will deliver this, will, I presume, give you the latest Intelligence we have received of the Motions of the Enemy in Virginia.
Enclosed are Extracts of Letters from Martinique of the 3d & 8th of May, announcing the Arrival of the French Fleet under Count de Grasse &c.(4)
I have the Honor to be, with the greatest Respect & Esteem, Your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington Presidt.
1 See JCC, 20:585; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:119-22.
2 See Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781.
3 See Huntington's circular letters to the states of June 1 and 2.
4 For this enclosure, which is in the Washington Papers, DLC, see the preceding entry, note 2.
We received at 10 oClock last night your favor of the 1st Instant, (1) previous to the receipt of it We had pressed Congress in the most earnest manner to succour the Southern States and were ability equal to inclination they would soon be relieved. The Treasury of the United States is totally exhausted, without the hope of its soon being replenished.
Inclosed you have a Resolution of Congress of the 31st of May (2) which if it can be carried into execution will afford some relief. If we
We shall transmit by an express going to the General this evening a Copy of your Letter (4) and doubt not but he will do every thing in his power to afford the desired assistance, consistent with his General plan of Operations for the present Campaign which we presume he has before this time concerted with the Count de Rochambeau.
We are with the greatest respect & esteem, Gentlemen, Your most Obedient Servants,
Daniel of St Thos Jenifer
Danl. Carroll
1 For the June 1 letter from Maryland assembly speaker Bruff and senate president Plater, which was read in Congress on June 4, See JCC, 20:597; and PCC, item 70, fols. 473-76. "The General Assembly and the Governor and Council have wrote you several letters within these two Days," they anxiously observed, "and requested you to inform Congress of the Movements of Lord Cornwallis, and to urge them in the most pressing Manner to order all the force, which can possibly be spared, to march immediately to the assistance of the Marquiss Fayette....We wish you would communicate the Intelligence you receive to his Excellency General Washington, whose presence, with a Body of Regulars, would effectually stop the Progress of the Enemy." They further requested the assistance of one thousand Pennsylvania militamen "as We are apprehensive the stand must be made on the North side of Potomack." For the May 30 and 31 letters from Gov. Thomas Sim Lee and the Council to the delegates see Md. Archives, 45:450, 452. The former was read in Congress on June 4. See JCC, 20:597; and PCC, item 70, fols. 469-72.
2 See Samuel Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781.
3 See Maryland Delegates to Thomas Sim Lee, June 4, 1781.
4 Carroll and Jenifer's June 3 letter to Washington, which he acknowledged on June 7, has not been found, but a copy of Bruff and Plater's June I letter to them is in the Washington Papers, DLC. See Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:173-74; and the postscript to Maryland Delegates to Thomas Sim Lee, June 4, 1781.
We inclose you a Copy of a Bill sent [to us by] Mr. Braxton for the balance of the Warrant [obtained] from me last December. This payment [was $]1000 short of the true balance and was by [agree]ment with Mr. Jones to have been made the last week [in A]pril. We presented the bill to the Kieldles who [tell] us they would accept it and pay it in the monies [the] Bill requires either in old continental money or [in] the new emissions but your Excellency knows that [if] paid in the first the State will be a considerable [los]er
Jos. Jones
Theok. Bland
[P.S.] 7 Battalions of Militia Infantry in the whole & 160 Horse.(5) The Legislature of this State [vote]d a repeal of the Tender [Law....]
1 This undated letter is undoubtedly "the letter from the delegation" cited by Bland in his personal letter to the governor of this date.
2 See Virginia Delegates to Jefferson, November 5, 1780, note 2.
3 Undoubtedly Samuel Huntington's June 1 circular letter to the states.
4 For Congress' reply to Jefferson's May 28 appeal for assistance, see Huntington to Jefferson, this date.
5 See Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781.
The inclosed papers will furnish you with the most important foreign intelligence we have lately received, And of what has been done by Congress in consequence thereof.(1)
We thought it necessary to give you this communication, not knowing how far [it ma]y influence your future operations, [so t]hat you might thereby be enabled to take your measures accordingly.
We have received undoubted intelligence of the arrival of the french fleet in the West Indies, which makes their force at present in that quarter 25 sail of the line-that of the British is said to be twenty one. The two fleets had a skirmish on the 29 of April, but nothing decisive happened. By letters of the 8th ulto. from Martinique, we are informed that the french fleet sailed on the 7th with 7000 troops to attack St. Lucia, which place it was expected would be reduced in a few days.
We suppose the Commander in Cheif has of course communicated to you, his plan of operations for the campaign, particularly the blow meditated against New York. It is therefore unnecessary for us to say anything further on that subject.(2)
We are, sir, with much Esteem & Regard Yr. most Obed. Servts. By order of the Committee, Jno. Mathews Chrmn.
P.S. The inclosed papers are for your private information & must not on any account be communicated to any other person.
Pray inform us particularly whether this reaches you in safety.
1 Among the "inclosed papers" was a copy of Samuel Huntington's June I circular letter which bears Greene's endorsement: "From Mr. Mathews, June 4th. 1781." At the end of the letter is the following note written and signed by William Sharpe, a member of the committee appointed to correspond with the commander of the southern department. "The foregoing is a copy of a circular letter sent to the executives of the respective states. It may be proper to note that change of circumstances in Europe has altered the plan of sending us the second division as was at first proposed, but the squadron at Rhode Island is to be reinforced so as to be able to put to sea with confidence." Continental Congress Miscellany, DLC.
2 For Washington's May 27 letter to Congress revealing his plan of operations," which was read in Congress on June 1, and his June 1 letter to Greene on the same subject, See JCC, 20:585; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:115}22, 146-47
I enclose a resolve of Congress of May 24 respecting an Interest of Messrs Dumaine & Lyon with their petition annexed.(1) I also add the copy of a resolve of Sepr 27, 1780 and of a Short Letter of mine to a gentleman in Teneriffe, to serve as a Memorandum in Case you have not already procured justice for Mr Magnall and his associates who took the Dover Cutter.(2) Mr McCarrick of St. Cruz is knowing to all the circumstances of that affair. Magnall has been unfortunate from the time he left this place, last October-he is now here. I do not know whether this is the Matter referred to in the Letter of Mr Carmichael Decr 24, When he says "The Minister also engaged to do justice to certain Americans who carried a British Privateer to the Canaries."(3) I sent you an extract from Instructions given to Dr Franklin concerning Mr D'Audibert Caille which may serve to govern your Conduct towards that Gentleman.(4) Your humble Servant, vide October 4. 1780(5)
Signed James Lovell
1 On May 24 Congress had directed John Jay to present to the Spanish government the claim of the Boston firm of "Dumaine and Lyon" for a merchant vessel carried as a prize into Tenerife, Canary Islands, by Capt. Samuel Waters, and there seized by the Spanish admiralty office. JCC, 20:331. For the background of this case, whose principals were probably Daniel Du Maine and Humphrey Lyon, see the Board of Admiralty's March 10, 1781, report in PCC, item 37, fols. 359-62; and JCC, 19:260-61 .
This case was also the subject of the following brief letter from Lovell to Jay of June 15, 1781.
"On the 4th I transmitted to you a resolve of May 24 respecting an Interest of Messrs Dumaine & Lyon with their petition annexed. You will herewith receive other Copies of those papers by opportunities Which the party concerned will industriously find. I recommend the business afresh to your attention. Those worthy men having already met with Vexatious delays on this side of the water." PCC, item 79, fols. 283-84.
2 For the case of John Mangnall and his associates at Tenerife, see Committee for Foreign Affairs to Mr. McCarrick, October 4, 1780.
3 William Carmichael's December 24, 1780, letter to the Committee for Foreign Affairs, which had been read in Congress on April 30 (JCC, 20:464), is in PCC, item 88, fols. 187-94; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 5:68-69, where it is printed under December 24, 1781, just as Carmichael had misdated it.
4 See JCC, 20:553; and Samuel Huntington to Etienne d'Audibert Caille, December, 1780.
5 Undoubtedly a reference to the letter to McCarrick cited in note 2.
The Express set out on his return to Annapolis before we had time to answer your Excellencys Letter of 30th Ulto.(1) The Board of War had offered us for some days 1000 stand of Arms if we could furnish £1000. Specie to pay for Bayonets & repairs; the apparent distress that our state was likely to be under for want of them, obliged us to offer our personal Security for the repayment of this Money in two Months in Specie, or Flour to the amount; and the board of War in consequence thereof immediately gave the necessary Orders. But upon Your Letters & one from the President of the Senate & Speaker of the House of Delegates being laid before congress, they were referred to the Board of War to take order thereon, & means furnished them for not only the necessary expences of repairs, but also for Transportation, by which we are released from our engagement for the Specie or flour. The board of War has assured us that in 7 days time 1500 Stand of Arms shall be ready for our State & 2500 for the State of Virga. & other accoutrements. I am sure that every thing that can, will be done, and altho the funds of Congress have been totally exhausted, yet We have the pleasure to assure you that they have now a small stream that will set our Wheels in motion.
President Reed has informed us that the assembly of Pennsylvania must pass an Act before he can set the Militia of the State in motion in consequence of the Resolution of Congress, and expects this will be done in a day or two.
Your Excellency has not intimatated to us, the time when we may expect a supply of Money to defray our necessary expences; we do assure you, that unless it soon comes to hand we shall be in the most distressed situation, for altho we could have procured, or at least engaged £1000 for the purpose of Arming our Troops yet We should be ashamed to apply to the same quarter for our dayly Subsistence.(2)
We are with the highest regard and respect, Sir, Your Excellencys most obedient and most humble Servants,
Daniel of St Thos Jenifer.
Danl. Carroll
PS. By an express that was to have set out yesterday afternoon to Head Quarters (but did not go off 'till this morning) we transmitted to the General a Copy of the President of the Senate and Speaker of the House of Delegates Letter to us & doubt not but he will do every thing in his power towards relieving Virga. & Maryland from their present distress.(3)
If the Embargo Act is not already repealed We think the sooner it is done the better.
We do not know what has become of Mr. Paca. Since writing the above, Mr Carroll has informed me that he is about to set out to take the Country Air for two or three days, in his absence our State will not be represented. Be pleased to inform Mr. Hanson or Mr. Potts that one of them ought immediately to set out to Congress. Your obedt Servt.
Daniel of St Thos. Jenifer
1 See Maryland Delegates to William Bruff and George Plater, June 3, 1781, note 1 .
2 See Maryland Delegates to Lee, May 30, 1781, note 2.
3 See Maryland Delegates to Bruff and Plater, June 3, 1781, note 4.
Sundry letters have been lately received from France dated from the 8th to 20th March. Instead of the second division only a few Ships of the line are to be sent so as to make the squadron at Rhode Island superior to Arbuthnots; they are expected every day. This arrangement took place in consequence of the Dutch war which requires to be cherrished by France. A sum of 6,000,000 livres tournois is granted us as a subsidy the greater part of which is to be laid out in cloathing and Stores for the Army-the remainder to be drawn for by bills. Mr. Franklin had negociated the business of Mr. Laurens mission before he arived and the disposition of the french fleet was made. Count de Grass with 21 sail of the line arived in the West Indias on the 29th of April, Rodney with 17 of the line lay in the way to intercept them coming into Martinique not expecting Count de Grass to be so strong. The Counts first object was to get 153 transports, Merchantmen &c under his convoy safe into Port which he effected and gave 4 sail of the line which lay in port the opportunity to join him. He then attacked Rodney who fled and the Count was pursuing when the Holker left St. Piere and brought a letter from Parsons. We are promised a Naval superiority on the American Seas this campaign; but the contingencies of war may blast the most promising appearances. Admiral Darby sailed from England on the 13th March with 25 sail of the line in order to raise the seige at Giberalter. A vessel just arived from Cadiz, brings advice that Darby effected his purpose without opposition. And that when he came away admiral Cordova with 30 sail of the line lay close in Cadiz because the English Ships were larger, & heavier mettal.
Comodore Johnstone with a small squadron is gone to the East Indias. The French have sent a squadron there also. It is supposed that a squadron of French will, or have joined Cordova.
The Empress of Russia and Emperor of Germany have offered their mediation between the beligerent powers which has been accepted with an aparent eagerness by the Court of London. France has answered that it is personally agreeable to him; but that he has allies which must be consulted before he can conveniently give a definitive answer. The answer of Spain has been somewhat equivocal, but the measure will doubtless be infinitely agreeable to him. Mr. Cumberland has failed in his object, that of inducing Spain to a seperate peace. The most vigorous exertions on our part are indispensibly necessary in order to expel the enemy or at least to confine them to their strong holds. The enemy will strenuously insist on the proposition of Uti possidatis which is held up by our Ally as totally inadmissable. The Northern army are preparing to attack New York. I forbear making any observations on the propriety of this measure. There are some appearances of the enemys evacuating that post. There are about 7000 of the enemys troops now in Virginia. The Marquis with 900 and Genl. Wayne with 850 regulars to oppose them. We have called upon Pennsylvania for 2000 Militia to be equipped & Marched immediately, Delaware 500, Maryland 1200, to serve to the southward. The legislature is now met here and appears a little more engaged to support the southern states than formerly.
We wish to be relieved; but as the circumstances of our State are so distressing, we have resolved, not to leave the State unrepresented.
Mr. Johnston has written to Mr. Willie Jones and Genl. Caswell. I have written to Colo. Martin.(1) Please to communicate these things to such of our other friends as you may think proper. I could not have written so freely, but expect this to go by some confidential person whom the President will send with some communications to the Executive of our State.
[I] long to hear again from Genl. Greene.
With great esteem & respect I am, Sir, Your Most Obt. Humble Servt. Wm. Sharpe
N.B. In all our letters from Europe there is not a word of Englands sending a reinforcement to Genl. Clinton.
1 These letters have not been found.
I was Yesterday honoured with your Excellency's Favour of 29 ult. inclosing a Letter to Capt. Hutchins. I immediately sent it to the Captains Lodgings, and I believe it found him, though he told me two Days before that he meant to set out for Princeton on Monday Morning. He will doubtless wait upon your Excellency, and it is unnecessary for me to bespeak your Civilities or those of your Friends to him.
