Chapter 4: A. Books and monographs, 1983.
Reference: 111.
Name: Abrahams,
, Mildred K.
Publication: Formerly in the Possession Of: Books from the Libraries
of William Byrd II,
Landon
Carter, Thomas Jefferson, and Their Contemporaries .
City: Charlottesville:
Publisher: Department of Rare
Books,
Date:
University
of Virginia Library, 1983.
Pages: 81.
Notes: Keepsake of an exhibition, 16 October--31 December, 1983,
with a brief introduction;
the
Library houses 152 titles once owned by TJ, mostly from his last library
formed after the great
library had been sold to the Library of Congress.
Reference: 112.
Name: Adams,
, William Howard.
Publication: Jefferson's Monticello .
City: New
York:
Publisher:
Abbeville
Press,
Date: 1983.
Pages: x, 276.
Notes: Well informed, elegantly written and presented treatment of TJ's
life-long architectural
project. Separate chapters cover his architectural reading and the buildings
he would have
known
in Virginia before he began building Monticello, the first Monticello
project, the second
Monticello,
his landscaping of the grounds, his furnishings for the house, and the
subsequent history of
Monticello. Illustrated with handsome photographs and with reproductions
of TJ's architectural
drawings. Argues more strongly than some other architectural historians do
for a fairly direct,
significant Palladian influence. A major book on Monticello.
Reference: 113.
Name: Allison,
, Andrew M.
, with M. Richard Maxfield, K. DeLynn Cook, and W. Cleon Skansen.
Publication: The Real Thomas Jefferson .
City:
Washington,
D.C.:
Publisher: National Center for Constitutional Studies,
Date:
1983.
Pages: xvi, 709.
Notes:
"Second edition, revised."
(1st in 1981, not seen). First 334 pages are a biography by Allison,
"Thomas Jefferson,
Champion
of Liberty," and the rest is a collection of quotations arranged topically
under the heading of
"Timeless Treasures from Thomas Jefferson." In contradistinction to the
"analyses" and
"interpretations" of other historians, this volume purports to give the "real"
TJ in his own words.
Naive and uncritical.
Reference: 114.
Name: Brick,
, Blanche Henderson.
Title: "Changing Concepts of Equal Educational Opportunity: A
Comparison of the Views of
Thomas Jefferson, Horace Mann, and John Dewey."
Publication: Ph.D. dissertation. Texas A & M University,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 248.
Publication: DAI
Volume: 45
Date: (1984),
Pages: 435-A.
Notes: Examines changing concepts of equal educational opportunity
in order to develop better
policies in the present. Examines what each man meant by the term equal
educational
opportunity
[a term TJ never used as such] and relates it to each man's philosophical
views regarding human
nature, individual responsibility, and the "Good Society." TJ realized the
threat of institutions to
personal liberty, but because Mann and Dewey lived in a world beginning
to view man more as a
creature than a creator of his institutions, they sought to equalize
opportunity by expanding rather
than by limiting institutional power.
Reference: 115.
Name: Cable,
, Carole.
Publication: Thomas Jefferson, Architect: A Bibliography of
Scholarship from
1968-1981 .
City: Monticello, IL:
Publisher: Vance
Bibliographies,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 10.
Notes: Intended to supplement O'Neal's 1969 bibliography of work on
TJ's architectural
activities.
Annotated.
Reference: 116.
Name: Carson,
, David Allen.
Title: "Congress in Jefferson's Foreign Policy, 1801-1809."
Publication: Ph.D. dissertation. Texas Christian University,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 302.
Publication: DAI
Volume: 44
Date: (1984) ,
Pages: 2553-A.
Notes: Examines the composition of the Seventh through the Tenth
Congresses in order to
consider
the relationship between President and Congress on specific foreign policy
issues. Contends that
TJ's changing relationship with Congress helps explain the foreign policy
successes of his first
term
and the failures of his second. In TJ's first term Congress was relatively
docile, disciplined, and
cooperative, and he was able to turn even the Federalist opposition to use
in acquiring Western
territory. Congress also gave him extensive authority to deal with the
Barbary Pirates. In the
Ninth
Congress, however, the relationship began to break down relative to foreign
affairs as a
consequence
of the revolt led by John Randolph and the Federalist opposition headed by
Timothy Pickering.
In
the first session of the Tenth Congress TJ dominated Congress completely,
but his support
collapsed
in the second session with the apparent failure of the embargo policy. He
all but abdicated his
authority during the last four months in office and left the Congress and
nation virtually
leaderless.
Reference: 117.
Name: Egan,
, Clifford L.
Publication: Neither Peace Nor War: Franco-American Relations,
1802-1812 .
