Lefebure, Victor
. The riddle of the Rhine, chemical strategy in peace and war ...
Electronic Text Center, University of Virginia Library
|
Table of Contents for this work | | All on-line databases | Etext Center Homepage |

THE LIVENS PROJECTOR -- 1. A completed battery of projectors in the foreground, with a battery on the left rear, half dug in. Suitably camouflaged with brush, the batteries are not observable by aircraft, and, being in "No-Man's-Land," neither party can detect them by day. Frontispiece
THE RIDDLE
OF THE RHINE
CHEMICAL STRATEGY IN PEACE AND WAR
An account of the critical struggle for power and for the decisive war initiative. The campaign fostered by the great Rhine factories, and the pressing problems which they represent. A matter of pre-eminent public interest concerning the sincerity of disarmament, the future of warfare, and the stability of peace.
BY
VICTOR LEFEBURE
Officer of the Order of the British Empire (Mil.) Chevalier de la Legion d'Honneur, Officer of the Crown of Italy Fellow of the Chemical Society, etc.
WITH A PREFACE BY
MARSHAL FOCH
AND AN INTRODUCTION BY
FIELD-MARSHAL SIR HENRY WILSON, BART.
Chief of the Imperial General Staff
THE CHEMICAL FOUNDATION, INC.
81 FULTON STREET
NEW YORK CITY
Published, 1923 ,
By THE CHEMICAL FOUNDATION, INC.
-- --
All Rights Reserved
Printed in the United States of America
-5-
PREFACE
My motives in writing this book are sufficiently explained in the first chapter. The silence surrounding the true facts of the chemical campaign, the tardy realisation of the real forces behind it in Germany, and our failure to grasp the significance of the matter in the Treaty, all pointed to the need for an early statement. More recently, this need has been emphasised by inaccurate public utterances on the matter, and by its vital importance for the full and fair treatment of certain legislative measures before Allied countries.
A unique experience of chemical warfare in all its aspects, first with a combatant gas unit on the British front in France, then as Liaison Officer with France and other Allies on all Chemical Warfare and allied questions, has afforded me an exceptionally complete survey of the subject. Later post-armistice experience in Paris, and the occupied territories, assisting Lord Moulton on various chemical questions in connection with the Treaty, and surveying the great chemical munition factories of the Rhine, has provided a central view of the whole matter which can have been the privilege and opportunity of very few.
Further, my association with the dye industry, since commencing this book, leaves me with a deep conviction of the critical importance for disarmament, of a world redistribution of organic chemical production. It is inevitable that such a step should benefit the growing organic chemical industries of
-6-
countries other than Germany, but this issue need not be shirked. The importance of the matter is so vital that it eclipses all reproach that the disarmament argument for the maintenance of the dye industry is used on selfish grounds. Such reproach cannot, in fairness, be heard unless it destroys the case which we have established. We are faced with the following alternatives. Safety demands strong organic chemical industries or cumbersome and burdensome chemical warfare establishments. The stability of future peace depends upon the former, and the extent to which we must establish, or can abandon, the latter depends entirely on the activity and success of those whose special duty it is to organise against war. A recent visit to America revealed the considerable publicity and public interest surrounding chemical warfare, strengthening my conviction that the facts, now noised abroad, should be presented in their proper setting. They are supremely significant at the present time and for the future, hence the chapters which follow.
V. LEFEBURE.
HAMPSTEAD, October 12, 1920.
-7-
PREFACE BY FIELD MARSHAL FOCH
In 1918, chemical warfare had developed considerably in our army. Before 1914 Germany possessed chemical factories which permitted her to manufacture in great quantities chemicals used at the front, and to develop on a large scale this new form of fighting.
The Allies, to retaliate, had to experiment and organise important centres for production. Only in this way, though starting late, were they able to put themselves in a position to supply the growing necessities of their armies.
To-day, the ability for aviation to carry increasing weight furnishes a new method for abundantly spreading poison gases with the aid of stronger and stronger bombs, and to reach armies, the centres of population in the rear, or to render regions uninhabitable.
Chemical warfare is therefore in a condition to produce more formidable results over more extended areas.
It is incontestable on the other hand that this growth will find an easy realisation in one country, Germany, addicted in times of peace, to wholesale manufacture of chemical products, which a simple modification in reactions can transform into war products.
This country, deprived, partially at least, of its former methods of fighting, and its numerous forces of specially trained soldiers, regularly organised and
-8-
strongly armed, will be more drawn toward the new systems of attack -- that of chemical warfare. Chemical warfare must therefore enter into our future provisions and preparations, if we do not wish to experience some terrible surprises.
The work of Major Lefebure gives an exact idea of the possibilities he finds to-day in Germany, and through them the dangers with which she threatens us. In this form it constitutes a warning; and information of the highest order, for the minds who remain anxious for the fate of their country confronted by the inefficience of the old fighting methods which the progress of industry out of date renders daily.
By sounding the alarm in both our countries, I find myself in company with my faithful friend Field Marshal Sir Henry Wilson. This is an old habit, contracted by both of us, many years ago, which we still maintain at the present time to insure for ourselves once again, peace in the future.