I am, with much Respect, your Excellency's most obedt and most hble Servant. W.C. Houston
I thank you for your favor of the first Inst. Censor had much better in my opinion employed his Penn in attempting to heal breaches than to have widen'd them, as to one of the Rulers I do not care how soon he is changed .(1)
The Governor has informed Mr. Carroll that our Supply of Money shall be speedy,(2) & therefore it would be doubting his & the Councils attention at this time to apply immediately to the Genl. Assembly, but our wants are so great that Mr. Carroll who whas been for some days & still continues unwell could not apply to the Doctor because he had not Money to pay him for his Visit & Medic[ine]s. The first Resolution of the Committee of the whole will do very well, the second perhaps is too broad. See what the other States do in this business before you carry your Resolution into a Law. Congress have laid the foundation of a general Bank which will preclude the idea of erecting others. Congress have heard nothing from General Green lately nor of the success you mention.
I expect that General Wayne will be able to join the Marquis tomorrow, and that he will have it in his power to check the progressive Motions of the Enemy.
Mr. Carroll and I wrote to the Genl assembly to add two members to the Delegation.(3) We expected the choice would have been immediately made & that we should have seen by this time Mr. Johnson, Mr. Stone, Mr Carroll (4) or yourself. Subjects of the last importance to the United States are before Congress, and unless we have the assistance of one or two of you in the course of this week it
I shall enquire for the Map & Pamphlet you mention. I am with my compliments to Mrs. Hall.
Dr Sir Your affectionate friend,
Daniel of St Thos Jenifer
1 In his letter of June 1, Hall had evidently enclosed the May 24 and 31 issues of Frederick and Samuel Green's Maryland Gazette, each of which contained a letter written by Samuel Chase under the pseudonym "Censor" attacking the Maryland senate for the devaluation of the state currency in the wake of the congressional fiscal resolves of March 18, 1780. Since efforts to redeem old bills at the rate of 40 to 1 had been sabotaged by a senate party which had "violated our public faith, and fomented quarrels and divisions," Chase charged, "we must change our measures, and our rulers, or this country will be undone." Trying to influence voters in anticipation of the September elections, he broadened his attacks on Senate policy in the June 7 and 21 issues of the Gazette. Chase was soon joined in debate through the summer and fall by various pseudonymous authors and was finally challenged directly by Charles Carroll of Carrollton, especially on the charge that Chase had speculated in flour in 1778 by taking advantage of secret congressional information. See these Letters, 10:626-28, 12:520-22; and James Haw, et al., Stormy Patriot: The Life of Samuel Chase (Baltimore: Maryland Historical Society, 1980), pp. 114-15. See also Jenifer to Hall, June 11, note 1, and July 24, 1781.
2 For Thomas Sim Lee's promise of financial relief "as soon as possible," see Maryland Delegates to Lee, May 30, 1781, note 2.
3 Not found.
4 That is, Thomas Johnson, Thomas Stone, and either Charles Carroll of Carrollton or Charles Carroll, Barrister.
5 For the congressional resolutions respecting "British 8: Refugee property" that were adopted the preceding October in response to inquiries from John Adams, see JCC, 18:948-50.
You will perceive by the papers, that the Belligerent powers under the Mediation of the Empress of Russia and Emperor of Germany are about holding a Congress, and I fear that our Interests will not be so immediately attended to as we might wish: however, I think France must procure us tolerable terms, or She cannot expect to keep us long in her interest, therefore I trust more to her policy than her Justice. She is powerful in the West Indias, & from present appearances could do everything with apparent success, but that of taking Castles, & this She is attempting-strange infatuation.
I wish with all my heart that the Marquis may be able to check Cornwallis. If he should March through St[r]atford & Prince William to Alexandria, I think the Marquis will have charming defensive Ground to make Stands upon.
The Board of War has promised to have ready in 7 days 1500 Stand of arms for our State, Greyson is indefatigable. I expect that the Pennsylva. Assembly now sitting will empower their executive, to send forward immediately four Battallions of Militia to the assistance of Maryland or Virginia as the situation of the Enemy may require.
I wish our State had delayed the Selling of British property a little longer, it would perhaps have been to her advantage to have done so; I do not care to enter in to particular reasoning at this time on the Subject, because it may be thought that I am influenced by former prejudices, and that wiser heads have determined otherwise; but rest assured that I-have greater reason to be of this opinion now than I ever had. I wish you health and happiness and am very truely, Your Affectionate friend, Daniel of St Thos. Jenifer
I do myself the honour to enclose you the papers which will give you the news of the day. Some part of it looks well. But the Brittish gain upon us in Virginia. Pensylvania, Maryland & Delaware militia are raising (too slow) to meet them. The eastern Post not arrived makes us apprehensive for its safety.(1) Genl Sullivan is well, with whom I am very intimate. Please to let me hear from you especially on the subject of supporting your Delegates.
I am Dear Sir your most obedt servant.
Samuel Livermore
1 The "eastern Post" had, indeed, again fallen victim to the British and the captured letters began appearing in the June 9, 1781, issue of James Rivington's New York Royal Gazette.
Not having any of yr. Favors since that of April 17th I am singularly mortified at the Failure of the Post yesterday. I suspect the Rider is carried into New York.(1) We had a few days ago some good Intelligence from the West Indies which is now in the Gazette. I need say nothing of european Letters as Communications are made to the Government of Massa.
I think I gave you some Time ago the same Advice as to my Family vizt-to keep confidential ready written till a private hand offers that you may not lose such Opportunities, now, more than ever, necessary.
My Impatience, however, to communicate some Hints to you will induce me to use Cyphers before this Post sets off. You will readily understand them by making a Column of Figures from 1 to 27 and place two other Columns of Letters by the side of it; the 1st of them beginning with the 2d Letter and the 2d of them beginning with the 3d Letter of the maiden Name of the Wife of that Gentleman from whom I sent you a Little Money on a Lottery Score.(2) Look alternately into these Columns against my Figures and you will have proper Letters for Words. TheNumber, and natural Sequence of the Alphabet is
| 1 a 2 b 3 c 4 d 5 e 6 f 7 g 8 h 9 i | 10 j 11 k 12 1 13 m 14 n 15 o 16 p 17 q 18 r | 19 s 20 t 21 u 22 v 23 w 24 x 25 y 26 z 27 & |
I retained yr. 2 Bitts with yr. Whip & Linnen.
I still continue lame tho but slightly. The Family is well and some of it not a little uneasy thro Fear that you are not so in Health.
Affly.-JL
[P.S.] There appears to be a desire in the vexed {de Vergennes}(3) the obedient if not designing {Fr. ministration} in America and the
1 See the preceding letter, note.
2 Although the person has not been identified, the key letters are "e o." See Adams, Family Correspondence (Butterfield), 4:395.
3 Words printed in braces in this text were written by Lovell in cipher.
4 Lovell was referring to the delegates who regularly dined with the French minister, La Luzerne.
5 The subject of this postscript was also the subject of this day's congressional debate on the report of the committee appointed May 25 to confer with La Luzerne on French concerns over prospective peace negotiations in Europe. The committee's conference with La Luzerne had been ordered in response to a request from the French minister acting on instructions he received from Vergennes asking for a greater French voice in such future negotiations and a plenipotentiary more compliant than Adams. Lovell's alarm at this threat to Adams' authority was amply justified by the results of the next day's debates, which resulted in the adoption of new diplomatic instructions, effectively placing control of negotiations in Vergennes' hands and naming Benjamin Franklin, Henry Laurens, John Jay, and Thomas Jefferson as ministers plenipotentiary to join Adams. See JCC, 20:601, 605-19, 625-28, 638-40, 648, 650-55; Huntington to Franklin, June 19; Lovell to Adams, June 21; and Lovell to Abigail Adams, July 13 note 5.
For the continuation of this letter, see Lovell to Gerry, June 13, 1781.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, a Resolve of Congress of the 2d Instant, directing that all Bills which are issued in the respective States in Pursuance of the Resolution of the 18th of March 1780, after the Expiration of one Year from the Time the Interest on such Bills begins to be computed, be stamped with the Words or Characters, Int. pd one, (or 1) Year.
And that such of the said Bills as have already issued, whenever the Interest is paid, be stamped in like Manner, to prevent the Necessity & Expence of exchanging them.
It is also the Sense of Congress that the several States suspend, as far as possible, the Issuing of such Part of their respective Quotas of said Bills as remain to be issued.(1)
I have the Honor to be &c &c &c S. H.
1 For the adoption of this June 2 resolve, see JCC, 20:577-78, 591-94; and Madison, Papers (Hutchinson), 3:143-44. See also Jesse Root to Jonathan Trumbull, April 3, 1781, note 1.
For other aspects of the campaign to curtail paper money emissions in the aftermath of Congress' devaluation of the Continental dollar in March 1780, see Huntington to the States, September 2, 1780; JCC, 19:376-81, 20:500-504; and Morris, Papers (Ferguson), 1:l00n.2, 179-83, 193-200.
A Resolve of Congress of the 2d Instant relative to the Bills emitted in Pursuance of the Act of the 18th of March 1780 is herewith enclosed for the Information of your Excellency.
By sundry Prisoners from Charles Town who are exchanged & just arrived at this Port in a Flag, we have received Information which seems not to admit a Doubt, that Lord Rawdon had evacuated Camden and retreated to Charlestown with his Troops, and was pursued by General Greene. 'Tis also reported, that on his Retreat he was attacked by General Greene with considerable Success, but this latter Report wants further Confirmation.
From various Accounts it seems highly probable the Enemy have evacuated or lost all their inland Posts. It is said our People are in Possession of Ninety Six, Augusta and some other Posts nearer Charlestown, but we have no Advices from General Greene later than those already communicated to your Excellency.
I have the Honor to be, with the greatest Regard, Your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam Huntington President
I am requested by the Delegates from Pennsylvania to transmit your Excellency the Papers enclosed, containing Petitions, Complaints &c against Colonel Broadhead.(1)
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Respect, Your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
1 See Huntington to Washington, June 2, 1781; and Pa. Council Minutes, 12:747. The enclosed memorials to the Pennsylvania Council from the "Town of Pittsburgh" and from the "County of Westmoreland," dated May 9, 1781, are in the Washington Papers, DLC.
I have expected for some Time since, the Determination of the State, respecting their Delegation;(1) but remaining uncertain, Patience has taken the place of Information, and personal Credit removed some of the Inconveniences of local Situation
I wish it was in my Power to give you a particular Account of our Affairs in the Southern States; but we have no very late Intelligence from the Carolina's. A Report by a Flagg from Charlestown has just come to us, that General Greene has gained very capital Advantages over Lord Rawden; but how extensive, Time must determine.(2) Our Finances assume a more favorable Aspect; and I hope will soon be productive of salutary Events. The Enemy are in great Force in Virginia under Lord Cornwallis, and the Troops opposed to them very inferior in Numbers. That State Suffers much, and I am fully Persuaded, will find Relief only in the Exertions of the eastern States. The present Campaign is pregnant with the most important Events; and it is in the Power of the States to render it glorious for America. The Policy of this State [Pennsylvania] has assumed a very respectable Aspect within a few days and I am persuaded will furnish Supplies in a great Measure proportionate to her Resources. The Money of her own Emissions, has risen from seven to four for one, & is still appreciating; while the Money of other States is of very inferior Credit. But as the whole Emissions form a Medium very inadequate to the Sums demanded in Taxation, punctual Payments will bring the whole to a respectable Level, or evince the Necessity of committing it to the Flames, and of relying wholly upon Silver and Gold. The Eastern Male,(3) Which should have come to us on Monday last, has been intercepted on the West side of the Hudson, and carried into New York. Casualties of this kind, however disagreeable, are the natural Consequences of defensive War, when the resisting Army become too feeble to Straiten the Enemy's Lines. I have wished, for a long Time, that the Post Office was abolished, or at least suspended, as more Injury results from than Benefit.
I have the Honor of being Sir, with great Respect & Esteem, your Excellencys most obedient, & very humble Servt.
JM Varnum
1 Rhode Island had elected a new slate of delegates on May 2, consisting of Varnum, Ezekiel Cornell, William Ellery, and Daniel Mowry, but the news apparently was not received until the beginning of July when Cornell returned to Philadelphia from his recent tour of military posts. As Cornell and Ellery were serving as commissioners of the Board of War and the Board of Admiralty, respectively, and the attendance of two delegates from each state was required under the Articles of Confederation, Rhode Island remained unrepresented until Mowry attended on July 20. Varnum's concern over the state's lack of representation at this time was also voiced by Ellery in the following June 9 letter to Governor Greene.
"I had the honor of writing to your Excellency by the last post; but, as my letter may have been intercepted, I beg leave to repeat the substance of it, so far as I can bring it to my recollection, for it was written in haste in the Admiralty Office, and I had not time to copy it.
"It mentioned that no credentials of my being elected a delegate had been received by me, from which I inferred that either Mr. Cornell or Mr. Mowry had set out for Congress, or that my credentials had gone to New York with the last eastern mail, which is supposed to have been intercepted by the enemy. The first I concluded was the case, because I could not conceive that it would be inconvenient for Mr. Mowry to come forward, and presumed that it might suit Gen. Varnum to continue here until Gen. Cornell had finished his visit to his family, and returned to Philadelphia; and because I had been so long absent from home, and been so long confined to business, that the Assembly would imagine that not only my clothes, but my spirits would want repairs, and that my family affairs would require my return. Besides, I mentioned that I had, some time since, upon hearing that my name was in a prox, written to some of my friends that, let the election issue as it might, I must return home this summer, and supposed that they might have mentioned it in the Assembly. These reasons have led me to think that one or both of the gentlemen I have mentioned might be here soon, and that it was not expected that I should take a seat in Congress until the next fall or winter. Most certainly the General Assembly must know that I was not entitled to act as a delegate without a legal notification of my appointment.