City: Baton Rouge:
Publisher: Louisiana State University
Press,
Date:
1983.
Pages: xxvi, 226.
Notes: As the title suggests, the focus is not primarily on TJ but it
offers a useful account of his
foreign policy concerns after the Louisiana Purchase agreement. Argues for
TJ's neutrality as
president towards Great Britain and France and a deep-seated desire for
peace. Neither his
domestic
opponents nor the British believed in his neutrality, however, and the
British in consequence rode
rough-shod over American rights. French diplomatic observers more
correctly saw him as an
American nationalist above all, even if he was sympathetic to France.
Reference: 118.
Name: Garver,
, Newton.
Publication: Jesus, Jefferson, and the Task of Friends
.
City: Wallingford,
PA:
Publisher: Pendle Hill,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 30.
Notes: In discussing the work of Friends
(Quakers) in the world, the author appeals to the examples of Jesus
(especially Matthew
25:31-40)
and TJ. TJ is interesting because his ideas
"delimit the domain of politics" and because he exemplifies a hope
necessary for
survival in the world. This hope "that things in general will work out" is
not the same as
optimism,
"hope made specific," and thus includes a necessary skepticism about any
single human
endeavor.
Reference: 119.
Name: Jordan,
, Daniel P.
Publication: Political Leadership in Jefferson's Virginia
.
City: Charlottesville:
Publisher: University Press of
Virginia,
Date:
1983.
Pages: xiv, 284.
Notes: Only a few pages directly on TJ; analyzes the political system
and practice rather than
focusing on
"leaders" as such.
Reference: 120.
Name: Kirtland,
, Robert Bevier.
Title: "George Wythe: Lawyer, Revolutionary, Judge."
Publication: Ph.D. dissertation. University of
Michigan,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 335.
Publication: DAI
Volume: 44
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 1896-A.
Notes: Regrets that Wythe is not better known, since the better we
knew him and his close
relationship with TJ, the better, too, we would understand Jefferson. Wythe
the revolutionary
wished to establish an American jurisprudence within the framework of the
English common
law,
and with TJ and Edmund Pendleton proposed a drastic, simplified redrafting
of Virginia statutory
law.
Reference: 121.
Name: Lewis,
, Jan.
Publication: The Pursuit of Happiness: Family and Values in
Jefferson's
Virginia .
City: New York:
Publisher: Cambridge University Press,
Date:
1983.
Pages: xix, 289.
Notes: Not specifically about TJ but discusses him and members of his
family in passing
through
the book. First rate social history which has much to say about the values
and experience of
family
life in Virginia, particularly among the literate middle and upper classes at
the end of the
eighteenth
and the beginning of the nineteenth centuries. After an opening portrayal of
the
pre-Revolutionary
gentry, chapters are organized thematically around religion, death (TJ's
response to his wife's
death
bridged two modes of mourning; his determination to reenter public life and
obliterate the traces
of
his grief was typical of the eighteenth century, but his near collapse after
her death prefigured
later
sentimental responses), worldly success, and love. A final chapter considers
the transformation
of
values that took place between the revolutionary generation for whom civic
affairs had been a
way
of life and the generation of their grandchildren who found greatest
meaning in private family
life.
Reference: 122.
Name: Llewellyn,
, Robert.
Publication: Thomas Jefferson's Monticello .
City: Charlottesville:
Publisher: Thomasson-Grant,
Date:
1983.
Pages: 112.
Notes: A collection of handsome color photographs taken by Llewellyn;
foreword by Dumas
Malone; commentary by Charles Granquist.
Reference: 123.
Name: Cullen
, Charles T.
Publication: The Papers of Thomas Jefferson .
Volume: Volume 21. Index, volumes 1-20.
ed. Charles T. Cullen, R.R. Crout, Eugene R. Sheridan, Ruth
W. Lester.
City: Princeton :
Publisher: Princeton University Press,
Date: 1983.
Pages: xi, 592.
Notes: Replaces three
"temporary" indexes, but the editors caution that they have made no
systematic attempt to
prepare
new subject entries for this index. Some categories were not covered in
each of the earlier
indexes,
e.g. "farm implements" is a category in the second index but not in the first
or third, and in
preparing
the present index the editors did not review Volumes 1-6 and 13-20 to
complete the category.
Thus,
the "temporary" indexes may retain some value.
Reference: 124.
Name: Adams
, Dickinson W.
Publication: The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Second Series:
Jefferson's Extracts from the
Gospels .
ed. Dickinson W. Adams and Ruth W. Lester,
Introduction by Eugene R. Sheridan.
City: Princeton :
Publisher: Princeton University Press,
Date: 1983.
Pages: xii, 438.