Together, we say, read this work of Major Lefebure.
F. FOCH.
-9-
CONTENTS
CHAPTER I-EXPLANATORY
The Riddle of the Rhine-A Critical Point in Disarmament-Need for a Balanced View of Chemical Warfare-Some Preliminary Explanation -- "Poison Gas" a Misleading Term-The French Physiological Classification-Asphyxiating Substances-Toxic Substances-Lachrymators-Vesicant or Blistering Compounds-Sneezing or Sternutatory Substances-The Tactical Classification-Persistent Substances-Non-persistent Substances-Penetrants-Special Gas Weapons and Appliances-Gas Shell. . . . . . . . 17
CHAPTER II-THE GERMAN SURPRISE
The First Cloud Gas Attack-The Element of Surprise -Lord Kitchener's Protest-German Preparations -- Research-Production-Field Preparations-German Opinion of Results-Germany Prompted by Production Monopoly-Standard Uses for Gas-Gas Shell-Further German Cloud Attacks-Hill 60-Origin of German Gas Shell-Early German Gas Shell-A Successful Experiment-Lachrymators at Loos, 1915-The Flammenwerfer-German Phosgene Clouds-Gas and the Eastern Theatre-Conclusion. . . . . . . . 31
CHAPTER III-THE ALLIED REACTION
The Need of Retaliation-First Signs-The Loos Attack, September, 1915-The Somme Battle, 1916 -- Reasons for British Cloud Gas Success-Our Casualties- Exhausting Preparations for Cloud Attack-The Livens Projector-British Gas Shell-German Gas Shell Development, 1916-Main Features of the Period. . . . . . . . 48
CHAPTER IV-INTENSIVE CHEMICAL WARFARE
The Mustard Gas Surprise-Blue Cross-German Emphasis on Gas Shell-The German Projector-German Projector Improvements-Dyes in Gas Shell -- German Flame Projectors-Their Origin-Further Flame Development-The 1918 Offensive-Ludendorff's Testimony-Preparations for Assault-Gas Defensive Flank at Armentières-Fixed Gas Barrage at Kemmel-Percentage of Chemical Shell-Gas Retreat
-10-
Tactics-General Hartley's Analysis-Percentage of German Gas Shell in Enemy Dumps-Forced Exhaustion of Stocks-Yperite, French Mustard Gas- Effect on German Gas Discipline-Allied Gas Statistics- Critical Importance of Rapid German Production. . . . . . . 66
CHAPTER V-CHEMICAL WARFARE ORGANISATIONS
German Research-Leverkusen-Höchst-Ludwigshaven- Early Formulation of Policy-Movements of Personnel-German Simplicity of Organisation- German Organisation at the Front-The Gas Regiment -- Early German Gas School-New Gas Regiments-Gas Shell Experts-Inspection of Protective Masks and Method-British Field Organisation -- "Breach" Organisations-Central Laboratory-New Type of Casualty -- Directorate of Gas Services- British Home Organisations-The Royal Society- Royal Society Chemical Sub-Committee-The Trench Warfare Department-Scientific Advisory Committee -Commercial Advisory Committee-Split Between Research and Supply-Munitions Inventions Department-Imperial College of Science-The Chemical Warfare Department-The Anti-Gas Department -Designs Committee French Organisation-Italian Developments-Supply Organisations-British Supply Organisation-Allied Handicaps-The German Solution -Departmental Difficulties-Allied Success Against Odds-Allied Lack of Vision in Production- British Lag in Organisation-French and American Characteristics-Inter-Allied Chemical Warfare Liaison- Inter-Allied Supply-Nature of Chemical Warfare Research-Discovery of New Substances-Technical Method of Preparation-Filling Problem-Protection- Half Scale Investigation-Two Classes of Research-Conclusion-The "Outer and Inner Lines." . . . . . . . . 85
CHAPTER VI-THE STRUGGLE FOR THE INITIATIVE
Meaning of the Chemical Initiative-Controlling Factors -- Rapid Manufacture Rapid Identification Essential- Propaganda and Morale-Peculiar Peace-time Danger-War Fluctuations of Initiative-The Tense Protective Struggle-The German Mask-Enforced German Modifications-Shortage of Rubber-Gas Discipline-Summary-New German Attempts-Yellow and Blue Cross-Yellow Cross-Blue Cross-"Particulate" Clouds-Potential Production and Peace. . . . . . . . 111
-11-
CHAPTER VII-REVIEW OF PRODUCTION
Critical Importance of Production-Significance of the German Dye Industry -- The Interessen Gemeinschaft-War Production by the I.G.-Allied Difficulties-Conclusion. . . . . . . . 143
CHAPTER VIII-AMERICAN DEVELOPMENTS
Special Attention justified-Special Value of American Opinion-Early American Activities-Field Activities -Special Difficulties-Edgewood Arsenal-Research -- Production-Post-Armistice Developments-Views of General Fries-The Gas Cloud Inescapable-Importance of Smoke-Casualty Percent ages-Short Range Projectors-Vast Expansion in Personnel. . . . . . . . 173
CHAPTER IX-GERMAN CHEMICAL POLICY