"I expect to return to the State in a short time, unless I should receive credentials, and a direction from the Assembly to take my seat in Congress. Such a direction I should obey, however inconvenient and disadvantageous it might be, for I hold it to be the duty of a public servant to comply with the injunctions of his masters, unless they should be illegal." Staples, Rhode Island, pp. 344 45.
2 Official word of these "Advantages" was received by Congress on June 11 with the arrival of letters of May 10, 14, and 16 from Gen. Nathanael Greene. See JCC, 20:620; and Daniel of St. Thomas Jenifer to John Hall, June 11, 1781.
3 That is, the Eastern Mail, which had been intercepted again by the British. See Samuel Livermore to Meshech Weare, June 5, 1781.
I am sorry to observe, that after going through the instructions to be given to our plenipotentiary or plenipotentiaries, we should have so warm a debate,(2) and indeed seem to be so equally divided upon the question, whether there should be one or more to whom we will entrust the negociation?
As to the practice of European nations, I believe it is so various as not to afford any argument on one side or the other; we may
As to the first of these, on the side of one person, it may be said there will be more precision, more expedition, more uniformity and more certainty of agreement with others, and consistency with himself. And the person whom we have employed, is a man of sound and clear understanding, and has had the advantage of being a long time in Europe, and no doubt has been turning his thoughts, and making enquiries upon the subject ever since he went there; so that we may suppose him pretty ripely advised.
On the other side, it may be said, that, if alone, he might be at a loss, and that it would be of advantage to him to have the advice of others. It is even said, that there is a necessity of others better acquainted with parts of the country different from those with which he has been chiefly connected. As to council, that does not strike me much-perhaps there is greater safety in one than three; because he is fully responsible; whereas if a common council is taken, the blame is divided, and every one is less difficulted to justify his conduct in the issue. Besides, is there no danger to the cause itself, from an obstinate division of sentiments in those who are entrusted with the conduct of it? This would expose us, in the opinion of those who observed it, and might perhaps give less respect to what each or all of them might say or do.
As to the necessity of persons from different parts of the country, it is not easy to conceive what circumstances, in a negociation of this kind, can be peculiar to one part of the country more than another. If it were to make rules for the internal government, taxation, or commerce of the states, there would be some force in the remark; but when it is only to make peace for the liberty and protection of all, there seems to be little weight in it.
But now let us consider our particular circumstances. Mention has been made of the difference between Mr Adams and the count de Vergennes. I have given particular attention to all that was said in his letter upon that subject, and all that has been said by the minister of France here; and there was not one hint given that could lead us to think it was their desire or expectation that he should be dismissed or superseded, or even bridled by the addition of others in the commission. We have fully complied with their desire upon this subject, in the instructions. There is the greatest reason to think
I cannot help putting you in mind, upon this subject, of what has just now come to light. You are informed by the French court, in the most authentic manner, and indeed if I am not mistaken, it is by implication at least in the king's letter,(3) that you had been ill served by the people you employed there, and cheated both in point of quality and price; and on this account they intend to give directions on that subject themselves. Now, Sir, perhaps it may be news to many members of this body, that these were the very contracts made by Mr Dean, without the knowledge or consent of Mr Lee, of which Mr Lee loudly complained. These were the very servants whose accounts Mr Lee objected to, and whose conduct he censured. But what did he get by it? Mr Dean was supported by his venerable old friend, as he called him: Mr Lee was complained of as jealous and troublesome, and disagreeable to the court of France; and not only opposed and slighted by many members of this house, but I may say attacked and persecuted in such a manner, that if he had not been supported with a generous frankness by others, might have ended in public infamy.
I have just further upon this subject to observe, that you very lately sent a new minister to the French court, Mr Laurens-a measure much disapproved by many; and it was then foretold, it would be a disgraceful thing to Dr Franklin.(4) Probably he has
Some have mentioned the importance of the matter, and that the chance is greater against corruption, where three are to be taken off, than one. It is very true, that ceteries paribus, as is commonly said, there is a greater chance for one incorruptible person in three than in one: but there are single persons in whom I would confide as much as in ten. And besides, the thing may be taken the other way; for there is a greater chance of finding one corruptible person in three than in one; and in a commission of that nature, one traitor is able to do much mischief, though the others are perfectly upright. He, being admitted into the secret, may not only disclose measures, but perplex them, let the abilities of his colleagues be what they will. I have seen a man in Congress, who upon the supposition of his being a traitor, I am sure had address enough to draw many into his measures-many not contemptible in understanding, and sincerely attached to their country's cause.
Before I conclude, I would say a little upon our circumstances in another respect. The first appearances we make upon the public stage, are of consequence. It is to be wished therefore, that the credit of the United States were consulted. If we were sure that our commissioners would be immediately admitted to public and coordinate session with the other plenipotentiaries, perhaps a commission of three would be august and honourable; but if, as I strongly suspect will be the case, they are not at first publicly admitted at all, but obliged to negociate through the plenipotentiaries of France-if, as it is not impossible, even in the settlement of the treaty, we are not considered as the formal contracting parties at all, but our interest attended to in articles as it were occassionally introduced-if this is done as a salve to the honour of England, and to purchase for us advantages substantial and durable, a pompous commission to a number of delegates will rather lessen our dignity, and detract from our wisdom and caution.
Upon the whole, Sir, I am of opinion, that it would be much better to assign to one the commission already given, with the instructions which have been cordially agreed upon, and seem to be in every respect agreeable to the desires of the court of France, and the opinion of the king's minister in this country.
1 Although this document is not dated, Witherspoon undoubtedly delivered the speech in Congress on June 9 or 11 during the debates over a motion to "join" additional peace negotiators to John Adams as minister plenipotentiary. See JCC, 20:619, 627-28; Varnum L. Collins, President Witherspoon, a Biography. 2 vols. (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1925), 2:54-62; and James Lovell to Elbridge Gerry, June 5, 1781, note 5.
2 Congress had been "going through the instructions to be given our plenipotentiary or plenipotentiaries" since June 6.JCC, 20 604-17.
3 Undoubtedly a reference to the March 10, 1781, letter of the king of France, which is in JCC, 20:556-57.
4 For the concern that the appointment of a special envoy to France would be interpreted as a lack of confidence in Franklin, see James Lovell to Elbridge Gerry, November 30, 1780, note 3.
I am obliged to you for your favor of the 8th. Necessity will justify extraordinary measures, and altho the liberty of the Citizens be encroached upon, yet it is to be hoped they will submit; but the Cord may be stretched too tight. That of drafting Blacks is a serious Question should it take place, those not drafted will be miserable, & probably will fly to the Enemy, & those that may be drafted cannot in my opinion be depended upon.
The Negative to the Bill you mention has I suppose sharpen'd Censors pen, I thank you for the paper, and wish you to continue sending me any publications of that sort. Poor Senate! (1) General Green has taken very lately three Posts with 500 Prisoners. Pikins is before 96; which Genl Green expects will soon fall; this is the last Post remaining in S.C. except Chas. Town. I believe that there is not so much disaffection in North Carolina as you imagine. Lord Cornwallis added but 200 to his Corps during his stay in that State. I fear the intelligence of Parkers surprizing Portsmouth is premature, as is that also of Cornwallis's retreating. The Marquis Fayette's not so strong as you immagine. He has taken Post 30 Miles to the Westward of Fredericsburg. I cannot think that France will agree to the Uti possidetis unless compelled to it by the Mediating powers.
Yesterday Congress finished the important business occasioned by dispatches from the Court of Versailles and to the Wish of your Delegates.(2) Great obstructions thrown in the way by Virga., Massachusets & Conectcut especially the former we were several times overthrown but regained our feet again. I cannot say I expect either peace or Truce soon, unless the French should be victorious at Sea. If the independence of the 13 States be acknowledged, the Enemys Ministry or some of them I think will lose their heads probably an act of Parliament may be obtained before a peace takes place to Sanctify the measure. By the Generals Letter to your Delegates which they have transmitted to the Genl Assembly there appears to be a ray of hope.(3) Perhaps the Enemy may have occasion to look behind him.
Your affectionate friend, Daniel of St Thos Jenifer
1 The "paper" sent by Hall in his letter of June 8 was probably the June 7 issue of the Maryland Gazette, for which see Jenifer to Hall, June 5, 1781, note 1.
2 Since Congress finished this "important business" on June 11, Jenifer probably added this concluding paragraph on June 12.
The congressional debate on the "dispatches from the Court of Versailles" had come to focus on the issue of the control of peace negotiations should Britain accept a recent Russian mediation offer. The French court wished to manage any such negotiations and entertained suspicions of the American plenipotentiary, John Adams. La Luzerne therefore sought to obtain a revision of Adams' instructions and to have additional negotiators appointed to dilute his influence, and in this endeavor the French minister had had the support of Jenifer, who apparently believed that Adams would be influenced by John Temple, the Massachusetts loyalist previously employed by the North ministry to promote negotiations with the Americans. Jenifer, La Luzerne reported to Vergennes on June 1, "me dit qutil savoit avec certitude que M. John Temple avoit la plus grande influence sur M. John Adams, et que si ce particulier aprochoit du lieu des negociations, il seroit tres-important d'observer le degre de liaisons qu'il pourrvit y avoir entre l'un et l'autre. M. Jenifer a lui-meme avec plusieurs personnes en Angleterre des connexions qui donnent du poids a la confidence qu'il m'a faite." Correspondance politique, Etats-Unis, 17:30-36, Archives du Ministere des aflfaires etrangeres.
3 See the following entry.
We have the honor to inclose a Letter from his Excellency the Commander in chief; which we received last night, and which you will be pleased to lay before the respective branches of the legislature over whom you preside.(1)
We have the honor to be with the highest regard and esteem, Gentlemen, Your most Obedient Servants,
Daniel of St Thos Jenifer
Danl. Carroll
1 The Maryland legislature's June 1 appeal for troops and arms had been transmitted to Washington on June 3, for which see Maryland Delegates to Bruff and Plater, June 3, 1781. In his June 7 reply Washington informed the delegates of his orders implementing the May 31 resolution of Congress, but was unable to "promise any further assistance." Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:173-74. See also Washington's June 7 letter to Gov. Thomas Sim Lee and the Maryland Council's June 29 reply in Md. Archives, 47:275, 45:491.
My being on a Committee appointed to Confer with the Minister of France upon European affairs and to Draw up Instructions for our Minister appointed to Negotiate a peace (1) has Deprived Me untill now of the pleasure of Acknowledging the receipt of your Excellencys Letter of the 29th Ulto. or rather the Duplicate-altho I am not pleased at the originals falling into the Enemys hands I Think that Instead of being of advantage to them it will only Serve to Embarrass them.(2) The object mentioned in mine(3) to which that was an answer is by no means Discoverable from any thing in your Excellencys Letter. The Situation of our affairs as therein represented they were not Ignorant of. The only thing then that they can derive advantage from is the Idea held up of Attacking New York & this will only anticipate the Intelligence which our preparations would have demonstrated in a few Days & Even this may afford Some relief to the Southern States. I am Extremely mortified at having so many Mails taken & am not without Suspicions That There must be some hidden Influence in it. I find by Your Excellencys reasoning that the Plan I proposed is at present impracticable I shall Therefore wave the Motion. I find also that the reasons for Invading New York were reasons of Necessity and was the only practicable attempt in our present Circumstances. I have however some Doubts respecting the probability of Success. Your Excellency may rest assured that Congress will use Every Exertion to promote the Success of so important an object. We have very favorable Accounts from General Green which I Suppose will be Sent to Your Excellency by this Express.(4) We have not Yet received any official Accounts yet I think it May be relied on that a Fleet from England Consisting of a 74, two frigates, Several Sloops of war and Eighty four Transports with 4000 Troops on board arrived in Chassapeak Last Thursday. This will Make the Enemy 10,000 Strong in Virginia and Enable them to do Much Mischief to that State.
I have the honor to be with the Most perfect Esteem Dr General, Your Excys most obedt & very Humble Servant,
Jno Sullivan
1 Sullivan had been appointed on May 25 with Daniel Carroll, Joseph Jones, John Mathews and John Witherspoon to a committee to confer with La Luzerne about dispatches he had received from the comte de Vergennes. Sullivan, who was already a recipient of French funds, was credited by La Luzerne with a major role in the May 28 conference and the subsequently successfull efforts to assert French control over the peace process and undermine John Adams' authority as American negotiator. "C'est au general Sullivan seul," La Luzerne reported to Vergennes in his June 11 dispatch, "que j'en ai l'obligation; ce delegue a developpe dans toute cette affaire autant de patriotisme que d'attachement a l'alliance, et je crois pouvoir compter que
Sullivan's support of French policy is also detailed by La Luzerne in June 1, 8, 13, 14, and August 11 letters to Vergennes, in ibid., 17:1-7, 65-78, 125-39, 161-87 18:82-84. For Sullivan's French connection, see also Sullivan to Washington, November 26, 1780, note 5.
2 The original of Washington's May 29 letter to Sullivan had been captured by the British, and ultimately was printed in the London Gazette, July 14, 1781. Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:131-32.
3 That is, an invasion of Canada, which Washington referred to only as "the plan" in dismissing it as "absolutely impracticable. " Ibid., p . 131. See also Sullivan to Washington, May 2, 1781.
4 See James M. Varnum to William Greene, June 8, 1781, note 2.
Your Kind concern about my health lays me under particular obligations. I received some benefit from the short visit I made to the Country, & as Mr Potts is come to Town,(1) & most of the grand Points are adjusted, & I hope will, I expect to confirm my health by another Tour.
We have wrote you & the Council about money.(2) You know my Situation, & the time I have been here. I am anxious to hear of my Daughter Sims health.(3)
My Comps. to all enquiring Friends, Yrs with truth & Affection, Danl Carroll
[P.S.] Present my Compts to Docr Murray. I received his letter & nothing in my power has or will be omitted on the Subject of it.
I have wrote a few lines to Mr Carroll,(4) to which I beg to refer you on this occasion.