Notes: The first volume in the
Papers edition's second series, which will include the longer
items most amenable to
topical
rather than chronological arrangement. Included here are a reconstructed
version of
"The Philosophy of Jesus," a major piece of textual scholarship on the part
of Dickinson W.
Adams,
and TJ's later scissors edit of the Gospels, "The Life and Morals of Jesus."
Sheridan's
"Introduction"
traces the evolution of TJ's religious opinions and examines the three
versions he constructed of
the
life of Jesus, from the "Syllabus" included in the letter of April, 21, 1803,
to Benjamin Rush to
the
final "Life and Morals." Points out the genesis of TJ's beliefs in his early
reading of
Bolingbroke,
the influence of Joseph Priestley, and the effect of his correspondence with
Benjamin Rush.
Contends that TJ is best understood as a "demythologized Christian," whose
rationalism and
religiousness have variously been distorted in the accounts of partisans of
one position or the
other.
This essay is probably the best single account of TJ's religious beliefs and
will have to be
consulted
by all future scholars on the subject; the volume also includes a useful
appendix of TJ's
correspondence pertaining to religion.
Reference: 125.
Name: Peterson,
, Sanford William.
Title: "The Genesis and Development of Parliamentary Procedure in
Colonial America,
1609-1801."
Publication:
Ph.d. dissertation. Indiana University,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 383.
Publication: DAI
Volume: 44
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 3206-A.
Notes: Discusses TJ's contributions to evolving understanding of
parliamentary procedure in
America during his career as Burgess, Delegate to the Virginia
Constitutional Convention,
Delegate
to the Continental Congress, and President of the Senate. Uses TJ's notes
from his
"Parliamentary
Pocketbook" which led up to his
Manual . Argues for an emergence of colonial rules of order
entirely unlike those of the
Houses of Commons or Lords and contends there is no direct evidence for
transportation in fact,
language, or substance of the English rules of order to the colonies.
Includes Giles Gray's
transcription of and notes to TJ's "Parliamentary Pocketbook."
Reference: 126.
Name: Sheldon,
, Garrett Ward.
Title: "Classical and Modern Influences on American Political Thought:
The Political Theories
of
Thomas Jefferson."
Publication: Ph.D. dissertation. Rutgers,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 337.
Publication: DAI
Volume: 44
Date: (1984) ,
Pages: 1564-A.
Notes: Seeks to situate "Jefferson's political theory ... within the entire
history of Western
Political
Thought." Argues that TJ's early, Revolutionary writings targeted at the
organic ideology of the
British Empire were defined by a Lockean liberalism which emphasized
freedom, independence,
equality, limited government and revolution. After the Revolution his
writings increasingly drew
upon classical Greek concepts of human nature, politics, and ethics to
support the construction of
a new republic. When he later saw the possibility of a remote and corrupt
national government
as
a threat to local freedoms, the liberal tendencies in his politics reasserted
themselves, once again
employing Lockean metaphors on behalf of Aristotelean commonwealths.
Reference: 127.
Name: Shuffelton,
, Frank.
Publication: Thomas Jefferson: A Comprehensive, Annotated
Bibliography of Writings about
Him:
1826-1980 .
City: New York:
Publisher:
Garland
Publishing,
Date: 1983.
Pages: xix, 486.
Notes: Predecessor to this volume. Lists 3,447 items about Jefferson
arranged under five topical
headings. Includes brief introduction, subject index, and list of authors.
Reference: 128.
Name: Yonkers,
, Tescia Ann.
Publication: Shrine of Freedom: Thomas Jefferson Memorial
.
City: Washington,
D.C.:
Publisher: The author,
Date: 1983.
Pages: [52].
Notes: Sketch of TJ, the work of the Memorial Commission , and the
building of the Memorial.
Souvenir booklet, good of its kind.
B. Essays and book chapters.
Reference: 129.
Name: Adams,
, William Howard.
Title: "Historic Houses--Thomas Jefferson's Monticello."
Publication: Architectural Digest
Volume: 40
Date: (August, 1983) ,
Pages: 116-26.
Notes: Brief account, generously illustrated with photographs by
Langdon Clay.
Reference: 130.
Name: Allen,
, Esther A.
Title: "Jefferson's Naval Policy and the Southern Congressional
Response."
Publication: M.A. thesis.
Georgia Southern College,
Date: 1983.
Notes:
Not seen.
Reference: 131.
Name: Barnouw,
, Jeffrey.
Title: "The Pursuit of Happiness in Jefferson and Its Background in
Bacon and Hobbes."
Publication: Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy
Volume: 11
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 225-48.