Origin of German Chemical Monopolies-German Chemical Commercial Policy-Evidence of the U. S. A. Alien Property Custodian-Pre-war American Situation -German Price Cutting-Salicylic Acid-Full Line Forcing-Bribery and Corruption-German Patent Policy-Propaganda and Information -- Espionage-Activities of the Dye Agencies-Manoeuvring Raw Materials-Chemical Exchange Association -Doctor Albert's Letter-Dye Agency Information System-Dr. Albert on Chemical Warfare-The Moral Aspect-Report of the New York World-German Policy Regarding Dye Supplies to the U. S. A. -- Professor Stieglitz's Evidence Ehrlich's Discovery -- Drugs and Medicinal Products-The German Monopoly- National Health Insurance Commission-The Royal Society-Novocain-Beta-Eucaine-Photographic Chemicals-War Activities of the I.G.-The Rhine Factories and the Armistice-War Mentality of the I.G.-German Attitude towards Inspection-The Rhine and Chaulny Contrast-German Revolution and the Industrial Leaders-The German Peace Delegation -Recent Signs of Government Interest-Nitrogen Fixation-The German Nitrogen Syndicate-Haber Process Prominent-The New German Dye Combine -Aggressive Nationalist Policy. . . . . . . . 186
CHAPTER X-LINES OF FUTURE DEVELOPMENT
The Element of Speculation-Chemical Tactics and Strategy-New War Chemicals -- "Camouflage" Chemicals-Functions Hitherto Immune-Chemical Constitution and Physiological Action-Unsolved Problems
-12-
of Mustard Gas-A New Type of Obstacle -- The "Persistent Lethal" Substance-The Critical Range-The New No-Man's-Land-The "Alert Gas Zone" -- Gas and Aircraft-Protective Development-Individual Protection-Collective Protection-Conclusion. . . . . . . . 215
CHAPTER XI-HUMANE OR INHUMANE?
Nature of Gas Casualties-Sargent's Picture-Need for Safeguards. . . . . . . 238
CHAPTER XII-CHEMICAL WARFARE AND DISARMAMENT
The Treaty of Versailles-German Information-Limitation of Armament-Report of the Hartley Mission -New Conceptions in Chemical Disarmament-Limitation Mechanical and Chemical-Tank Disarmament -Chemical Limitation-Research-Production-Mechanical and Chemical Preparations for War-Recent Disarmament Proposals-The Covenant of the League Need for Guarantees-Viscount Grey, "Germany must disarm first'~ -- Suggested Methods -- "Vested Interests" -- "Handing Over" Inventions-Neglect of Chemical Disarmament in the Treaty. . . . . . . . . 242
CONCLUSION-THE TREATY OF THE FUTURE.
. . . . . . . . 264
-13-
ILLUSTRATIONS
THE LIVENS PROJECTOR-I. . . . Frontispiece
A completed battery of projectors in the foreground, with a battery on the left rear, half dug in. Suitably camouflaged with brush, the batteries are not observable by aircraft, and, being in "No-Man's-Land," neither party can detect them by day.
TYPICAL GAS SHELL BURSTING. . . . FACING PAGE 30
THE LIVENS PROJECTOR-II. . . . 61
A working party fitting electric leads and adjusting bombs prior to discharge. This work occurs at night.
THE LIVENS PROJECTOR-III. . . . 133
Explosion of Livens bombs on the objective.
SMOKE BARRAGE. . . . 181
Note the sharp curtain which is formed, behind which the infantry advance.
-15-
INTRODUCTION
No one who has the welfare of the country at heart can fail to share Major Lefebure's anxiety that a clear, accurate, and unbiased account of chemical warfare should be presented to the public, so that the many erroneous ideas now prevalent in regard to poison gas and its uses may be dispelled.
The whole subject of chemical warfare is at present sub judice, and there is great danger that the future safety of this country may be jeopardised by the almost universal ignorance of the peculiarities and potentialities of this class of warfare. Recent publications in the Press have shown a tendency to deal with the subject on purely sentimental grounds, and attempts have been made to declare this form of warfare illegitimate without full and careful consideration of all the facts and their significance for the future.
Major Lefebure has therefore attempted in his book to make it quite clear that no convention, guarantee, or disarmament safeguard will prevent an unscrupulous enemy from employing poison gas, especially if that enemy has discovered some new powerful agent, or possesses, as Germany does in her well-organised and strong chemical industry, a ready means for producing such chemicals in bulk at practically a moment's notice; further, that the safety of this country makes it imperative that the study and investigation of the subject should be continued and that our chemical and
-16-
dye industry should be developed, so that when an emergency arises we may have the necessary facilities for supply ready to hand. It is not for me to express any opinion here either as to the desirability of using gas as a weapon or as to the possibility of preventing an enemy from using it. But I am convinced that a decision come to without full knowledge of the facts may involve grave danger and heavy preventable loss of life. I am further convinced that Major Lefebure, by his special knowledge and long experience as chemical liaison officer during the war, is well qualified to speak, and that his opinion is entitled to full consideration. For these reasons I think that his book will do a much needed public service. I wish it every success, and the greatest posible number of readers.
HENRY WILSON, F.M.