1 That is, Maryland delegate Richard Potts, who took his seat in Congress this day. JCC, 20:629.
2 See Maryland Delegates to Lee, May 30, 1781, note 2.
3 That is, Carroll's daughter Mary, the wife of Lee's cousin Col. Patrick Sim.
4 Not found.
I have nothing in particular to add to inclosed Intelligence, except that Circumstances reported by a Flag from Charlestown indicate that Lord .Rawdon and the Garrison of Camden have probably arrived at the first-mentioned Place, or in the Neighbourhood of it. It is not probable that General Greene will bend his Course towards Charlestown, but in another Direction. An Attack upon the Town would promise little Success.
The Operations described in the General's Despatches have put him in Possession of the Carolinas, except Charlestown and Wilmington, with one other Post of no very great Consequence. In the mean Time, Lord Cornwallis is making rapid Progress in Virginia. [That] State seems now to be in the way of suffering exceedin[gly] and it is very unfortunate that it [is] not in the Power of Congress or the General to give them any other immediate Aid than some Reinforcements of Militia.
I do myself the Honour to hand your Excellency a rough Draught (1) of that Part of the Country which is now the Seat of General Greene's Operations. It is sufficiently exact to give an Idea of the general and comparative Situations of the several Places most comonly mentioned. You will please to communicate it to the Legislature or such as may be anxious to examine it.
I have the Honour to be, Your Excellency's obedt. hble Servt. W.C. Houston (2)
1 Not identified.
2 Houston wrote a second brief letter to Livingston this day requesting a "Pass to the North River" for "Mrs. Arthur, wife of a Gentleman in the State of New York, and a Relation of the Family in which I lodge at Philadelphia." William Livingston Papers, NN .
We had the honor to receive your favor of (1) enclosing a resolve of the Genl. Assembly. The Board of War ordered Col. Wood the 26 Ulto. to remove the Convention Troops from Maryland & Virginia without delay, & we expected this information had been transmitted to you officially.(2)
As it is intended we shall be supply'd with money from the proceeds of some of the flour directed to be sent to Delaware, &
We have the honor to be with the greatest respect & esteem, Yr. Excellencys Most Obt & Humble Serts.
Daniel of St Thos Jenifer
Danl. Carroll
1 Undoubtedly the Maryland Council's first letter of June 2 to the delegates concerning the immediate removal of the Convention prisoners "from Fort Frederick to the Northward," for which see Md. Archives, 45:457. For the Council's second letter of June 2, see the following entry, note 1.
2 For directives concerning the removal of the Convention prisoners, see Samuel Huntington's first letter to Washington of May 28, 1781, note 1.
3 For the delegates' efforts to secure such funds, see Maryland Delegates to Lee, May 30, 1781, note 2; and Maryland Delegates to Lee, June 26, note 1.
Your Excellencys Letters of the 2d & 4th Inst. came to hand last night.(1)
If Arms are to be had in Philadelphia for Flour, or Tobacco, We shall endeaver to Contract for them on behalf of the State. We wish that you had mentioned the time and place of delivery of these Articles; essentials we apprehend necessary to be known before any person will engage to make a Contract with us.
Had we experienced the most partial supply of Money, it would have been of Service. Perhaps the intended Scheme of raising Money from Tobacco may prove as abortive to us as that of Flour. We have been reduced to the humiliating circumstance of attempting to borrow without success. If the Tobo. That Mr. Key is to transport, lies on Potomack, We cannot hope for any relief from it, as we shall be under the necessity of decamping before he can get it to this place.
Congress hitherto, has refused to allow the Shipping of Flour for the purpose of paying Debts contracted by our officers at New York. The Board of War have wrote to the General to inform them if Clinton will allow us to Ship Tobacco for that purpose.(2) As soon as they receive an Answer we shall transmit to you the result.
We are with the highest esteem and respect, Sir, Your Excellencys most Obedient and most humble Servants,
Daniel of St Thos Jenifer
Danl. Carroll
PS. Be pleased to forward the inclosed.(3)
1 For the Maryland Council's second letter of June 2 concerning the purchase of arms from Philadelphia merchants for flour or tobacco, and its June 4 letter regarding the shipment of tobacco to be sold for the support of the state's delegates in Philadelphia, see Md. Archives, 45:458, 461.
2 See Maryland Delegates to Lee, May 19, 1781, note.
3 Not identified.
The Bearer of this, a Mr Storer, has applied to me for Information whether any Resolution of Congress exists which may counteract his request of a Comission for an armed Boat to cruize against the Enemy. I do not know of any, and so have told him. I know there have been Instances in which the Crews of such Boats have abused the Confidence of a Commission, and have been guilty of very impolitick and even unjustifiable Acts of Depredation; but these Things might happen in the Case of any armed Vessel; and every Instance ought to stand upon it's own Circumstances. Bonds are always taken when Commissions are granted, and Delinquents are punishable by Forfeiture of their Commissions or by being prosecuted upon their Securities. If there is any Resolution of Congress which apparently discourages a Thing of this Kind, probably it may refute sortaille Parties which make Excursions into the Enemies' Lines merely for the Sake of indiscriminate Pillage contrary to the fair and honourable usages of War; but this I understand to be different from the Object of the Applicant on the present Occasion. This may also be in some Measure guarded against in the Bonds and Instructions, if they are not already sufficiently explicit.
I suppose your Excellency is supplied with Commissions, Bonds and Instructions from the Offices here; and I will observe to you that the Ratification of the Articles of Confederation, enlarges the Power of the respective States in these Matters, as you will find by consulting the 6th Article. If therefore the Person who solicits will come under proper Restrictions, and give adequate Security, I do not think your Excellency in Danger of counteracting any Resolution of Congress in granting his Request.(1)
I am, with-due Respect, Your Excellency's most obedt and most humble Servt. W.C. Houston
1 Houston had additional thoughts on this subject almost immediately, and accordingly returned to it the following day. See Houston to Livingston, June 14, 1781.
I receiv'd, My Dear Genl., your favour of the 3d and agree with you that the complexion of affairs in Virginia is truly embarassing. There must be powerful aid afforded to the army in that Quarter, but from whence they are to come I know not, as the whole of the allied force with considerable draughts of militia from New Hampshire to Pensylvania Inclusive, are to be employed in the Siege of New York. Genl. Washington intends to begin that operation on the first of July. We have had no knowledge of Sir Henry Clinton's being in Virginia, and letters recd. yesterday from the commander in chief take no notice of that matter. This State, Delaware & Maryland have been called on by congress, for Eight battallions of militia-the first for four, the second for One and the last for three batts. for the Service of Virginia. I have my doubts whether the compliance will be as immediate or effectual, as we could wish.
Your letter to Congress was debated two mornings-on various grounds. It produced a Resolve to Genl. W to take every immediate Step to accelerate the court of inquiry. A letter yesterday from the Genl. takes notice of your's to him and of the Resolve-and the satisfaction he would find in doing everything in his power to have the matter effected.(1)
As Mr. Morris did no[t] go to head Quarters, the matter of information you desired cannot be transmitted you. I have no doubt, but he will correspond entirely with your wishes, when he has the opportunity of communication.
We have had a great run of Success in South Carolina & Georgia. I believe the two towns of Savannah & Chs. town excepted-they have lost the whole of both States. I think the expedition to Canada a measure necesary to be pursued-and must be adopted-none can look forward to the command in that department with so much Justice as you.(2)
I will be constant in Writing to you by every proper opportunity. I will in my next, perhaps, have matters of great importance to communicate to you. Do not forget to Write to Congress and Genl. W
I wish you, My Dear Genl., much health and Spirits, and be assured that among your friends, none can be with greater passion for your fame, than yr. faithful & obedt. Servt.
Richd. Howly
1 For Gates' frustration over his inability to obtain exoneration from a court of inquiry for his conduct at Camden, see Samuel Huntington to Washington, April 26, note 3 and Huntington to Gates, May 22, 1781, note. In his June 6 letter to Congress, which was read "yesterday," Washington had observed that while he wished that the "affair" could be quickly decided, Gates had informed him "that he cannot think of serving untill the matter shall have been properly investigated, and that he shall retire in the mean time to Virginia. I see no probability of any thing further being done untill there shall be some recess in southern operations." JCC, 20:629; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:168.
2 For recent interest in an "expedition to Canada," a project long favored by Gates and lately revived by John Sullivan, see Sullivan to Washington, May 2 and June 11, 1781.
I have this moment yr. Letter of May 20 printed by Rivington as Mr. Gerrish's.(1) I suppose that some Folks who were angried at the former Discovery will endeavor to make Harm out of these Transactions between you & me. As Accident has brought the matter to their Knowledge they will chuse to conceive it to be what I wished to have concealed. I am quite indifferent.
I have more Reasons than you hinted for believing old Delegates will be put aside. Plausible Arguments may be drawn from the Confederation.(2) But tho Connecticutt acted upon it in regard to Mr. Sherman, She has now again sent him. Genl. Ward might have been accomodated with hard Cash by yr. Treasurer, if he had been a Worshipper. He has been forced to put off his Paper at 4.
I will be more particular as to the figured Business by Genl. Ward some Time this Week.(3)
Yours Affly, J L
1 Gerry's captured May 20 letter to Lovell was misattributed to "Mr. Gerrish" when it appeared in the June 9 issue of James Rivington's New York Royal Gazette. For Lovell's later apprehensions concerning the tone and wording of Gerry's letter, see Lovell to Gerry, August 10, 1781, note 1.
2 Lovell was referring to article five of the Articles of Confederation which prohibited delegates of Congress from serving "more than three years in any term of six."
3 Lovell apparently sent Gerry "the figured Business by Genl. Ward" the following day, for which see Lovell to Gerry, June 15, 1781 (not in printed text).
Since writing your Excellency yesterday I have had an opportunity and Leisure to turn to the Resolution of Congress upon which, I suppose, you hesitated to grant a Comission to Storer. It is of the 22 June 1779, but you will perceive, on Inspection, that the Object of it is no more than I described before.(1) Certainly Persons who recieve Commissions under the requisite Conditions, ought not to be debarred from operating against the Enemy anywhere; but the Intention of this was to prevent pillaging private, Family Furniture and Property of innocent and sometimes well-affected Persons which is contrary to Policy as well as Interest. Certainly making Prisoners of the Enemy, or of obnoxious Citizens, taking publick Property or Merchant-goods and many other Things, and that in any Place whatever, on the Land or on the Water, could not come within the Meaning of the Measure. At the same Time proper Precautions against Abuses of the Rules of War, and Contraventions of the Laws of Nations, are, no Doubt, necessary and proper.(2)
I have the Honour to be Your Excellency's very obedt. Servant. W.C. Houston(3)
1 See JCC, 14:758-59; and Houston to Livingston, June 13, 1781.
2 For the recent complaints of New York against Connecticut for similar abuses against her citizens on Long Island, and Congress' response to the state's memorial against the excesses of Connecticut privateers, see Thomas McKean to George Clinton, August 8, 1781, note 1.
3 Houston's congressional attendance is difficult to document because of the frequency of his visits to New Jersey. He apparently made a brief trip home soon after writing this letter, for a note from him to Livingston written from "Trenton 20 June 1781," stating that he expected to return to Philadelphia Friday or Saturday June 22, or 23]," is the Livingston Papers, NN.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, a Resolve of Congress of the 12th Instant, among other Matters, earnestly recommending to the State of Maryland to raise & accoutre two Troops of Militia Horse properly officered, including those called for by the Act of 31st of May, and send them forward with all possible Expedition to the Southern Army, to serve three Months after they join the Army.(2)
It is hoped that the present Situation of Affairs in Virginia will excite the most vigorous Exertions in Compliance with this recommendation.(3)
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Respect, Your Excellency's Most obedient & very humble Servant.
Sam. Huntington Presidt.
1 The presidential letterbook copy of this letter is dated June 15. PCC, item 16, fol. 18.
2 JCC, 20:635. For "the Act of 31st of May," see Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781.
3 Huntington also sent a similar letter to Pennsylvania president Joseph Reed on June 15, asking the state "to compleat Colonel Moyland's [Stephen Moylan's] Legionary Corps to it's full Compliment" as well as "to raise three Troops of Militia Cavalry...to serve in the southern Army three Months, or until relieved by the Arrival of Moyland's Corps." See JCC, 20:634-35; and PCC, item 16, fols. 15-16.
I fear that yr. favorable Expressions respecting Col. Palfrey are founded on Stories circulated here some Time ago. We believe nothing favorable to him at this day. I am distressed for his amiable Family as well as sincerely afflicted at the Loss of him. He would have repaired our tattered Affairs in France and have raised a Character of Honesty & Ability in mercantile Transactions for the Public.
I took up my Pen at first only to cover the inclosed.(1) JL
1 Not found, but apparently the "figured Business" to be sent by Gen. Artemas Ward, who this day left Congress, which is mentioned at Lovell to Gerry, June 13, 1781, note 3.
You will find by the contents of this, that it is a Confidential Letter, conveying you very important and pleasing intelligence.
Congress has received a Letter from the King of France and are also otherwise officially informed by his minister here-That the Empress of Russia threw out an invitation for the Belligerent powers to apply for her Mediation at which the Court of London eagerly Caut and mentioned the emperor of Germany as another mediator and a Congress was proposed to be opened at Viena for the purpose of Settling a general Peace. The answer of the Court of France was that they Could Send no Plenipos. To said Congres Till they had Consulted their allies, but as the Mediators are such respectable
Green has Taken Camden and Two other posts and we make no dobt but the Brittish have lost every post in Georgia & the Carolinas by this Time except Savannah, Charles Town and Wilmington. Green has had a rapid series of success.
Pensylvania is Determined to be vigirous in giving effectual aid against Cornwallace and there is no doubt but Maryland will do the same. I hope our state will not be behind them, a bold push now obtains us every thing. We have no account of any reenforcements arrived yet to the Brittish from the other side the water. Mr. Morris is gitting our Finances into a better Train and all things now begin to favour us.
I am, yr. Most Obedt. Thomas Rodney
1 Rodney's account of the maneuvering that led to these appointments is the most detailed record of these proceedings that survives. Although the account preserved in Secretary Thomson's secret journals conforms in outline to Rodney's summary, it neither records the votes reported by him on several specific motions nor suggests the central role that he assigned himself in the proceedings, for which see also Rodney to Rodney, July 10, 1781, note 3.