Notes: Argues for a connection between the ideas of the pursuit of
happiness and a spirit of
enterprise, "a sense of venturesome self-reliance which is essential to
happiness" and is grounded
in the thinking of Bacon and Hobbes. Claims their "psychology of
endeavor" differs from
Locke's
denial of the freedom of the will, (although it is debatable if TJ and most
of his compatriots
would
have read Locke in this way). Interestingly suggests that Bacon's conception
of science as a
disciplining of the mind through deliberate experience figures in the
tradition of American
republicanism which notably differed from classical republicanism in its
acceptance of time as a
medium of change and chance. Concedes that Hobbes had no overt
influence in Revolutionary
America, but suggests that his ideas made their influence felt through the
works of Priestley,
Blackstone, Hume, Hutcheson, and Locke. An ambitious and challenging
essay.
Reference: 132.
Name: Beiswanger,
, William L.
Title: "The Temple in the Garden: Thomas Jefferson's Vision of the
Monticello
Landscape."
Publication: Eighteenth-Century Life
Volume: 8
Date: (January, 1983) ,
Pages: 170-88.
Notes: Surveys TJ's proposed temples and garden buildings for
Monticello, only one of which
was
built. The temple he built on the edge of the stone wall overlooking the
vegetable garden
collapsed
by 1827, perhaps because of a poorly laid foundation. His earliest projects
were inspired by
literary
and romantic associations, but he was also interested in constructing
historically and
archaeologically accurate designs of Chinese, classical, and Palladian
architecture. By 1800 he
showed more interest in the symbolic values of structures, with a preference
for classic forms
suggesting the republican vision.
Reference: 133.
Name: Bell,
, Barry.
Title: "Reading and `Misreading' the Declaration of Independence."
Publication: Early American Literature
Volume: 18
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 71-83.
Notes: Notes the tendency many of our most persuasive readings of the
Declaration to map its
text
against the tradition which supposedly contains its key terms; if it seems
hopeless to assess the
precise degree of credit each contending "tradition" bears, the history of the
Declaration's
interpretations points to the complex problem of intertextuality, here
evidenced by one of its first
interpreters, Peter Whitney, a minister in Northborough, Massachusetts, in
1776. His sermon,
American Independence Vindicated , "misreads," i.e.
creatively
interprets, the Declaration as congruent with the political concerns of Real
Whigs as well as with
those of evangelical Christians. Encouraged by textual images of slavery,
of paternal and
Christian
responsibility, and of involuntary social and historical rupture, Whitney
exploited the protean
qualities of the Declaration's text which allowed diverse and even divergent
interpretations.
Reference: 134.
Name: Bell,
, David.
Title: "Knowledge and The Middle Landscape: Thomas Jefferson's
University of
Virginia."
Publication: Journal of Architectural Education
Volume: 37
Date: (Winter, 1983) .
Pages: 18-26.
Notes: Argues that TJ's plans for the University of Virginia reflect his
awareness of his own
mediating position between the natural and cultural universes. he thus
invented a "middle
landscape," one neither wild nor refined, for America, and the University
represents his
"architectural incarnation." Interesting analysis of the pavilions,
concentrating upon the
elevations.
Reference: 135.
Name: Bradley,
, Bert E.
Title: "Jefferson and Reagan: The Rhetoric of Two Inaugurals."
Publication: Southern Speech Communication Journal
Volume: 48
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 119-36.
Notes: Using "analog-criticism," compares the 1801 and 1981 inaugural
speeches, both
addresses
following a "pivotal election," for responses to questions about excessive
federal powers,
mistaken
foreign policy, and the large number of citizens with negative perceptions
of each man. Claims
both
men developed effective rhetorical strategies of conciliation and moderation
to gain voter
approval,
and goes on to contend that this similarity in two pivotal election inaugurals
suggests the high
degree
to which rhetorical response is contingent upon the situation. "The situation
controls the
rhetorical
response," in effect. See below for critique by Gregg Phifer which exposes
the simplistic attitude
toward comparison of texts from different historical periods.
Reference: 136.
Name: Bradley,
, Bert E.
Title: "A Response to `Two Inaugurals: A Second Look'."
Publication: Southern Speech Communication Journal
Volume: 48
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 386-90.
Notes: Rebuts Phifer's critique (see below) of the preceding piece by
accusing it of being
politically
biased.
Reference: 137.
Name: Clark,
, Clifford E.
Title: "American Architecture : The Prophetic and Biblical Strains"
in
Publication: The Bible and American Arts and Letters
,
ed. Giles Gunn.
City: Philadelphia:
Publisher: Fortress Press,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 105-27.