On June 9 Congress had rejected a motion to join "some persons...with the honourable John Adams in negotiating a treaty of peace," but two days later voted to reconsider the proposal, deciding to add two plenipotentiaries. John Jay, John Laurens, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, Joseph Reed, and William Carmichael were thereupon nominated for the two positions. The following day the delegates were able to agree only upon Jay and postponed the selection of the second person. Congress then voted on June 14 to add "two more persons," appointing Franklin, Jefferson, and Henry Laurens to join Adams and Jay. See JCC, 20:619, 627-28, 638, 648; and John Witherspoon's Speech, June 9-11 ? 1781.
Rodney had just recently resumed his seat in Congress, probably on June 12. Although he had written to Caesar from Wilmington on June 9 that "I expect to move toward Congress To Morrow," he is not listed on the roll call votes of June 11. He is not mentioned in the journals between May 8 and June 14, but on the evidence of this letter seems to have had direct knowledge of the debates of June 12 and 13. See JCC, 20:487, 626-27, 648; and Rodney, Letters (Ryden), pp. 411-12.
Before this comes to Hand your Excellency will have received my Letter of the 2d Instant with it's Enclosures, (1) by which you will be informed that a Negotiation for Peace between the Belligerent Powers may probably take Place through the Mediation of the Empress of Russia & Emperor of Germany, In Consequence of which, Congress have thought proper to add four other Plenipotentiaries to the Honorable John Adams Esquire to assist in the expected Negotiation, of which you are elected one, as you will be informed by the enclosed Resolve, you will doubtless come this Way to embark, if Circumstances will admit of your undertaking the important Service. The Commissions will be prepared immediately, as no Time should be lost.(2)
Your Appointment is ordered to be kept secret, that the Enemy may not get Intelligence of your Embarkation.
I have the Honor to be &c &c S.H.(3)
1 See Huntington to Certain States, June 2, 1781.
2 See JCC, 20:627-28, 638, 648. See also John Witherspoon's Speech, June 9?; and Huntington to Benjamin Franklin, June 19, 1781. For Jefferson's decision to decline this appointment, and the delay involved in his notification to Congress of his decision, see Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 6:113-14; and Thomas McKean to Jefferson, August 20, 1781.
3 This letter was transmitted via Col. Richard Humpton and the marquis de Lafayette, as explained in the following letter of this date from Huntington to Lafayette. "I have been favored with your Dispatches of the 24th of May & 3d Instant. The Bearer Col. Humpton is charged with an important Letter addressed to Governor Jefferson, which I am to request you Sir to forward immediately by a confidential Express." PCC, item 16, fol. 17.
Your Excellency will recieve enclosed a Resolve of Congress of the 13th Instant recommending to the several States to which the Officers of Hospital & Medical Department now in Service respectively belong, or of which they are or were Inhabitants, to settle their Accounts for Depreciation on the Principles established by the Resolution of Congress of the 10th of April 1780, and to make Provision for paying the Balances that may be found due, in the same Manner with Officers of the Line.(1)
Each State which shall advance on this Account more Money than it's Proportion, is to be allowed for the same in Account with the United States.(2)
I have the Honor to be, &c S.H.
1 For this extension of the benefits of depreciation allowances to the officers of the medical department, See JCC, 16:344-45, 20:624, 637.
2 To Huntington's letter to Connecticut governor Jonathan Trumbull, the following paragraph was added at this point. "I have also enclosed another Resolve of the same Date, by which your Excellency will be informed that on the Receipt of your Letter of the 17th of April, which being referred to the Board of War for a Reconsideration of the Subject respecting the Invalids in the Connecticutt Line, and in the mean Time the Commander in Chief having called for the whole Corps of Invalids, to be stationed in the Garrison at West Point, it is determined to comply with the General's Requisition." Trumbull Papers, Ct; and PCC, item 16, fols. 19-20.
For this congressional decision and Trumbull's April 17 letter seeking a reconsideration "respecting the Invalids in the Connecticutt Line," See JCC, 20:452, 637; PCC, item 66, 2: 194-97; and Huntington's second letter to Trumbull of March 24, 1781.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, several Resolves of Congress, viz, one of the 11th Instant & one of the 13th respecting the Officers in the Hospital & Medical Department, sundry Resolves of the 12th respecting the Convention Prisoners, to be halted for the present in Pennsylvania, the Depreciation to be settled in Behalf of Colonel Armands Legion; and earnestly recommending to the State of Pennsylvania to complete Moylands Legionary Corps to its full Compliment, and also immediately to raise three Troops of Militia Cavalry, to serve three Months after they join the Army-the State of Maryland to raise in like Manner two Troops of Militia Horse to serve three Months. Also one Resolve of the 13th relating to the Corps of Invalids which are to be stationed at West Point.(1)
I have been honored with your Excellency's several Dispatches of the 30th Ulto, 6th & 7th Instant, and forwarded your several Letters. Those for Virginia were sent by a confidential Express, as the Conveyance by the Post that Way is now become too precarious.(2)
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Regard, Your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
1 For the adoption of the enclosed seven resolves, which are in the Washington Papers, DLC, See JCC, 20:624, 630, 634-35, 637.
2 Washington's letters are in PCC, item 152, 10:125-37; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:134-35, 167-69, 172-73. In his letter of the 7th, Washington explained that he was enclosing letters (of the same date) for the governors of Delaware, Maryland, and Pennsylvania concerning three months troops being called up from those states but the letters "for Virginia" that Huntington forwarded "by a confidential Express ' have not been identified. Writings, 22:171-72n.45.
Your Several Letters according to the following list have been read in Congress, (1) and your industrious care to give frequent, early, and general information, of those things in Europe which may have influence upon our National affairs, has been not only highly pleasing in itself, but has acquired value lately from the loss of all packets from Mr Adams Since his date of October 24. I am Sir, your Friend & humble Servant, Signed James Lovell
| Read 1780 | Dated |
| May 11 | Feb 19 |
| Oct 16 | May 28 July 17 |
| Decr 4 | Aug 22 P.S. Sept 6 Sept 9 |
| 9 | Sept 25 |
| 1781 | |
| Feby 12 | Nov 28 Dec 19 |
| Mar 26 | Oct 15 |
| Apl 24 | Jan. 4 |
| 27 | Feb 22 |
| 30 | Decr 4(2) |
| May 10 | Jan 29 |
| 21 | Mar 11 |
| June 4 | 11/14 |
1 Carmichael's letters, except that of December 4 [i.e. 24], 1780, are in PCC, item 88, fols. 47-50, 59-74, 79-126, 135-38, and Miscellaneous Papers of the Continental Congress, reel 2, fols. 39-41. Except for the March 14 postscript to his letter of March 11, these are printed in Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 3:507, 736-39, 865-66 4:38-41, 51-54, 69-72, 99-100, 164-68, 198, 227-28, 242-44, 265-66, 279-80.
2 That is, December 24, 1780. See JCC, 20:464.
Yesterday I wrote you respecting the Congress of Mediation but when I shall have an Opertunity by which I may safely Trust the
It was closed by the decision of an important Article in the instructions to Our Commissioners (1) which requires them after having obtained our Independance in all things else to be Ultimately Governed. by the advice of the French Court or minister. It was moved to reconsider this Clause and to Strike it out as being Too Abject and Humiliating. It was argued some hours and at last rejected so that the Clause stands and the French Court is thereby in possession of full and Sufficient powers to make a peace, for there is not the least doubt but the Mediating powers will readily Consent to our Independance provided they may make it as Simple as possible and it will be even the Interest of France that they should do this least we should at a future day form an alliance with Great Brittain. I was against this Clause because I think it must convince even the French Court that we are reduced to a weak and Abject State and that we have lost all that Spirit and dignity which once appeared in the proceedings of Congress and considering our selves unable to Carry on the War any longer we are ready to Accept of peace on Any Terms; and we may be sure they will not hesitate about granting any thing the Mediating powers may require respecting us after they Consent to Our Independance so that there need be no longer doubt about the Certainty of peace. I am far from thinking we are reduced to a State of such necessaty-Yet what is done for aught I know may be best. We have much relyance on its being the Interest of all the powers Concerned to place us in such a respectable situation that we may not fall a prey to any one of them, and that they may all have an equal opertunity of enjoying the benefits of Our Commerce-And there was some fear that our Plenepotentiaries might make such extravigant demands as would preclude an equitable Peace and in this Case that France would not be obliged to prosecute the War with the direct Object of the Alliance being simply Independance-And Genl. Washington strongly presses the making Peace on the best Terms that can be Obtained. Indeed all the powers of Europe seem so eager to have Great Brittain reduced to a Level with themselves that no danger may arise perhaps from this unlimited confidence which we have placed in the Court of France and indeed where there own interest is not materially in view perhaps she may do better for us than we could for our selves for we may suppose that as a new System of Police is now to be Settled that all the ablest negociators in Europe will be sent to this Congress and our Plenepotentiaries not being so well versed in the refined art of negociation might by them be overeached or mislead more easily than the French who are much better acquainted with the Interests of Europe and inferior to none of them in the Arts of negociation. In
Every thing respecting this Treaty is required to be kept [secret by] Congress and they are such excellent hands at doing this that I [...] about it almost by Common report before I came up, yet I wou[ld not] have any thing transpire through me. I expect to go home [next] week and wish your business would permit you to be at Wilmington then. Yr. most Obedt. Thomas Rodney
Saturday: June 16th. We have an acct. by an officer from the Eastward that a 50 Gun Ship, Two Frigates and Two flutes with some store ships & 1200 Men are arrived at Boston from France and that the Alliance & a number of American Vessels are also arrived with them.
The operations against New York may be Expected to Commence Shortly. The last Intelligence from Virginia (8th Inst.) says Wain had joined the Marquis-That Lesely with 1000 Men had landed up Potomack. Tarlton had Advanced toward the head of James River to Distroy a large quanty of Stores which were Guarded by the Barron Stuben, and Tarlton & Simco being Too Weak to Effect it Cornwallace was moving that way with his whole Army but the Virginians think that Greens Successes to the Southward will oblige him to Continue his Rout Towards Carolina. T.R.
1 For the adoption of these instructions, see Samuel Huntington to Benjamin Franklin, June 19; and James Lovell to John Adams, June 21, 1781.
The Committee of foreign Affairs lately wrote your Excellency on the Subject of my Son John Witherspoon who was Surgeon to the Letter of Marque De Graaff taken at St Eustatius and sent to England as I have been informed in the Alemene Man of War requesting you to use your Endeavours to obtain his Release upon Parole and his Exchange as soon as possible.(1) I beg Leave further to
I believe Your Grandson who is with you was an Acquaintance of my Sons. I would therefore beg of you to make my Complements to him and recommend this Matter to his Care.
I have the honour to be, Your Excellencies most obedt humble Servant, Jno Witherspoon
1 See Committee for Foreign Affairs to Franklin, May 9, note 2; and Witherspoon to Richard Henry Lee, May 19, 1781, note 2.
I have already acknowledged the Receipt of yr. Letter of May 10th covering a Copy of March 17th, and accompanied by one of May 14th. I think I told you I would be more particular, at some future Day, in considering certain Parts of them.(1) I meant to do it by Cyphers; but the present opportunity renders that mode needless. Genl. Ward will probably take a safe Road for himself and consequently for my Scrawl.
"A captured Letter, not to Portia thank fortune-published by the Enemy-has made some Talk, let the Writer's Conscience tell him whether any Thing ought to escape his Pen, even to a confidential Friend, that might be just occasion of Pain to an affectionate a Wife." "I have not yet seen it, I fear it is not fit I should."(2)
As to the Letter Madam, there is one Expression or rather one Mode of Expression that I wish was not there. I am very unwilling that it should be submitted to the Eye of one so very much my Friend as you profess yourself to be. My Enemies are welcome to read it a thousand Times over. It was an unbecoming Levity, and quite unfit for a "Senator." But it is not that which will give Pain to my affectionate a Wife. She will be pained with what you would smile at. For she is more apt to fear than to despise the Enmity of Little-Great-Folks. I should have submitted the Letter, however to your severe anti-shandean Criticism, if I had not thought that an angried Few would have wisely kept from saying any Thing about it, rather than to make spiteful Interpretations of Parts that did not refer to themselves purely to vent that Malice which had been put into a State of Fermentation by Jemmy Rivington's marginal Notes upon those Parts which did really appertain to their Worthyships.(3) I am persuaded Madam I thus hit upon the authors-original Authors
I must now be very serious. There is in the World, in the Hands of one of my best Friends, a Bond of about 80 Pounds Lawful money against me, but I have that amount and more against a Farm mortgaged to me for myself & others, tho' not worth what it is dipped (5) for. This is the whole Connexion I have with Money matters, and a poor one it is, except with my Pay for Time & Service as a Delegate, which ceases the day I arrive in Boston, though my Wife and Children will expect to dine the day after and peradventure they will be extravagant enough to expect it the third Day also. I shall not say much about the Probability, that many of those who have dined & supped formerly, often, for a Course of Years, elegantly both as to the Table & Sideboard, tho not luxuriously, upon the Product of the exemplary Industry of the Usher of a Grammar School, will call to pay their Compliments to the Honorable Delegate of Congress, and wellcome him Home, while He poor Wretch cannot in Return offer them a Glass of small Beer to drink in Case of Thirst.
Do those who condemn my Absence mean to take me into their Stores as a Clerk? Will they risk such a Test of my Desire to live with one of the most faithful endearing Wives within the Circle of my whole Acquaintance, the tender & discrete Mother of my numerous Children, the benevolent Neighbours, the chearful sensible Companion of both Sexes.
"I must return if only for a short Visit."(6) Will they be willing to maint...-But, I shall forget who I am writing to, and shall draw upon myself, and not myself only, a Condemnation of a secret Compact against short Visits. I am told that a Dollar and an Half per Day is to cloathe me as a Delegate, and to support the Wife and the seven Children of the same Delegate! Some of my Boys however begin to help me.
And now Madam, do not think that this serious Subject shall prevent my taking occasion to censure your Sophistry in one part of yr. Letter.(7)
"What Right has She, who is appropriated, to appear lovely or charming in any Eyes but his whose Property she is?" I answer, all that Right & Title which Virtue inherits above Vice.
I am persuaded says a Lady who had seen much of the World, "That a Woman who is determined to place her Happiness in her Husband's Affections, should abandon the extravagant Desire of engaging public Adoration."
I underscore Part to show that it had nothing to do with yr. own Question above.
But I go further, and say, that the Lady needed not to travel to get double the Wisdom of what she here discovers. She might have sat in her Chamber and known that a Woman who is determined to place her Happiness in her Husband's affections not only "should" but would abandon "the extravagant" and even any Desire of Engaging "public Adoration."
"Portia can join with Juba in the Play. 'By Heavens I had rather have that best of Friend's approve my Deeds than Worlds for my Admirers.' " In Troth a very pretty Scrap of a Play! but quoted very unseasonably. For let me ask may not those very Deeds be approved & the Author of them consequently be admired by Thousands & Tens of Thousands; and has not a Wife, as well as a Maid, a Right thus "to appear lovely & charming to other Eyes than his whose Property she is"?
Property! Oh dutch Idea!
Besides, Madam, your fine tuned Instrument cannot be an american one; it must be english with which we are at War. It cannot be italian, or it would be more sensibly touched by the amiable than by the lovely, the first being of roman and the last of british Extract, but otherwise, critically the same.
My Letter dated April 13 was written the 23. (8) The Duke of Leinster not Leominster carried yr. Letter safely, but she is herself carried into New York.
I begin now to be uneasy about your Goods. OEconomy has banished all Waggoning almost from this City; and if I send by Water to Trenton I know not the Store Keeper's there, so that I shall run new Risques. Perhaps I may hear from you or Mr. Cranch Tomorrow. I am worried by a Paragraph in one of my Son's Letters which mentions your Good's by Doct. Winship being injured by the Rain. It must have been before Mr. Hughes boxed them; and he mentioned no such Thing to me.
I "have recd. your Letter of March 27 (9) (and worse ones too) in that Spirit of Friendship with which they flowed from the Pen of Portia." You see nevertheless that I think it a bad one, And it is that Thought which prevents me from following the Dictates of my own Sincerity in subscribing.
I have not yet worn out the word MADAM, your most devoted humble Servant, JL
1 See Lovell to Abigail Adams, May 29, 1781.
2 This quotation from Abigail's March 17 letter to Lovell, refers to a sexual innuendo in Lovell's November 20, 1780, letter to Elbridge Gerry, which had been captured and printed by James Rivington in the New York Royal Gazette. Adams, Family Correspondence (Butterfield), 4:91-92.
3 James Rivington's "marginal Notes" were actually appended to Lovell's letter of November 20, 1780, to John Hancock, which had also been captured and printed in the Royal Gazette, December 27, 1780.
4 That is, Samuel Adams and Elbridge Gerry.
5 That is, involved in debt or monetary liability, mortgaged. OED.
6 Paraphrased from Abigail Adams' May 13 letter to Lovell. Adams, Family Correspondence (Butterfield), 4:112.
7 That is, Abigail Adams' March 17 letter to Lovell. Ibid., pp. 91-92.
8 See Lovell to Abigail Adams, April 23, 1781.
9 That is, " 17. "
I was honord with your Excellency's favor enclosing a letter for the Govr of Virginia (1) which was immediately put into the hands of the President to be forwarded by an express that was to be dispatched the next day. We have not had any very late official accounts from the Army or the Executive of our State; but from private intelligence we are informed that the British Cavalry has under the Command of Tarleton made a very rapid and bold push up to Charlotteville where the Legislature and executive were assembled the whole of whom were dispersed, (2) and not less than eight of the Members of the assembly taken by the Enemy, among whom our advices say is Col. Jno. Simm of Hanover-it is also said by an officer from Genl. Greenes army who passd thru Virginia and has been in Charlotteville since the above mentiond affair, that Some Arms, and a Small Quy. of Powder fell into the hands of the Enemy, as did also the Printing Press. I imagine the Assembly must before this time have assembled at Stanton, and tis to be hoped that experience will teach them to be better guarded against an event so disgracefull, as well as so prejudicial in its consequences. Private letters also mention that Ld. Cornwallis was moving towards James River inclining upwards, tis supposed with an intention of making a stroke at our Stores & Magazines at the fork of James River, the Marquis is Said to be Seven thousand strong and is disposed to Battle; these Sr. are reports, but what Credit may be given to them I cannot say except to the event at Charlotteville which I believe may be relied on. I am with The Greatest respect Sr., Yr. Excelly's Most obedt. Sevt. Theok. Bland
1 Not identified.
2 For Lt. Col. Banastre Tarleton's June 4 cavalry raid on Charlottesville, the dispersal of the Virginia assembly, and the last-minute escape of Governor Jefferson, see Lafayette, Papers (Idzerda), 4:164-65, 170n, 193-94; and Jefferson, Papers (Boyd), 4:256-78.
You will receive herewith enclosed, a Letter addressed to his most Christian Majesty, (1) with a Copy of the same for your Information, also a Commission constituting yourself with the four other Gentlemen therein named, our Ministers for negotiating Peace;(2) also another Commission & Duplicate authorizing the same Ministers to accept of the Mediation of the Emperor of Germany and Empress of Russia, in one of which the Emperor is first named & in the other the Empress, (to be made Use of as Circumstances shall render it expedient).(3)
I have also herewith enclosed, Instructions (in Cyphers) for your Government, in Addition to those formerly given Mr Adams for negotiating Peace.(4) A Letter in Answer to yours of the 12th of March last will also accompany this.(5)
You will please to communicate immediately to Mr Adams & Mr Jay the Receipt of these important Dispatches.
Mr Secretary Thomson desires you would be so good as to send him the Machine with proper Directions to be used for striking Copies of Letters as mentioned in yours of the 12th of March.(6)
For Want of Time myself I must refer you to Mr Lovell's Dispatches for American Intelligence in general.
I have the Honor to be, with the highest Respect, Sir, Your most obedient & most humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington, President
1 For this letter to Louis XVI, adopted by Congress on June 13, See JCC, 20:638-41. This and the four following enclosures were adopted after extended congressional debate touched off by the chevalier de La Luzerne's May 26 announcement that a mediation offer from Austria and Russia had been received by the French court, for which see Huntington to the States, June 1, 1781.
2 For this commission, adopted on June 15, See JCC, 20:652-55.
3 This instruction was adopted on June 8.JCC, 20:615-17.
4 JCC, 20:651-52.
5 For the second letter of this date, notifying Franklin that his "request to retire from publick employment would be inconvenient at this particular conjuncture," see JCC, 20:675-76.
6 Franklin had apparently mentioned this "Machine" in a March 12 letter to Charles Thomson that has not been found (there is no mention of it in his March 12 letter to Huntington). He responded to Huntington's comment, however, in the following postscript to his September 13, 1781, letter to the president: "The Copying Machine for Mr. Secretary Thomson is in hand, & will soon be finished & sent to him." PCC, item 82, 1:301-12, 2:15-18; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:281-84, 710.
I have drawn a sett of bills of this date on you for two hundred & sixty six dollers & two thirds of a doller in behalf of the state towards my subsistence in Congress in favour of Clement Biddle Esq. This gentleman wants his mony in Boston and I have engaged it shall be sent there. So I request the favour of you to send it by Mr. Noble the post if he presents the bills & pay the postage, or by any other safe conveyance you please. I should not give you this trouble, but I could not negotiate a bill on any other terms at this time, as no one here that I could meet with wants mony in Portsmth.
I am Sir, Your most obedt. Humble servt.
Samuel Livermore
Long 'ere this I expected to have opened a Correspondence with you from this City, but Circumstances already communicated prevented my earlier Attendance on Congress.(1) As our information very imperfect, from the Southward passes through that State nothing can be expected on that Subject, our prospects there are become more favorable and from the spirited and truly laudable Exertions of Maryland much may be hoped for if time is allowed for their Arrival. The french have a small Reinforcement arrived at Boston, a fifty Gun Ship, 2 frigates and some transports with Horses for their Army and between 12 & 1500 Men, (2) to counterbalance this we have a report that a fleet supposed to be the Cork fleet was seen twelve days ago off Charles Town, if true a Reverse of fortune must take Place in that State. The great Business is over in a manner I beleive consistent with the voice of our State-the particulars are not to be communicated. For your Amusement I inclose you the last Papers. Be pleased to make a Tender of my Compliments to Mrs. Lee and believe me with Sentiments of perfect Esteem, Yours very affecly, R Potts
[P.S.] 1000 Arms will be sent off in a few days to Maryland, (3) they were like those sent to the Eastern Shore, but with Alterations & Repairs are rendered very good.
1 For Potts "Attendance," see Daniel Carroll to Lee, June 12, 1781, note 1.
2 For the arrival in Boston in early June of the small French reinforcement escorted by the 50-gun Sagittaire, see Lafayette, Papers (Idzerda), 4:202-4; and Lee B. Kennett,
3 For the Board of War's promise that 1,500 stand of arms would be sent to Maryland "in 7 days time," see Maryland Delegates to Lee, June 4, 1781.
You will receive herewith enclosd a letter addressd to his most Christian Majesty; with a Copy of the Same for your information.(1)
Also a Commission constituting the four gentlemen therein named in addition to yourself our Ministers for negotiating peace. Also another commission & duplicate Authorizing them to accept the Mediation of the Emperor of Germany & Empress of Rusia, in one of which you will observe the Emperor is first named, & in the other the Empress, these are to be made use of as circumstances shall render expedient.
I have also enclosd Instructions (in cypher) for your government in addition to those formerly given for negociating peace with Great Brittain .
No additional Instructions to your former are yet given relative to a treaty of Commerce with Great Brittain.
You will immediately communicate the receipt of these dispatches to Docr Franklin & Mr Jay to whom duplicates are also forwarded with Similar directions.
I have the honour to be, with perfect Respect, your humble Servant, Saml. Huntington Presidt.
P.S. Since writing the foregoing, for want of another conveyance, I have determined to Send this by the Same Conveyance that carries the Duplicates to Docr Franklin, have therefore taken out, the letter to the King of France, & Copy mentiond in the foregoing.
S.H.
1 For the enclosures mentioned in this letter, see Huntington to Benjamin Franklin, June 19, 1781.
I have been honoured with your letter of the 4th May.(1)
The death of Don Juan de Miralles was much lamented here, (2) his
The agreable behaviour of Don Francisco Rendon (3) makes him respected and he will doubtless receive that friendly treatment and attention which it is proper to manifest to him personally and as a Servant of an ancient and honorable nation with whom we wish to cultivate the most sincere friendship and for whose Sovereign we entertain the highest respect.
I most sincerely congratulate you on the reduction of Pensacola by the Arms of his Catholic Majesty, and have the honour to be, with esteem and regard, your Humble Servant,
Sam. Huntington
1 This letter from Navarro, the governor general of Cuba, is in PCC, item 97, fols. 426-29. Although it is endorsed by Charles Thomson "Read June 6. 1781," the journals record that it was read in Congress on July 6, 1781.JCC, 20:722.
2 See these Letters, 15:75.
3 Rendon's reports from Philadelphia to Navarro and Juan Manuel de Cagigal, who succeeded Navarro as governor general of Cuba at about this time, are in the Papeles Procedentes de Cuba, legajos 1282, 1319, Archivo General de Indias, Seville (Aileen Moore Topping translations, Manuscript Division, DLC). In his dispatch of June 26, Rendon sent the following request to Cagigal concerning delegate Thomas Bee.
"Mr. Bee, a member of Congress for South Carolina, has had a letter from a commercial house in Boston, reporting having had intelligence that the ship Friendship, Captain Manize, was wrecked on the coast of Cuba, and that the crew was arrested and imprisoned because they were thought to be English. Mr. Bee begs Your Lordship to order that the captain and crew of that ship be put aboard the Columbia (which belongs to him) and brought here; Captain William Sargeant of the Columbia has been ordered to take them aboard with Your Lordship's permission." Ibid., legajo 1319.
Your Excellency will receive enclosd, a petition from Genl Bailey & others Inhabitants in the Northern Frontier of Connecticutt river; which is refer'd to the Commander in Chief. (1)
Congress are anxious to obtain the release of the late President Laurens from his Confinement and for that purpose have passd a resolve directing our Minister at Versailles to offer Genl. Burgoyne in exchange for him, the resolve passd in consequence of a report we receivd that Genl Clinton has refused to Exchange Burgoyne.
This constrains me to trouble your Excellency on[c]e more on the Subject, and request you would inform me whether Genl Clinton
This information is necessary before the orders for exchanging President Laurens are transmitted to Europe.
I have the honour to be, with perfect Respect, Your Excys. humble Servt. Sam. Huntington Presidt.
1 See JCC, 20:656. This May 24 petition from Gen. Jacob Bayley and 12 associates on the Vermont frontier, seeking protection and recommending an invasion of Canada, is in the Washington Papers, DLC. A duplicate of the petition, addressed directly to General Washington, is also in the collection. In his June 28 reply to Huntington, Washington responded that an expedition into Canada was "utterly impracticable." Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:278.
2 For Congress' interest in obtaining the exchange of Henry Laurens for Gen. John Burgoyne, see JCC, 20:647-48; and Huntington to Washington, April 23, 1781. Responding to Huntington on June 28, Washington explained that Clinton had heretofore placed conditions on any exchange of General Burgoyne "in the Military Line," but that there was "nothing at present...to prevent a Proposition being made by Congress for the Exchange of Mr Laurens for Genl Burgoyne, in the Mode mentioned." Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:278.
I must beg the favor of your Excelly to forward the enclosed Letter to London. The Father of Mr. Lowndes who wrote it, is a worthy Citizen, and very desirous of seeing his Son in America before the 1st of March 1782, the time limited by a Law of the State of Maryland for the return of absentees in the British Dominions, under penalty of forfeiting to the State their property.(1)
I suppose the Special appointment of Col Laurens to the Court of Verseilles, was a measure that you could not have suspected would have been adopted by Congress. Your having negotiated the business for which he was sent before his arrival, proved, that his errand was unnecessary.