Notes: Argues that from TJ on American architects have functioned
(whether they recognized it or not) within what Perry Miller and Sacvan
Bercovitch have called
the
jeremiad tradition. TJ was "an initiator and cornerstone of this tradition"
because of his concern
for
the moral purpose of architecture and for raising the practice of architecture
to standards
appropriate
for a nation that was in effect a "city upon a hill."
Reference: 138.
Name: Dewey,
, Frank L.
Title: "Thomas Jefferson's Law Practice: The Norfolk Anti-Inoculation
Riots."
Publication: Virginia Magazine of History and Biography
Volume: 91
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 39-53.
Notes: TJ represented Dr. Archibald Campbell and James Parker
against the charge of
maintaining
a public nuisance when they had their families inoculated against small pox.
Mobs in Norfolk
had
rioted in 1768 and 1769 against their practice of inoculation, and Dr.
Campbell's house was
burned.
TJ was also employed by Campbell and Parker to assist in the prosecution
of the rioters.
Reference: 139.
Name: Downs,
, Robert B.
Title: "Thomas Jefferson"
in
Publication: Memorable Americans ,
ed. Downs, John T. Flanagan, Harold W.
Scott.
City:
Littleton CO:
Publisher: Libraries Unlimited,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 172-74.
Notes: Biographical sketch; the usual.
Reference: 140.
Name:
Title: "The Edgehill Portrait of Thomas Jefferson."
Publication: Virginia Cavalcade
Volume: 32
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 148-49.
Notes: Brief account of the history behind the Edgehill portrait, Gilbert
Stuart's second oil
portrait
of TJ. During the June 1805 sitting, Stuart mixed a sample of the grass
green color TJ wished to
use
on the entrance hall floor at Monticello.
Reference: 141.
Name: Falk,
, Richard.
Title: "Beyond Internationalism"
in
Publication: The End of the World Order: Essays on Normative
International
Relations .
City: Princeton:
Publisher:
Princeton University
Press,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 105-41.
Notes: Argues that "the Jeffersonian perspective on America's role in
the world is suggestive,
although no more than that, for those who favor a value-oriented foreign
policy with roots in the
historical past and that can yet respond to likely discontinuities in the
probable future." TJ
placed
his hopes and faith in an America dedicated to liberty as well as to
independence. His
importance
today, symbolic rather than literal, owes to his recognition of the dangers
in the materialist cult
of
progress, of the need for a balanced social and economic order in which
rural, agrarian patterns
are
not displaced by urban and industrial modes, and of the need to trust people
to care for
themselves.
Reference: 142.
Name: Fender,
, Stephen.
Title: "The Declaration of Independence"
in
Publication: American Literature in Context, 1620-1830
.
City: London:
Publisher: Methuen,
Date: 1983.
Pages:
97-121.
Notes: Observes that George III is arraigned as the emperor of dullness
and reads Pope's
Dunciad not as an influence
per se but as an intertextual reference. Contends that "this
intertextual reference to
Augustan
satire is the rhetorical equivalent of the Declaration's appeal to natural
law," lifting the argument
to
a disinterested standard of order and chaos. Follows with a more
conventional account of TJ's
intellectual sources in Locke and the common sense philosophers and
discusses themes of natural
rights, liberty, etc.
Reference: 143.
Name: Hatch,
, Peter.
Title: "Thomas Jefferson, Gardener."
Publication: Flower and Garden
Volume: 27
Date: (July, 1983) ,
Pages: 6-9, 28.
Notes: On the restoration of the Monticello gardens, written by the
Superintendent of Grounds
there. Slanted towards gardeners, with information on TJ's mulching
practices, manuring, and
varieties planted.
Reference: 144.
Name: Hauer,
, Stanley R.
Title: "Thomas Jefferson and the Anglo-Saxon Language."
Publication: PMLA
Volume: 98
Date: (1983) . 879-98.
Notes: Authoritative study of TJ's interest in and knowledge of Old
English which began with
his
early legal studies. Includes an analysis of his "Essay on the Anglo-Saxon
Language" and the
translations from the Old English Heptateuch and a critique of the
importance and validity of his
ideas. Finds TJ admirable as a pioneer in the study of Old English, but
criticizes his sweeping
generalizations and heedless oversimplifications of Old English grammar.
Publication:
Reference: 145.
Name: Henderson,
, Phillip G.
Title: "Marshall versus Jefferson: Politics and the Federal Judiciary in
the Early
Republic."
Publication: Michigan Journal of Political Science .
Volume: 2
Date: (No. 2, 1983) ,
Pages: 42-66.