Public bodies in all Countries, and more especially in this New World are too apt to take up, and determine hastily upon Subjects of the greatest consequence. I was absent when that Gentleman was ballotted for; and however the Magot may have bit on that occasion, I can assure you that Congress have the greatest reliance on your abilities, integrity and address, in so much, that it is with pleasure that I can inform you, in the late choice of Ministers to Negotiate a peace you were unanimously elected.(2)
I have the honor to be with Sentiments of the highest respect and esteem, Sir, Your Excellency's Most obedient and most humble Servt. Daniel of St. Thos Jenifer
P.S. Congress are well disposed towards your Grandson whom you recommended to their protection.(3)
1 Christopher Lowndes of Bladensburg, Md., was seeking the return of his son Francis, who had travelled to England in 1775 and visited France in 1778. See Lowndes to Thomas Johnson, August 8, 1779, Red Books, MdAA.
2 For the recent election of the five-man commission to negotiate peace, see Thomas Rodney to Caesar Rodney, June 14, 1781, note.
3 In his letter to Congress of March 12, 1781, proposing his retirement, Franklin had also asked that Congress provide employment for his grandson, William Temple Franklin. Temple had "lost so much of the time necessary for Law Studies" by serving as his personal secretary the previous four years, Franklin explained, that he might be more suitably employed in "the Line of public foreign affairs." Franklin therefore requested that Temple be appointed secretary to Congress' minister "at any European Court...as a Favour to me." Congress, however, never acted on Franklin's request and Temple remained in Paris, becoming secretary to the peace commission. See JCC, 20:549, 675-76; Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:283-84; and PCC, item 82, 1:308-9.
Jenifer also sent a duplicate of this letter to Franklin on July 6, 1781, which is in the Franklin Papers, PU.
I have your favour of the 7th instant which gives me intire satisfaction of the propriety of your remaining with the Northern Army and that it was out of your Power from the small Army under your Command to afford any present succour to the southern States.(1) The same Sentiment I find was entertained by Governor Jefferson to whom I presume you have written on the Subject but from the contents of a Letter I have just received (or rather the Delegates of Virga.) from R. H. Lee inclosing one to be forwarded to you I expect you will be further solicited on that head and as it may not be practicable for you speedily to give that Gentleman an answer by safe conveyance from the present situation of the Country I shall as soon as an opportunity offers write to him upon the subject.(2) From all accounts we receive our greatest disadvantage lies in the great superiority of the Enemies Horse wch. being encreased since their advancing into the Country from the number of fine Horses that have fallen into their hands to 7 or 800 to range about the Country as to dismay the people not a little and keep them in continual alarm for the safety of their Families. The superiority of the Infantry I believe consists more in the distinction between
"We are in a most distressed Condition from the Sea to the Mountains, so many fine Horses have fallen into the hands of the Enemy that they roam at large over all that Country and the Marquis is by no means able to check their progress-he has power given him by the Assembly to impress Horses wherever he can find them but he has not necessaries to mount the Men when he gets them. This being the Case we know not what course to take to preserve the Country from their ravages, we want Arms greatly for Infantry, but when we have them it is difficult to find men to use them, all owing to the danger their Families are in from the Horse. We have 600 fine Men under Baron Stuben wch. he will not carry into action, what are his Reasons I know not, but I can assure you his Conduct gives universal disgust and injures the Service much, the People complaining and with reason that they are draged from their Families at a time when they are most wanted to make bread for
"We have now no Executive in the State for want of a Senate the Govr. will act no more, and the remainder of the Council will not get together. I hope we shall set these matters right next week."
A Copy of a Letter from the Marqs. of the 3d inst. to Genl. Greene (3) intimates that he was ignorant till lately that Genl. Greene had ordered these levies to act in Virga. but it does not appear he had orders from Genl. Greene upon the subject as he complains in the Letter that he had not heard from him for some time. Perhaps your interposition may be necessary upon this business to prevent misunderstanding. How far Col. H.'s opinion abt. the Baron requires your interference You will judge. I had heard some complaints of that Gentn. before I left the State but attributed them to his being long in the Milatary line, unacquainted with the civil institutions and disgusted that his requisitions were not immediately complied with, rather than any other quality-however if he has disgusted the people prudence requires he shod. not be detached, but subject to the controul of some superior officer or recalled. These matters you will direct as you shall see best for the Service. Could not Genl. Greene be well spared from the South to take the Command in Virga. The great scene of action is there, and as you cannot be present, his Abilities and experience may be very usefull. Excuse the haste of this Letter wch. I have been obliged to write in Congress and believe me with perfect esteem, D Sr., Yr. aff Friend & Sevt. Jos. Jones.
1 See Jones to Washington, May 31, 1781, note 2.
2 While Richard Henry Lee's letter to the Virginia delegates has not been found, his June 12 letters to Washington and to James Lovell appealing for Washington's presence in the south are in Lee, Letters (Ballagh), 2:233-38. Lee also enclosed in his letter to Washington a copy of his letter to Lovell, both of which are in the Washington Papers, DLC.
3 For which see Lafayette, Papers (Idzerda), 4:162-65.
Your Excellency will receive enclosed, three Acts of Congress.
No. 1 of the 16th Instant relative to granting Furloughs & Discharges &c.(1) No 2 of the 18th containing Regulations for the Department of the Clothier General, also an Order to the Board of War respecting the medical Department and Resolve relative to the Canadians in Col. Hazens Regiment.(2) No 3 abolishing the Department of Assistant Quarter Master General.(3) I have the Honor to be, with the highest Regard, Your Excellency's Most obedient & most humble Servant, Sam. Huntington President
1 For this June 16 resolve terminating the authority of regimental commanders to grant furloughs and requiring greater accountability in registering furloughs and discharges, See JCC, 20:656-57.
2 The June 18 resolves on these three subjects are found in JCC, 20:662-68.
3 This June 20 resolve was adopted in response to a March 24 recommendation from Quartermaster General Timothy Pickering, which had been referred to the Board of War. See PCC, item 147, 6:427-49; and JCC, 19:313, 20:677-78. Upon learning that Pickering had recommended abolition of this position as a cost-cutting measure, Assistant Quartermaster Charles Pettit offered his resignation to Congress on June 12. PCC, item 78, 18:395-98; and JCC 20:649, 677. Huntington reported the congressional decision on the two requests to Pettit on June 21 and to Pickering on June 22. His letter to Pickering is in PCC, item 16, fol. 25; copies of his letter to Pettit are in the Washington Papers, DLC, and the Nathanael Greene Papers, MiU-C.
France appears to be most perfectly satisfied with the {present mediators yet presses us} (1) for an Arrangement final of the most {moderate terms. Franklin, Jay, H Laurence and Jefferson are added to you}. You would be made very happy by such an Event being grounded on a Desire to alleviate the Distress of a great {discretion but blush blush} America {consult and ultimately concur in every thing with} The Ministers of his most Christian Majesty, the Independence of the United States according to the Tenor of our Alliance {kept sole ultimatum}. I might have mentioned a Circumstance, not very material in the present Turn of Affairs {all or less or one can conclude as plenipo}.(2) It is a Satisfaction to me and others alike interested that your other {parchments are untouched}. I hope therefore that we may conclude our {haddock safe}.(3) I presume you will be at very little Loss to come at the Clue of this Labyrinth. {Gravier now} persuaded of the absolute Necessity of the most cordial Intercourse between {him and you strongly pressed for
The President has sent the Papers before referred to.(5) I furnished the Instructions in a Cypher. If any Thing prevents your coming at the Purport Doctr. Franklin can certainly decypher his. I[t] was intended to send only one Set by one Vessel, but I think that would have added Something to the List of oddities in this Business.
I do not despair of being able to write again by this opportunity.
The Franklin came into the River today. Letters from Mr. Dana are recd. to April 3d.(6) Yr. last is still Oct. 24. Affecty JL
1 Words printed in braces in this text were written by Lovell in cipher.
2 That is, as explained in the new instructions adopted by Congress for the conduct of Adams and the recently appointed ministers plenipotentiary, for which see note 5 below.
3 A reference to the New England fisheries, which Lovell believed would remain safe as long as Adams retained his "other parchments"-his authority to negotiate a commercial treaty with Great Britain. However, Congress revoked Adams' commission to negotiate such a treaty on July 12, for which see JCC, 20:746-47; James Madison's Notes, July 12; and Lovell to Elbridge Gerry, July 13, and to John Adams, July 21, 1781.
4 Lovell is explaining that the key word to the double column, polyalphabetic cipher he enclosed with this letter, which is also in the Adams Papers, was "Cranch."
5 See Samuel Huntington to Franklin, June 19, and to John Adams, June 20, 1781.
6 Letters from Francis Dana of March 24, 28, 31, and April 2 and 4, 1781, were read in Congress on June 22. See JCC, 20:688; PCC, item 89, fols. 506-20, 524-27; and Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:325-27, 333-334, 344, 349-51.
I have received the very obliging letter which you did me the honor to write on the 5th of May by Capt. Ohara, and feel the greater obligation when I consider the very little time you have for private correspondence. The picture which you give of the miseries of the inhabitants of the southern States and your opinion respecting the necessity of a permanent body of troops, at least, equal to the collective force of the enemy, before we can entertain a well grounded hope of recovering and defending those states are most assuredly well founded, and are farther confirmed by every account which I have recieved. What are we to do? The states which are apparently secure from the invasion of the enemy, look with too much indifference upon those which are suffering and unable to make a vigorous opposition.
I would enter into detail on a variety of subjects, if I had any doubt that you will see Govr. Rutledge, who is minutely acquainted with every circumstance of our affairs civil as well as military and from whom you will have much more information than can be communicated by a letter.
Your sufferings and perseverance as well as that of your officers and privates in the defence of the Southern States in particular, demand the gratitude of every individual and makes a deep impression on the heart of him who has the honor to be, With perfect respect and esteem, my dear general, Your most Obt. Humble Servt.
Wm. Sharpe
Congress having received some important Communications from the Minister plenipotentiary of France respecting the Intentions of the Courts of Petersburgh & Vienna, have come to some Determinations thereupon which are not only interesting to the united States in general, but to the State of Virginia in particular; I took the Liberty therefore to insist that you should be added to the Ministers of these States already in Europe, that the State of Virginia particularly & the united States in general might have the Benefit of your abilities in a Negociation that may probably take place. I am not at Liberty to communicate to you explicitly by a Letter, the Objects that will require your attention, or the Nature of the Restrictions by which you will be bound. You will therefore not be able to determine whether the Embassy will be agreeable & honourable; but, I am confident that you cannot fail of rendering very essential Services to the State by your intimate Knowledge of its Interests; and I am persuaded that it can only be requisite to suggest to you that the Business will be very important and your Usefulness in negociating it very great, to induce you to accept the Appointment.(1)
Exertion & Unanimity are now more than ever requisite in the State of Virginia. Assistance will come but slowly; but I beseech you to avoid Despair. It can only produce Divisions which will encrease your Distresses without procuring for you one valuable End. This State and some others in the union, enjoy most of the Blessings of Peace; and, attentive to other objects more pleasing, they are not willing to beh'old the Distresses of Virginia. Congress is so destitute of Money & consequently of Power, that if there was the most cordial Disposition to give immediate & effectual assistance to the State, it is not practicable. I have no Doubts however, but that the Campaign
My Situation here is really distressful, I have not had any authentic Intelligence concerning my family & Estate since the month of April, having designed to leave this City on the first of May, which prevented any Letters from being written to me, if the Communication had not otherwise been cut off. I am the more distressed because my funds will not enable me either to stay or to go from hence.(2) However the Virginia Delegates are not the only suffering Delegates here, & they must submit to the Hardship of the Times. I hope it will not be of long continuance; and [be] assured that while I do remain here, I shall not neglect to try every Expedient which may promise any Relief to the State.
I am Dr. Sir, yr. most obedt. & hble Servt.
M. Smith
1 For Jefferson's delayed refusal of "the Appointment," see Samuel Huntington to Jefferson, June 15, 1781, note 2.
2 For Smith's eventual departure in early September, see Virginia Delegates to Thomas Nelson, August 21, 1781, note 2.
It gave me much Satisfaction to hear of your safe arrival in France and that you had proceeded on the business of your embassy-the letters of March the 20th in cyphers came Safe(1) and your mode of executing was agreeable to congress. I wish you may Succeed in the great point, of the naval Superiority. This alone can enable us to wage an equal war with the foes of our independence. The interests of France and these States are so united, that any unnecessary delay in establishing the independence of the latter is a real detriment to both.
We have appointed five commissioners to manage the business which had been entrusted heretofore to Mr. Adams-your father is one of the member-Doctor Franklin, Mr. Jay and Governor Jefferson-are also joined in the Commission. We have passed a resolve authorising our plenipotentiary to offer Genl. Burgoine in Exchange for your father and hope it will prove Successful (2)-as his Services will be much wanted. Should the mediating powers be in Earnest to terminate the disputes among the beligerent powers, I
Genl. Greene has had a great Tun [Run?] of Success in the Carolina's and Georgia. I believe the british are now confined to the two towns of Charlestown and Savannah-Virginia is feeling the force of the british. The Marquis our excellent young Genl. commands there-every hour we expect to hear of an action-the british are between six and Seven thousand strong in that Quarter.
Mr. Price, by whom I send this letter is a Gentleman of much Worth and merit and will be able to communicate all the intelligence you desire-his private affairs lead him to France.(3) He rendered much services to the States in the time of the Canada Expeditions you will find him worthy of your Esteem.
I have the Honor to be Dr. Sir, yr. most humble & obedt. Servant. Richd. Howly
1 Laurens' March 20 cipher letter to Congress, enclosing a copy of his memorial to the comte de Vergennes and a list of military items requested from France, had been read in Congress on May 30 and referred to the committee appointed to confer with the French minister. See JCC, 20:577; Wharton, Diplomatic Correspondence, 4:317-21; and PCC, item 109, fols. 417-52.
2 For the proposed Burgoyne-Henry Laurens exchange, see Samuel Huntington to Washington, June 20, 1781, note 2.
3 For James Price's June 16 letter, read on the 18th, informing Congress of his "intention to embark for France in four or five days" and offering his services to Congress "on all occasions" while abroad, See JCC, 20:658; and PCC, item 78, 18:403.
Mr. Henderson, who has the honor of presenting this to your Excellency, finds himself obliged to depart within the hour or lose his Passage on a Ship for Havana, which prevents me from giving you the Answers that I would wish to your several Letters,(1) for they are in the Office of the Secretary, and it is not possible for me to obtain them at this moment.
Mr. Henderson has been most diligent, loyal, and solicitous in carrying out the matter committed to his Charge and has secured the settlement of the Account, in the particulars of which he has been instructed to inform you.(2) I only lament the State of our Public Treasury, due to the circumstances of a Cruel and inhuman War that works against us, in such a manner, as to make it impossible for
Your sincere Wish (expressed in your Letter of 22 July 1780)(4) to assist the United States in every possible way and the Gracious Offer of Services out of your Kindness, call for the most heartfelt Recognition. I am convinced that your Wisdom and integrity will permit the most Reasonable consideration of our situation, in our strenuous exertions against the Powerful and vengeful Nation, although we have firm expectations that in the end we shall overcome all Difficulties. I have the honor to be, with the greatest Respect, Your Excellency's most Obedient and very humble Servant,
Samuel Huntington
1 Except for the letter cited in note 4, these documents are not in PCC.
2 John Henderson had been in Philadelphia several months as agent for Oliver Pollock seeking settlement of Pollock's accounts with the Committee of Commerce for which See JCC, 18:1027-28, 1106-7, 19:32, 41, 71, 118-19, 130, 142, 312, 341-42 20:462, 491; and PCC, item 41, 4:161-72, 177-82, item 50, fols. 123-38.
3 For Capt. William Pickles' contact with the Spanish authorities at New Orleans, See JCC, 18:1130-31; and these Letters, 15:251-52.
4 Copies of Galvez's June 22, 1780, letter to Huntington are in PCC, item 50, fols. 171, 309.
I have herewith inclosed for your Information three Acts of Congress of the 13th, 16th & 18th Instant.
No. 1 recommending to the several States to which the Officers of the Hospital & medical Department now in Service respectively belong, or of which, they are or were Inhabitants, to settle their Accounts of Depreciation on the Principles established by the Resolution of the 10th of April 1780, in the same Manner with Officers of the Line, and each State which shall advance on this Account more than it's Proportion, is to be allowed for the same on Account of the United States.(1)
No. 2 contains Regulations for granting Furloughs, the Forms of Furloughs & Discharges, to be made Use of under the Direction of the Commander in Chief or Commanders of separate Departments.(2) The Act was passed in Consequence of an Application from the Commander in Chief.
No. 3 containing new regulations for the Clothing Department, and repealing all former Regulations in that & the Hide Department that are inconsistent with this Arrangement.(3)
Your several Despatches of the 5th, 10th, 14th & 16th of May have been received.(4)
This will be delivered you by Governor Rutledge, to whom I must refer you for particular Intelligence from this Quarter.
I have the Honor to be, with much Respect, Your most obedient & most humble Servant, Sam. Huntington President
1 See Huntington to the States, June 15, 1781.
2 See JCC, 20:656 57.
3 JCC, 20:662-67.
4 See JCC, 20:620, 658; and PCC, item 155, 2:51-74.
I had the pleasure of receiving your Letter of the 4th of last month and is the latest intelligence which I have received from that Country, your representation differed very little from what I expected from that quarter so I was not much surprised you were very much out, contrary to your usual Sagacity, with regard to the movements of Lord Cornwallis, indeed both Green and his Lordship have taken their Measures in a manner so diametrically opposite to what was generally expected that you were not the only person who was disappointed. The Assembly is now sitting at this place (2) and it is said discover a disposition to do great matters, but you know these people better than I do and can better Judge what is to be expected from them. You will before this reaches you have heard that a Negociation for peace is on foot in Europe under the Mediation of the Emperor & Empress Queen of Russia. The Events of this Campaign will determine whether America is to reap any Advantages from this Measure. We have the most friendly and unequivocal Assurances from our Ally that our Interest will be attended to and that he will make good on his part every thing that he has undertaken.
We have just heard of a Reinforcement having arrived at Charlestown on the 10th of this month said to consist of about two thousand men, three thousand were said to have embarked in that
I have heard that our Assembly was to meet the 15th Instant and not doubting but the Delegates are by this time ready to set off for this place, I shall turn my face homeward as soon as compleated a little business of considerable importance to our State.(3) My Complements to all our friends. I wish I had some good news to write, I hope to be able to tell them some when I return. In the mean time believe me with the most Sincere Regard & Esteem, Dear sir, Yours,
P.S. The Assembly adjourned yesterday after passing a Law for compleating their Quota of Troops which it is thought will be effectually executed. They have very Judiciously put their funds under the Direction of your friend R. Morris which will have a very happy effect on their Credit. I consider myself as particularly unfortunate in not having been able to cultivate an Acquaintance with that Gentleman, owing partly to my indisposition and in some measure to my ignorance of the Etiquette of this place. There is no confirmation of the Report respecting the Arrival of the Ship Fayette has not yet taken place and I fear she is lost.
June 27th.(4)
1 Johnston originally wrote "25th" over which he wrote "23" without altering the "th."
2 That is, the Pennsylvania assembly.
3 For Johnston's departure from Philadelphia, see William Sharpe to Burke, July 28, 1781, note 1.
4 Presumably the date the postscript was written.
Verry few Opertunities to Dover have Offered since I came up to Congress so that probably you have been but indifferently supplied with news. It has been some time since we have had any officially here, either from the Eastward or Southward. The last Eastern mail was Taken by the enemy, the week before last, with the general
I am very Anxious to hear that our Assembly have reformed their Malitia Law and done every thing else in their power to put the state in the best possible posture of defence for If our army in Virginia should be unfortunate a strong Detachment of the Enemy may be Expected to Cross the Bay. The Maryland assembly have increased their Malitia on duty to Two thousand-and I think it would have been well in Delaware to have adopted a similar plan. These Malitia are in pay every day they Exercised (2) and are liable to be imbodied whenever called for. But it was unfortunate that our assembly sett at Lewis quite out of the way of intelligence. I have not had a line from them nor had an opertunity of writing to them since they met. I very much fear they have not been sufficiently informed to do what was necessary at the present Crisis, and harvest drawing near has probably hurried them home sooner than I would wish as the present time requires particular and extraordinary exertions to Complete our Glorious struggle for Liberty.
I am Sir, your Most Obedt. Thomas Rodney
1 William Killen (1722-1805), Dover, Del., barrister, was chief justice and later chancellor of Delaware.
2 Rodney inserted an asterisk at this point, to which he keyed the following passage at the foot of the page. "You never will have a good Malitia till you lay an adequate fine on non attendance, and pay them that do attend for every day they exercise. If this principle was adopted you would soon find your Malitia what you wish-this is the principle adopted by the Swiss Cantons."
The inclosed news papers will give you the current news of this quarter. For other particulars I refer you to Govr. Rutledge (1) who can say to you, all I can at this time, except such matters as I dare not communicate either to him or you.
I hope his presence will be productive of all the good consequences you expect. I am well persuaded many advantages will result from it, & if you can but be happy enough to maintain the ground you have with such infinite labour, & honor, gained from the enemy, that you will have the heart felt satisfaction of seeing your generous exertions crowned with as much success, as could possibly be expected, that is, order, & all the tranquillity that a state of war can admit of, restored to a grievously distressed country.
I am My Dr. sir with the highest Esteem & Regard, Yr. most Obedt. servt. Jno. Mathews
1 Gov. John Rutledge of South Carolina was preparing to leave Philadelphia following his second recent visit and appealed to the South Carolina delegates in a letter of June 27 to seek an exception to Congress' stringent ordinance of March 27, 1781, on the capture of prizes by granting him passports for vessels carrying much-needed salt to North and South Carolina. "As I only wait to know their Determination," urged Rutledge, "be pleased to obtain it, this Morning." Congress acceded to Rutledge's request the same day, granting him "four sets of permits" under strict conditions for their return to Congress. The governor apparently set out for South Carolina on June 28. See JCC, 19:314 16, 20:705-6; PCC, item 36, 1:201-2, item 177, fols. 10-11; and the "Letters of John Rutledge," South Carolina Historical and Genealogical Magazine 18 July 1917): 136n.13.
That Vanheer's Corps. called the Marechausie Corps be considered as part of the Quota of Troops to be furnished to the Army of the United States by the State of Pennsylvania.
1 Although the journals indicate only that a motion by the Pennsylvania delegates was "referred to the Board of War" this date, it is clear from the board's correspondence with General Washington concerning Capt. Bartholomew Von Heer's corps that this brief motion was the subject of Secretary Thomson's journal entry of this date. It was enclosed with a June 26 letter from commissioner Richard Peters to Washington questioning the propriety of establishing the corps in the Pennsylvania Line because it was composed heavily of German deserters enlisted contrary to Continental policy. "I think you will find," Washington replied on July 9, "by referring to the Returns which have been heretofore made, that Von Heers Corps have been considered as part of the quota of Pennsylvania. But it will be improper to permit them to count upon them any longer, because the term of their service expires in a very short time. It is true that several of them have been found to be deserters, but as they were inlisted within the State, they passed as part of their quota of it. This has been the case in all the States. These men or so many of them as have been credited to the state are justly intitled by their faithful services to have their depreciation made up in common with the other corps." See JCC, 20:695; Richard Peters to Washington, June 26, 1781, Washington Papers, DLC; and Washington, Writings (Fitzpatrick), 22:343-44. For additional documents concerning the pay and status of Von Heer's corps, see also ibid., pp. 149-50, 372; JCC, 20:660; and PCC, item 78, 23:185-88, item 147, 5:337-44. George Clymer, Joseph Montgomery, and Thomas Smith were the Pennsylvania delegates attending Congress at this time.
The Delegates of South Carolina have received a letter from Mr. Drayton, who was appointed by Congress as Dy. Qr. Mr. Gl. for the Southern Department in Novr. 1778.(1)
Mr. Drayton mentions the disagreeable situation in which he stands, by not having received any intimation of what has been done in the department since the new arrangement took place, particularly on what footing he is to be considered, or whether he is to be considered as still in the service, or not.
We should therefore be obliged to you, Sir, to satisfy Mr. Drayton on this head, & if a new appointment is necessary, that you would be pleased to make it, if his character is such a one as you approve of. Mr. Drayton was at the beginning of this revolution a gentleman of independent fortune, & one of the first families in So. Carolina. He has served in this department with reputation, & is as well qualified as any man we know for a continuance in it.
If the department he formerly held should be filled up before you receive this, we could Wish him to be appointed for the state of So. Carolina. But we rather hope for his continuance in the first.(2)
We are sir', Yr. most Obed. servts.
Jno. Mathews Ns. Eveleigh
Isaac Motte Tho. Bee
1 For Stephen Drayton's election to this post, see these Letters, 11 :234-36.
2 No evidence concerning the resolution of Drayton's "disagreeable situation" has been found.
Being engagd on a Committee of consequence this morning (1) I can do little more than acknowledge the receipt of your favor by Post, & thank you for that part of it respecting My Daughter & the supplies anxiously expected. Mr Potts will Communicate to you what intelligence we have. I Believe there is little doubt but that part of the Cork fleet is arrivd at Charles Town, & perhaps some in our Bay.
I hope soon to have a good opportunity of forwarding yr hat &ca. I can do nothing better with yr Carrich than what Col Forrest informd you. Let me Know yr determination. My Compts to your Lady & all inquiring friends. Beleive Dr Sr, yrs. with the greatest regard & esteem. Danl Carroll
1 Apparently the committee on the memorial from the minister of France, which had been considering letters from Francis Dana since June 22 and which issued a report this day allowing Dana to serve as secretary to the peace commissioners in the event that he had not proceeded on his mission to Russia. See JCC, 20:688, 698-99.
I recd yours of 28th May by yesterdays mail. This is the only letter I have recd. from you: and this I suppose has been detaind at Fishkill for want of a post rider as one of our postriders with his mail were taken & carried to York abt. begining of June.
You have doubtless recd. sundry of my letters (1) before this time informing of my arrival &c and of the bad state of the currency: Since which I have drawn on you in behalf of the state two small bills the first 133 1/3 dolls. the second 266 2/3 dollers which I suppose will come to hand before this.
If this meathod of supply be disagreable I beg some other may be pointed out, or that I may be informed of the pleasure of the Court.
I have between 8 & 9 hundred dollers of the new emission dollers & several thousand of the old: but paper mony is of no use. The court would be unwilling to have me put away the paper at 6 or 7 for one which they must redeem in so short a time.
As to Vermont I am sorry to see the distressed situation we are in by the policy of a few. The affair might have been settled a year ago, upon the plan I proposed. (2) But the rejecting that has irritated the people on the grants, on both sides of the river, and given our enemies the advantages they now possess. We have no delegate from New York as yet & Congress has been very thin 'till very lately: as soon as any thing can be done I shall do the utmost to bring matters to a settlement: But which way it will be settled I am at a loss. Your letter will be of great use, I am perswaded, in exciting the attention of our friends in congress. I shall accordingly shew it to a number of them.
They must see that Rome or Carthage must be demolished. I am very strongly impressed with an idea that this dispute will never be settled but by dividing the territory between N York & us: but I have no authority to act on this plan. Genl. Sullivan has expresst the same sentiment to me lately. Should the whole be decreed to us they might be too powerfull under the influence of Mr Allen to obey the decree: Should they be divided that part that would fall to us wd. perhaps be easily reconciled.
The Ship Franklin which arrived here from France last week had a very long passage, consequently brought no news.
You will observe the Brittish & Tory news everywhere holds forth that America is to be excluded from the