Notes: Explains the differences between TJ and Marshall over the
constitutional role of the
judiciary and contends that their debates remain strikingly relevant. Their
legacy, however, is
misunderstood by those who praise Marshall's activism without
acknowledging the elitist
dimension
of his political philosophy as well as by those who want the judiciary to
advance principles of
Jeffersonian democracy while ignoring TJ's concern, at least after 1800, to
limit the Supreme
Court's
authority. Claims that in recent years paradoxically it is Justice Rehnquist
who "has taken on a
distinctly Jeffersonian tone in judicial conduct," but if TJ were alive today,
he might have
preferred
the work of the activist Warren Court.
Reference: 146.
Name: Kelso,
, William M.
Title: "Landscape Archaeology: A Key to Virginia's Cultivated Past."
Publication: Eighteenth-Century Life
Volume: 8
Date: (January, 1983) ,
Pages: 159-69.
Notes: Discusses archaeological work on the gardens at Carter's Grove,
Kingsmill, and
Monticello,
with emphasis on the latter. Archaeological research has proved invaluable
in providing physical
details for reconstruction and help in interpreting TJ's garden notes and
sketches more accurately.
Describes TJ's landscaping and improvements on Mulberry Row and his
ha-ha designed to
protect
the lawn.
Reference: 147.
Name: Kessler,
, Sanford.
Title: "Jefferson's Rational Religion"
in
Publication: The Constitutional Polity: Essays on the Founding
Principles of American
Politics ,
ed. Sidney A. Pearson, Jr.
City: Washington:
Publisher: University Press of America,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 58-73.
Notes: Offers a conventional account of TJ's "rational religion," but
goes on to argue that
although
his religious views were never as popular as he hoped they would become,
TJ's beliefs have
deeply
influenced the doctrines of most American churches. These churches do not
teach the right of a
favored few to rule over the rest, nor for the most part do their clergymen
seek to prevent their
members from regulating their own "pursuit of industry and improvement."
Reference: 148.
Name: Kessler,
, Sanford.
Title: "Locke's Influence on Jefferson's `Bill for Establishing Religious
Freedom'."
Publication: Journal of Church and State
Volume: 25
Date: (1983) . 231-52.
Notes: Extensive examination of the influence of the
Letter on Toleration and
The Reasonableness of Christianity establishes the strength
of Locke's influence.
Considers
important differences as well. TJ trusted government less than Locke did
and thus sought to alter
the Lockean framework in the direction of greater religious freedom. He
also trusted people
more
and was willing to see their "good sense" as a defense against error. Does
not overturn earlier
similar analyses but offers more comprehensive examination.
Reference: 149.
Name: Leiner,
, Frederick C.
Title: "The `Whimsical Phylosophic President' and His Gunboats."
Publication: American Neptune
Volume: 43
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 245-66.
Notes: A detailed and critical survey of TJ's naval policies. Faults him
for undervaluing the
strategic importance of a high-seas fleet and for persisting in the untested
gunboat scheme.
(Although initial support by Commodore Preble for the gunboats may have
contributed to his
mistaken enthusiasm.) Obstinately maintained despite evident failures, this
came close to
undoing
the country.
Reference: 150.
Name: Llewellyn,
, Robert.
Title: "A New View of Monticello."
Publication: Historic Preservation .
Volume: 35
Date: (no. 5, 1983) ,
Pages: 48-51.
Notes:
Photographs.
Reference: 151.
Name: Loss,
, Richard.
Title: "Thomas Jefferson Versus Wellesley High School."
Publication: Teaching Political Science: Politics in Perspective
Volume: 11
Date: (Fall, 1983) ,
Pages: 15-19.
Notes: Contends that one reason for concern with the quality of
American high schools concerns
the limits their performance places on what colleges or universities can
accomplish. Uses TJ's
views
of education as criteria to judge the education he received in Wellesley MA.
Wellesley High is
considered to be an excellent school, at least compared to those in seriously
disadvantaged
communities, but it fell far short of realizing its potential or what TJ hoped
schools would
accomplish.
Reference: 152.
Name: MacFadyen,
, J.
Tevere.
Title: "The Once and Future Gardens of Thomas Jefferson."
Publication: Horticulture
Volume: 59
Date: (September, 1983) ,
Pages: 12-19.
Notes: Restoration of Monticello gardens. Substantive account with
emphasis on archaeological
research and the original design of the gardens. Best account of the fence
TJ had built around the
garden.
Reference: 153.
Name: Malone,
, Dumas.
Title: "Monticello."
Publication: Horizon
Volume: 26
Date: (June, 1983) ,
Pages: 53-61.
Notes: Text from Malone's
Jefferson and His Time accompanies illustrations by Robert
Llewellyn to promote a
forthcoming volume of photographs.
Reference: 154.
Name: McCabe,
, Carol.
Title: "Mr. Jefferson's Garden."
Publication: Early American Life
Volume: 14
Date: (no. 3, 1983) .
Pages: 44-49.
Notes: On Monticello's gardens as now restored; for a popular
audience. Gives account of
efforts
by Peter Hatch and staff to find varieties of fruits and vegetables which TJ
planted.
Reference: 155.
Name: McGraw,
, Joseph.
Title: "`To Secure These Rights': Virginia Republicans on the
Strategies of Political Opposition,
1788-1800.
Publication: VMHB
Volume: 91
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 54-72.
Notes: Discusses within the context of statewide moves to oppose the
Federalists TJ's Kentucky
Resolutions, his concern for electing Republicans, and his interest in
publicizing Republican
principles in journals, pamphlets, and letters from representatives to
constituents. Useful view of
TJ as a party builder.
Reference: 156.
Name: Peterson,
, Merrill D.
Title: "Jefferson, Madison, and Church State Separation"
in
Publication: Conceived in Conscience: An Analysis of
Contemporary Church-State
Relations , ed.
Richard A. Rutyna and John W. Kuehl.
City: Norfolk :
Publisher: Donning,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 34-42.
Notes: Sees policy of church-state relations as resulting from
rationalistic theory mixed with the
practical experience of religious pluralism. Points out two versions of the
purpose of religious
freedom: to protect the state from church interference and to protect
religious life from the
secular
state. TJ's Statute was passed with support from both points of view; he
upheld the former,
secular-Enlightenment version, but Madison in his "Memorial and
Remonstrance" appealed to
both
arguments.
Reference: 157.
Name: Phifer,
, Gregg.
Title: "Two Inaugurals: A Second Look."
Publication: Southern Speech Communications Journal
Volume: 48
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 375-85.
Notes: Critiques Bert E. Bradley's essay of this year (see above),
contending that comparison
between TJ and Reagan speeches is suspect because "even when the words
look alike, the social
setting makes it unlikely that Jefferson and Reagan meant the same thing."
Concedes the
difficulty
of scholarly objectivity when dealing with controversial contemporary
issues, but claims that it is
important to look not just at what is said in a literal sense, but at what is
done, at the difference in
settings, the difference in times.
Reference: 158.
Name: Preyer,
, Kathryn.
Title: "Crime, The Criminal Law and Reform in Post-Revolutionary
Virginia."
Publication: Law and History Review
Volume: 1
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 53-85.
Notes: Rejects Julian Boyd's contention that TJ's Bill to Proportion
Crimes and Punishments did
little more than restore generally accepted practice concerning capital
offenses. Traditional
means
of mitigating the law's severity were swept away with the idea that "none
may be induced to
injure
through hope of impunity." Claims that the Jeffersonian formulation was
intended to supercede
the
immediate past, as were the Statute of Descents and the Bill for Religious
Freedom, by
embracing
what were understood as ancient realities. Points out that it is difficult to
evaluate TJ's bill since
we
have insufficient knowledge about crime and the criminal system in Virginia
at this time.
Reference: 159.
Name: Quinn,
, Sandra L.
, and Sanford Kanter.
Title: "Thomas Jefferson's Children"
in
Publication: America's Royalty: All the President's Children
.
City: Westport
CT:
Publisher: Greenwood Press,
Date:
1983.
Pages:
15-22.
Notes: Briefly discusses each of TJ's children; includes the Hemings
children, but withholds
final
judgment on the question of his paternity.
Reference: 160.
Name: Schulz,
, Constance B.
Title: "`Of Bigotry in Politics and Religion': Jefferson's Religion, The
Federalist Press and the
Syllabus."
Publication: Virginia Magazine of History and Biography
.
Volume: 91.
Pages: 73-91.
Notes: Intelligently discusses the Federalist attacks on TJ's supposed
religious principles during
the
first term of his presidency; credits them (along with Priestley's Jesus
and Socrates
Compared ) with motivating him to write the Syllabus of the merits
of the doctrines of Jesus
which he sent to Benjamin Rush and also with reawakening his curiosity
about theological
matters.
Thus sees TJ's interest in religion as at first reactive, motivated by a desire
to counter accusations
of irreligion, but then becoming an interest for its own sake.
Reference: 161.
Name: Simpson,
, Lewis P.
Title: "The Concept of the Historical Self in
Brother to Dragons "
in
Publication: Robert Penn Warren's Brother to Dragons: A Discussion
,
ed. James A. Grimshaw, Jr.
City: Baton Rouge :
Publisher: Louisiana State University Press,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 244-49.
Notes: Discusses Warren's revision of
Brother to Dragons in terms of the representation of TJ; the
most important change
involves
a lessened hope for the melioration of the human condition and a more
pessimistic attitude,
expressed by the character TJ, toward the human heart and its capacity to
love.
Reference: 162.
Name: Somerville,
, Terry.
Title: "Did America's Founding Fathers Really Stand on the Word of
God?"
Publication: Christianity Today
Volume: 27
Date: (June 17, 1983) ,
Pages: 17-19.
Notes: Warns Christians not to turn to TJ for spiritual or theological
teaching, no matter how
much
he has to offer us politically.
Reference: 163.
Name: Stockdale,
, Eric.
Title: "John Stockdale of Piccadilly: Publisher to John Adams and
Thomas Jefferson"
in
Publication: Author/Publisher Relations During the Eighteenth and
Nineteenth
Centuries ,
ed. Robin Meyers and Michael Harris.
City: Oxford UK:
Publisher: Oxford
Polytechnic
Press,
Date: 1983.
Pages: 63-87.
Notes: Stockdale was introduced to bookselling and publishing by John
Almon, who had
established a reputation for printing and selling material friendly to British
Whigs such as Wilkes
and Americans such as Benjamin Franklin. When John Adams visited
London in late 1783, he
took
rooms at Stockdale's, and in turn Franklin and Adams referred TJ to
Stockdale as a bookseller
and
otherwise useful London connection. Stockdale first approached TJ about
publishing
Notes in London, but eventually TJ stopped doing business
with him because of his
slowness
in providing requested books. Discusses circumstances surrounding
Stockdale's publication of
Notes in some detail.
Reference: 164.
Name: Summy,
, Ralph.
Title: "Comparative Political Biography: Jayaprakash Narayan and
Thomas Jefferson."
Publication: Biography
Volume: 6
Date: (1983) .
Pages: 220-37.
Notes: Compares the two men as embodiments of world revolutionary
ideals and finds a marked
similarity in their proposals, doubts, fears, dilemmas, and styles. Somewhat
facile
generalizations
limit the usefulness of the comparison.
Reference: 165.
Name: Thompson,
, Peggy.
Title: "Jefferson Trimmed the Bible to His Taste."
Publication: Smithsonian .
Volume: 14
Date: (September, 1983) .
Pages: 139-45, 47-48.
Notes: Popular account of TJ's preparation of the Life and Morals of
Jesus, noting the new
Princeton edition (listed above).
Reference: 166.
Name: Tucker,
, Spencer C.
Title: "Mr. Jefferson's Gunboat Navy."
Publication: American Neptune
Volume: 43
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 135-41.
Notes: The shortcomings of TJ's gunboat policy stand out in view of
the principles of seapower
espoused by A. T. Mahan (and thus offer more evidence for the strength
of Mahan's argument).
Gunboats were plagued with problems, were not economical to build in
terms of the numbers of
cannon they made available, and were in proportion more expensive to
maintain than the navy's
frigates. Their poor showing in the War of 1812 was their undoing.
Reference: 167.
Name: Welsh,
, Frank S.
and Charles L. Granquist.
Title: "Restoration of the Exterior Sanded Paint at Monticello."
Publication: APT Bulletin
Volume: 15 (#2)
Date: (1983) .
Pages: 2-10.
Notes: Account of restoring the sand finish paint, made by dusting dry
sand over a freshly
painted
surface so as to imitate the appearance of stone. The east and west portico
columns were
originally
done this way, as were the east front rustication and the door and window
frames within the
portico.
Reference: 168.
Name: Wetmore,
, Robert George.
Title: "Seditious Libel Persecutions in 1806 in the Federal Court in
Connecticut:
United States v.
Tapping Reeve and Companion Cases."
Publication: Connecticut Bar Journal
Volume: 57
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 196-210.
Notes: Prosecutions of ardent Federalist Tapping Reeve for libeling TJ
raises questions about
TJ's
genuine commitment to civil liberties. This will not be new to readers of
Leonard Levy, but it is
a
good account of the Reeve case. TJ knew what was going on in
Connecticut, but he apparently
made
no comment on it nor tried to stop it. Does not explain why he made no
comment on the case.
Reference: 169.
Name: Whitehead,
, John S.
Title: "Caught Between Two Worlds: Mr. Jefferson's University and
the Literature of American
Higher Education."
Publication: South Atlantic Quarterly
Volume: 82
Date: (1983) ,
Pages: 206-15.
Notes: Essay inspired by Virginius Dabney's
Mr. Jefferson's University (1981), comparing it to other
recent studies of institutions of
higher learning. Where many of them go beyond the traditional
parochialism of such works, this
history seems still caught up in it in various ways. Given the significance
of TJ's founding vision
for the University, we might have hoped for a better, more thoughtful
account of how his
institution
evolved.